Canada -   

Bureaucrats with smartphones a risk: privacy report

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News Channel: Jennifer Stoddart on privacy
Canada's Privacy Commissioner says there is privacy risks involved when using handheld devices since messages sent pin-to-pin on Blackberries are not encrypted but scrambled, which makes it susceptible of interception. T

Font-size: Bigger  Smaller  Share Share Print Print Comments Comments(7)

Photos

Slideshow image

View Larger Image

CTV.ca News Staff

Date: Tue. Oct. 5 2010 1:56 PM ET

The federal government has not done enough to protect its smartphones from interception, leaving Canadians' personal information vulnerable, Canada's privacy commissioner warns.

In the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada's annual report to Parliament, privacy commissioner Jennifer Stoddart said none of the five federal agencies she had audited had "fully assessed the threats and risks inherent in wireless communications."

The report also specifically singled out pin-to-pin messaging between smartphones – which is popular among government staffers – as vulnerable to interception.

"They are using the pin-to-pin messaging . . . in which the messages are not encrypted, only scrambled," Stoddart told CTV News Channel. "This means they are more susceptible to interception with easy-to-get off-the-shelf devices."

Stoddart said in her office the pin-to-pin capacity of employees' phones is disabled, except for a handful of officials who would be able to use it if their main server crashed.

Stoddart also noted government practices for disposing of paper documents and unneeded computers were similarly putting Canadians' private information at risk.

"Our audits turned up some disturbing gaps in the privacy policies and practices of government institutions," Stoddart said in the report. "Whether they're using a BlackBerry, shredding old papers or disposing of outdated computer equipment, public servants need to know that the security of people's personal data is a top priority."

However, the commissioner's report is focused more on the potential risks than on privacy incidents that have already occurred.

"Considering the vast amounts of personal information on Canadians that the government holds, problems are relatively rare," Stoddart acknowledged.

The privacy commissioner argues because of the sensitivity of the information the federal government has access to -- such as taxation, income support, the correctional system and international travel information -- the report requires serious action.

"When it comes to safeguarding the personal information entrusted to it, the government of Canada must always be held to the very highest standards of account," the report said.

Other report highlights:

  • An audit found that 90 per cent of a sample of donated government computers to a recycling program for schools had not had their hard drives wiped – leaving some data behind that was confidential and even classified.
  • Unauthorized access to tax records by Canadian Revenue Agency officials has led to new measures. The report notes one agency worker put the tax records of a professional athlete online.
  • The report raised concerns about the disclosure of personal information by administrative tribunals and other quasi-judicial bodies.

Please Add Comments( )

Frank Buchan
said

These are HR issues more than technology issues. Flat out, the government has too many fingers in too many pies, and too many people working at cross purposes. Streamline government, return it to its aggregate purposes, and most of this would be less threatening.


Jack Lambert
said

Not wiping Hard Drives before disposal? There is already very stringent regulations for doing this. Find out who didn't do their job and reprimand them. As usual, it's lack of enforcement that leads to these problems.


PBW
said

disk-wiping software is available to anyone, and it should be standard operating procedure for any government employee who deletes files to have a program that deletes and overwrites three or four times. IT managers and techies could easily set parameters for deleting files so that they are automatically scrubbed clean. It seems that there is inadequate training in place and insufficient supervision of wiping and deleting operations. Given the burgeoning size of federal - and provincial - bureaucracy, why am I not surpised? Too many managers and not enough worker-bees; and the managers are too busy preening themselves to do their jobs effectively.


alexander
said

Human resource and IT dept is sleeping at their desk when this is happening. It is just common sense to format your entire hard drive when you want to give or sell your computer to another person . I am sure you don't want a complete strangers to see all or even parts of your private information.


Peter Mac
said

An enormous amount of data is thrown away each day by each and every one of us. Think about what ends up in your household rubbish. Confidential information is only confidential if you don't want another person to know it, and then only a problem if used with malice or contrary to your interest.

I assume that there are many people who can find out just about anything they want about me, if they wanted. Especially the government. Still I close my bedroom window when I go to bed at night.


Honza
said

PIN messaging wth Blackberries is not secure huh? That's interesting given that the same technology that is used to deliver corporate e-mail to these devices. I guess that's not secure either. Either this is the media getting this wrong or the Auditors don't know what they're talking about.


ANJ
said

Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater here. Pin-to-Pin messages, can be secured / encrypted by configuring this policy on the BES. The bigger security gap is the use of SMS / Text Messaging for sensitive information...


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

Contest

User Tools

About the tools

Need to get in touch with CTV? You can email the CTV web team using the 'Feedback' button.

Share it with your network of friends

Share this CTV article or feature with your friends. Click on the icon for your favourite social networking or messaging system, and follow the prompts.

Facebook

Share this article with Facebook

DIGG

Share this article with Digg

Newsvine

Share this article with Newsvine

Delicious

Share this article with delicious

Email

Share this article.
Send Email

Twitter

Share this article with Twitter

StumbleUpon

Share this article with StumbleUpon

Reddit

Share this article with Reddit

Yahoo! Buzz

Share this article with Yahoo! Buzz

Most Talked about Stories

These are HR issues more than technology issues. Flat out, the government has too many fingers in too many pies, and too many people working at cross purposes. Streamline government, return it to its aggregate purposes, and most of this would be less threatening.

Frank Buchan

Bureaucrats with BlackBerrys a risk: privacy report