1. WHATEVER STRATEGY IS FOLLOWED BY THE ENEMY OVER THE NEXT FEW MONTHS, IT WILL DERIVE NEITHER FROM A POSITION OF DESPERATION, NOR FROM A POSITION OF STRENGTH.

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
06786681
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
U
Document Page Count: 
24
Document Creation Date: 
April 27, 2019
Document Release Date: 
April 30, 2019
Sequence Number: 
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
February 28, 1969
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon 1. WHATEVER STRATEGY IS [15617868].pdf745.07 KB
Body: 
NDEX: 0 YES 0 NO LASSIFY TO, FILE NO. .REF TO FI 'c8 NO. ILE RIDE! RET. TO BRANCH 0 ,ESTROY 0 SIG Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 ( :V4SIFIED MESSAGE -TOTAL COPIES 1): GROUP I CROAT= PROM AUTOMATIC DOWNCRADINO AND � ORCLASSIMPATON REPRODUCTION PROHIBITED 413313r 1CTION 4r INFO PERSON/UNIT NOTIFIED 2 3 7 4 8 a ivt- 2-- 0 RID COPY ADVANCE COPY ISSUED El SLOTTED El TUBED UNIT. TIME BY 3E c R DIRECTOR r to� .SECTION 1WP2 5 //k vJ ",) 8 FP 0 j REF g DIRECTOR 76712 * Requested contribution to SNIE titled "Short-term outlook in Vietnam." GEN ER AL 1. WHATEVER STRATEGY IS FOLLOWED BY THE ENEMY OVER THE NEXT FEW MONTHS, IT WILL DERIVE NEITHER FROM A POSITION OF DESPERATION, NOR FROM A POSITION OF STRENGHT. HE STILL HAS MOST OF HIS MILITARY FORCES INTACT. TENUOUS INDICATIONS ARE THAT HE SUBSTANTIALLY BUILT UP HIS FORCES IN THE MONTH PRIOR TO THE TET OFFENSIVE AND IS NOW BUSILY RECRUITING IN THE FORMER. GVN- CONTROLLED AREAS WHERE MANPOWER 'WAS' NOT PREVIOUSLY AVAILABLE TO HIM. IT IS CONCEIVABLE THAT THE TOTAL OF MAIN, LOCAL AND GURERRILLA FORCES AVAILABLE TO HIM TODAY IS NOT SUBSTANTIALLY BELOW THAT AVAILABLE TO HIM ON. 1 JANUARY, DESPITE THE CONSIDER ABLE ..LOSSES INFLICTED ON.. HIM SINCE THAT DATE. MOREOVER, HE RETAINS THE OPTION OF SENDING IN ADDITIONAL FORCES FROM THE NORTH EITHER AS NEW UNITS OR TO SERVE AS REPLACEMENTS, IF HE SO CHOOSES. ON THE OTHER HAND, THE LOSS SEC Elf. Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 3.5(c) 3.5(c) r Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 2 SECTION 1 OF 5 SAIGON 9276 OF IMPORTANT SEGMENTS OF THE VC INFRASTRUCTURE, THE IMPRESSMENT OF LARGE NUMBERS OF UNTRAINED PERSONNEL INTO THE LOCAL FORCES, THE LOSS OF MANY TRAINED ELEMENTS SUCH AS SAPPER 1SONNEL AND MIDDLE-LEVEL UNIT COMMANDERS, TOGETHER WITH HEAVY EXPENDITURES OF WEAPONS AND AMMUNITION, SUGGEST THAT THE COMBAT EFFECTIVENESS OF THE ENEMY FORCES HAS SUFFERED AT LEAST A TEMPORARY DECLINE. MOREOVER, THERE ARE INDICATIONS THAT THE ENEMY IS CONCERNED OVER THE MORALE OF HIS FORCES IN THE LIGHT OF HIS PROMISES OF AN EARLY FINAL VICTORY. IN ANY EVENT, IT SEEMS CERTAIN THAT THE SCOPE AND INTENSITY OF THE REMAINDER OF THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGN WILL DECLINE SOMEWHAT IN THE MILITARY SPHERE, AND INCREASE CONSIDERABLY IN THE POLITICAL SPHERE, SHORT RUN CONSIDERATIONS � 2. THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAI G51 WHICH APPARENTLY WAS FORMULATED SOMETIME IN THE SUMMER OR FALL FO 1967, WAS TO CONSIST OF THREE PHASES: OCTOBER TO DECEMBER 1957; JANUARY TO MARCH 1968:- AND APRIL TO JUNE 1968.- CAPTURED VIET CONG (VC) DOCUMENTS AND PRISONER STATEMENTS AMPLY DEMONSTRATE THAT THE COMMUNIST VIEW THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGN AS THE : Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 3 SAIGON 9276-SECRET "DECISIVE" PHASE PHASE OF THE WAR, CRUCIAL TO ITS ULTIMATE OUTCOME. INDEED, IT APPEARS THAT THE COMMUNISTS IN ASSESSING THE SITUATION BELIEVED THAT THE MOMENT FOR AN ALL-OUT PUSH HAD COME, AND THAT THERE WERE GOOD PROSPECTS FOR A VICTORY VIA THE "GENERAL UPRISING" WHICH WOULD PUT THEM IN A VERY STRONG POSITION FORM WHICH TO "NEGOTIATE" A UNITED STATES WITHDRAWAL FROM SOUTH VIETNAM. 3. �THE FACTORS THAT LED THE COMMUNISTS TO THIS ASSESSMENT ARE MANY AND VARIED. THREE, HOWEVER, STAND OUT AND APPEAR TO BE ENDEMIC TO THE COMMUNISTS, FIRST, THE VIETNAMESE COMMUNISTS ARE VICTIMS OF THEIR OWN DOCTRINE. IT IS DIFFICULT TO SORT OUT COMMUNIST INTENTIONS FROM THE RHETORIC OF THEIR DOCTRINE, BUT IT NOW SEEMS CLEAR THAT THE COMMUNISTS ACTUALLY SUBSCRIBED TO THE OFT-REPEATED SHIBBOLETHS THAT "THE LONGER WE FIGHT, THE STRONGER WE BECOME;" "THE MORE VICIOUSLY THE ENEMY FIGHTS, THE CLOSER HE IS TO COLLAPSE;," AND "THE P- OiLE SUPPORT US AND WHEN THE URBAN PEOPLE HAVE THE CHANCE TO RISE UP OUR VICTORY WILL BE ASSURED." THIS DOCTRINAL BLINDNESS IS FED BY THE GROSS MIS-REPORTING EMANATING FROM LOWER-LEVEL ECHELONS TELLING THE COMMUNIST Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 4 SAIGON 9276 - SUPERIORS WHAT THEY WANTED TO HEAR, NAMELY THAT THE WAR WAS GOING WELL. FINALLY, AND PERHAPS WITH MORE BASIS IN FACT, THE COMMUNISTS BELIEVE FERVENTLY THAT THE EVER- INCREASING UNITED STATES INVOLVEMENT IN THE WAR AND, PERFORCE, IN VIETNAMESE SOCIETY WAS CREATING WIDESPREAD "CONTRADICTIONS" BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF VIETNAM (GVN) AND BETWEEN THE GVN AND THE VIETNAMESE PEOPLE WHICH WOULD LEAD INEVITABLY TO A NEW GOVERNMENT, TO SENDING THE AMERICANS HOME, AND TO ENDING THE WAR. 4. GIVEN THIS BACKGROUND, THE COMMUNISTS APPARENTLY BELIEVED THAT A CONCERTED ATTACK AGAINST THE CITIES WOULD LEAD TO THE LONG-AWAITED AND MUCH HERALDED "GENERAL UPRISING" IN WHICH: THE PEOPLE WOULD RALLY TO THE VIET CONG OR THE PAPER FRONTS WHICH THEY PLANNED TO CREATE; THE MILITARY FORCES OF THE GOVEPNMENT WOULD DEFECT OR FOLD UP AGAINST THE VC ONSLAUGHT; AND THE GVN WOULD DISINTEGRATE. THE END RESULT OF ALL THIS WOULD BE THE FORMATION OF A "COALITION GOVERNMENT" WHICH WOULD ORDER THE UNITED STATES TO LEAVE. THUS THE TET OFFENSIVE. IN TERMS OF ITS MAXIMUM GOALS, THE OFFENSIVE OBVIOUSLY WAS A FAILURE: THE PEOPLE 141 IVrs Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 5 SAIGON ;276 SECRET DID NOT RISE UP, ARVN AND THE GVN DID NOT COLLAPSE, AND NO GOAL ITION GOVERNMENT WAS CREATED. WE DO NOT KNOW HOWEVER WHAT MINIMUM GOALS THE COMMUNISTS HAD IN MIND FOR THIS PART OF THE WINTER�SPRING CAMPAIGN, BUT, DESPITE THEIR CONVICTION THAT THEY WOULD SUCCEED, IT IS PROBABLE THAT THEY ALSO HAD LESSER GOALS. GIVEN THE ENORMITY OF WHAT THEY COMMITTED IN THEIR ATTEMPT, THEY MAY HAVE ACHIEVED SOME OF THESE. . .1! _e1e. THEY CERTAINLY DEMONSTRATED A CAPABILITY FOR COORDINATED ACTION AND. FOR SUSTAINING SUCH ACTION WHICH WENT BEYOND WHAT WE HAD PREVIOUSLY ASSUMED. THEY HAVE UNDERMINED THE CON� FIDENCE OF THE PEOPLE IN THE GVN' S ABILITY TO PROTECT THEM. THEY HAVE INFLICTED RECORD LOSSES ON THE FREE WORLD FORCES, THEY SCORED A PSYCHOLOGICAL VICTORY IN THE WORLD� WIDE, AND TO SOME EXTENT, THE UNITED STATES PRESS. MORE IMPORTANT, THEY MADE AT LEAST IN. THE, SHORT RUN TREMENDOUS - OM 1.�u 77 ( iiin tdioeysi aren e 01- they flu girleRrs-Vi E�DE� Pief?Tv16,01)Rov ceS Cep THIS WILL GO FAR TOWARD 'ALLEVIATING THE FOOD UTD MANPOWER SHORTAGES THAT WERE PLAGUING THE VC. E C ii E4- 1114":". Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE .6, SAIGON 5. WE CAN ANTICIPATE THAT THE FUTURE STRATEGY OF THE COMMUNISTS WILL SEEK TO EXPLOIT THE GAINS ALREADY MADE, WHILE AVOIDING THE HEAVY LOSSES SUSTAINED IN THE PAST. � T HEY ARE OBVIOUSLY DISAPPOINTED THAT THE TET OFFENSIVE DID NOT SUCCEED 9 BUT THEY ARE EQUALLY LIKELY TO VIEW IT AS A STEP TOWARD FUTURE SUCCESS IN THAT IT BR OUGHA T HE AR -HOME TO THE CIT IES, FLIRT HER 13 URI) EN ED AN ALREADY OVER-BURDENED AND SOMEWHAT INEFFECT IVE GVN 9 AND IN VC EYES, SPEEDED. UP THE PROCESS OF CREAT ING CONTRAD ICT IONS BETWEEN THE VIETNAMESE �AND THE AMERICANS, FURTHERMORE, THERE IS THE GREAT OPPORTUNITY FOR THE COMMUNISTS IN THE COUNTRYSIDE WHERE THEY HAVE THE iA CAPABILITY TO MOVE INTO THE VAC UN LEFT BY THE WITHDRAWAL OF SECURITY FORCES. IN ANY EVENT, WE BELIEVE THAT THE COMM UN ISTS WILL LOOK AT THE. TET OFFENSIVE AND � REASON THAT IF IT WAS NOT THE FINAL BLOW, IT STILL GREATLY CONTRIBUTED TO THE FINAL BLOW, AND ALL THAT IS �NEEDED IS FOR THE coMMUN IST FOR CES '1.0 PRESS FORWARD EVEN HARDER T BRING IT ABOUT. IN SHORT, THE "LOG IC" AND REASONS BEHIND THE WINTER -SPR ING CAMPAIGN ST ILL HOLD, AND THE CAMPA IFirj HAS YET TO RUN ITS ALLOTTED COURSE. Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 1 PAGE 7 SAIGON 9276--e--E�C-11� SHORT -TERM STRATEGIC CONCEPT AND CA PABIL IT IES 6. CAPTURED DOCUMENTS, AGENT REPORTS, AND INTERROGAT ION REPORTS INDICATE THAT THE ENEMY'S STRATEGY FOR THE SHORT -TERM IS TO KEEP HIS MILITARY FORCES POISED AGAINST THE PRIMARY OBJECTIVE WHILE CONSOL ID AT ING HIS HOLD ON RURAL /-1 AREAS. HE PLANS TO KEEP FR 1- Y FORCES OFF-BALANCE BY ATTACKING BY FIRE KEY MIL IT AR'? BASES, URBAN AREAS, LINES OF COMMUNICATION, AIRFIELDS, �AND PORTS. HE APPARENTLY PLANS TO AVOID LARGE SCALE ATTACKS AGAINST UNITED STATES FORCES BUTiaf TO TRY TO ISOLATE THEM. BY FOLLOWING SUCH A COURSE OF ACT ION, HE EXPECTS TO KEEP POPULAR TENS ION HIGH, TO DISRUPT THE URBAN ECONOMIC STRUCTURE, TO EXACERBATE DIF- FERENCES BETWEEN ARVN AND ALL IED FORCES, TO DETER FRIENDLY UNITS FR OM COUNTERATTACKING, AND TO EXPLOIT MIL IT AR IL Y ANY OPPORTUNITY THAT MIGHT ARISE. AT THIS TIME, THE ENEMY REPORTEDLY EXPECTS TO BE IN POSITION, MILITARILY AND POLITICALLY, TO CONCLUDE THE WAR BY WINNING A BIG VICTORY- OVER i KEY STRATEGIC OBJECTIVE, SUCH AS SAIGON, KHE SANH, ) OR IN THE WESTERN HIGHLANDS. 1-1' 9 �FVER MOST SOURCES DO NOT - INDICATE THAT HIS SPECIFIC TARGET IS PREDETERMINED BUT THAT Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 fP,'�';'� rg Lla PAGE 8 SAIGON 9276 5t OPPORTUNITY, EMBODYING THE KEY FACTORS OF PREPARATION AND. SURPRISE, WILL DETERMINE WHICH TARGET WILL BE CHOSEN. 7. GIVEN THE ENEMY'S RELATIVELY EXPOSED POSIT IONS AND EXTENDED SUPPLY LINES, HE IS NOW MORE VULNERABLE TO ALLIED ATTACKS THAN PREVIOUSLY. AGGRESSIVE ALL IED COUNTERATTACKS - WOULD GREATLY REDUCE THE ENEMY'S CAPABILITY TO MAINTAIN PRESSURE THROUGHOUT SOUTH VIETNAM. A M ISCALCUL AT ION BY THE ENEMY AT THAT TIME AS TO HIS RELATIVE STRENGTH COULD LEAD TO LARGE SCALE ASSAULT S ON A NUMBER OF URBAN AREAS WHICH WOULD UNDOUBTEDLY RESULT IN HEAVY LOSSES. IN SUCH A. CASE A REVISION TO THE PRE-TET PERIPHERAL STRATEGY IS POSSIBLE. THIS WOULD INVOLVE THE PLACEMENT OF ENEMY 4A IN FORGES NEAR BORDER SANCTUARIES TO PROVIDE SAFEHAVENS, SHORTEN HIS SUPPLY LINES, PROVIDE MORE FAVORABLE COMBAT COND IT IONS, AND -ALLOW HIM TO PREPARE TO EXPLOIT ANY OPPORTUNITIES FOR OFFENSIVE ACT ION . Al THE SAME TINE, EMPHASIS WOULD BE PLACED ON GUERRILLA TACT ICS AND SMALL UNIT ACT IONS TO CONTEST CONTROL OF THE RURAL POPULATION . 8. IN RESPECT TO THE ENEMY' S MILITARY CAPABIL IT IES, THERE IS LITTLE DOUBT THAT THE COMBAT EFFECTIVENESS OF Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 9 SAIGON 92 7 6-77�C-11�E�T--- MANY UNITS HAS BEEN REDUCED BECAUSE OF LOSSES DURING THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGNS THERE IS GROWING EVIDENCE, HOWEVER, THAT THE ENEM /SIGNIFICANTLY INCREASED .HIS FORCES PRIOR.- TO 4 THE TEl OFFENSIVE BOTH THROUGH EXPANDED- INFILTRATION AND IN-COUNTRY RECRUITMENT. SINCE TET THERE HAVE BEEN NUMEROUS INDICATIONS THAT THE ENEMY IS EXTENSIVELY RECRUITING AND IMPRESSING ADDITIONAL MANPOWER FROM THE AREAS PREVIOUSLY. DENIED TO HIM. THUS IT IS POSSIBLE THAT THE ENEMY'S TOTAL STRENGTH MA Y NOT HAVE BEEN REDUCED SIGNIFICANTLY THOUGH HE IS QUALI- TATIVELY WEAKER THAN WHEN HE INITIATED HIS WIDESPREAD T ET ATTACKS. THIS REDUCTION IN EFFECTIVENESS MAY BE OFFSET TO SOME DEGREE BY HIS RECENTLY GAINED ACCESS TO THE COUNTRYSIDE WHICH WILL GO FAR TOWARD ALLEVIATING THE FOOD AND MANPOWER SHORTAGES THAT HAVE PLAGUES HIM OVER THE PAST YEAR. 9. THERE HAVE BEEN MANY REPORTS OF A "SECOND PHASE" OF EXTENSIVE ATTACKS, BUT LACKING THE ELEMENT OF SURPRISE AND THE COVER OF 64IET, WE BELIEVE THE ENEMY LACKS THE CAPABILITY FOR ANOTHER MASSIVE EFFORT AGAINST THE CIT IES SUCH AS AT TET. THE CONTROL AUTHORITY WHICH DIRECTED THE RECENT COORD INATED ATTACKS REMA INS BASICALLY INTACT C Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 10 SAIGON 927 C fl rT� AND HAS ORDERED MAIN FORCE ELEMENTS TO MAINTAIN THEIR PRESSURE ON THE CITIES, THE ENEMY ALSO HAS HIS FORCES DEPLOYED IN A THREATENING POSTURE NEAR NUMEROUS URBAN AREAS. . WE. THINK IT LIKELY THAT IN THE SHORT RUN HE PLANS TO EXERT PRESSURE ON THE URBAN AREAS THROUGH HIS PRESENCE AROUND THE r: CIT IES AND BY EXTENSIVE 'ATTACKS BY FIR, MOUNTING GROUND ASSAULTS ON SLECTED 'TARGETS ONLY.WHE.RE THE. BALANCsE OF FORCES IS FAVORABLE, ALT HOUGH HE IS NOW IN � A :MORE VULNERABLE POSITION, THE ENEMY IS PROBABLY CAPABLE OF MAINTAINING LOOSE ENCIRCLEMENT OR MANY URBAN AREAS, INTERD ICT ING LINES OF. COMMUNICAT ION, - AND MOUNTING ATTACKS BY FIRE ON CIT IES AND MILITARY INSTAL- LAT IONS. WE BELIEVE THAT THE ENEMY NOW REALIZES THAT. HE DOES NOT HAVE THE CAPABILITY TO MAINTAIN CONTROL OVER MAJOR URBAN AREAS FOR AN EXTENDED PERIOD OF..T IME. � HE AL SO REALIZES THAT HE MUST MAINTAIN PRESSURE ON ALL IED FORCES. � TO KEEP THEM TIRED DOWN, KEEP THEM FROM REORGANIZING, AND MOST IMPORTANT, KEEP THEM FROM LAUNCHING COUNTERATTACKS. 10. REGARDLESS OF WHAT SHORT�RANGE MILITARY STRATEGY THE COMMUNISTS EMPLOY, IT .ALMOST CERTAINLY- WILL BE ACCOMPANIED- BY AN INTENSIFICATION OF POL IT ICAL, PSYCHOLOGICAL Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 1 1 SAIGON 92 765E CR E T AND ECONOMIC PRESSURES AIMED. AT UND�ERM IN ING THE AUTHORITY. OF THE GVN , SUBVERTING THE GVN FORCES,- STIMULATING DISCONTENT AND FEAR AMONG THE POPULATION, � AND BUILDING -UP TILE NEW-FRONT STRUCTURE . A STEPPED-OP CAMPA IGN OF TERRORISM, ESPECIALLY IN THE CITIES, CAN BE ANTICIPATED. WHERE POSSIBLE THE COMMUNISTS SEEM LIKELY TO TRY TO INTERDICT LINES OF COMMUNICATIONS TO INTERFERE WITH FOOD SUPPLY AND OTHER ECONOMIC ACT IV IT Y. 1 1. IN THE DIPLOMATIC FIELD, HANOI IS LIKELY TO PR OBE THE UNITED STATES POSITION, IF FOR NO � OTHER REASON THAN TO FUEL THE ENGINES OF WORLD OPINION PRESSING THE UNITED STATES FOR A CESSATION OF BOMBING AGAINST NORTH VIETNAM (NVN ) IT IS POSSIBLE, MOREOVER THAT AT SOME POINT DURING THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGN THE COMMUNISTS WILL VIEW THEIR POSIT ION AS BEING CONDUCTIVE TO SERIOUSLY UNDER - TAKING TALKS. THISMOVE -NIGHT -OCCUR. IF THE.CONMUNIST.S BELIEVED THEY HAD SIGN IFICANTLY LTERED THE STRATEGIC BALANCE OF FORCES WHICH WOULD ALLOW THEM TO TALK FROM A POSIT ION OF STRENGT H--A LONG HELD TENET IN THE IR STRATEGY CONCERNING Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 12 SAIGON 9276 SECRET THE WAR. THE CAPTURE OF ONE OR MORE PROVINCE CAPITALS OR A MAJOR MILITARY VICTORY MIGHT BE VIEWED BY THE COMMUNISTS AS BRINGING ABOUT THIS SIT UAT ION. LONGER TERM CONSIDERATIONS 12. IF AT THE END OF THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGN THE COMMUNISTS HAVE NOT BEEN ABLE TO SUSTAIN THE GA INS THEY HAVE MADE TO DATE, THEY ARE LIKELY TO FIND THEMSELVES IN AN UNFAVORABLE POSIT ION. MANY OF THE ADVANTAGES T.HE COMMUNISTS HAVE GAINED BY THEIR ALL-OUT EFFORT DURING TEl WILL BEGIN TO DISSIPATE. GIVEN TINE, IT IS ASSUMED THAT THE ALLIED FORCES WILL GET BACK INTO THE COUNTRYSIDE AND THE GVN. WILL FOLLOW-IF SO, THE GVN AND UNITED STATES WILL PROBABLY MANAGE TO ACCOMODATE THE WORST AFTER-EFFECT:S OF THE DISRUPTION CAUSED BY THE TET ATTACKS. MOREOVER, DESPITE THE INCREASED ACCESS TO THE COUNTRYSIDE, ATTRITION WILL TAKE ITS TOOL FROM THE COMMUNIST FORCES. IN ADDITION, THE COMMUNIST CADRES AND TROOPS HAVE BEEN PROMISED IN NO UNCERTAIN TERMS THAT 1968 WOULD SEE THE WAR BROUGHT TO A SUCCESSFUL CONCLUSION. DESPITE THE ABILITY OF THE COMMUNISTS TO VERBALIZE DEFEAT INTO VICTORY, WE ANTICIPATE THAT THERE *ILL. BE INCREASING Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 13 SAIGON 9276 SECRET DISAFFECT ION WITHIN COMMUNISTS RANKS IF THE COMMUNIST POSIT ION AGA IN BEGINS TO DECLINE. THE VC DO NOT NECESSARILY HAVE TO WIN, BUT THEY DO NEED TO SHOW MOMENTUM IN THAT DIRECTION IF THEY ARE TO AVOID SUCH DISAFFECTION. 13. WE VIEW THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGN AS. BEING A CRUCIAL PERIOD FOR THE COMMUNISTS IN FORMULATING THEIR 'STRATEGY FOR THE FUTURE 0 THEY WILL PROBABLY MAKE 'A -'MAJOR ASSESSMENT OF THEIR POSIT ION AT THE CONCLUSION OF THE CAMPAIGN IF THEY HAVE NOT CONT INUED TO REAP ADVANTAGES IN THE WAR, AND SEE NO WEAKENING IN UNITED STATES AND GVN DETERMINATION, THEY MIGHT CONCLUDE THAT " VICTORY" AS DEFINED IN PARAGRAPHS 2-5 ABOVE IS NOT LIKELY, THUS ONE OF THE MOST IMPORTANT . RESULTS. OF THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGN COULD BE TO BRING THE COMMUNISTS CLOSER TOT HAT MOMENT OF TRUTH WHEN. THEY WILL HAVE TO MAKE BASIC DECISIONS CONCERNING THE FUTURE COURSE OF THE WAR, 14. IT IS IMPOSSIBLE AT THIS ST AGE TO .SAT WHAT HANOI MIGHT DEC IDE AT THE CONCLUSION OF . THE W INTER - SPR ING . CAM PA IGN THERE'S, OF COURSE, THE POSSIBILITY. THAT IT WOULD CONTINUE ALONG THE SAME COURSE AS. PRESENT PER-HAPS ONLY BECAUSE IT WOULD BE UNABLE TO COME TO A DECISION ON WHAT COURSE TO TAKE . Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 .7) PAGE 14 SAIGON 92 76 THE SITUATION IS NOT LIKELY TO BE ALL GOOD OR ALL BAD, AND IT MIGHT CALCULATE THAT ALL THAT IS NEEDED IS FOR ONE MORE HARD PUSH, PARTICULARLY IF COMMUNIST FORCES ST ILL HAD ACCESS TO MUCH OF THE COUNTRYSIDE AND HAD A STRONG BASE FOR WHICH TO LAUNCH THE PUSH. IF' THEY SENSE A WEAKENING OF THE HOME FRONT IN THE UNITED STATES, THEY MIGHT CALCULATE THAT NO RAD ICAL CHANGE FOR THE PRE-JET STRATEGY IS NEEDED THAT PROTRACTED STRUGGLE AIMED AT FRUSTRATING GVN /UN ITED STATES PACIFICATION GOALS WILL EVENTUALLY LEAD TO A FAVOR ABLE SETTLEMENT . 15, BEYOND MERELY CONTINUING WHAT THEY ARE DOING, THE COMMUNISTS WOULD HAVE THREE BASIC OPT IONS IF THEY, DECIDED TO ADOPT A NEW STRATEGY, THEY COULD DRAMATICALLY ESCALATE THE WAR, PERHAPS BY MOUNTING AN ALL-OUT OFFENSIVE FROM NORTH VIETNAM AGAINST SOUTH VIETNAM AND EVEN CALLING OF CHINESE COMMUNIST COMBAT TROOPS TO PROTECT NVN WE DO NOT BELIEVE THAT HANOI WOLD OPT FOR THIS STRATEGY; IT PROBABLY WOULD NOT CONSIDER THE PROSPECTS/ 01 SaCCESS AS PR7tING ; THE LIKELIHOOD OF MASSIVE UNITED STATES COUNTER-ACT ION WOULD BE VIEWED IN HANOI AS BEING HIGH; AND HA_N.Q.L. AL09,pT_ CERTAINLY 4 J ( Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 15 SAIGON 9276 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 DESIRES TO REMAIN MASTER OF ITS OWN DESTINY, A POSITION IT WOULD ENDANGER, IF NOT SACRIFICE, BY INVITING LARGE -SCALE CHINESE INTERVENT ION IN THE NORTH. NEVERTHELESS, IT SHOULD BE POINTED OUT THAT THE COMMUNISTS HAVE SHOWN THEMSELVES IN THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGN AND THE TET OFFENSIVE CAPABLE OF TAKING RATHER MOMENTOUS TURNS IN THE CONDUCT OF THE WAR. 16. RATHER THAN SIGNIFICANTLY EXCALATE THE WAR, WE THINK IT MORE LIKELY THAT THE NORTH VIETNAMESE LEADERS WOULD RENEW THE IR EFFORTS TO MANEUVER FOR SOME TYPE OF TAAKS NEGOTIATIONS.OR THERE ARE ALREADY SOME IND IV IONS THAT THEY ARE GINGERLY UNDERTAKING THIS TASK. ALTHOUGH THEY COULD VIEW SUCH TALKS SOLELY AS A RUSE WHICH WOULD ALLOW THEM A RESPITE IN WHICH TO RECOUP, WE BELIEVE IT MORE LIKELY THAT AT THIS STAGE THEY WOULD BE-WILLING TO GIVE SERIOUS CONSIDERAT ION TO THE POSSIBILITY OFA SETTLEMENT. PRESUMABLY, HANOI, IF IT CHOSE THIS APPROACH COULD COUNT ON THE ACTIVE ASSISTANCE OF THE SOVIET UNION. INDEED, THERE IS THE POSSIBILITY THAT MOSCOW VIEWING THE SITUATION AFTER THE WINTER-SPRING CAMPAIGN, WOULD- BE MORE WILLING TO TAKE A MORE ACTIVE ROLE IN COUNSELING HANOI TO BE FORTHCOMING CONCERNING SECRET .71 1.7.0i R Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 16 SAIGON 9276 NEGOTIATIONS, PEKING WOULD REMAIN OPPOSED TO THE IDEA OF TALKS, BUT WOULD BE VERY UNLIKELY TO TAKE ANY POSITIVE ACT ION AGAINST HANOI IF RIJ DECIDED TO TAKE THIS OPTION. 17, THE THIRD OPT ION OPEN TO HANOI WOULD BE TO RESORT TO GUERRILLA WARFARE AND GIRD FOR A LONG-TERM STRUGGLE. THIS OPTION, OF COURSE, IS NOT INCOMPATIBLE WITH NEGOTIATIONS SINCE IN NO EVENT WILL NORTH VIETNAM ABANDON ITS ULTIMATE GOAL OF DOMINATION AND REUNIFICATION OF VIETNAM UNDER COMMUNIST CONTROL. THE COMMUNISTS WOULD PROBABLY HAVE SOME D IFFICULTY IN SELLING THIS APPROACH TO ALL OF THEIR ADHERENTS IN THE SOUTH, BUT BY ITS VERY NATURE, PROTRACTED WAR DOES NOT REQUIRE A SUPER-ABUNDANCE OF PERSONNEL. IT DOES REQUIRE HOWEVER, A HARD CORE OF DEDICATED CADRES WHO ARE WILLING TO FOLLOW COMMUNIST DIRECTIVES NO MATTER WHAT, COME WHAT MAY. THE COMMUNISTS HAVE 9 AND UNDER ANY FORESEEABLE CIRCUMSTANCES, WILL CONTINUE TO .HAVE ENOUGH SUCH CADRE FOR THIS PURPOSE. FACTORS AFFECTING ABILITY OF GVN TO WITHSTAND NVA /VC PRESSURES 18. THE QUALITY AND COHESIVENESS OF POLITICAL AND MILITARY LEADERSHIP IS THE KEY FACTOR IN DETERMINING THE GVN 'S ABILITY TO WITHSTAND VC POLITICAL AND PSYCHOLOGICAL PRESSURES. --TSTELGA44_L Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 17 SA IGON 9276 SECRET THE GVN COULD STIMULATE AND GUIDE THE. CONSIDER ABLE ENERGIES AND TALENTS OF ITS PEOPLE IN A BROAD EFFORT AGAINST THE VIET CONG IF IT ENJOYED INSPIRATIONAL AND EFFICIENT DIRECTION AT THE TOP. THE PRE JT LEADERSHIP IS ABLE ENOUGH AND PROBABLY DEDICATED ENOUGH BUT IT IS NOT WORKING TOGETHER. MOREOVER, THE PRESIDENT LACKS THE INSPIRATIONAL QUALITIES SO NEEDED IN A COUNTRY AT WAR AND WEARY OF WAR AT THAT. HE LACKS A SENCE OF URGENCY AND SEEMS UNABLE OR UNWILLING TO DELEGATE AUTHORITY. ON MANY ISSUES HE IS INDECISIVE AND CAUTIOUS. HIS DIFFERENCES WITH VICE PRESIDENT KY, WHILE NOT INSURMOUNTABLE, ARE COMPLICATED BY SHARP DIVERGENCES OF PERSONALITY AND METHOD; THEY ARE AGGRAVATED BY AMBITIOUS AND SCHEMING COTERIES OF A SSOC ITES . KY COULD PROVIDE. BYNAMIC LEADERSHIP, BUT WHEN HE DOES ASSUME THAT ROLE HE IS SUSPECTED OF FURTHERING HIS PERSONAL POLITICAL POSITION. THE RECENT --r CR ISIS TEMPORARILY BROUGH4 AN APPEARANCE OF UNITY AT THE 'TOP, BUT THE SPL IT BETWEEN THE TWO SEEMS NOW TO HAVE BEEN AGGRAVATED DURING THE PAST TWO WEEKS. THE PRIME MINISTER IS INTELLIGENT BUT, LACKING GUIDANCE AND DIRECTION, IS INCAPABLE OF RUNNING A GOVERNMENT. Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 18 SAIGON 9276 CECR ET F. I 19. THE PROSPEAS ORM-IMPROVEMENT OVER THE COMING WEEKS AND)1ONT HS ARE NOT GOOD IT IS POSSIBLE THAT �LOC COULD BE REPLACED TO SOME ADVANTAGE BUT POL IT ICALLY VIABLE AND CAPABLE SUCCESSORS ARE NOT IDENTIFIABLE AT THE MOMENT. THE PRESIDENT MIGHT ENCOURAGE KY TO TAKE ADDITIONAL RESPONSI- BIL IT IES BUT THE LIKELIHOOD OF LIBERATING KY'S FULL ENERGIES ON TERMS ACCEPTABLE TO THIEU IS SMALL. THE PRESIDENT CONTINUES TO DEMONSTRATE A GOOD INTELLECT UAL GR ASP OF THE PROBLEMS FACING THE GOVERNMENT BUT WILL PROBABLY FAIL TO TAKE ACT IONS FOgEFUL ENOUGH OR EARLY ENOUGH TO TRANSLATE THA t UNDERSTAND IN73 INTO TRULY MEANINGFUL PROGRAMS.p "2JO A SECOND FACTOR IS THE ABILITY OF THE GVN 10 ZEAL WITH THE DESTRUCT ION AND DISLOCATIONS CA D BY THE T.ET OFFENSIVE� DESPITE POLITICAL WEAKNESSES AND MANAGER IAL PROBLEMS, THE GVN AS PRESENTLY CONST IT4D , FULLY BACKED BY THE UNITED STATES WITH PERSONNEL AND FUNDS, HAS BEEN ABLE TO PR OV IDE AN ACCEPTABLE LEVEL OF RELIEF AND RECONSTRCUT ION. THE IMMENSE TASK OF CARING FOR 500,000 EVACUEES AND RESUMING SOMETHING RESEMBL ING NORMAL ECONOMIC INTERCOURSE IN THE CIT IES HAS BEEN APPROACHED WITH REASONABLE EFFICIENCY AND ���-�:����" � Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 r -b ". L. Cri a' PAGE 19 SAIGON 92 76 SECRET DRIVE. THE SPECIAL COMMITTEE MECHANISM WORKED RATHER WELL. WHILE IT BENEFITTED FROM THE AMERICAN INPUT IT WAS IN MANY WAYS A VIETNAMESE SHOW. SLOW TO BEGIN OPERATIONS IN THE PROVINCES, THE COMMITTEE IS BEGINNING TO MOVE RESOURCES AND PROVIDE GUIDANCE TO THE COUNTRYSIDE. WHILE THERE WILL BE PERSISTING COMPLAINTS AND DISCONTENT, THE LEVEL PROBABLY WILL NOT BUILD TO A BREAKING POINT UNLESS A SECOND, OR THIRD, WAVE OF DEVASTATION HITS. UNDER THESE CONDITIONS THE GVN ADMINISTRATIVE MECHANISM WOULD BE SEVERELY TAXED. IF THE VC WERE, AT THAT TIME, BEATEN OFF AND A LENGTHY RESPITE EARNED, THE GVN COULD PROBABLY ST ILL MANAGE AN ACCEPTABLE EFFORT AT REHABILITATION. 21. THERE ARE MANY AMBIVALENCES IN ATTEMPTING TO ASSESS THE WILLINGNESS OF THE SOUTH VIETNAMESE MASSES AND ELITE TO SUPPORT THE GVN. ALTHOUGH THE VC GAINED NEW RESPECT FROM THE PEOPLE FOLLOWING THE TET OFFENSIVE, IT ALSO CREATED A STRONG FEELING OF ANTAGONISM TOWARD THEM, AND WE DOUBT THAT ATTACKS HAVE GAINED THEM MANY NEW FRIENDS. DURING THE PAST MONTH CONFIDENCE IN THE GVN HAS WEAKENED AND DISENCHANTMENT WITH THE AMERICAN PRESENCE HAS INCREASED, BUT THERE REMAINS 60 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 r f.71 '2�. a PAGE 20 SAIGON 9276 SECRET SOME APPRECIATION FOR THE FACT- THAT GVN /UNITED STATES FORCES DID, AFTER ALL, REPULSE THE ATTACK ON THE CIT IES AFTER REELING UNDER ITS INITIAL IMPACT, THOSE DIRECTLY AND ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY THE GVN/UNITED STATES COUNTERATTACK, ,SUCH AS DESTRUCT ION OF HOMES AND LOOTING, CONSTITUTE ONLY A 'SMALL PERCENTAGE OF THE POPULATION. THE PEOPLE AT 'LARGE REMAIN FEARFUL, INCREASINGLY WEARY, ANXIOUS FOR BREAK IN THE LONG TENSION. OUTWARDLY, THEIR DOMINANT REACT ION HAS BEEN, AND WILL PROBABLY REMAIN RESIGNATION AND PASSIVITY-STEMMING IN PART FROM THE ORIENTAL BELIEF IN AN INEXORABLE FATE, AND IN PART FROM A FEAR OF . BECOMING OPENLY INVOLVED WITH THE GOVERNMENT IN THE POSSIBLE PRESENCE OF THE UNKNOWN VC SYMPATHIZER . POPULAR � REPONSE 'TO FURTHER VC SUCCESSES, EVEN IF TEMPORARY, WILL PROBABLY BE FURTHER WITHDRAWAL. ALTHOUGH: THE PEOPLE ARE NOW MORE VULNERABLE TO ENEMY PSYCHOLOGICAL ATTACK, WE, DOUBT' THAT THE VC WILL BE ABLE TO MOBILIZE ANY ADDITIONAL SIGNIFICANT, VOLUNTARY SUPPORT. IN. THE NEAR FUTURE. IN THE FINAL ANALYSIS, THE URBAN MASSES DO NOT :WANT TO BE ASSOCIATED WITH THE LOSER, AND AT THIS POINT THE ALLIES' ABILITY TO RESTORE CONTROL IN THE CITIES PROBABLY IS THE Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 9A76 PAGE 21 SAIGON 02:= Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PREDOMINANT FACTOR IN THEIR ATTITUDE. 22. AMONG THE ELITE POLITICAL GROUPS THE PREDOMINANT TREND HAS BEEN TO SUPPORT THE GOVERNMENT AND CONDEMN THE VC, ALTHOUGH THE THIEU-KY SCHISM AND LACK OF 'DYNAMISM IN THE GVN WILL PROBABLY PREVENT THE DELELOPMENT OF AN ANTI- COMM UN IST FRONT FR ON REACHING IT S FULL POTENT IAL . WIT H IN THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY, A REFLECT ION OF BOTH EL ITE AND POPULAR OPINION, THE RESPONSE HAS BEEN GENERALLY CONSTRUCTIVE WITH BOTH HOUSES CALLING FOR A CLOSING OF RANKS. AT THE SAME TIME, THERE IS AN UNDERCURRENT OF CRITICISM-CURRENTLY SUPPRESSED IN THE INTEREST OF UNITY-AGAINST THE ARMY FOR ITS LACK OF PREPAREDNESS AND THE INCOMPETENCE OF SOME ARMY COMMANDERS, AND AGAINST THE GOVERNMENT FOR ITS INT I IAL INEFFECTUAL RESPONSE TO THE VC ASSAULT. HOWEVER THERE ARS NO DEEP CLEAVAGES BETWEEN THE EXECUTIVE AND THE LEGISLATIVE AND FOR THE SHORT TEEM, THE OUTLOOK FOR CONT INUED COOPERATION APPEARS GOOD. 23. THE MOST CRITICAL ELEMENT AMONG THE ELITE IS THE YOUNG OFFICERS GROUP, WHO ARE CHAFING OVER THE POOR QUALITY OF LEADERSHIP, THE LACK OF AN EFFECTIVE COMMANS STRUCTURE Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 L PAGE 22 SAIGON 9276 SECRET CONTINUED AND RAMPANT CORRUPTION, AND THE LACK OF AN AGGRESSIVE POSTURE ON THE PART OF AR VN . THESE OFFICERS APPEAR AWARE OF THE ADVERSE CONSEQUENCES OF A COUP, PARTICULARLY THE IMPACT IN THE UNITED ST ATES,AND DO NOT SEEM INCLINED TO MOVE AGAINST THE GOVERNMENT IN THIS MANNER . THEY ARE CONCERNED HOWEVER, THAT THE CONTINUED FAILURE ON THE PART OF THE TOP POLITICAL LEADERS TO SHOW GREATER PROGRESS WILL INCREASE SENTIMENT FOR A COALITION GOVERNMENT IN THE UNITED STATES, WHICH THEY REGARD AS A EUPHEMISM FOR DEFEAT. THEY APPEAR TO BE SEARCHING FOR WAYS TO BR ING PRESSURE TO BEAR FOR CHANGE WITHIN THE BROAD FRAMEWORK OF THE CURRENT SYSTEM. 24. WHILE DIFFICULT TO EXPRESS IT IN TERMS SUITABLE FOR A NATIONAL ESTIMATE, THE FACT REMAINS THAT THE GVN'S CAPABILITY TO FACE UP TO THE FUTURE VC CHALLENGE IS DIRECTLY RELEATED TO THE ABILITY AND W ILLINGNE SS OF TH# UNITED STATES TO APPLY "LEVERAGE" ON THE GVN LEADERSHIP TO MOVE FORWARD MORE RAPIDLY. THIS WOULD BE RESISTED BY THE VIETNAMESE, WHOSE SENSIBILITIES IN RESPECT TO AMERICAN INFLUENCE APPEAR TO HAVE INCREASED MARKEDLY DURING THE PAST SIX MONTHS. THE SPECIAL AGGRAVATIONS CAUSED BY RUM-Q_RS OF- ALLEGED AMERICAN 1 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 23 SAIGON 92 76SE CR E T Pt. CA THE SUSCEPTIBILITY TO A COALITION GOVERNMENT COMSIPPODTED 41;itiazg" AMER ICAN ROLE UP TO THE EVE OF THE T ET OFFENSIVE . HOWEVER 9 THE PROVIDING OF COUNSEL, RATHER. THAN D IRECT IVES TO THE VIETNAMESE GOVERNMENT HAS NOT PRODUCED ACT ION AND PROGRESS BROADLY OR RAPIDLY ENOUGH. IT IS POSSIBLE THAT ONLY A GREATER APPL ICAT ION OF LEVERAGE, TO WIT,AN IMPL IED IF NOT EXPLICIT INDICTION THAT FUTURE UNITED STATES SUPPORT IS CONTINGENT UPON THE ACCOMPL ISHEMENT OF ESSENTIAL AND STATED GOALS. IVEN VIETNAMESE SENSITIVITIES, IT IS FAR FROM CERTAIN THAT SUCiltA MOVE WOULD ACCOMPLISH THE DESIRED RESULT- THE VIETNAMESE PR INC IPLCS, CONFIDENT THAT THE UNITED STATES COULD NOT SIMPLY PULL OUT MIGHT WELL FEEL THAT THEIR HONOR AND SELF-RESPECT DEMANDED A REJECT ION OF SUCH BLATENT AMERICAN PRESSURE. ANY INCREASED PRESSURE ON THE VIETNAMESE WOULD HAVE TO BE ACCOMPANIED BY INCREASED SUPPORT, IF NOTHING ELSE AS EVIDENCE OF OUR INTENT IONS TO REMAIN BY THEIR SIDE. 25 FROM A MILITARY STANDPOINT, THERE ARE NUMEROUS, WEAKNESSES IN THE GVN ' S ARMED FORCES WHICH WILL AFFECT ITS ABILITY TO WITHSTAND FUTURE VC PRESSURES. AR VN IS NOT EXPLOITING ITS OPPORTUNITIES TO PURSUE THE ENEMY AGGRESSIVELY Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681 PAGE 24 SAIGON 9276 SE CR E T AT A TIME WHEN HE IS IN AN EXPOSED POSITION, OPERATING FAR FROM HIS BASES, AND AT A LOW LEVEL OF COMBAT EFFECTIVENESS, INSTEAD THE GVN FORCES HAVE PULLED BACK INTO THE CITIES INTO A GENERALLY PASSIVE, DEFENSIVE POSTURE. THIS IS A REFLECT IONX POOR AND UNAGGRESSIVE LEADERSHIP WHICH RANGES FROM THE HIGH COMMAND ON DOWNWARD, ALTHOUGH THIS IS BY NO MEANS UNIVERSAL. THE CONFIDENCE OF THE ARVN FORCES IS ALSO REPORTED TO BE BADLf SHAKEN IN THE FACE OF SUPERIOR FIREPOWER DEMONSTRATED BY EVEN THE LOCAL VC FORCES, AND THE INCREASING APPEARANCE OF HEAVY ARMAMENT AMONG THE ENEMY FORCES. THE STEPPED-UP MOBILIZATION DECREE AND THE CHANGE IN TWO CORPS COMMANDERS AND APPARENTLY SEVERAL PROVINCE CHIEFS WERE STEPS IN THE RIGHT IRECT ION BUT AN ACCELERATED CAMPAIGN TO REMOVE INEFFECTUAL UNIT COMMANDERS AND PROVINCE CHIIS, AN IMPROVEMENT IN THE COMMAND STRUCTURE, BETTER COORDINATION BETWEEN UNITED STATES ANDiARVN AT THE CORPS AND DIVISION LEVEL, AND IMPROVED WEAPONRY FOR THE GVN MILITARY, PARAMILITARY AND POLICE FORCES AR ESSENT IAL IF THE INITIATIVE AGAINST THE VC IS TO BE REGAINED. Approved for Release: 2019/04/17 C06786681