ARGENTINE - PARAGUAYAN RIVER NAVIGATION PROBLEMS REACH NEW STAGE WITH ARGENTINE SUSPENSION OF ACT OF BUENOS AIRES.

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP08C01297R000800100005-0
Release Decision: 
RIFPUB
Original Classification: 
C
Document Page Count: 
15
Document Creation Date: 
December 23, 2016
Document Release Date: 
October 16, 2012
Sequence Number: 
5
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
July 28, 1965
Content Type: 
CABLE
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP08C01297R000800100005-0.pdf1.37 MB
Body: 
N N " I ZD 1. Text of Argentine Note of June 15, 1965. 2. Statement by Sr. Vidal Bedoya. 3. Text of Paraguayan Note of June 30, 1965. 4. Argentine Note of July 22, 1965. 5. Report of Press Conference by Foreign Minister Sapena Pastor. GROUP 3 Downgraded at 12-year intervals, not aut-aztically declassified. Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 "R TO : DEPARTMENT OF STATE INFO BUENOS AIRES DATE: 1F ly 28, 4965 FROM Amembassy ASUNCION 'v r SUBJECT: Argentine - Paraguayan River Navigation Problems~zReach New Stage With Argentine Suspension of Act of Buenos Aires. REF :.Embtel 30;.Embassy's,A-376; Weekas 23, 24 and?25. Summary The Act of. Buenos Aires, signed in February.1964, was proclaimed as facilitating Paraguay's. access to the sea by easing Argentine' restrictions on the use of the Parand River. This airgram summarizes the recent events leading up to,the Argentine suspension of the Act of Buenos Aires on July 22. The immediate economic effect of the denunciation on Paraguayan river commerce is negligible as neither of the two. important features of the Act, i.e., use of Paraguayan pilots on Paraguayan vessels, and amplification of free port facilities in Buenos Aires, had been realized. Politically the Argentine action represents the renewed salting of old wounds. The incident also represents a trial for Paraguayan Foreign Minister SAPENA Pastor, already under attack for the Foreign Ministry's,. handling of the affair., Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 CONFIDENTIAL Page 2, A- 3 7 from Asuncion Background The Embassy's airgram referred to above, and the previous reports referenced therein, report the prolonged story of Paraguay's attempts to obtain recognized and unrestricted access to the sea from the Argentines. The most recent act of this century-long drama commenced with the signing of the Acta de Buenos Aires on February 7, 1964. The drawn-out negotiations necessary to implement this act, and the Paraguayan dissatisfaction with the eventual Argentine implementing regulations, have constituted a continuing source of frustration for the Paraguayan Foreign Ministry. The recent developments leading to the current impasse had'their origin when Argentine port authorities at Corrientes stopped one Paraguayan vessel, on May 24 and another on May 31. After some hours of delay while the Argentines inspected the ships' papers and cargo the vessels were allowed to proceed to the port of Asunc16n. Both of the vessels belonged to the Paraguayan State Merchant Fleet (Flota Mercante del Estado). In a press conference on June 5 Sr. Vidal BEDOYA, the Administrator of the State Merchant Fleet, was reported as decrying the."abusive attitude of the Argentine authorities which constitute a flagrant attack on the principle of free navigation." He maintained that "A vessel which has sailed from an Argentine port with the required documentation cannot be detained or delayed under any pretext, and not in any case to check cargo in transit-destined to an international port, which is the case of the vessels of our fleet which travel from Rio de la Plata to Asunc16n." Foreign Minister Sapena Pastor described the Argentine action as "truly arbitrary and an abuse" and announced that he had directed the Paraguayan Ambassador in Buenos Aires to express the GOP's complaint to the Argentine Foreign Office. The Paraguayan note was delivered on June 10. On June 15 the. Argentine reply was given to the Paraguayan Ambassador. The Argentines asserted their authorities deemed it necessary to verify that the Paraguayan? vessels still included in their cargoes large quantities of foreign cigarettes taken aboard in Buenos Aires. The Argentine note proceeded to specify incidents in which cigarettes consigned to Asunc16n firms had been smuggled into Argentina and affirmed that the detentions resulted as a legitimate exercise of its police powers. The text of the Argentine note is. transmitted as enclosure (1). The Argentine note brought a prompt and impassioned response from the Administrator of the Paraguayan Merchant Fleet. In a letter directed to Foreign Minister Sapena Pastor and released to the local press, Fleet Administrator Bedoya rejected what he described as the unjustified allegations of the Argentine reply. Denying that vessels of the Merchant Fleet were involved in contraband he charged that under private law the Argentine statements would be criminal defamation. The text of Sr. Bedoya's statement is transmitted.as enclosure (2). CONFIDENTIAL Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 CONFIDENTIAL Page 3, A- S 7 from Asunc ion The Foreign Minister privately took a somewhat less adamant line on the matter. In a conversation with our Charge at the time he indicated that he was less than satisfied with the Fleet's response and that he-did not reject so categorically the allegations that the Fleet might be involved in contraband activities. He did maintain, however, that the cargo operations of the Fleet were not the concern of the Argentine authorities. The Paraguayans responded to the Argentine note on June 30. However strong Sapena Pastor's personal doubts on the integrity of the Fleet there.. is little evidence of moral uncertainty in.the Paraguayan reply which describes the Argentine actions as "unnecessarily rigorous" and "characterized by arbitrariness." Further, it was stated that the GOP "would not recognize the application of measures, however legal in Argentina, which tended to restrict Paraguay's right' of communication, navigation, and transportation ,via the Paran&/ to and from Paraguay." The text of the Paraguayan note is transmitted as enclosure (3). Of little relevance but of direct importance to the larger issue was the annual visit of the Argentine War College to Asuncion during the last week of June. In their. customary interview with President Alfredo STRQESSNER on June 30, which was reported in unusual detail in the Colorado Party newspaper, Patria, the President repeated the standard Paraguayan complaint against the connivance of the Argentine military' in the guerrilla raids on Paraguayan territory by exile groups (1959-1960). Specifically mentioning General Carlos TORANZO Montero and other Argentine military chiefs involved, President. Stroessner stated that although they are anti-communists they nevertheless promoted the infiltration of communism into Paraguay. It subsequently became apparent that the President's remarks were not well received in Argentina., Argentine Suspension of-the Act of Buenos Aires On July 22 Argentina delivered its response to the Paraguayan note of June 30. The note, delivered in Buenos Aires, restates Argentina's claim to sovereignty over the Parana River. It notes that the Act of Buenos Aires had granted Paraguay its objectives; the use of Paraguayan pilots on Paraguayan vessels and greater free trade zone facilities in Buenos Aires. It expresses surprise that the Paraguayans objected to the GOA's exercise of its police powers to such an extent that it would not recognize measures, legal in Argentina, which tended to restrict Paraguay's river navigation rights. Further, that such an attitude would lead a Paraguayan vessel to refuse to embark an Argentine official. The Argentine note also expresses concern over statements made at "high levels" of the GOP casting.aspersions upon senior officers of the Argentine military. Stating that the measures taken by the Argentine authorities were necessary to prevent "vast and international" contraband, the. Argentine note states that they could largely be avoided if the Paraguayans CONFIDENTIAL Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08C01297R000800100005-0 CONFIDENTIAL Page 4, A_ 3 from Asuncion would study with them measures for the suppression of such contraband. Finally, the GOA concludes that due to the circumstances cited, the planned improvement of the free port area would be postponed and that Paraguayan vessels passing through Argentine rivers would be required to use Argentine pilots as "they have been doing to the present moment." A copy of the text is.included.as enclosure (4). Paraguayan Reaction to.Argentine Move The immediate Paraguayan reaction to the Argentine denunciation of the Act of Buenos Aires was one of shock. Foreign Minister Sapena Pastor was quoted .by Patria as saying the Argentine note was "truly surprising" and;again.repeating the Paraguayan thesis that the Parana is an international river, that Argentine sovereignty over the Parana is not absolute but subject to servitudes, that undenied police jurisdiction should not serve as a base for arbitrary acts,, and that Argentina does not have the right to suspend the Act of Buenos Aires which assures to Paraguay "the minimum rights belonging to a mediterranean country." The press report of the Foreign Minister's remarks are transmitted, as enclosure (5). The'opposition political parties have not yet reacted to the most recent Argentine note. It is of interest, however, that their earlier reaction to the Argentine note of June 15 was largely to accept the Argentine allegations of contraband at face value and to use.the incident as one more example of corruption within the government. Both the Levi-Liberals La Libertad and the Febreristas El Pueblo pointed editorial fingers at the State Fleet for jeopardizing the interests of the nation. In view of the tone of the recent Argentine note, however, it is expected that they probably will rally as Paraguayans to the national cause, or. at least temper their criticism of the. administration. Congressional leaders Dr. J. Augusto SALDIVAR and Dr. Luis Maria ARGA iA of the governing Colorado Party have published a resolution which they will present to a special session of the National Congress July 28 "emphatically condemning" the attitude of the Argentines. A Foreign Ministry source claims that student demonstrations have been avoided, and that the. GOP has prevented the stoning of the Argentine Embassy, and stopped public rallies. However, a student rally has been announced for July 27 at which Dr. Emilio SAGUIER Aceval will speak (see below). Immediate Consequences of the Argentine Move The suspension of the Act of Buenos Aires will have practically no immediate economic effect on Paraguayan river commerce. As of the present time Paraguayan-vessels passing through those parts of the Parana under Argentine jurisdiction are still piloted by-Argentine river pilots and the facilities of the Paraguayan free port area in Buenos Aires reportedly have not yet been CONFIDENTIAL Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08C01297R000800100005-0 Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 CONFIDENTIAL Page 3, A-3 7 from Asuncion .The Foreign Minister privately took a somewhat less adamant line on the matter. In a conversation with our Charge at the time he indicated that he. was less. than. satisfied with the Fleet's response and that he did not reject. so categorically the.allegations that the Fleet might be involved in contraband activities. He did maintain, however, that the cargo operations of the Fleet were not the concern of the Argentine authorities. The-Paraguayans responded to the Argentine note on June 30. However , strong Sapena Pastor's personal doubts on the integrity of the Fleet there. is little . evidence.. of. moral uncertainty in.the Paraguayan reply which describes the Argentine actions as. "unnecessarily rigorous" and "characterized by arbitrariness." Further; it was-stated that the GOP "would not recognize the application'of.measures, however legal in Argentina, which tended to restrict Paraguay's right . of. communication, navigation, and transportation Lvia the Parand/ to and from Paraguay." The text of the Paraguayan note is transmitted as enclosure (3). Of little relevance but of direct importance to the larger issue was the annual visit of the Argentine War College to Asuncion during the last week.of June. In their customary interview with President Alfredo STROESSNER on June 30, which was reported-in unusual detail in the Colorado Party newspaper, Patria, the President repeated the standard-Paraguayan complaint against the connivance of the Argentine military in the guerrilla raids on Paraguayan territory by exile.groups (1959-1960). Specifically mentioning General Carlos.TORANZO Montero and other-Argentine military chiefs involved, President Stroessner stated that although they are anti-communists they nevertheless promoted the infiltration of communism into Paraguay. It subsequently became apparent that the President's remarks.were not well received in Argentina. Argentine Suspension of the Act of Buenos Aires On July 22-Argentina delivered its response to the Paraguayan note of June 30. The.note, delivered in Buenos Aires, restates Argentina's claim to sovereignty over the Parand.River. It notes that the Act of Buenos Aires had granted' Paraguay its objectives; the use of Paraguayan pilots on Paraguayan.. vessels and greater free trade zone facilities in Buenos Aires. It expresses surprise that the. Paraguayans objected to the GOP's exercise of its police powers to such an extent that it would not recognize measures, legal in Argentina, which tended to restrict Paraguay's river navigation rights. Further, that such an attitude would lead a Paraguayan vessel to refuse to embark an Argentine official. The Argentine note also expresses concern over statements made at "high.levels".of the GOP casting. aspersions upon senior officers of the Argentine military. Stating that the. measures taken by the Argentine authorities-were necessary to prevent "vast and international" contraband, the. Argentine.note states that.they could largely be avoided if the Paraguayans CONFIDENTIAL Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 CONFIDENTIAL Page 4, A--3- I from Asuncion would study with them measures for the suppression of such contraband. Finally, the GOA concludes that due to the circumstances cited, the planned improvement of the free port area would be postponed and that Paraguayan vessels passing through Argentine rivers would be required to use Argentine pilots-as "they have been doing to the present moment." A copy of the text is included,as enclosure (4). Paraguayan Reaction to.Argentine Move The immediate Paraguayan reaction to the Argentine denunciation of the Act of Buenos Aires was one of shock. Foreign Minister Sapena Pastor was quoted by Patria as saying the Argentine note was "truly surprising" and again.repeating the Paraguayan thesis that the Parana is an international river, that Argentine sovereignty over the Parancl is not absolute but subject to servitudes, that undenied police jurisdiction should not serve as a base for arbitrary acts, and that Argentina does not have the right to suspend the Act of Buenos Aires which assures to Paraguay "the minimum rights belonging to a mediterranean country." The press report of the Foreign Minister's remarks are transmitted as enclosure (5). The'opposition political parties have not yet reacted to the most recent Argentine note. It is of interest, however, that their earlier reaction to the Argentine note of June 15 was largely to accept the Argentine allegations of contraband at face value and to use the incident as one more example of corruption within the government. Both the Levi-Liberals La Libertad and the Febreristas El Pueblo pointed editorial fingers at the. State Fleet for jeopardizing the interests of the nation. In view of the tone of the recent Argentine note,. however, it is expected that they probably will rally as Paraguayans to the national cause, or at least temper their criticism of the administration. Congressional leaders Dr. J. Augusto SALDIVAR and Dr. Luis Maria ARGAJTA of the governing Colorado Party have published a resolution which they will present to a special session of the National Congress July 28 "emphatically condemning" the attitude of the Argentines. A Foreign Ministry source claims that student demonstrations have been avoided, and that the GOP has prevented the stoning of the Argentine Embassy, and stopped public rallies. However, a student rally has been announced for July 27 at which Dr. Emilio SAGUIER Aceval will speak (see below). Immediate Consequences of the Argentine Move The suspension of the Act of. Buenos Aires will have practically no immediate economic effect on Paraguayan river cmnmerce. As of the present time Paraguayan vessels passing through those parts of the Parana under Argentine jurisdiction are still piloted by Argentine river pilots and the facilities of the Paraguayan free port area in Buenos Aires reportedly have not yet been. CONFIDENTIAL Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 CONFIDENTIAL Page 5, A-`~ from Asuncion improved. This does not discount the fact, however, that Paraguay stood to save in the future a considerable sum annually in fees paid to Argentine river pilots had the Act been fully, implemented; nor does it deny that improved transshipment facilities in. Buenos Aires are badly needed. The immediate significance of the Argentine action is political, especially as it effects internal Paraguayan politics. Foreign Minister Rail: SAPENA Pastor has been the object of cons.idorable criticism in regard to the unsuccessful conclusion of the negotiations which preceded the implementing regulations of the Act of Buenos Aires. Much of this criticism has come from Dr. Emilio Saguier Aceval,. editor of the two semi-official tabloids El Pais and La Tarde, and known to harbor aspirations for Sapena Pastor's job. (Emb A-435, April 10,'1965). The recent Obi. action may well give added fuel to the fire that Saguier Aceyal apparently delights in lighting under Sapena Pastor. .. For the Ambas ors l e M. Poienmire Second Secretary of Embassy OOXFIDENTIAL Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 UR%o" 1QQ.LZ li.L raye7 t, G4L' J. a t, n J 11 t LL liesuiLatvi1 .7 `. Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 r LA TRIBUNA _. A.sunc16n, Jaws 17 de Jun lo 1965 5 01NOCESE EL TEXTO DE LA RESPUESTA ARGENTINA A PROTESTA PARACUAYA Reproducimos a continua "Queda, an consecuencia, - ci6n el texto de la nota res Como materia de considers- puesta del gobierno argen-jci6n, los hechos consigiladosi tine, dado a conocer por less an la nets, quo contests cu_ - "Adem&s,, - procedimientos de fechas innlediatamente an Como el qua se lle- teriores , v6 a cabo el 13 de abril timo por personal de la Bub- mo se recordara la misma prefectura de Puerto Nuevo, trades por less autoridades nor fue motivada por una nota cfonales pertinentes easy esta determinaron la incautaciu protesta entregada al Minis- . Cancilleria, sod;,-las siguien- de 8.977 cartones de cigarri- terio de Relaciones Exterio-'ten:?~ llos de procedencia extran- res y Culto por el Dr. Augus- "En, el cash, la Chi -do jera, cuyo destino debi6 ha- to R. Fuster, Embajador del bandera paraguaya "Guru- bar sido la Ciudad de Asun- Paraguay, eumplieedo instruc ?paity", la misma fue despa- ci6n pero fueron ilegalmente clones de ]a Cancilleria Na- chada an Buenos Aires con desviados a introducidos an cional, Como consecuencia destino al Puerto do Asun- la Argentina segun consta an de la detenciOn de buques ci6n y escala an el puerto el sumario judicial numero de la Flota Mercante del Es de Corrientes, a remolque del; 404C0 con intervenci6n del tado en el Puerto de Co- vapor de igual bandera "Pi- sefior juez national de 1s, ::cnt.es y sobre la que se ? rabeb6", Ilevando a bordo un instancia en lo penal econ6- cieron amplias referencias. cargamento de 3.000 cajones mico, doctor Julio Gonzalez La nota a que aludimos de cigarrillos extranjeros an Goytfa, secretarfa del doctor fue entregada por el Canci- trdnsito. La eitada chats, a.rri Federico Fauz6n. Sefialo a Her Dr. Zavala Ortiz al Em- h6 al Puerto de Corrientes V. E. que an dicho caso, las bajador Pfister an entrevista integrando un convoy forma- mercaderias venfan consigna- habida anteayer an el Pala- do, ademds, por el reniolca das a firmas comerciales ra- cio "San Martin". Dice asi , dor "Itacuruby" y la chats diadas an ese Pais, textualmente: "Pikisiry" habidndose modi4l. -`Circunstancias similares "Tengo el honor de dirt- ficado el despacho origins Moron lugar a sendas inter- girme a V. E. con referen- sin intervenci6n de la auto- venciones policiales los dias cia a su nota del 10 del ac- ridad competente motive 2 y 12 de mayo ppdo; En la- tual, an la que trasmiti6 una por el cual se instruyen ]as primera oportunidad se se- protests. formal de su gobierI actuaciones correspondien cuestraron 19.964 cartones de no, relatives a -procedimien ten. cigarrillos a interc]ictaron tos llevado3 a Cabo por la "Asimismo, la jefatura de ot1os 57.01$; instru'y etose-et Prefectura National Marfti- la 8ubprefectnra de Corrien sumario judicial numero 8165 ma, an el `puerto de la ciu- ten procedi6 a; efectuar la ve con intervenci6n del juez dad de Corrientes, an bar- i rificaci6n de la carga men- nacional de primera instan- cos de bandera paraguaya. cionada, medfante una comi- cia an to penal econbmico, "En dicha presentaci6n se sf6n integrada por funciona- doctor Sdrsfield Otero, se- alude a circunstancias y de- rios e la DirecclOn Nacio- ,cretarfa del doctor Agustin talles a los quo he de referir- nal dde Aduanas y de la au- Durafiona y Vedia. En el ter- me, despuds de haber consi- toridad marftima y al com-cor procedimlento, efectuado derado el aspecto mss im- probarse, medlante un calcu- an esta capital, se Incautaron portante que, a mi entender, , Io estima.tivo, qua conducfa 1.977 cartones de cigarrillos subordina y condiciona la co- la misma carga declarada, I de origen extranjero. En es- rrecta apreciaciOn de los mis- se autoriz6 la prosecuct6n tors dos uitimas ocasiones, co mos. del viaje. I mo en el primer ca.so citado, "La Prefectura National "En el caso del buque de los productos que ingresaron Maritima Argentina ha ajus- motor de bandera paraguaya a Is, Argentina, on contra- tado invariablemente sus pro "Rio Blanco" el mismo zar-i bando, estaban consignados cedimientos al estricto cum- p6 del Puerto de Buenos Al- tambidn a firmas domicilia- plimiento de has normas que I res con destino al de Asun- dada an Asunci6n del. Para- rigen sus actividades, tales ci6n, con Linica escala an Co guay enya identifieacidn como las contenidas an el Lrrientes conduciendo a su consta an surnariog instrui- Digesto Maritime -y Fluvial, bordo 1.400 cajones de ciga- dos al respecto. sin aplicar jam'as criterion rrflios extranjeros an trdnsi- "Estimo que lea hechos re discriminatorios, respecto a to. Tambi6n an esta oportu- latados llevard?n al dnimo de la bandera de las embarca- nidad se orden6 la verifica- V. E. la absoluta conviction ciones verificadas, ni de sin ci6n, con intervenci6n de lai de que las medidas de vigi- guna otra `naturaleza. Tanto Aduana local. lancia adoptadas an los ca- por sentido del derecho que ! "En consecuencia, debo ex nos de 1 a s embarcaciones nos rige Como por el amis- presar a V. 9, quo una con- Curupaity" y "Rio Blanco", toso respeto qua guards, mos frontaci6n analitica de las in tuvieron el 16gico fundamen- para todos, absolutamente to formaciones me permits con-, to qua surge de la lectura dos los pafses, serfa imposi- cluir, an primer lugar, que de las razones expuestas y, ble que agentes de la Naci6n ? no existen motiva.ciones que primordialmente, per la cir- argentina hiciesen diferen- respalden la presentaci6n de cunstancia de qua las mar- cia.s o distinciones de nacio- una protestor diplomdtica; an cas de indivfdualizaciOn de nalidades, menos a$n an detri-t tes Bien, las actuaciones, co- la mercaderfa transportada mento del Paraguay, al cual mil mo manifestd con anteriori- correspondfan a las mismas gobierno lejana y. reciente-i dad, revelaron qua se produ-i firmas comerciales paragua- mente ba dado pruebas caba-1 jo la modification -per par- yas a has Qua iban destina- les de consideraciOn y afec-I to de una embarcaciOn pare. dos los eargamentos quo pre to. La Prefectura National I guaya-, del despacho rorigi- tendieron ingresarse.a la Repu Maritima, pues, se ha limita- nab sin la debida autoriza- blica an contrabando, siendo do al ejercicio del poder do ci6n oficial, per lo quo se seeuestrados mediante los policfa y continuard, ejerci6n instruyen has actuaciones ya procedimlentos policiales del dolo, como potestad quel mencionadas. 13 de abril y-del 12 de mayo emana de la soberanfa na- ( U1 de_ 1965 cional. i7- /V rf - "Convenes L. ante ta- lea antecedentes; an la `ne cesidad de aunar esfuerzos en la lucha contra at con- trabando, prop6sito para el cual, rettero a Iii ilustrado gobierno, is mejor di$posi- ci6n de las autoridadee de `4a Prefectura National Mariti. ma Para coordinar con las autoridades paraguayas, la major forma do combatir, dentro de los respectivos din bites jurisdiccionales, aqua Has perniciosas actividades. "No puedo, an consecuen- cia coadyuvar a la concre- ci6n de less meRidae que V. E. solicita por parte del. gA- bierno argentine, a fin -,do evitar, Como el sefior emba- jador expresa, la repetidiOn de procedimientos Como los a,puntados, yes que, ellos cons- tituyen medioo :legales de prevenciOn y reprrgsi6n ._-de actos:delictivos, con cuyafilra das has informactones qu61-le tvasmitb". - _ , Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 S+A+aman+ by Rr- Vidal Aedova_ Administrator of the Paraavavan State Merchant Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24_ CIA-RDPO8CO1297ROO0800100005-0 rLa NotAjentina es de un Refinamiento Perverso Dice Nora , de Flog: Mercante En informe elevado a la prolongation de bodegas. con Caneileria Nacional, el Ad- servan su individualidad, a ministrador General de la los efectcs de su docuztsen- Ilut.a Mercante del Estadc, tociOn. Asi to estableetr el Sr. Vidal Bedoya, refuta car- articulo 19 de nuestro C6di- gos insidiosos de. la gancille- go Fluvial Y Maritime. que ria del vecino pals. El texto dispose: "Las embarcaciones del informe que fue entrega- I sin propulsion propia que na- do a PATRIA ayer a medio-. 'vegan en convoy conserva- dia, dice lo siguiente: ran su individualidad 2 los "SENOR MINISTRO: - Ten- go el honor de dirigirme a V.E. avisando recibo del ofi cio D.P.I. N? 21 de la fecha, relacionado a nuestra nota N? 706 &1 4 del corriente. En atencidn a los informes requeridos en vuestro expre sado oficio crimpleme mani festar a V.E. 10 sigu.iiente: 1?) La Gabarra "CURUPAY TY" fue despachada del Auer to de Buenos Aires en fecha 18 de Mayo, a remolque del b'm "PIRABEBE" eon desti no a Asuncion y escala en Co. rrientes, tal Como se expresa en el rol de tripulaci6n de la citada embarcacidn. Es ^_ier- to que dicha Gabarra llego al Puerto de Corrientes ante grando un iconvoy formado. ademds, por la Gabarra "P1 KYSYRY" a remolque del Re molcador "ITACURUBI". 2^) Despues de zarpar de Buenos Aires, la `CURUPAY- TY''; a remoique del "PIRA. BEBE", Ia Agenoia de la F1ota dispuso, por razones operativas, que al ilegar a Santa Fe, Ia Gabarra "CURU- PAYTY" pasara a formar par ? to de on convoy juntamente con In Gabarra "PIKYSYRY", que estaba cargando trigo, a ser remolcadas ambas por el Remolcador "ITACURUBI", one se encontraba en el mis- mo Puerto, quedando asi el "PIRABEBE" libre Para otra c peraci6n. No se produjo una modi- ficaci6n del despacho origi- nal, por dificultades, de ca- r: cter formal, en la redac- ci6n de esta clase de docu. mentaciones, por no saber podido preverse, antes de la s.lida del Puerto de Buenos Aires, al cambio del Remol- c:dor. La operaci6n de cambio de Remolcador es frecuentt v normal en la navegaci6n, or lo cual estd iconsagrado en el Derecho Maritimo que las embarcaciones sin propulsion propia, que forman parte de on convoy de, las que no son efectos de su documenta- cion..." Asi frecuentemente ocurre que por razones de fuerza mayor, de.seguridad-tde ave- `rias " cnicas o de simp le' convenie 1Cia, oce rativa, se producers";t"ambios de remoi= ceder de un convoy. Las embarcaciones que for man parte-de un convoy tie- nen, repetimos, su documen- taci6n independiente en cuan to a cargamento, personal, etc. No constituye ninguna irregularidad sensurable o punible un cambio de Re- molcador. James las autori- dades Maritimas Argentinas han hecho cuesti6n alguna por dichos carnbios, en veces anteriores, asi como tampoco lo han reecho nuestras auto- ridades cuando estos cambios se han operado en buques de bandera argentina. La costumbre se hate Ley en Dereche Maritime, que es- emineritemente.tabnsuetudina- rio, mdxime cuando'esta cos-. tumbre tiende a agilizar e1 transporte y reducir sus cos tos operatives. Es la labor en que estamos afanosamen to empenados en el dmhito del a -OEA, de ALALC y v: gtra8;pui tc s-,nrgbnt nos, por ALAMAR, En coeto, no hubo mo- riificacion'ile 4espacho, Como pretende ,1a noia argentine sine a . m .s una omision de consigner en el rol de -la Gabarra "CURUPAYTY" que, a parti '.. de Santa Fe debia seguir a remolque de otra embarcatci6n distinta del que la rtemolcd hasta dicho puer- to, omisi6n excusable porlas' razones expuestas antecedes temente y porque en nada, absolutamente en nada, al- tera la documentaci6n que ampara la embarcacion. La nrueba de nuestro acer- to estd,"?en que las autorida- des argentinas en su proce- dimiento, no formularon nin" guna observation de haberse producido is tal modification de despacho, en el caso de la "CURUPAYTY", circxtrts- tenido el "RIO BLANCO" al dificaci6n alguna, tai como que`esto significa una cpe- rucidn de cabotaje que esta reservada tinica y exciusiva- meinte a lop bisques de'=niche nacionalidad. Por un,,error de expresi6n se pone -en el rol, por exigencia de Ins.au- `toridades argentinas, "Escala en Corrientes", pues hater eseala implicarfa: operar, que, como tenemos explica- do, nos estd vededo, 44) En Los proeedui lentos realizados en el Puerto de Bifenos Aires a lus que alu de la Nota :de- la Ca gille ria "Argen"tina, absolutamen to na.da tiene Que- otr ]as embarcarciones de la Plota Mercante del ~Estado, -.? Segun hemos ?podido in formarnos, ya despuds de -esta insidiosa alusl6n,?es un problema, que atai e..a bu I ques de ultramar y a lap an toridades portuarias argen tinas, y Los sumarios''exclaL: e cerd,n seguramente, el gra do de res+ponsabilidad que incumbe a unos y otros. En la nota argentina no -se dice desdgkluego -que es tuvieran impWicados, 3rcos de la. F1ofa 31ercantg-del Es, tatty en lea sendas interven- clones policiales a que die- ron Lugar los contrabandos. :de, cigarrillos en ese Auer `,to, pues de existir tai int plicancia, otras h.uhtesen si' do la situhe 6n de -nuestra, 1Flota - oe 'oe (Pasa a la 8U PY .g.) Mercante no hacen escala en el puerto de Corrientes OZ. Puerto es al solo efecto de subir o bajar 1oa, b queancs argentinos 44ue ~t!$t an en nuestras embarcaof~s. Des- de luego las et2ibarcaciones de bandera paraguaya no pue den recibir cargas, en puer- tos argentinos, destinadas a uNCLAsszg_ Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297ROO0800100005-0 YTA OT.ARRTVT.1 T) Pecre 2- Encl. 2. A-.R q from .Asuncion Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 La Notla Argent (De la 14L Pag.) No podemos reprocbarle semejante c.ilumnia, Pero el, atribuirle un refinamieu to perVerso en la redaccl6n de an nota por hechar u11a. aombra, en 'forma, velada, digamos pia;dosl, hacia nues tra Flota, ad rel: rionar esos hechos do contra.bando en las que aabsolutamente nada tenemas que,ver, y que.'han de ser uno de los miles en gtfe a dia?rio descubren en ese puerto,. con el transpor to de cargas de cigarrillos que en forma normal y co. rrecta' efeetuaran buques de nuestra Flot.a, cuyo nir g gpto f ieron verificados ly encontrados de "Confor midad" por las autoridades .argentinas, en ocasi6n del .., Into y airbitrario proce dinliento coritr, el cual- he: mos levanta i i neetra voz de, protests,:, Y decimos que 1a. red ac cidn do Is, nota arg~entina es die un refinamlento. perver .so, porque al leer Is note argentina,.,,aun' md?s avisa do, ha-de *I e> sar que Ai las redadas de eras intervencio nes,-.polici.,les, a que ,elude la; ?nota,:'?cayeron ' bareos de 1a! 'Flota, culpables de con trabando! y que con justa razdn.las. autoridades argen tinas podrian. desconflar de nue.'vo y' con sobrados,, Jere cho reviser el.coutenido de las egas de nuestroa bar cos .. ,.,. ... . Elena dedtccidn ' aefior Mi nistro, que hake eugerir .la nota argentina,configure un pensamiento II.nfasne, que on el Dereeho, Privado -,darf.i lugar a. una aeci6n criminal_. por dtfamaci6u, por , to . que tea,nuestro.de!b,gr...formular nue?tra vIva;. Y' endrgica pro tests., d?audo.a conocer a la opinion national y a la de todo el Continente, que la Flota Mercante. es victima de ? tna imputiici6ln malevo lente resultants de la' rota de la Canvilierfa, Argentina, que puede eonsdderarse co mo obra maeatrade ins dia. Que . el Obbferno Argenti no busque y castiguea los contraband4stae; que delin quen en sus fronteras, pi diendo, sf 'cabe, auxillo de nuestro Gobierno, ?sin recu rrir.` al deleanti?ble, expedieu ede arrojar sombras de t' dada qule empafien.la .llmpi da?trQdicl6n de nuestra Flo to ? Mercante, que esta -orgu llass de su renacimlento,li al ImPulso y al amtparo de un ?Gobierno 'Patriota''y Pro gresista, a1 que servimos ' con leadtad, honor y dignl dad. 3E]eperando haber.'satiste cho el peaido que ha teni do ' a blen formularnvs V E., Mme Place .'sailuidarle : con mi disttngulda considers elfin" - VIDAL BEDOYA, Administrador General. UNCLASSIFIED Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 UNCLASSIFIED Page 1, Encl. 3, A- c3q frozen Asuncion Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 LA TRIBUNA Awrnci6n, Viernes 2 &W 10 de 1963 -- 3 Aclaraciones de Embajada en Bs. AS. a Nota d.e la Cancilleria Argentina El ministerio do Relaciones Exteriores di6 en Ia inariana de ayes a Ia pub.icidad el texto do Ia nota "R. E. C. NV 61j65" prescntada el mi&coles 30 ultimo alrededor de las 18 horas por el Dr. Auguste R. Fuster, embajador del Paraguay on Ar- gentina al Dr, Miguel Angel Zavala Ortiz, canciller del vecino Pais. En Ia misina se replica el contenido do Ia nota respuesta argentina a Ia nota protesta paraguaya sobre detention y re- vision de buqu,cs de. Ia F. M. E. en el Puerto de Corrientes (RA) y que es do conocimiento publico. He aquf !a transcrip. cion do Ia nota do refarencia: "Bgenos Aires, 30 de Junio de i96,,. - R. E. U. NY 61/65. aeffor i'Iinistru: Tengo el honor de dirigir me a vuestra txeciencia en ocasiOU de referirnie a is Nota que en fecha 15 de Ju I'..i' de 1965 tuvo a Bien diri _. en respuesta a la do e:la,Embajada. del 10 del ni smo sues, mediante ,4a ,cual el Gobierno del Paraguay forniaiizd su protesta ante el Gobierno Argentino por Ia. aplicaci6n do rigores in uecesarios cometidos ; por Jas autoridades del Puerto do'. Corrientes con entba.rcaciol nes de bandera paraguaya pertenecionte a la Flota Mer canto del Estado Paragua.yo. Cumpliendo expresas ins I trucciones de mi Gohierno, me g0eldeher do form. Bar Bas siguientes aclaracio pechosas, no autoriza a nin gun 'funcionario argentino a tomar medidas contra Ia em barcaci6n que las conduce. Ello, con mayor raz6n si se trata de mercaderfas que en Argentina se hallan en trap sito hacia el Paraguay y quo han side embarcadas con il, tervenci6n de sus propias aduanas. 89 - Las medidas adopta das por las autoridades de Corrientes podran estar all torizadas per las -eyes y di gestos argentinus, Imru su apiicacion consutuyO, en es tos casos, un "rigor. ipnece sario", con caracteres de an bitrariedaci. Lo confirman el resultado de la inspecci6u, quo como era 16gico, no ha 116 nada anormal. 99 - Por ultimo, debo do jar expresa constancia de quo mi Gobierno no admiti ra la oplicaci6n de medidas, por legales que sean en Ia Republica Argentina, qua tiendan a restringir el ejer cicio de su derecho de comu nicarse, navegar y transpor tar nrercaderfas de/y al Pa. raguay. Reitero a Vuc/r.Ta Exce lericia la seguridad de ml mas distinguida consider! cidn. AUGUSTO R. FUSTER Embajador 34 - El t;;onierno de la Rc pdblica Argentina conoce d( masiado bien qua a Las err barcacionea "CUR.UPAYTY' ,y ''RIO BLANCO", gbf come cualquiei of are' embarcaciOr do bandera paraguaya lea csta veaado hacer comercio de Cabotaje en la Republica Argentina. La palabra "esca la" en Corrientes que traje ra en el rol, no es pues una, escala operativa, sino simple mente una detenelbn forzosa pars bajar log practices ar gentinos, 44 - Las ' embarcaciones "CURUPAYTY" Y "R.IO BLANCO", ni ninguna otra, podrian desembarcar en Co rrientes, ni en otro Puerto, absolutamente nada que no d.eba pasar por las Adua.. nag Argentinas. 54 - Las embarcaciones '4CURUPAYTY" y "RIO BLAAICO", salieron de l3ue nos Aires y llegaron a Co rrientes con Ia intervention siempre continua de, pr ,cti, cos argentinos,,.a quienes no pueden pasar desapercibidos actos iUcitos si transcurrea durante el viaje. 60 -- La Flota Mercante del Eebado nada tuvo quo ver en las "incautaciones" y "procedimientos" tan minu ciosamente sefialados por fa nota do Vuestra Excelencia, cuyo registro, deja la impre si6n en quien Ia lee, de que existieron anteriores hechos ilicitos por parte de la 1`O to Mercante del Estado 'Pa raguayo, que justifican Una posterior desconfianza hacia nes sobre -el contenido do vuestra Nota del 15 do Junio citada: ' 1V - De las investigacio nes realizadas resulta tier to quo la Gabarra ?`CURIJ PAYTY" que fuera despacha da de Buer;os Aires el 18 de Mayo ultimo a remolque del b/ru "PIRABEBE", con des Lino a "Asunci6n y Escala on Corrientes'", Ileg6 a este Puerto integrando un con voy formado por Ia Gabarra "PIKYSYRY", a remolque del reniolcador t'ITACURUBI".. Este cambio de convoy, pie namente justificado por ne cesidades operativas, y que no puao ser previsto a Ia per trda ell -Buenos Aires, en ninguna manera configura, ea cl poor de los casos, ui. do todas y eada una de As embarcaciones quo Integra ban ell convoy. 3ti' - La llabarra "CURU, PAYTY" deteniaa ell Cd rrientes el 24 do Mayo y' cuya bodega fue revisada ell 2 do !1'iay,m, y el b/in "slip JJLANCO", quo so prete:rail0 revisar en cl inismo Lugar el 31 do IVVayo, tuvieron oq 1110 punto rnicial do su vi Jc. el Puerto do Buenos At res. Toda carga quo hubie r,a subido a las mrsinas, asi come a cualquier otra ear harcac16n paraguaya, debit pill ar inevitablemente por las Aduanas **gentinas. TTRTf+T ncclTt+T%T1 La Flota Mercante de 1 Estado desconoce tales in cautaciones y tales procedi mientos de los que no es Par to Ill estd fn?ormada, ?tratan. !dose de hechos ocurridos en territorio argentino, Y en log quo mds verosimilmente pue den estar comprometidos fun cionarios argentinos. 79 - La licitud de _ . una carga' no so determina, por Bas condiclones morales de sus duenos, sino por el he Cho do quo haya, o no hays cumplido cone los requisitos y exigenclas legales del ca so. Por consiguiente, quo ]as caritas transportadaf4 on una emharcacion pertnnezczn. tL i personas a, (pones el (,oblor no Argentina consldera sos Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 UNCLASSIFIED Page 1, Encl. 4, A-,17 from Asuncion Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 C" '.rii l:TSCRIB: SE A CCNTINUACION TEXT(` NOTA ARGENTINA &.1 REPUESTA NOTA PARAGUAYA DEL 30 JU.NNI C PROXI JIC 211SADC : BU-NOa AIi3i;0,, 221 DE JULIO DE 1965 6E& OR E JIBAJADOR : TENGC EL HCNCR DE DIRIGIR,1E A VUE STRA EXCELENCIA PARA CCNTESTAR SU NOTA DEL 30 DE JU.JIQ ULTIMVIC,VINCULADA, COMO LA DEL,15 DE JUNK DE ESTA CANC.I.LLERIA, A LA PRCTESTA.DEL aEi41CR EMBAJADOR SCR PROCE DIMIENTOS DE LA PREFECTURA NACIONAL MAARITIMA LLEVADOS A CABC EN BAR COS DE BANDERA -PARAGUAYA. FUNDADCS VICTIVCS TENIAMOS PA3.A ESPERAR QUE, ANTE" LA RE 'ETICIO J DE HECHOb QUE ALTER-0 LA ORDENACION JURIDICA DE NUESTRC CCIVIER CIO Y APECTAN EL .'ATRIMONIC DE NUESTROS PAISES, AMBOS GOBIERNOS COINCI DIERAN EN ENCCNTRAR RAPIDAS Y.. ENERGI CAS;-,MEDIDAS ~PARA .EXTIRPAR LAS PRAC TICAS DEL CCNTRABANDO ORGANIZADO INTERNA.CIONALMENTE. CREIAMOS QUE, AD- VERTIDO EL GCBI RNC PARAGUAYO DE LOS ANTECEDENTES DE AQUELLOS --3ROCEDI- MIENTOS, ACEPTARIA NUESTRA AMISTOSAINVI.TACION A ESTUDIAR EL PROBLEMA. PERO OBSERVAMOS QUE LAMNTABLEiVIENTE EL GOBIERNO DE V .E . HA PREFERIDO DEJAR D,',.LADO LA S.ITUACI:CN MENCIONADA P A_RA,~ EN CAMBIC, F ORMULAR AFIRMA CIONES. QUE MI GOBIERNO DEBE RECTIFICAR CATEGORICAMENTE. S.I LA.REPUBLICA DECIDIO FAC.ILITAR A LA NACION PARAGJA- YA S.?LIDA AL MAR LO HTZC INSPIRADA EN SU INVARIABLE SENTIDO DE FRATER- -' NIDAD QUE MANTIENE Y MANTENDRA PARA EL PUEBLO P.ARAGUAYO, Y LO ?UDC HACER ?CaQUE CCRRESFONDIA PLENAMENTE A SU SOBERANIA TERRITORIAL QUE EJ.ERCIA DANDC 0 PROMETIENDO LAS FACILIDADES, LO CUAL EL GOBIERNO PARAGUAYO RE- CCNOCIO, ACEPTANDO LAS MISMAS. DE, OTRA MANERA NO HUBIERA TENIDO SENTI- DO NI MCTIVO EL ACTA DE BUENOS AIRES. EN NI NGUN CASC, PUES, MI GOBIERNO RENUI::TCIC A SU SCBERA NIA TERRITORIAL SOBRE SUS RIOS NI, TAMPCCO, AL PODER DE POLICIA- CLARA M3NTE DICEEL-APARTADO C) DEL NUMERAL I DEL ACTA DE BUENOS AIRES:... "TODD ELLO SIN 'ERJUICIO DE LA JURISDICCION DE. PARAGUAY Y ARGENTINA EN LAS PARTES DE LOS RIOS PARAGUAY Y PARANA QUE STAN DENTRO DE SUB RES-- PECTIVCS TRRITORIOS. EL ?ODERRDE POLICIA A BORDO 82 PODRA EJERCER, EN THE CTRAS FCZ-41AS, MEDIANT E INS2ECTORES CUYAS FUNCIONES Y ATRIBUCIONES SERAN DETERMINADAS POR CADA GOBIERNO TENIENDO EN CUENTA LAS RECOMENDA- CIONES QUE ,E FORMULEN CONFORME AL NUMERAL IV"" M TM IIC30TT+TL'T1 Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 UNCLASSIFIED Pace 2_ Encl. 4. A- R from Asuncion Declassified and Approved For Release 2012/12/24: CIA-RDP08CO1297R000800100005-0 ES QUE NUNCA NADA DE ESTO ESTUVO EN CUESTION. LG,QUE SC LICITABA EL PARAGUAY ERA SOLAMENT:' EL USO DE PRg.CTTCOS DE SU NACIONALI- DAD EN LOS BUQUES DE SU BANDERA, ADEMAS DE MAYORES FACILIDADES EN EL. PUERTO DE BUENOS AIRES. TODO ESTO ESTA EN EL ANIMC DEL GOBIERNO ARGEN-- TINO DE ACCEDER SOLICITAMENTE. ?OR ESO, SGRPRENDE r.,?UE FRENTE AL EJERCI CIO DEL 2CDER DE POLICIA, TAN LEGITIMO COMO JUSTIFICADO, LA NOTA DE V.E. CCNTENGA AFI2MACIONES TAN GRkVES COMO LA DE QUE SU GOBIERNO "NO -ADMITI RA LA APLICACION DE MEDIDAS, POR LEGALES QUE SEAN EN LA REPUBLICA AR-- GENTINA, QUE TIENDAN A RESTRINGIR EL EJ:ERCICIO DE ' SU DERECHO DE CGi'INNI CyRSE, NAVEGAR Y TRANSPORTAR M I CADERIAS DE/Y AL PARAGUAY" . Y QUA ESA AFIRM:ACION HAYA TE11"1ID^ PRINCIPIO DE EJECUCION, AL NEGARSE EL CAPITAN, DLL B/M "LARANA" A% EMBARCAR A UN. CFICIAL DE LA PRuFECTURA ARGENTINA. CA.TEGCRICAIVI.ENTE EL GCBIERNO ARGEN'TINC EXPRESA AL GOBIERNO DE V . E'. QUA; ESTA DISPUESTO A EJERCER 6SU SOBERANIA EN LAS AGUAS DE SU JU RISDICCICN, CON TCDA LA AMPILITUD Y NECESIDAD QUE CREA CORRESPONDER.DE- SEO TAMBIEN RACER PRESENTE AL SENOR EMBAJADOR QUE ES MOTIVO. DE PREOCU- ACION PARA. MI GCBIERNO, QUE EN LOS ALTOS NIVELES GUBERNAMENTALES DEL PARAGUAY, SE HAYA ALUDIDO, EN C,IRCUNETANCIAS POCC PROPICIAS, A.'AS EC- TOS REFERENTES A PROBLEMAS DE NAVEGACION Y, AL MISMC TIEMPO, FORMULADO APRECIACI ONES SOBRE OFICIALES SUPERIORES DE LAS FU:ERZAS ARMADAS ARGEN- TI NAS . POR OTRA PARTE, NO SE PUEDE CALIFICAR DE "RIGORES :INNECE- SARIOS" SIMPLES MEDIDAS DE VIGILANCIA PARA REPRIMIR UN CONTRABANDO QUE EL GOBIERNO PARAGUAYO SABE, ',COMO