FLIGHT TEST SONIC BOOM MEASUREMENTS

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
25
Document Creation Date: 
December 19, 2016
Document Release Date: 
January 30, 2003
Sequence Number: 
1
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
June 1, 1965
Content Type: 
REPORT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7.pdf2.48 MB
Body: 
Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71 B00822R00010028000 COPY ? CIf 9- ADVANCED DEVELOPMENT PROJECTS B U R BAN K. CAL I FOR N I t REPORT NO. SP-815 DATE 1 June 1965 COPY NO.. I- TITLE FLIGHT TEST SONIC BOOM MEASUREMENTS STAT Clarence L. JO nson Vice President Advanced Development Protects On file USAF release REVISIONS instructions apply. DATE Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 P-31i Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71 B00822R000100280001-7 'age t ~ e-, 0~ ? CALIFORNIA COMPANY A D I V I S 1 0 N O F L O C K H E E D A I R C R A F T C 0 R P C R A - I O N Sonic boom overpressures of 1.2 to 1.7 pounds per square foot were measured under the aircraft track during the YF-12A record rune. The Match number range was 2.6 to 3.1 M. at altitudes of 60,000 to 76,500 feet above terrain. Fifteen nautical miles to the side of the aircraft track the overpressure was reduced from 1.7 to 0.8 PSF and the boom was described as "very faint". Fifty-one sonic boom recordings were obtained in the low superecnic Mach number range. The maximum overpressure was 5.0 PSF and the minimum was 0.3 PSF. Statistically, 4% of these data points were between 4.0 and 5.0 PSF, 67% were between 2.0 and 4.0 FSF and 29% were less than 2.0 PSF. The data are the average of five microphones individually recorded by an oscillograph. The system was calibrated using AC calibrations in the frequency range from approximately 400 to 1200 cps. Present plans are to obtain additional data using five DC calibrated pressure transducers. Approved For Release, 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 SP- 113 Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 Pape i yoo&ft~ ? CALIFORNIA COMPANY TABLE OF CONTENTS Title Summary Table Of Contents Figure Index Discussion YF-12A Record Runs Observers' Comments Atmospheric Conditions Supplementary Data Instrumentation Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 P.ge ii Approved For Release 2093/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 pCALIFORNIA COMPANY A D I V I S I O N O F L O C K H E E D A I R C R A F T C O R P O R A 1 1 J N FIGURE INDEX No. Title Pa !Na Comparison of Measured Sonic Boom 1. Overpressure With Measured -B-58 Data. YF-1ZA Record Runs. 2. Comparison of Measured Sonic Boom Overpressure With Volume & Lift Theory. Y'F-1ZA Record Runs. 3. Tracing of Oscillograph Boom Recordings. 4. Tracing Of Oscillograph Boom Recordings. 5. Tracing Of Oscillograph Boom Recordings. 6. Tracing Of Oscillograph Boom Recordings. 7. Track For Sonic Boom Recordings During Record Runs. 8. Local Weather Balloon Data, 1 May 1965. 9. Wind Data, 1 May 1965. 10. Comparison Of Measured Sonic Boom Overpressure With Measured B-58 58 Data. YF-1ZA Practice Run. 11. Comparison Of Measured Sonic Boom Overpressure With Measured B-58 Data. Condition I. 12. Comparison Of Measured Sonic Boom Overpressure With Volume & Lift Theory. Condition I. Approved For Release 2003/04/17 :. CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 "219 e ii; G~K/teACL CALIFORNIA COMPANY FIGURE INDEX (Continued) No. Title 13. Comparison of Measured Sonic Boom Overpressure With Measured B-58 Data. Conditions I. II and II to III. 14. Comparison Of Measured Sonic Boom Overpressure With Volume & Lift Theory. Conditions I. II and II to M. Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 Pajja No. SP?-815 Page 2 Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 ? CALIFORNIA COMPANY r L O C K H E E 0 A I R C R A F T C O R P O R A 1 1`) N A D I Y I 5 I 0 N O F DISCUSSION YF-12A Record Runs The sonic boom overpressures meadnzed during the YF-1ZA record: runs. are shown in Figures 1 through 6. Figures 1 and 2 show over- pressures .of 1.2 to 1.7 pounds per square foot measured at a record- lug station located under the aircraft track. Also shown is a measure- Mont =Wde:apps'oX11 tely 15 nautical miles to the side of the aircraft track during the 500 kilometer run. This data point shows a reduc tion in overpressure from 1.7 to 0.8 PSF, slightly more than 50%. The Mach numbers for the various runs were 2.6 to 3.1 M. and alti- tude was 60,000 to 76,500 feet above the local terrain level. Note that the two recording stations were located outside of the traps for the course, therefore the Mach numbers and altitudes at time of data recording were somewhat different-than the records established over the official course. Figure 7 shows the location of the two data recording stations in respect to the aircraft trick. Figure 1 compares the measured YF-12A data with measured B-58 data. Although there is a disparity in the size and Mach number of Approved For 'Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 'i '-blh Page Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 CALIFORNIA COMPANY A D I V I S I O N O F L O C K H E E D A I R C R A F T C 0 R P O R A T 1 U N YF-12A Record Runs (continued) the two aircraft, the measured overpressures are in good agreement. Figure .Z compares measured and theoretical YF-IZA data. Measured values are consistently higher than would be expected from theory. The theoretical data are based the "signature" curve for the Y `-lZA. developed by the ADP Aero/Thereto department. Figures .3 through 6 are actual recorded data tracings. These figues also show the layout and spacing of the five microphones and the operator's comments on the nature of the boom. Note that the sequence of the pressure pulses can be used as an indication of the aircraft fligbt path. For example, Figure 3 shows microphones D, E. A, C and B pulsing in sequence, indicating the aircraft approached from the WSW. Also of interest is the difference in peak pressure recorded by indi- vidual microphones. Figure 3 shows a 0.5 PSF difference between microphones B and D located 100 feet apart. This, represents 33'% of the average of the five microphones. Figure 5 shows a 0.46 PSI` difference between microphones A and E located 50 feet apart, which is 27% of the average for the five microphones. Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 Approved For LRelease 2003104 C~! OMIBQQa 22R0,06-1 0.0280001-7 >x -1 rr g -.1 I t" Hif DIVISIONS PER INCH, 150 X 200 04VISIONS. A~,R Z o V I fit L Approved For Release 2003/04/17: --- -"-' PHINTED IN _ U B.A. ON CLEARPRINT TECHNICAL PAPER NO. IOOON __ '-. -. --.. --.-.. =' D X r ni ni T C c ~r Z y T' T , ++{+. t. .l 1: rrrf_ ~a a ill. , + ..". 1 t - r%I Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 LL, N&M tT 4 i 1~1~.1 it ve'd Fele T se 2 3l0 %fl Ai ('1 4~ 4. (1 1 7,-~ ; ~; # 1 ~'___ '? CAL.tt? A 3.S F sr=/ IN, F> 3.8 PSF/IN? C 4?( PSF/I W. D 4. 0 PS F1 IPI. E 4.0 P5 F/) NU, Approved For Release 2003/04/1 CIA-RDP71 B00822R000100280001-7 Ty,,~kci N r. OF (SC-, t3O tGo12.~ ~ 4 ~ t ly+ { jc Its! 04 His ,- "ME D I U Pl Dc')(.)B L Bc oM" Su fr, 8 A 4-4-50 Fr;--- t - $ FT--~ f Mlcei~rw,~yx (_ Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 AcF - w i~, CHANNEL CA--I 13 A 3?S Psr/aN, B 3.4s P''F/ 1 H, c 4.~ PSF/ + k p 4, O pSF/ + N E 4.G P5F/) h1 Approved For Release 2003/0 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 T`A~~N of (5 OOY f zD1NCR_ ,30 .331 Ni G d1R Puss uy-E 1,23 PSF I,-4 PSF I.aO PSf I.Wo P5F I,3Z F'Sz I. 2Z. PS F (AVG ?- SELLI STAT:vkd I 1`+:Fad19G5 16" Z5 HI- /1 D o v 13 Lk~ IU CSO Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 B j -50i=r. A SOFr' - SOFT 1 E MICWPNO4 LAYOUT' Approved For Release 20031001q': CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 T1?Ac.tt~l~,,a OF OS.. Boom C.0$ IIUG,~, =a- ~1 C H Pmme'L .441! A 1 I CAI-I13, OVEN r=?-ES~:,UV Z'' A 3.5Psi=/N I.S4PSF off 13 -3.19 PSF/IPI 1.79 PS; C. 4.6. PSF/I N 1,70 P5 F D 4,0 PSF/IN P S F E 4.0 P F/-N ?-,Do Ps i 1,73 PSF .`! THT10) 17,21H9- S, PIFUIUV DOU SLE OO 1* , r M tcROPNUNr_ LA ip,=r Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71 B00822R000100280001-7 AF Approved For Release 2003/04V-: CIA-RDP71 B00822R000100280001-7 TV, JaicIratG ol= Dsc. jo~M }2 CORD w OQ K yy.iBIN, . (51 N_ CALI S. I 45 PSF/IN? a 3.7 PST/P4, a. I PSF A t ON SourHE-~ST HEADING - VARY FA 1 NT 3 3.8 FSFI4w, O.S4 Per 4 4.7 PSF/IN, O. 85 r~~G 5 4.5 p5F/IN, o, l0`'3 p5F O S 1 -t F (rw(: 3 4-f-Eb F'r- S FT !I Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71 B00822R000100280001-7 13 Page 10 Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 7 vE c%^ P 77r r a2 1VAj7iC4L MILES Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : P31B 82 RO 100280001-7 3 r Sef~- 5O F s I 50F--r MICROPHONE tArouT I. _ 2EL1.! 3 _- ~ ~ A Df$- SOF--SD~r+~ B SOFT { --1 MICRoplioN LP W'JT LLY Z 6Gi,?~ G?~ Rev io Figure 7 A6-'D3.2 SP-85 Approved For Release 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP71 B00822R000100280001-7 Page 11 ? CALIFORNIA COMPANY A D I V I S I O N O F L O C K H E E D A I R C R A F T C O R P O R A T r O N Observers' Comments Experienced observers located at the YF-12A service area commented that the booms were generally quite light. As shown in Figures 3 through 5, the operator at the recording station under the aircraft track reported "medium" booms. Figure 6 shows that the operator at the recording station to the side of the aircraft track reported that the 500 km course boom wai 'Avery faint.". This is consistent with the data and only indicates the effect of different locations with respect to the aircraft track. Atmospheric Conditions Figures 8 and 9 show the ambient air temperature variation and wind direction and velocity measured on the day of the runs. At the altitudes concerned, the temperature was within + 5?C of standard and wind velocity was 10 knots or less, varying from West to North. The --naxi- mum wind velocity was approximately 65 knots at 40,000 feet from WSW. These data are included because of the possible effects on the sonic boom recordings. Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA'RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 FORM 5767A.2 PREPARED SY DATE .._...._._Ap.proved For Release 2003/0 ION ? 17 &~ U x> f ~~ RQ00100280001-7 17. - 7 -1 1 j y Y y 1 '7Y - - T J 7 , ~ - s -3 -- t F. t I r - i I:- 'cam i iTr !~ qT. 4? 1 I i T / 6 -;~ kk rl ; ? ,t i if t 31 ff + =L L, t S f T' - t _ s x } ia z T I z .~ b ~ - I 1i I i IN , 4 t1 t _ .[r 11w n:~e? Approved For Release 2003/04/17 CIA--RDP71 B00822R000100280001-7 ! 3 ?' , r * f r~ ft r rr rl e ?LOQ , C~ t t > t 0 t 81 l r r Mr t ; }af7 1.4 ,. I i t 11 , i tl + Y7r 1 t } r z t i. l, j tt~ r+, t * I Y" f' i t>~ t 1' - lt l 1 I 1 J' t f ~f I} t , rt tf `t. ~ 7t' r rr r { -t '+ i t t f J~" t 9 .{~ i s r' o' .s~ ' t,r1i/Q ' 9 '! EST 1 F t ` I [ I 7 7 - - 1-3-3 T' I , _ 1 :: I 7 77 77 SF 7 1 T t. { { ` t ' 1~ 4 .tt r , I 1: t t t i ' t t t i f_ ' t T f t r iI + + F'r +jr ,, tt t? .' Il' - hT .X. III, -ty t. -{k r .~ .li~ 1 T 7.1 T - It J i + { ' t + - ' ' , 17 Ti t i c } , + y 3 ( r Y r tjL "n t rt + ~ ti Y fi y S r i ;_ F i i# +1 1 T 1 ;: tt 1i x ? T 1 ~t I `I } G t { t; t { t 1 1, ! ll at qi 1t T.'; T f r T 71 t 1 tr { ~' ,t ', r+ it .+I ', , ti I ~~.} Ir , L r _ t ,~I f {`J 1 ' tEl F t ., ' } 1 fit rTi' is $ ...-i r. r r ,~ I i a? y. I I It? - 1 .+. t } `.~ .- ~ r l 7H t y a i, T tt 1 - T _ ' r ~I I I t { l.. r ~ t t t .r 1 3 APO $ '17' -66- A T -77 7 OCKHLLD-CALIFORNIA COMPANY A DIVISION Of LOCKHEED AIRCRAFT CORPORATION FORM 5278A Approved For Release 20031,04/1 CAA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 P-81 l =age t4 Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 'WkAZ' ? CALIFORNIA COMPANY A D I V I S I O N O F L O C K H E E D A I R C R A F T C 0 R P C R A T O N Supplementary Data Figure 10 shows YF-12A data obtained during a practice flight prior to the actual record runs. This data point also agrees well with measured B-58 data. Figures 11 and 12 are data obtained from a different series of fli&ht tests In this case, the recording station was located at 5000 feet terrain level and all of the data were obtained in the low supersonic Mach number range at altitudes from 25,000 to 42,000 feet above terrain. The maxi- mum measured overpressure was 5.0 PSF and the minimum was 7.3 PSF. Statistically, 51 total data points were measured of which 4% were between 4.0 and 5.0 PSF, 67% were between 2.0 and 4.0 PSF, and 29% were less than 2.0 PSF. The largest variations were at lower altitudes where the aircraft was near "cutoff" Mach number; that is, the minimum supersonic Mach number at which a sonic boom Will reach the ground. Aircraft attitude, flight path and atmospheric vari- ations become more critical at this condition. Overpressure variations of this order undoubtedly will be typical of actual service operation. Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 PRINTED IN IN Cat;RPRINT TEC:NN:C;~ Pk PER NO. 1000.._ CLfaRVRNrt HApiS Approved For Release 2003/04/17-: CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 ;S 41"i it" T~~,,~ M- + j}~t ~.. ~. `y.M}jyy~ V r T i -- _..*+ MT I , { V ;'. _ ? { ' } 1 1 ` [ k'Y+" R ? ;R 1- V ?L `.y. Ir ^Y Lt t? 1,11 +~ r 1 L i Ir i~ t ?~ ~, y~ r i t "i ., 1. .~? + i :.; .1 j ..y.: 4 r t7 ~. _ 1I.. I1a .I'di alf .. {? .1+t.. --1+t'+ Yr1--T ?~ 71 ii'1 _ ? T I, 1 -r-? + 1 t 'mi '1"kE: til r r7 i . R..kL - - -J 5 A UN CLCARPNINT 1ECHNiCAL PAPER NO 10001H IEARORI Approved For Release 2003/04/17: CIA-R F722R000100280001-7 iii Approved For Release 2003/04117-:?CIA- 22R000100280001-7 w41 +$y i} jr rr !! 1- J Z ~- '}! 1-+ r t T- 1-T - 1 - _ M i ? ?-, r $} r _#- ' -4Y? ?T t it "4 i'Fi- 1 4+f f yy l t-L 7 {?~. ty T{j . r Y y l Y r r . r r t i r it 77 r .t + . T i rr + ,+ . } 1 + + 4 41- + +" i, . T 1 _i , Y u r T I -I Tr "~1 r Y r Y n ., ~j' 4 ! 11 ' 4 r + _t r r . +^ r ~ r 1Lf + L a r ? T ti r f ? - r +-, '1 ' Y { ? ~ ` T E T ' -?-?l !- _ L _ : r ^i -r- 4 - 0 `r. - -J y. -r'r - T, -t ~t -~ i J - +- it i T+ t r - r i- F r+r 1-.., r ' ~" + r -.-i?r+ 1 _ 4 +!. ~ 1 r I `-~'Y +1 1 ? i, t 1 J.iy.,~ _ rl + 1 ~ r +i H _ J t l ~ f ~. 4 - } i`- .-~- -. } 1 1 11 ? ! } _r-! _ } ? T iii-T - 11 4 r 1K-r- 1 .r - .+- {.~ .L-L11 . ~t L 1 4T 4y 4 ' i ~ r _ 1 ~ Yt ?j. ? i-Y -Y'i T' Y ? 44 t rml IT - _ f ~.` r 1 . -r +_ l }, { T } Fj i' }1i J +} ++ i u* 1+ ri~ i. t+f { ? rf + , t + ++ +r t -1' + ?i +-r- ++ A ++i w L'T ~ '" _.i *.. r T ~ ti _ rT 1 i r -'- I la r +}}. y ; Y t }+ } ~ l _ r 1-L-Lr fJ { - 1-h$ 41- h ~Y j : -4 1 4ti L~ . Ii l r. 141 4 1- 1 ? r + T T ,- 1 r 1, ?~_r , ~ T_ - }.C{TT ti 1 rrr J t--r .-11 ~-?- t?.l , "'! . f `I j.:,. i . . e+ Y ,.. i_ _ ,y,r?r i; tl..rri ~Tt , t f7,rr.-~ ~ t?-."i ~-. Y ,tY T I y ..,,} ~~~._....~ ~-.+.'rTI 1 j~ } 'J-:_ r { ~ii i1 r it -. -aa + -~ -r+- y. .-+ i-* ~' i--. . rr . Y 1 '~IT" I I ~ 117 Z J._' `.'-, r` :+ } -+ ~. ,.. , ~ ~. ;-.~ ;-~-_-.~ -, ~_~+, r- rh--4~-, r + -~ ,.? T.,~ 1-- t,- .. #+#r+ 1 FF 1 r - r r!._ -T.l i.~ r + ,?'ly rt. : { t a.I '1~ tt j.. + 4.1t "1 h iH r r~~ e+-T 'i 11 trY~ `H~ r 114, ri} !}r+: ~i- -!: -1~ ~. .{1 1J-!lh t'i ri. Ji+~J-h- tv Ii I ` t + 1 :1 } t . ~:' 1 l - + : tr -rL.V Tt i+ ! + :: + +? _.~-. r+? ~+r ,i+ +i 1 i' tr {- rt i 1 ! = i t r t-, X4;4 11.{ ~4 71 Tl j r :t r} ;+ fir, t w tr} JI ; I + Lrt , T p + ~ jt.. } t ' . L'1r ti 1+ T,1 ?? +T r +a}1 ~J_ry 4+ f ~} 1'T' +?. T +`. 1,, ., Via! r:T ii +1 Z r - 1'Ja + ,I1 .' , rf* Crt - t j I 1. + .~.: +-+-:- Y- I r{. ++~- . -1 Y1{: + F '+rr . - _ { t f~ ,.. t1 .--t?? i ryI -'-*-r L ~y.+"` r:_ r l!{+ { 4~-? - ~-1~ . r ~ 1 7 t Y } +-_. .. t ? 71~ i. . i } 1~? i. ~ i 1 # - i~ j + Zt+ '+H yr+j + + + i -+ ra Ital '~ I r + L 1 i{~ ' L 1 i T~ L + ? 7i J.1 I- + .L -Iilr 'rht~ r 'r. '-t' .L 1 -+-.t } _- 11 +:. ~ ..11Y 't j 'F'f A'a ? + t 'Y' r ` .- . -? ,. .J11 . .,r ,j i +?-?t4 +L r iJ r, if i t i ~ I' ~-,} ; ~ -~-+ - 1 4 I i ~-~-+-~?a r r - r' ~ r _.+ n L $ x t L(_.r iJ? 7L. - -, r -1,.~ y y+?.f -. 44 . - f;.i - 3- 4 ". - ri= + ?t r j-f #l'i~i+~Tff +~fYr ji r y i Y rt ' t 1 '. r~ ~ r }... ri '4 ~ ~ i H 4J4 11' ? ;4 r Lj da ' ~ 1 X _ - - _ i .r1T." '27?"_ T _2 1 7 !'11 : 711 7^'!q"""'!12..,r.2." ~ ,1 1, -14 t-4 14 :3-13 "1. 1:; Tj 7_17_17=rlim or I_ -1 t!4 t 41- b -fT M I . v ~1. x r - Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 age 16 OG CAL1fORNIA COMPANY A D I V I S I O N O F L O C K H E E D A I R C R A F T C O R P O R A T O N Instrumentation All of the foregoing data were obtained with the same equipment used by Lockheed during the FAA Oklahoma City tests. Similarly, the I microphones and recording system were calibrated using AC call rat 4:n=+ in the frequency range from approximately 400 to 1200 cps. It can be argued that DC calibrations are inherently more accurate because there are few sonic boom frequencies above 100 cps. Figures 13 and 14 show data obtained over a wide Mach number and altitude range but measured with a single, DC calibrated pressure transducer. In general, the mea- sured overpressures were less than shown in Figures I through 12. However, other effects may have been introduced since these were es- sentially "unsolicited" tests and the flight conditions were not as well controlled as the record runs. Present plans are to obtain additional data using five DC calibrated pressure transducers. Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : CIA-RDP71B00822R000100280001-7 Approved For Release 2003/04/17: -CIA-?$22R000100280001-7 ~' :J f ,, ?rt i+$+ +rt rrf t 7 1 t 1 yf: 1, = { T. t* "4 r + T7: -; :t t}e i- '? rt '` Tit - J- 7 t - - r IT T4. ?~ y 744, t , 4 4_ 4 k i t I it ! `4w t w , t i ... ti ? - r ? t . 1 } :;-{_+. ? + t + -: _ _ r 77 - = tt 4r r T 1 [+_ t k+ 1 r 1 1 - ~ [ - T t I 7t 4 1 i } r.T ? 1.r~?~+7 k 1 J - r-F 4 1.7 4 . 7 771 ?: ,"I-- ` t: t: i J~j.r 1 .i11i Lt::l ?C1, I :I't` } }. f f it 1t' ~AY ~ ~~t ' t a 1 ' ~;: ~. ; }+t + ( T 1 ti: f t. 1 yi a i i -17 1 :-r ~4 i+ Z14 Z ' .i 7 +7-, . ~r rl ? ' t t a -} + 1 . ?-~ 7 Y t J ;T t' 1 - . T 71 ' -H T L a .+ r .+ r =t ~ WIT' -tt . ,. _ f ( } } t i';i 1 +i irft 7t ~? ji~+ ++' "fig. * ~? .' .; ;; T .1 1 k+t lz: ~r r .1 }? , yjl f+~i rk,;,. s , 4tl. L.rt+ +t ' L tai '+ :1 1 + t ? .t f, k .,I. 1, :k.; r , li rL -.? t3 lTL [ i. H f; ~ 1.+.L ?t :- ~k .l.Ti-