SPECIAL REPORT INDIAN PRIME MINISTER GANDHI: PERFORMANCE AND PROSPECTS

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP79-00927A005400050002-8
Release Decision: 
RIFPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
14
Document Creation Date: 
December 19, 2016
Sequence Number: 
2
Case Number: 
Content Type: 
REPORT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP79-00927A005400050002-8.pdf1.38 MB
Body: 
Release2006/04/27 4opy No: 3 8 CURRENT INTELLIGENCE WEEKLY INDIAN- PRIME MINI EA .GANDHI: PERFORMANCE AND PRO PELTS CENTRAL INT LLIGEN 1 ~ A EN ' DREC TO 06,E SECRET GROUP Extiuded Ftorq autat9tic downgrod ng and declla5sificaticitt 40, Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00 A005400050002-8 %J w Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 SECRET INDIAN PRIME MINISTER GANDHI: PERFORMANCE AND PROSPECTS In her seven months as head of India's govern- ment Indira Gandhi has shown greater decisiveness in her approach to major policy questions than most observers expected. This has earned her the dis- approval of some early backers in the ruling Con- gress Party who believed they were getting a more malleable prime minister. At the same time, a num- ber of party wheelhorses who resisted her appoint- ment are now supporting her for a variety of essen- tially pragmatic reasons. Her future position will depend in large measure on how well the party fares in the general elections scheduled for next Febru- ary. The elevation of Mrs. Gandhi to the premiership following Shastri's sudden death seven months ago was essentially a stopgap. She was not considered the most competent of the half dozen leading contenders, but it soon became apparent that her selection would be least likely to stir up antagonisms within the ruling party. She was not closely allied with any of the party's regional power blocs, nor was she caught up in the personal feuding that damaged other candi- dates' prospects. Her credentials for the job were mixed. As Nehru's daughter she had long been active in party work--she claims to have attended her first party conclave at the age of three. As her father's closest aide and confidante she had been drawn into decisions of crucial importance. The extent to which she influenced Nehru's judgment was never clear, how- ever. During his lifetime she shunned government posts, al- though she served creditably as Congress Party president in 1959. She was not impressive in her only previous cabinet position-- that of minister of information and broadcasting in the Shastri government. In recent months Mrs. Gandhi's image has changed. After an in- itial halting performance she has shown unexpected decisiveness in making and defending major shifts in economic policy. Some of these changes have involved back- ing away from the outdated brand of London School socialism she inherited from her father, and reducing controls over private business activities. These moves have brought her government under heavy opposition fire, and drawn anguished criticisms from Congress Party leftists who had previously regarded Mrs. Gandhi as solidly in their camp. She has countered by taking her case directly to the people in an impressive series SECRET SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug 66 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 INDIA Prime Minister INDIRA GANDHI IA44h4I 1IMIR Congress Forty President K. KAMARAJ Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927A00540005000~-8 SECRET of radio addresses and visits to the provinces. Mrs. Gandhi's approach to cabinet leadership differs from that of either of her predeces- sors. Where Nehru overwhelmed and dominated his colleagues and the mild-mannered Shastri patiently sought consensus among them, Mrs. Gandhi tends to rely heavily upon a few key associates whom she re- spects and trusts. Some observers feel she is not fully attuned to the substance of the problems fac- ing her government. Most major policies have, in fact, been authored by her advisers. Never- theless, in recent months she has shown an increased willingness to become personally involved in disputes and to make firm deci- sions in the face of conflicting advice. Economic Issues The most urgent problems con- fronting Mrs. Gandhi when she took office were economic. In tackling them she called upon the services of two men who had played impor- tant roles in economic policy form- ulation during the Shastri ad- ministration--Agriculture Minis- ter Subramaniam and Planning Min- ister Mehta. Both were on close terms with the prime minister prior to her selection, and both were already deeply immersed in a crisis brought on by a serious food shortage, dangerously low foreign exchange reserves, and the suspension of US economic aid commitments since last summer's war with Pakistan. Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Under Subramaniam's super- vision Indian delegations sought emergency food stocks from the West to make up the deficit caused by the worst drought of this century. The Indians esti- mated that 11 to 12 million tons of food grain would be needed, in contrast to a record 7.4 mil- lion tons imported during 1965. In July the Agriculture Ministry announced that over 11 million tons had been lined up, 80 per- cent of which would come from the US under PL-480 agreements. Although the specter of wide- spread famine thus appears to have been averted, localized hardships may occur before the November marketing of this year's autumn crop--particularly with monsoon rains now hampering grain handling. Moreover, food prices are continuing their sharp seasonal climb, creating an ex- ploitable issue for the opposi- tion. Some of the Gandhi govern- ment's efforts to cope with the food crisis have stirred protests. Subramaniam was chided earlier this year when he announced new policies designed to encourage private and foreign participa- tion in the faltering fertilizer industry--part of a larger pro- gram to improve long-term agri- cultural prospects. Indian left- ists, including the Congress Party left wing, argue that this does violence to a ten-year-old decision that increased fertilizer production should come primarily from government plants. Other food programs--such as rationing SECRET SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug 66 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 SECRET and distribution schemes--have been resisted by producers in food surplus areas who are re- luctant to sell to the govern- ment at controlled prices, and have caused complaints from def- icit states that they are not getting their share of avail- able stocks. The Gandhi government re- ceived additional brickbats when it acted on World Bank recommen- dations for economic reform. The new measures were introduced following a visit to Washington last spring by Planning Minister Mehta to discuss the resumption of economic assistance with of- ficials of the bank, which chairs the consortium of Western aid donors. He found the bank dis- satisfied with India's lagging economic progress during the third five-year plan (1961-1966). It was clear that the bank would not endorse New Delhi's requests for increased aid for its ambi- tious fourth plan--now in the final stages of drafting--unless the Indians agreed to begin clear- ing away the clutter of controls that was stifling productivity. In early June New Delhi took the first step toward reform by de- valuating the rupee by 36.5 per- cent, bringing it more in line with world market rates. Domestic critics promptly charged Mrs. Gandhi with follow- ing a "Made in America" economic policy and predicted that the move would lead inevitably to skyrocketing prices. There was a rumbling of discontent among Congress Party bosses, who feared runaway inflation would cost votes in the coming general elec- tions. These fears persist, even though the World Bank sub- sequently called upon the con- sortium to underwrite the re- forms by providing $900 million in nonproject loans during fiscal year 1966-67. At least $830 mil- lion of this'has been promised by member nations. Political Challenges Several political crises, most of them involving regional and linguistic disputes, have also plagued the Gandhi govern- ment. In meeting these Mrs. Gandhi has proven less forceful than in deali.racr with economic dislocations., An uprising in March by a thousand tribesmen in the Mizo Hills District of Assam State, paralleling the ten-year-old independence struggle of nearby Naga tribes, called attention to the need fo a new approach to the problem of India's ethnically distinct hill tribes. Mrs. Gandhi nerertheless found herself hobble by conflicting pressures from'',her colleagues. Some advocate qreater local autonomy while others demand harsh punitive', action. Indian troops managed to contain the Mizo guerrillas,, but the rebel- lion has not been stamped out. The Naga movement, quiescent since 1964 under the terms of a tenuous ceases-fire, shows signs of heating up again. Trouble ofia different na- ture broke out ~ri the northwestern state of the Punjab, almost SECRET SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug '66 ppiuved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 *4=101 NWW SECRET simultaneously with the Mizo re- volt. The Sikh religious minor- ity there resumed its periodic agitation for the partitioning of the bilingual state along linguistic lines. This proposal, designed to create a state in which the Sikhs would constitute a majority, had been resisted by previous Indian governments on the grounds that its emphasis on religious and linguistic dispari- ties would damage national unity. This time, however, the demand was backed up by an apparently genuine threat of self-immolation by the Sikhs' most popular leader. Fearing the disorders that would follow, the Congress Party's 21- member Working Committee recom- mended acquiescence. Although the prime minister--a member of the Working Committee--concurred and her government ordered par- tition, reports indicate that the decisive voice was that of party president Kumaraswami Kamaraj. The Punjab decision appears to have rekindled demands for border adjustments elsewhere. Maharashtra and Mysore states, both headed by Congress Party governments, have revived a long-standing quarrel over pos- session of several political sub- divisions along their common border. The territory in ques- tion is now included in Mysore, but a slight majority of the in- habitants speak Marathi, the language of Maharashtra. The attempt by the latter state to win control over the disputed areas sparked violent demonstra- tions in Mysore, spurred on, ironically, by state Congress Party and government officials. Disgruntled elements in eastern Maharashtra have now added to the confusion by reopening their own claims to separate statehood. Similar problems in other states lie just beneath the surface. Mrs. Gandhi seems inclined to tread cautiously, even though the continuing discord is damag- ing Congress Party unity. Mrs. Gandhi and the Party Mrs. Gandhi's own power po- sition is unclear. Her asser- tiveness and independence have established her as a force to be reckoned with in Congress Party councils. On the other hand, she has also earned the disap- proval of some party leaders who had expected her to be more amen- able to their advice. The picture is further clouded by the shifting of alliances that has characterized Congress Party politics since Nehru's death. Nehru's commanding stature--and that of Mohandas Gandhi before him--not only dwarfed other party leaders, but also obscured the fact that the Congress movement was anything but monolithic. Ever since the 1920s, when Gandhi ex- panded it into a broad-based ve- hicle for agitation against the British, the party has been es- sentially a federation of pro- vincial blocs organized along linguistic lines. Over the past two decades most of the nationally prominent independence leaders have died, leaving both party and government largely in the hands of regionally based strong-men and their proteges. SECRET SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug 66 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved For Rele e 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AOOkOO050002-8 SECRET Indira Gandhi is one of the few leaders who can claim an all- India image. She is without a solid local power base, however, even in her home state of Uttar Pradesh. Her selection as prime minister was engineered almost single-handedly by party presi- dent Kamaraj, south India's fore- most politico. Kamaraj chose Mrs. Gandhi for a variety of reasons. As Nehru's daughter she would be an asset at election time. She seemed less likely than others to divide opposition to the bid of conservative former finance minister Morarji Desai--a Kam- araj foe. Moreover, Kamaraj's previous dealings with her had been harmonious and her lack of political muscle seemed to guar- antee a cooperative future re- lationship. The Kamaraj-Gandhi Rift In recent months, however, that relationship has begun to erode. The earliest strains developed last February, when Kamaraj voiced objections to the cabinet's revised fertilizer policies despite his normal de- tachment from government deliber- ations. He judged that the new approach would work to the det- riment of India's rural poor, whose cause he has diligently championed throughout his po- litical career. Since then Kamaraj has been among those who have indicated growing disgruntlement at what they regard as an excessive read- iness on the part of Mrs. Gandhi to adopt Western proposals for economic reform. His opposition is more emotional than intellec- tual, and his understanding of the complex issues involved is rudimentary. The 64-year-old Kamaraj is a :Lower caste Hindu with little formal education. His political development has been conditioned by decades of active participation in anticap- italist and anti-Brahmin maneuver- ing in his native Madras State. He espouses an unsophisticated socialist philosophy in which the merit of any policy is meas- ured by its immediate impact upon India's downtrodden masses. Kamaraj's':Latest dissent was registered! over the currency devaluation, which the Gandhi cabinet apparently decided upon without his approval. It troubled him on several! counts. It could cost votes, it. was not well re- ceived by businessmen upon whom Kamaraj was depending to fill the party's election coffers, and it looked like a further knuckling under to Western in- fluence. Perhaps most important, however, it reflected Mrs. Gand- hi's growing independence in major policy areas. Kamaraj's!disappointment over the prime minister's perform- ance probably has been heightened by recent shifts in Congress Party power relationships which have re- duced his oncel-paramount position. Some of these adjustments have had the concurs-ent effect of strengthening Mrs. Gandhi's hand by winning her'the support--albeit SECRET Page 6 SPECIAL REPORT Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927A005400050002-8 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927A005400050002-8 SECRET opportunistic and transitory-- of powerful elements who were not among her early backers. The Revival of the "Syndicate" Among those most active in recent intraparty manipulations were three key members of the "syndicate" of regional bosses who worked with Kamaraj to secure Shastri's succession to Nehru. Two of these, Railways Minister Patil and Transport Minister Sanjiva Reddy, were caught badly off balance by Shastri's sudden death. Their relations with Kamaraj had already become some- what strained, and they lost further ground as a result of their inability to settle on and promote a winning candidate. Since then they have made a comeback. Reddy placed first in a party vote last May to select members of the important Election Committee, an ad hoc body formed to approve Congress Party candi- dates for state and national elec- tions. Patil, already an ex of- ficio member of the committee, stage-managed the election of one of his cohorts. Patil also scored well in recent elections to the Executive Committee of the Congress Party's parliamentary group. Patil, rightist political boss of wealthy Bombay and an important party fund raiser, has now publicly thrown in with Mrs. Gandhi. Although initially cool to her selection, he seems to calculate that her government is likely to drift gradually toward closer economic ties with the West. As one of India's most Western-oriented leaders, he prob- ably sees himself as a major beneficiary of such a trend. His support for the prime minister is clearly opportunistic, however, and could evaporate rapidly if her political prospects begin to dim. Sanjiva Reddy has been more reserved in his backing of Mrs. Gandhi, but political develop- ments in his home state of Andhra Pradesh may increase his inter- est in a more cooperative rela- tionship. His opposition to her at the time of her selection was largely the result of her support for his archrival D. Sanjivayya, a former chief minister of Andhra who is now industries minister in Mrs. Gandhi's cabinet. More recently, however, a revolt back home by an erstwhile lieutenant has driven Sanjiva Reddy into an odd alliance with Sanjivayya. The US Consulate General in Madras understands that the arrangement envisages Reddy, as senior partner, acting as Andhra's spokesman in New Delhi while Sanjivayya works to restore the pair's control over the state machinery. As part of the deal, Reddy reportedly has agreed to support the prime minis- ter. A third member of the old syndicate, eastern India's strong- armed political boss Atulya Ghosh, has indicated he is willing to go along with Mrs. Gandhi, at least for the time being. Although not one of her early supporters, Ghosh lost little ground because of her selection. Her finance minister, Calcutta lawyer S. Chaudhuri, is close to the Ghosh organization and probably helps keep open the SECRET SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug 66 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927A005400050002-8 Approved For Releasee06/04127: CIA-RDP79-00927AO0540 50002-8 SECRET lines of communications between it and the prime minister. Ghosh, like Sanjiva Reddy, has not been on the best of terms with Kamaraj lately. Nevertheless, he has attempted to debunk rumors relating to the Kamaraj-Gandhi rift and probably hopes an open confrontation can be avoided. Ghosh's most immediate ambition apparently is to succeed Kamaraj as the party president in 1967 or 1968, and he will weigh political decisions accordingly. As a re- sult, he will probably try to steer clear of binding commitments. Meanwhile, Ghosh has recently thrown his support behind the mach- inations of both Reddy and Patil, giving rise to speculation that the somewhat disjointed syndicate may be in for a revival. It would be an alliance of convenience geared to the advancement of spe- cific mutual interests. In the short run this might involve a nod in the direction of the prime minister, but the group would al- most certainly leave open the door to a deal with Kamaraj as a hedge against snifting political for- tunes. Other Cabinet Supporters Three other important cabi- net colleagues are actively sup- porting the prime minister: De- fense Minister Chavan, Agriculture Minister Subramaniam, and Planning Minister Mehta. Of the three, Chavan is by far the most influ- ential in terms of the votes he commands in Parliament and in party councils. He is the undis- puted overlord of Maharashtra State--excluding Bombay--and his capable handling of his portfolio during last year's war with Paki- stan brought him national acclaim second only to that accorded to Shastri. Chavan wants to be prime min-? ister, but e did not press his case following Shastri's death because heyrecognized that paro- chial rivalries with Patil and Mysore Chief Minister Nijalingappa would weaken his chances. He therefore cooperated with Kamaraj in promoting Mrs. Gandhi, thus preserving his already good re- lations with both. Chavari generally plays his cautiously and well. He knows that at age 53 he still has ample time Ito reach the top. In the early :months of Mrs. Gandhi's administration he remained aloof from the mdre contentious issues facing the government, concentra- ting narrowly on his own ministry and on cementing his relations with congress parliamentarians from other parts of India. In the uproar that followed the rupee devaluation, however, Chavan finally spoke out in de- fense of Mrs. Gandhi. His move probably reflects a judgment that the prime minister is doing at least an adequate job, and that she is not likely to be forced from office: in the near future. On the other hand, there is no indication !so far that the defense minister's (relations with Kamaraj have soure,3. Indeed, Chavan will probably continue to avoid moves that could ;deprive him of Kama- raj's important backing when the SECRET SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug 66 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 SECRET time finally comes for him to bid for the premiership. tions as a substitute for strik- ing directly at Mrs. Gandhi. Subramaniam and Mehta are valuable to the prime minister largely because they are competent and because their approach to In- dia's urgent economic problems accords with her own views. Nei- ther has a particularly strong political base, however. Subramaniam is strong in the Coimbatore district of western Madras, but the state's overriding loyalty to his sometime antagonist Kamaraj severely limits the value of this following in national level politics. Although an articulate debater, he has irritated other senior party leaders in the past by his schoolmasterish lectures on the wisdom of his programs. Mehta, a long-time socialist who broke with the Congress Party in the late 1940s and did not rejoin until 1964, has no grass-roots support. The recent friction between Kamaraj and the cabinet has en- couraged Congress dissidents-- both left and right--in their jibes at Gandhi government poli- cies, and Subramaniam and Mehta have provided ideal targets. They are inescapably identified with the most controversial issues, and they have relatively little ammu- nition with which to fire back. There have been rumors of an at- tempt to force one or both from office even before the 1967 elec- Despite the unsettled power relationships among the Congress Party leadership, the approaching general elections will discourage open feuding. Kamaraj's distress over Mrs. Gandhi's behavior is not likely to blind him to the fact that any move to replace her would cost the party heavily at the polls. Similar considerations militate against attempts to oust Subramaniam or Mehta against Mrs. Gandhi's will. Factional strains will continue to trouble the party, both in New Dehli and in the states, but the odds are against a major blowup between now and next February. Congress Party disarray is offset by the even more fraction- alized nature of its opposition. Major opposition forces at the national level include two right- ist parties, the relatively pro- Western Swatantra Party and the Hindu communal Jan Sangh. In ad- dition, there are four parties on the left: the irresponsible and obstreperous Samyukta Socialist Party (SSP), the more placid Praja Socialist Party (PSP), and the right- and left-wing Commu- nist parties. None of these groups has more than a limited regional following, and none has the slightest chance of displac- ing the Congress government in New Delhi. SECRET Page 9 SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug 66 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved For Rele 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927A00,50050002-8 SECRET In the individual state governments the Congress posi- tion is less secure. None of the 16 states is presently in the hands of the Congress' po- litical rivals, but several could be wrested from its grip in the next election. A Commu- nist-dominated coalition would have a good chance of defeating the badly split Congress Party of Kerala. In Orissa, Congress dissidence could well result in a victory by a Swatantra-PSP al- liance. In what remains of the Punjab after partition, the Congress Party may find itself edged out in a contest between the pro-partition Akali Dal, po- litical arm of the Sikh religious group, and the Jan Sangh, which adamantly opposed the division of the state. In two other states--West Bengal and Gujarat --opposition groups feel that they have the Congress Party on the ropes, but their predictions appear to be overly optimistic at this point. Recognizing that their best hope lies in capturing state legislatures, the opposition groups will probably concentrate their slender campaign resources on local rather than national efforts. They are exploring the possibility of electoral arrange- ments which would avoid splitting the anti-Congress vote. In spite of difficulties caused by diverse ideology and personal antago- nisms,the present trend of these interparty negotiations is toward a fairly impressive network of electoral accords. On the other hand, past exp rience has shown that where lat:nt competition between the a:>ociated groups is intense--as itlnow is between the two Communist factions--local politicians fetid subtle ways to evade the agre?ments and under- cut their foes Thus, the suc- cess of the electoral pacts will vary widely frpm state to state. Political debate over the next seven months probably will focus on the state of the economy as viewed by eLeection-minded pol- iticians. Elements now critical of the Gandhi administration will be looking for issues with which to tar the government, and any economic deterkioration will play into their hands. The more radi- cal opposition parties, particu- larly the Comunists and the SSP, will resort e tensively to open agitation, including street dem- onstrations, riots, and parlia- mentary uproa~s. At the some time, Congress Party fence-sitters will be carefully gauging developments to determine their own postelec- tion alignmen s within the party. Their decisions will turn as much on local situations as upon national issues. The outcome of such currE t: altercations as the MaharashtEL-Mysore boundary dispute and t:e Andhra Pradesh factional fic4~t will significantly influence the future positions of Chavan, Sa4jiva Reddy, and other key figures. SECRET Page 10 SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug 66 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 SECRET Mrs. Gandhi's own political future thus remains obscure. Her strained relationship with Kamaraj is a definite liability. On the other hand, she has been able to capitalize on her unique national stature to carry her message di- rectly to the people. In the past few months her public state- ments have reflected greater self- confidence. Such performances will probably become more frequent in the final stages of the cam- paign. If the party emerges from the elections without a substan- tial reduction of its parliamen- tary majority--now about 70 per- cent of the seats--the victorious prime minister will be difficult to dislodge. If she proves un- able to lead the Congress effort competently, however, there could be an attempt to force her from office next March when the party's newly elected Parliamentary Group meets to select its leader. A crucial determinant will be Kama- raj's own ambitions. If he wants the premiership himself, however, he is hiding his wishes well, and he is not likely to press any claim until the February vote is safely counted. (CONFIDENTIAL) SECRET SPECIAL REPORT 26 Aug 66 Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8 Approved Forlease 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-0092005400050002-8 SECRET SECRET Approved For Release 2006/04/27: CIA-RDP79-00927AO05400050002-8