CASTRO AND COMMUNISM: THE ESTIMATIVE RECORD*

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
17
Document Creation Date: 
December 19, 2016
Document Release Date: 
October 26, 2005
Sequence Number: 
11
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
May 13, 1964
Content Type: 
MF
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6.pdf845.78 KB
Body: 
Approved F,,Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00WA001000050011-6 10 S-E-C-R-E-T CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY OFFICE OF NATIONAL ESTIMATES 13 May 1964 MEMORANDUM FOR THE DIRECTOR SUBJECT: Castro and Communism: The Estimative Record* 1. Was Castro a Communist when he came to power? We are unable to prove or disprove it, but his 'political record as a whole suggests that he probably was not. The estimates prior to Castro's 1 December 1961 statement that he was a."Marxist-Leninist" did not label him a Communist. But there is clear warning that for most practical purposes his regime should be regarded as Communist. 2. The four following selections from SNIE's and NIE's, 1958-1960, are worthy of note. (The first of these was published six weeks before Castro came to power, and all of them preceded Castro's "Marxist-Leninist" statement by at least a year.) A more extensive selection of excerpts is attached as Annex B. Two annexes are attached: Annex A, "A Chronology of Significant Dates," and Annex B, "Relevant Judgments from Estimates and Memoranda." Two broader studies entitled "The Estimative Record on Cuba" and "Positions on Seven Major Aspects of the Cuban Situation in NIE's and SNIE's since Castro's Takeover" (dated 15 November 1960 and 30 July 1962 respectively) were sent forward earlier as memoranda to the Director. GROUP 1 E}ccluded from automatic downgrading and S-E-C-R-E-T declassification Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved Fe Release 2005/11/29: CIA-RDP79R009Q&A001000050011-6 S-E-C-R-E-T a. SNIE 85-58,, "The Situation in Cuba," 24 November 1958: "While we have insufficient evidence to establish the degree of Communist influence in the 26 of July Movement at the present time, the situation lends itself to Communist exploitation. Fidel Castro's control over his far-flung guerrillas is not so firm that he can prevent Communist infil- tration even if he should so desire." (Paragraph 10) b. SNIE 85-60, "Communist Influence in Cuba 22 March 1960: "We believe that Fidel Castro and his government are not now demonstrably under the domination or control of the inter- national Communist movement. Moreover, we believe that they will not soon come under such demonstrable domination or control . . . Yet, we believe that the Cuban regime is in practice following the line set for Latin American Communist parties at the time of the 21st Party Congress in Moscow in February 1959 and that it will continue to pursue policies advantageous to the Communists and; to accept Communist assistance and advice in carrying them out. Cuba may give increasing appearances of becoming. a Communist society." (Paragraph 8) co NIE 85-2-60, "The Situation in Cuba,' 14 June 1960: "We are unable to answer the simplified question 'Is Castro himself a Communist?' Communists are deeply involved in the remodeling of Cuba -- more so than in Guatemala in 1954 -- and the country has become a base for communism in Latin America. Clearly Castro regards the Communists as helpful and reliable allies in achieving his objectives; Communists and their supporters are in positions of importance throughout the revolutionary government. Given the mutuality of interest between the Castro regime and the Cuban Communists, it is difficult, and in most respects academic, to try to distinguish the policy and actions of the Castro regime from those which would be expected of a government under actual Communist con- trol in the present circumstances in Cuba. This situation will almost certainly persist so long as Fidel Castro and his associates remain in power. Indeed, the outlook is for Castro's increased dependence on Communists and they will continue to be able to make many decisions and take many actions without Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved Fo elease 2005/1/ ACA 9P79R009Q, A001000050011-6 consulting him. If this trend continuem, the. Communists will gain de facto control of the Castro regime, and are* near this point, now." (Conclusion. 4) d. SNIT; 85-3-6O "Prospects for the Castro R. me, TDecembbe:; !=96C "It is impossible to distinguish between the policies and actions of the Castro regime and the program presently advocated by the local Communists. The PSP is playing an increasingly important role in the Castro regime. It is pro- viding guidance to Castro through his chief aides. PSP members fill key administrative, managerial, and military positions. The Party's propaganda: apparatus is of inestimable value to Castro. The party line laid down at the PSP congress last summer called for continued strong support of Castro, who was characterized as carrying out the essential first steps of a 'revolution of national liberation.' PSP spokesmen indicated that the regime would eventually evolve into a Communist state. Virtually all institutions of Cuban life are being remolded in the likeness of a typical Communist society. In short, for most practical purposes, the present Cuban Government can be regarded as Communist." (Paragraph 5) 3. One can, of course, pick and choose sentences and passages from the estimates that mention Castro without linking him with communism or that discuss the various indications that he was not a disciplined Communist agent. NIE 85-62, "The Situation and Prospects in Cuba," dated 21 March 1962, sums up this situation by noting that, "Since his accession to power in 1959, Castro has collaborated in- creasingly with the Communists. However, the limited evidence The Director of Intelligence and Research, Department of State, would substitute "may be" for "are." -3- S-E-C-R-E-T Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6 Approved F elease 2005/11/99 SRJIA RDP79RO09WA001000050011-6 regarding the precise nature of his relations with the Communists is confused, contradictory, and open to various interpretations . . . While for all intents and purposes we can now consider Castro as being fully wedded to the Communist cause, his passionate avowals do not necessarily mean that he is considered by the Soviet and hardcore Cuban Communists as being a completely indoctrinated, disciplined, and reliable Communist." (Paragraph 19) And, "In sum, the story of Castro's relations with the Communists leaves much unclear. It seems established that he did not make his revolution as a disciplined Communist." (Paragraph 30) 4. In retrospect it seems to us that the confusion about Castro's political character and commitment arose from the fact that he was and is a new kind of phenomenon in the Communist movement. We had been accustomed to think of a Communist as a person firmly committed by formed membership and the acceptance of party discipline, meaning ultimately Moscow's discipline. This is in fact the way it was under Stalin'ci iron control of the movement. But a looser organi- zation of the Communist movement has developed over the last decade, permitting the association with it of a variety of political types. These are people who accept Communist political verbiage and ideas in a general way and see political advantage in an alliance with the Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved F elease 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79RO0$ A001000050011-6 S-E-C-R-E-T local Communist party and with Moscow, but who do not necessarily submit themselves to the traditional discipline of the movement. Many politicians of this type have been appearing in the conditions of revolutionary turmoil which now obtain in newly independent and underdeveloped countries. The Communists, eager to expand their influence and following in these areas, have been willing to work with such politicians pretty much on the latter's own terms. The result has been a variety of shadings inkallegiance to Moscow and a blurring of the lines that divide hardcore Communists from others who call themselves Marxists, socialists,! radical nationalists, 5. Almost certainly Castro should be understood in terms of this kind of development in the ranks of international communism. His early career and the relations of his group to the Cuban Communists before and after the seizure of power make it seem very unlikely that he was a secret and disciplined Communist conducting a political charade. Probably the critical turning point in his career arose from his need, in developing a radical course for his revolution, to adopt a strongly anti-American line. The usefulness of then finding protection and support from the Soviets as the principal opponent of the US was manifest. Ideological accommodation to a - 5 - S-E-C-R-E-T Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved Fc elease 2005/11/29: CIA-RDP79RO09QAA001000050011-6 S-E-C-R-E-T Soviet alliance was not difficult for one of his temperament. Since establishing the connection with the USSR, Castro has never- theless sought to remain more ally than puppet, a further indica- tion that his career cannot be explained in simple terms. FOR THE BOARD OF NATIONAL ESTIMATES Sfl N IWT Chairman 25X1 Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved F%6Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79RO09 4AOO1OOOO5OO11-6 S-E-C-R-E-T 26 July 1953 December 1956 January 1959 April 1959 May 1959 October 1959 February 1960 March 1960 March 1960 7 May 1960 May 1960 July 1960 July 1960 August 1960 January 1961 February 1961 April 1961 ANNEX A A CHRONOLOGY OF SIGNIFICANT DATES Abortive uprising by Castro Castro invades Cuba and goes into the hills Castro comes to power. Castro visits the US First Agrarian Reform Act announced Huber Matos arrested for denouncing growing Communist influence in regime First USSR-Cuban economic agreement signed The French ship La Coubre explodes in Havana ha -bo.T; Cuba accuses US President Eisenhower authorizes training of Cuban exiles Cuba renews diplomatic relations with the USSR Castro orders US refineries to process Soviet crude; they refuse and he nationalizes them in June. US rescinds Cuban sugar quota Guevara says Cuban revolution was "socialist" Communist leader, Blas Roca, calls for fusion US breaks diplomatic relations with Cuba US imposes economic embargo against Cuba The Bay of Pigs Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79ROO904AO01000050011-6 Approved Fa,G?Release 2005/11/29: CIA-RDP79R009Q#A00100005"_ A S-E-C-R-E-T 1 May 1961 July 1961 I December 1961 Mare 1962 October 1962 May 1963 October 1963 January 1964 February 1964 April 1964 Castro says Cuba is a "socialist" state Announcement of PUBS; OBI formed as inter- mediary step and Communists dominate it Castro says he is a Marxist-Leninist The Escalente affair The missile crisis Castro's first visitto the USSR Second Agrarian Reform Act announced Castrors second visit to the USSR The fishing boats-Guantanamo water incidents The U-2 overflight controversy -A2- S-E-C-R-E-T Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6 Approved Fa6Release 2005%1 /:~$-j DP79R009Q4A001000050011-6 RELEVANT JUDGEMENTS FROM ESTIMATES AND MEMORANDA 1. SNIE 85-58, "THE SITUATION IN CUBA," 21'November 1958: "Castro's lack of clarity about his objectives, beyond the elira- ina.tion of Batiste., has raised dotbts ab uv his lc -vance intentions among many non-26 of July opposition leaders who at the moment support him. Castro's infrequent pronouncements reflect no well- developed program, although they indicate definite concern for agrarian reform and the regulation of public utilities..." (Para. 5) "In its inception, the 26 of July Movement was not anti- American. Until last summer, it sought to cultivate US good will. Since then, however, rebel propaganda has stressed the supposed US preference for dictatorship . . . Recently, however, Castro's propaganda has again evidenced a desire for US understanding." (Para. 8) ~~. the Cuban Communist Party (PSP), as such, has been excluded from both the 26 of July Movement and the Frente Civico Revolucionario (FCR), despite its recent strenuous efforts to get in. In Caracas, the Venezuelan Communist Party has actually hindered FCR activities, in order to compel the FCR to admit the Cuban Communist Party." (Para. 9) "while we have insufficient evidence to establish the degree of Communist influence in the 26 of July Movement at the present time, the situation lends itself to Communist exploitation. Fidel Castro's control over his far-flung guerrillas is not so firm that he can prevent Communist infiltration even if he should so desire. A few alleged Communist sympathizers hold moderately important positions in the movement, especially among the troops led by Raul Castro." (Para. 10) 2. SSE 100-3-59 ""LHIREATS To THE STABILITY OF THE US MILITARY FACILITIES POSITION TN THE CARIBBEAN AND BRAZIL, 10 March 1959: "In Cuba, the newly installed nationalist regime of Fidel Castro . . ." (Conclusion 2) Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6 Approved F% Release 200511N2?- A%PDP79R009A001000050@ 1TW B "Moreover,, some of his top advisors are antagonistic toward the US and these can count on support from extreme nationalists as well as from the Cc=nunist Party whose over-all prospects have measurably improved in the post-revolutionary confusion." (Para. 16) 3. SNIE 8O-59. "THE SITUATION IN THE CARIBBEAN TIiROUGH 1959, 30 June 1959: "The Communists probably do not now control Castro, but they are in a position to exert influence in his regime and to carry on further organizational work. We believe that at least for the period of this estimate the Communists will continue to support Castro's program and will attempt to avoid giving Castro any cause for believing that they are seeking to usurp his position as leader. We, therefore, believe that Castro is unlikely to take the drastic steps necessary to check their increasing power." (Conclusion 2) "Castro's brother Raul, who is strongly sympathetic to com- munism . . . Major Ernesto "Che" Guevara Serra, . . . , has consistently furthered Communist interests . . ." (Para. 17) "Castro and certain of his followers have recently made anti- Communist statements which suggest that they have some concern about the local Communists as a potential threat to the 26th of July Movement's dominance. Thus far, however, Castro has taken virtually no action to curb the Communists, and we believe that he is unlikely to take drastic steps against them during the period of this estimate." (Para. 25) 4. Memorandum for the Director., "The Situation in the Caribbean," 17 November 1959: "The adverse trends projected in SNIE 80-59 have become con- siderably more p:ronQunced since June. Castro's radical advisors -- and the Communists -- have continued to consolidate their positions at the expense of more moderate elements,, but ultimate power appar- ently still rests with Fidel Castro himself." (Para. 2a) Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6 Approved FofAelease 2005(1 /29 n-C%j.- DP79RO09{ 00100005080 B 5. SNIE 80/1-59, "TEIE SITUATION fl THE CARbmpa THRouGH 196D.11 29 December 1959: ". . . Raul Castro and Che Guevara -- both staunch pro-Commu- nists if not actual. Cori unists . ": (Conclusion 1) "Communist influence will almost certainly continue to increase in 1960 , largely as a result of the influence the Communists exert through Raul Castro and Che Guevara and Communist success in placing adherents in key position in the government. Nevertheless, we do not believe that during this period the Communists will be able to force Fidel Castro to adopt policies to which he is opposed." (Conclusion 2) "In fact he 'probably trill become increasingly dependent on them ZC_ommunist2 and he may turn more to the Bloc for assistance." (Conclusion 3) 6. SNIE 85-64, "COsMMUNIST INFLUENCE IN CUBA, " 22 March 196D: "In the domestic field, Castro is pursuing an increasingly radical program eiirploying techniques used by the Communists themselves in other countries." (Para. 1) "These developments obviously raise serious questions as to the degree to which Cuba may now be or may become subject to in- ternational Communist control . . . Prolongation of the present situation will result in even greater Comtmmist influence in Cuba . . ." (Pare . 5) "His /'astro'J susceptibility to Communist influence and suggestion and his willing adoption of Communist patterns of action springs from the parallelism of his revolutionary views with the current Communist line in Latin America, from his con- viction that communism offers no threat to his regime, and from his need for external support. He almost certainly has no in- tentions of sharing his power or abandoning his announced objec- tive of developing; a neutralist "third, force" position for Cuba . ." (Para. 6) - B3 r Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved FoLelease 2005611-IIQA2DP79R00900100005, B V e believe that Fidel Castro and his government are not now demonstrably under the domination or control of the international Communist mo:rer{lent. Moreover, we believe that they will not soon cone under such demonstrable domination or control. We reach this conclusion in part because we feel that under present circumstances International Communism does not desire to see a situation arise in which it could be clearly demonstrated that the regime In Cuba was under its domination. Yeti ire believe that the Cuban regime is in practice following the line set for Latin American Communist parties at the time of the 21st Party Congress in Moscow in February 1959 and that it will continue to pursue policies advantageous to the Communists and to accept Communist assistance and advice in carry- ing them out. Cuba may give increasing appearances of becoming a Communist society." (Para. 8) 7. NIB 85-2-60 "TTIIL^SI'].'LTATION IN CUBA," i4 June 196D: "Fidel Castro has replaced Batistat:s military dictatorship with a radical-nationalist one which is deeply and increasingly influenced by Communists. There is no longper any prospect of democratic government under his regime." (Conclusion 1) "We are unable to answer the simplified question 'Is Castro himself a Communist?' Communists are deeply involved in the re- modeling of Cuba. -- more so than in Guatemala in 1954 -- and the country has become a base for communism in Latin America. Clearly Castro regards the Communists as helpful and reliable allies in achieving his objectives; Communists and their supporters are in positions of importance throughout the revolutionary government. Given the mutuality of interest bett Teen the Castro regime and the Cuban Communists, it is difficult, and in most repsects academic, to try to distin.^uish the policy and actions of the Castro regime from those which would be expected of a government under actual Communist control in the present circumstances in Cuba. This situation frill almost certainly persist so long as Fidel Castro and his associates remain in power. Indeed, the outlook is for Castro's increased dependence on Communists and they will con- tinue to be able to mare many decisions and take many actions without consulting him. If this trend continues, the Communists will gain de facto control of the Castro regime, and are* near this point now." (Conclusion 4) The Director of Intelligence and. Research, Department of State would substitute "tray be" for "are." - B4 - S-E-C P -E-T Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved Forelease 2005/ JI~-_DP79R009001000050011-6 r ANNEX B 8. SNIE 82-2-60""PROSPECTS FOR THE CASTO.REGIME," 8 December 1960: "These measures Lteiken by the Castro regime are closely paral- lel to the traditional pattern of Connnunist takeover." (Para. 2) "It is impossible to distinguish betz-reen the policies and actions of the Castro regime and the program presently advocated by the local Communists. The PSP is playing an increasingly important role in the Castro regime. It is providing guidance to Castro through his chief aids. PSP members fill key administrative, managerial, and military positions. The party's propaganda apparatus is of inesti- mable value to Castro. The party line laid down at the PSP congress last summer called for continued strong, ` support of Castro, who was characterized as carrying out the essential first steps of a "revolution of national liberation." PSP spokesmen indicated that the regime would eventually evolve into ` a. Communist state. Vir- tually all institutions of Cuban life are being remolded in the likeness of a typical Communist society, In short, for most prac- tical purposes,, the present Cuban Government can be regarded as Communist." (Para. 5) 9. MernorandUm for the Director, ' the Cuban Revolution of 1958 Led to Cuba's All. cent with the USSR, " 21 February 1961: "Prior to the overthrow of Batista, the 26th of July Movement was not Communist; inspired or directed." (Para. 2) "Fidel Castro, on his part, rejected Communist support when it was finally proffered. Indeed, on craning to power, he acted to break the control of organized labor which the Conmmunistshad seized . . ." (Para. 3) 5s disillusionment set i7 "the Communists became the only dedicated and effective organizers, operators, and supporters upon whom Castro could rely, and Raul Castro and Che Guevara were at hand to influence hiia toward increasing reliance on them." (Para. 8) Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6 Approved Foelease 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R009%1001000050011-6 S-E-C R-E-T AN NM B 10. NM 80 T-~Z7., "I,ATIPr At'~tTc~,tt!N RFr1~':TSo 'TO D'VELOxr..:~~ _S IN AND T731 RE az C-5-TOT CUBA 18 July tiy 19f~1.: 'fie ZPide1/ has pursued his objective /in L -- in close alliance frith international communism . . . (Para. 19) U. SNIE 85-61, "THE SITUATION AND PROSPECTS IN CUBA It 28 November 1961: "The regime is nor in the process of completely reorganizing the form of gove:rxment in Cuba, and is developing a new totali- tarian political party to operate and control it. The Communist model is apparent in both instances," (Para. 13) - B6 - S-E-C-R-E-T Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved FoloRelease 2005/11/29: CIA-RDP79R00WA001000050011-6 S-E-C-R-E-T ANNEX B 12. NIE 85-6?, "THE SITLtuION AND PPOSPECTS IN CUBA: It Pl March 1 2L "The pattern of events in Cuba clearly reveals the historical step by step Communist procedure for attaining complete control of a country. Daring the past year Cuba has, in effect, gone behind an iron curtain. The regime has thoroughly reorganized its political, economic, police, and military-systems in the classic Communist ideological fashion. It has also sought to identify itself with the Soviet Bloc in teims that would obligate the USSR to protect it. The Bloc, however, has avoided any explicit military commitment to defend Cuba." (Conclusion 1) "Since his accession to power in 1959, Castro has collaborated increasingly with the Communists. However, the limited evidence regarding the precise nature of his relations with the Communists is confused, contradictory, and open to various interpretations. On 1 December 1961, Castro said in effect that he was greatly influenced by Marx and Lenin while a university student, but that he was then prejudiced against the Communists -- that he held essentially his present ideas in 195+, but that his understanding of them was then doctrinally imprecise -- that he became a proper Marxist-Leninist some time after his accession to power in 1959. He intimated that he had kept the matter a secret because its announcement would have cost him needed support. This probably is an essentially true account of his present appreciation of himself and his personal political development. While for all intents and purposes we can now consider Castro as being fully wedded to the Communist cause, his passionate avowals do not necessarily mean that he is considered by the Soviet and hardcore Cuban Communists as being a completely indoctrinated, disciplined, and reliable Communist." (Para. 19) "In sum, the story of Castro's relations with the Communists leaves much unclear. It seems established that he did not make his revolution as a disciplined Communist. From expediency, and probably from conviction as well, he has identified himself with the Communists and evidently now wishes to be regarded as fully committed to their cause. It seems likely, however, that both the Soviet and Cuban Communists, partly because he is a recent and untutored convert and partly because of his impetuous personal style, retain doubts about his complete reliability. In this situation, some degree of friction is probable despite the identity - B7 - Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6 Approved Forw elease 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79RO09W001000050011-6 S-E-C-R-E-T ANNEX B of interests and mutual dependence that now bind Castro and the Communists. Whether it ever becomes significant enough to disrupt the present pattern of close collaboration will depend on Castro's temperament and his understanding of his own interests as well as upon the degree of flexibility which the Communists exercise in dealing with him. On balance we ibhink that the development of an open conflict between Castro and the Communists is highly unlikely." (Para. 30) 13. NIE 85-2-62, "SHE SITUATION AND PROSPECTS IN CUBA," 1 August 1962: Not pertinent to issue 14. SNIE 85-3-62, "THE MILITARY BUILDUP IN CUBA," 19 September 1962: Not on subject 15. SNIE 85-4-62 "CASTRO'S SUBVERSIVE CAPABILITIES IN LATIN AMERICA," 9 November i Not on subject 16. Memorandum for the Director, "Possible Soviet Courses of Action in and with Respect to Cuba," 13 March 1963: "The Soviets are having trouble controlling Cuba's Maximum leader: Soviet percheron and Cuban mustang do not work well in harness." (Para. 21) IT. Memorandum for the Director, "Cuba A Year Hence" 22 April 1963: "Castro's relations with the Moscow-oriented Communists are still uncertain. Castro is probably still suspicious of their relations with Moscow, ..." (Para. 13) "Castro wants all the benefits of Soviet economic and military commitments but insists on Can,J unique position in the Bloc outside Communist discipline and control." (Para. 24) B8 Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904AO01000050011-6 Approved Foelease 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R009Q001000050011-6 18. Memorandum for the Director, "implications of Castro's Visit," 29 May 12 "Khrushchev has also removed any doubt that Castro is leader of Communism in Cuba and its final arbiter." (Para. 5) 19. NIE 85-63, "SITUTION AND PROSPECT'S IN CUBA," 14 June 1963: Nothing new or relevant on subject. - B9 - S-E-C-R-E-T Approved For Release 2005/11/29 : CIA-RDP79R00904A001000050011-6