INSPECTOR GENERAL S SURVEY, OFFICE OF LOGISTICS, DIRECTORATE OF ADMINISTRATION

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP81-00142R000300070011-3
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
C
Document Page Count: 
28
Document Creation Date: 
December 14, 2016
Document Release Date: 
October 23, 2002
Sequence Number: 
11
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
September 13, 1978
Content Type: 
MF
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP81-00142R000300070011-3.pdf957.3 KB
Body: 
y,.~ ~..M1 .` . ~-" yy 1 gi .Ja 7f1,'~ Y, ~`~ ? f Approved For Relex~se 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142R0009D007001~-3 13 September 1978 MEMORANDIJM FOR: Director of Central Intelligence VIA: Deputy Director of Central Intelligence FROM: John N. ~Jaller Inspector General SUBJECT: Inspector General?s Survey, Office of Logistics, Directorate of Administration 1. Action Requested: fVone; for your information. 2. Background: This memorandum forwards the Inspector General's Survey of the Office of Logistics. An Executive Summary is attached. This Survey contains 32 recommendations which are summarized in Attachment 2. The Director of Logistics, whose comments are appended at the end of the report, has accepted the recommendations and has already initiated action on the majority of them. Attachments: 3 1 -- Executive Summary 2 -? Recommendations 3 - OL Survey Report . cc: DDA w/atts D/OL yr/atts 25X1A 25X1 Approved For Release 2003/04/'~c-~IA.\:t ?P~1^- 4?~2 00300070011-3 ? 25X1 gpproved For Release 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 Approved For Release 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 i~ i i Approved For F~alease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142F~00300070011-3 Executive Summ,3~ 25X1A Introduction The O~Ffice of Logistics (OL), a major component of the DDA employees and an operatin~i budget of over exists to support all Agency elements worldwide.. A majority of OL employees were interviewed in the course of this survey and excel- lent cooperation was received at all levels. tale found OL personnel intensely service-oriented. This report is organized by components, beginning with the Office of the Director of Logistics (D/~_) and moving through the branches, staffs and divisions. We conclude with three special attachments. Our findings led us to conclude th~:xt OL is a competent, well run organization. It is beset with problems but OL management is aware of them and attempting to solve t~-em. Office of the Director of Logistics D/1_) OL is headed by a dynamic, experienced, we71 synchronized, three-man management team dubbed "the troika" by OL employees. The DDA and his deputy, both former Dir,~ctors of Logistics, con- tinue interest in and support for the office. We found the OL management team somewhat isolated. from the rank and file and suggested that they circulate more to give their workers attention and recognition_ 25X1A Approved For Release 2003/04/17,:, C~A~R~P1~~0142R000300070011-3 ~r4j~~~1; ~~,~ ~t ~~~ ~! ~r..1i..~`d ~> ~t~~ Approved For.,$elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142~R000300070011-3 Budget and Fiscal Branch (B&F This srr~all branch handles B&F matters for OL, processing over $1 million a year. Its workload builds up heavily at the end of the fiscal year but the branch manages to keep up. We found some concern in the branch that overtime costs in OL are excessive and that payments are made to GSA for services not performed. OL expenditures for overtime in the current fiscal year are expected to exceed over ~1 million unless some curtailment can be effected. OL management is aware of this problem and has made a special study with a series of recom- mendations regarding overtime expenditures. - Records and Services Branch (R&SB) This branch serves as a standard "registry" and is performing well. Morale is high owing primarily tc7 the supervisory talents of the seasoned branch chief - tti"e found some hunger for recognition in this small shop and suggested that the Executive Officer be more demonstrative in nizing the work of this smoothly integrated, highly motivated re co g. team. . ,.._r _~ Systems Analysis~Branch (SAB) This branch is the focal point for development and maintenance of Automatic Data Processing (ADP} applications and serves as a bridge between the Office of Data Processing (ODP) and OL. Its primary activity is computer software maintenance and branch people deal principally with OL employees in an advisory capacity. Approved For Release 2003~~~'~~~+~~1~-=R~~~Q~42R000300070011-3 ~~;$~~r~~~~....ii~ f ~r~~ Approved For~elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-0014200300070011-3 We found a high degree of job satisfaction but encountered same unhappiness owing to perceived pressure from the Procurement Division to advocate an ADP system which SAB could not in good conscience support. This situation was subsequently resolved but we suggest that OL management ensure that pressure not be brought to bear on SAB to support preconceived [~alutions. Interviews in SAB produced information and views on ADP proliferation which are included in the attachment at Tab G. Security Staff This staff is responsible for the security of offices occupied by OL and for the Office of Security Industrial Security Program, the latter activity occupying most of its time. In conducting the Industrial Security Program the staff arranges for clearances and reviews contracts. Staff representa- tives or security officers assigned to the decentralized procure- ment contract teams inspect contract facilities and establish pro- tective procedures. The staff also sch?dules inspection of in- dustrial plants, dealing with some 580 firms. This staff maintains security files on companies involved in classified work .for the Agency. We found the description of these records in the Federal Register to he inaccurate and recommend that D/L take steps to amerid this description. The mair~ problern of this staff is a shortage of personnel. We have, accordingly, recommended a review of its responsibilities and assignment of sufficient personnel to carry them out. 3 Approved For Release 20I~~04~ = RD 001428000300070011-3 ~~ l~ ~i 1 Approved For,$elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142000300070011-3 Security officers with the contract teams feel isolated from the Office of Security. To address this problem we have reeom- mended that the Chief, Security Staff, comment in Fitness Reports on the performance of these officers. .Personnel and Training Staff (P&TS) This staff handles routine personnel matters and is charged with supervision of the OL personnel panel system. This system, as seen by OL employees, presents, one of- the _most_ser?ous_morale problems in pL. Our inspectors were assured by P&T`> that most OL personnel see the panel system as fair and efficif~nt. Our interviews failed to support this assertion. Ratht~r, OL_emplayees feel that panel findings are ignored and tin':ered with by management. Despite the recent issuance of a Headquarters Notice which makes panel ran kings and promotion recommendations subject to change only by the Director, we have suggested action by OL management to clarify what appear to be personnel m7.~p,erceptions. P&TS is also concerned withfcareer counselin~,.~ another ._ __ ~ .; _ problem area. IrJe have recommended issuance of an updated instruction concerning career counseling and more attention to supervisor compliance with career counseling responsibility. .... ~~ , We have also suggested that OL management improve its sys em for advertising ,job vacancies. We found OL management strongly committed to training and suggested reiteration of its policy that only the D/L can turn Approved For Release 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 ~.,' ~~i1~ ~'~~~ i~` 1 ~r~l. ~~ ~~ a Approved For-$,elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142000300070011-3 dawn a training request. The OL training budget for FY 78 is only $46,000, down from $60,000 the year~ before. We suggested that an effort be made to increase this budget. Plans and Programs Staff (P&PS} This staff acts as an advisory body to the D/L on matters affecting fhe overall mission of OL and performs a wide variety of functions. Turnover on the staff is quite high since it is looked upon as a holding area. This lack of continuity reduces staff efficiency and is the main problem facing its chief. Procurement Management Staff (PMS} This small staff is one of the most undermanned and over- worked offices in OL. It is assigned a bewildering list of tasks related primarily to guidance on procurement policy matters. Despite the high calibre of its personnel, they cannot perform the many tasks assigned to them with any degree of depth or con- sistency. Additionally, personnel assigned to PMS have often been reassigned elsewhere in short ordFr creating a lack of con- tinuity and "know haw." PMS has an important role to play as the D/L's center of expertise an procurement law, policy, inter-Agency coordination, and guidance to contract teams. We have recommended reinforce- ment of this staff and greater continuity of service for those assigned to it. 5 Approved For Release 20 4~(~1~ ~~~""1~4~~ [~f~8r,~~0142R000300070011-3 Approved For Tease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142R~Q00300070011-3 OL Contract Teams Cecentralized contracting teams, a~~signed to major Agency components to expedite contract and pro s .... e fl ~ Approved For ,lease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142R~0300070011-3 the DDA to improve processing of paymen~~s to Agency contractors~ Elsewhere, in our discussions of these teams, we recommend ac- tion focused on possible discretionary elimination of detailed audits of firms given contracts less than $1.00,000. We found security officers assigned to the contracting teams troubled by the present system of security clearances and have recommended a company-by-company survey to determine which clearances are valid in order to arrive at an accurate listing of persons holding valid clearances. W=~ further recommend formation of a unit of security personnel to visit contractors to give security guidance to contractor personnel.. Procurement Division (PD The Procurement Division of OL is the Agency's primary purchasing and procurement agent, spending 25X1A goods and services each year. With butQ persons it is per= 2 5X1A forming its tasks competently but under conditions requiring attention and redress by OL management. We found a personnel management problem which OL has since addressed. We also found problems-of "churni_n~?_,~r~p_~ trans- ..._-- . fer in and out) of personnel, especially in the General Procure- ment aranch and we recommend greater continuity of service for PD personnel. We found a need for more experienced personnel, especially with proven mechanical and technical abilities-, and formulated an appropriate recommendation. .~ Approved For Release 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 Approved For lease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-0014200300070011-3 Ira PI), even more than elsewhere, we found employee dis- . ,~a - -~ satisfaction with a lack of career counseling: Irle have suggested institution of automatic career counseling. Competitive bidding requirements a;?e increasing the PD workload, in some cases as much as 300 percent. Furthernx~re, dealings with GSA and compliance with the Freedom of Information Act tend to increase the workload. Des~~ite these problems, PD manages to continue its solid performan~:e albeit with a consider- able amount of overtime. We suggest the D/L take cognizance of the escalating PD workload with a view to increasing the staff accordingly. Some problems were found in the Automatic Data Processing and Engineering Branch (ADP&EB) of PD which handles the process- ing and procurement of ADP equipment -- some Business for this branch is increasing and the employee workload is extremely heavy. .We have recommended an inquiry into the apparent manpower shortage and improvements in guidance to and support of this branch. A more thorough examination of ADP problems is appended as Attachment C. !3 Approved For Release 200304/17] w Cs~~-~Q~B.'~-4Q142R000300070011-3 25X1A 25X1 25X1A Approved For Release 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 Approved For Release 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 Approved For~elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP$-1-0014?f~~00300070011-3 25X1A 25X1 25X1 25X9 Supply Division SDI The Supply Division is the second largest element of OL with 0 authorized positions, i n addition tc~ supply careerists assigned elsewhere. SD is in a personnel- surplus situation and the division chief spends most of his time. on personnel matters. This branch oversees the stocking of 15,000 line items at Agency storage facilities. It is the principal user of the Inventory Control System (ICS), an ADP system which keeps tabs SD is organized into four branches Supply Management Branch SMB stock inventory. We made special inquiries here about the possibility that materials might be stored in contravention of law or regulation. We found no evidence of illegal or questionable material in Agency hands. The branch has problems with unrealistic customer deadlines and with lack of information about some purchases being made by In this latter connection we recommend that D/L arrange for such information to be available to SMB. We also suggested familiarization trips between SMB 0 We found the branch chief of SMB t6~ be highly regarded by those he supervises. Operations Support Branch (OSB) This person branch is a catch-ail office which functions essentially as a staff. One section deals in ordnance, air drop Approved For Release 2003/04/17: ClA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 25X1A 25X1A 25X1 Approved For,,,~elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-0014?~000300070011-3 supply ar~d related matters. Another deals with writing and re- vision of Agency regulations snd notices. A third deals with budgetary matters, periodic reports, em~Floyee suggestions and other disparate matters. Interdepartmental Support Branch (TDSB) This branch handles all requis%tianing of supplies from or through other U.S. Government agencies. With the exception of its dealings with GSA, where there is same friction because of what GSA considers to be excessive Agency demands, the branch gets its job done smoothly owing to close personal relationships developed with officers in other agencies. We suggest that the Chief, SD consult with OL legal officers to ensure that reports to Congress on l~,ans and reimbursable sales to other agencies or individuals ~~re being handled properly. Data Control Branch (DCB This branch runs the Inventory Canz,rol System, mentioned earlier, a>d catalogs supply items. It is overstaffed and is used as a holding area. We found sentiEnent here and elsewhere in SD in favor of transferring the identification function, now handled by Supply Management Branch, back into this branch. We suggest that SD reexamine the rationale for the present location of this function. Approved For Release 200~;4l~7 ~~~ ~1~ 1428000300070011-3 Approved For,,,~elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142000300070011-3 Requisitions for Tlon-Standard Items Logistics personnel have difficulty accepting personally, although they accept bureaucratically, justifications they re- ceive in connection with requisitions f~~r non-standard, deluxe items . We suggest some guidance may be in order to curb appetites for such items and point out that the A-:~ency makes itself vulnerable when it caters to such reque:~ts. 25X1A 12 A roved For Release 20 ~ 04 001428000300070011-3 pp , _ n a'-r - a ,- f1~i;ls ai'1~~~ ~ ~~i~ .4 ~ i a Approved For~elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-0014?~000300070011-3 25X1A Careful attention was given to possible storage of question- able ma~teria1s at ~ but no problems were found. Storage and is- suance of sensitive items and drugs are carefully handled. In- ventory procedures appear adequate. Allegations of improper use of automotive maintenance facilities at the depot were investigated. It was determined that these Facilities had been abused. OL management has taken action to halt such practices.. In view of past problems with -- and high cost of -- fork lift maintenance, we have recommended development of an in-house capability to perform this work. In our inspection o~f the Freight Traffic Branch we found two employees exercising responsibilities which seem beyond those normally associated with GS-05 ocsitions. Accordingly, we have recommended an examination of these slots with a view to upgrading. Tn the belief that better planning by component logistics officers can reduce overseas shipment casts, we have suggested issuance of an appropriate notice by OL urging maximum lead time for arranging transportation. Inspection of the Small Purchases Branch revealed that security practices concerning Agency-sterile purchases need Approved For Release 2003/(} 13 .CIA-~R~ 428000300070011-3 '+ ~ 9 Y ~^ ~ V L. y, - Approved For~elease ~~~1C'11~=F~~~-001400300070011-3 tightening. It is recommended that the security staff of 0!. insure that purchases and deliveries are effected in a secure manner. We found some evidence in this samk~ branch of by-passing SMB to take advantage of quick buying services. No recommenda- tion was required since OL management was already examining these practices. Safety at the has an admirable safety record but there is some concern far the safety of new hires who lack training. We have suggested that steps be taken to train such people. Personnel, Policies and Practices Employees generally give ^ management good marks for EEO ,-..-- policies. We found no evidence of problems in this area. despite high levels of minority and female employment. Some complaints of discrimination in favor of college educated personnel. were received, as were isolated charges of tavortism. We were not able to verify the validity of these but did bring them to the attention of ^ management. Morale at ^ is generally good, although it could be improved if suspicions of being considered "second class people" cauld be dispelled. A sense of isolation and we/they thought patterns do exist. 4Je believe that greater efforts should be made to make ^ feel a part of the Agency. Mare attention and recoc~ni ti on wou l d het p. Approved For Release 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 ~~~~}~~ a~ R ~i~~~~.. Approved Fo~,$elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142000300070011-3 25X1A Real Estate and Construction Division (RECD This division handles real property matters throughout the world and provides engineering support for the Headquarters Building and other Agency-managed facilities. It has a higher proportion of professionals -- engineers -- than any other OL division. Management 'is of high quality and well respected by division personnel. Relationships are open and friendly but some dis- satisfaction exists among technicians who are blocked from pro- gressing beyond GS-11. 6~1e suggest discussion of this matter further with these valued employees. 4~e have also suggested additional attention to future technician requirements. Approved For Release 200~Oa~~-~LR8~1~0~142R000300070011-3 Approved For?$elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-001425000300070011-3 The Field Engineering and Real Estate branches seemed to be working smoothly but some problems exist between the Headquarters Engineering Branch (}iEB) and GSA. While NEB has kept these re- lationships fairly amicable, GSA performance has not been satis- factory. By default, HEB has taken on w~~rk 4vhich falls within GSA`s purview. The attachment at Tab A goes into some detail regarding relations with GSA. Logistics Services Division LSD This division consists of a collection of unrelated functions grouped under a common command to support overt Agency components in the Washington area. Separate branches deal with maintenance and operation of buildings, stocking anti issue of supplies and disposal o~F materials, mail and courier services, architectural design, and dining facilities. Morale is generally good, a tribut~? to the quality of division leadership and team spirit. There is same grumbling about slowness of promotions and a feeling of isolatior+ on the part of those who maintain the pneumatic tube system. Two legal questions regarding the 'r_xecutive Dining Room, a well run foci 1 i ty, have been referred tea OGC. Some security problems were noted in the Mail and Courier Branch, but we were apprised of an ongoing Office of Security investigation of this branch and deferrr~d to OS for specific recommendations. Approved For Release 2003/04~'~9~;:~~QEA~R~P~~~~; ~42R000300070011-3 Approved For$elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142$,000300070011-3 It is suggested that safety shoes be issued to branch personnel whose duties require lifting and moving of heavy material. In the belief that new techniques might be learned to enhance the security of Agency personnel, we recommend that D/L carrsider sending at least one Agency automobile armoring technician to visit commercial facilities. During the inspection of LSD, relations with GSA again came up for discussion. Printing and Photography Division (P&PDj This is the largest division in OL, employing people 25X1A and spending each year. The.P&PD runs printing plants in its own building and in the basement of the Head- quarters building. Known for its outstanding graphics and printing work, P&PD handles same 2,700 ;lob orders each .month: It is operating with fewer employees the=n it did 15 years ago. A recommendation is included regarding Agency copier machines 'in view of the obvious need to control proliferation of these machines. Another recommendation concerns 'the volume of material now being processed by P&PD. In connection with the graphics and Visual Aids Staff, we recommend another look at consolidation of this and similar units in the Office of Training and in DS&T. Better working space and working conditions for this s~.aff are also recommended. 17 .Approved For Release 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 25X1A 1 p?~1a az-, Approved For.Belease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142Rfl00300070011-3 Problems in the Supply and Services Staff,. regarding short- comings in stockage and provision of materials, have resulted in a management decision to name anew uni{. chief. We suggest this person be assigned better office space. Because some supervisors are earning less pay than those they supervise, it is recommended that the D/L look into the possibility for raising supervisory salary levels. P&PD has requested its own mini-computer system for inventory controls, casting information, and tracking of job orders. The ADP unit of the Audit Staff, OIG, will check on the need for this system. In connection with ADP application in this division, we suggest additional training in computer management. In terms of compliance with Title 44 of the Federal Code, covering U.S. Government printing and photography policy, the division has been conscientious and has obtained required ap- provals from the Congressional Joint Printing Committee. The division has had several EEO cases and feels the need for more feedback on the status of such cases. Manning levels, especially in the production manager`s office and the special printing plant, seem tight and may merit attention lest a critical situation develop with the absence of key pPr?sonne~. Relations with the GSA A special attac'r~,r~ent (Tab Al co;r.,~,rr-~s relations with 'GSA, also touched on earlier in this survey. 4Je have recommended that Approved For Release 2003/04/17 : ~~i4-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 Approved For.$elease 2003/04/17: CIA-RDP81-00142000300070011-3 D/L bring to GSA's attention reports of lack of cooperation and incompetence and, where appropriate, in~:ist on transfer of GSR personnel. We have also included a recommendation that. the D/L require periodic accountings on. GSA's. pf-rformance. A third recommendation addresses the need for mE~eting with the GSA Regional Administrator to arrange for tt~e granting of more leeway to OL in contracting for equipment maintenance. Elsewhere in this attachment we suGgest a priority effort to clean up the emergency power house. Destructian.of Material Another special attachment (Tab B) concerns the destruction of material, giving a few examples and concluding with a recom- mendation that such activity be revalidated if it is to continue. Problems in Procurement and Use of Automatic Data Processing Equipment A third special attachment (Tab C) concerns ADP problems and concludes with a series of suggestions. Approved For Release 2003/t~~,~ ~~AC~?F~D~$~~d~~142R000300070011-3 ~~ ~..~ , ~ L.' ~~ ~ ~ t ~ i.. 25X1 gpproved For Release 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 Approved For Release 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 Approved For F3slease 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-00142Fi~0300070011-3 ~NSPECfOR GENERAt_' `~ SURVEY ~}~ I F9r OFFICE OF LOG~S~ICS ~tUGUST 1978 RECOhiMEPdDA-f i.ONS '] , That the Di rr-?ctor of Logi s ti c ~ take steps to amend the section in the Federal Re~~ister which cone:erns the I_ogi ti r_s Security is Earance Records System so that it describes accurately the holdings in this sy~~> tem. 2. That the Director of Logistics, in c?operation with the Office of Security, revies~ the responsibilities of i:he Security Staff and arr rnye for the assign- ment of additional personnel in sufficient strength to carry out those responsioilities. 3. That the Di rector of Logi s ti c ~; , ~i n concert with the Ili rector of Security, arrange for the Chief, Secr~rity Staff, Office of Logistics, t~ cornme~t?in Fitness ___ .~._ Repor~_attachments on the peri`ormance of security officers assigned to the proe~arement'contr~cting teams. 4. -i`hat the Director of Logi sti c~> re~i slue an updated version of Logistics Instruction LI-~0-24 with an introductory acknowledgement of employee concern about la.r..ls..,of card?rm_cou,nsel.~g, and that thi ~ LI be circulated once yearly to u~11 OL personnel. Tha t_..~he ..~i rector__~_.Log.i s ti c y ~emntl _a 1.1 super_ui>>~r?~? a -r their care- e r.__ co r~r-s-~l i~n g r~ sus i~.~ l.I ~" n _i1~ ~_~ ~~ ~i n F= i mess _Fteports ,......where. a?:p 1_i~ab_le.e, apprapri ate CDIIUrrt'_r1t On supervisor cornpli~:lce ;Nlth ttll5 important duty. 6. Thai: tt~e Director of Logistics rein~Fcrce the F'rucure~nent Manacj?rnent S~ta f f and provide far greater Conti rrui ty of servi c;~~ for those as- signed t:o this Staff. Approved For Release 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-001428000300070011-3 Approved For?Tease 2003/04/17 :CIA-RDP81-0014200300070011-3 RECOi~IMENDA'i~IONS (Cunt` d) 7. That ~tho Director a f Log i sti cs i nsti lute a tear.?-by-- team persannr}1 study of contrr~:t t.eam5 to dete~~nint~ the workload of team members U,ith a view to increa_~- ing the seize of teams 4vhere tha_ workload is un- realistically high, not only ~nong OL contract negotiators