MILITARY IMPLICATIONS OF INCREASED SOVIET TUNGSTEN IMPORTS

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
20
Document Creation Date: 
December 20, 2016
Document Release Date: 
November 15, 2007
Sequence Number: 
2
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
November 1, 1982
Content Type: 
REPORT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6.pdf880.03 KB
Body: 
Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 atE~~.~. Directorate of ~ r~ ~ Intelligence ~l~~t~ary I~rnplicatons of ~~ ~~cre~as~ed Soviet u ~ ?gsten Imports 'An.t~tielligenee Assessment ON FILE DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR RELEASE INSTRUCTIONS APPLY Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Directorate of Secret Intelligence Military Implications of Increased Soviet Tungsten Imports The authors of this paper are Defense Industries Division, Soviet Economy Division, Office of Soviet Intelligence Council. Comments and queries are welcome and may be directed to the Chief. Defense Industries Division Secret SOV 82-10171 X November 1982 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 25X1 25X~ Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Secret Military Implications of Increased Soviet Tungsten Imports Key Judgments During 1979-81, the USSR bought unusually large amounts of tungsten on /nformation available the international market. In 1981 it purchased some 22,000 tons of as oJ'9 November 1982 concentrated tungsten ore-equal to about 11,000 metric tons of contained was used in this report. metal (pure tungsten). This was more than triple the annual imports during the early and middle 1970s. In 1980 and 1981, Soviet tungsten imports amounted to about 30 percent of the total reported world production for those years. The fact that the Soviets expended about $600 million in scarce hard currency on these imports during 1979-81 reflects tungsten's high priority. We are confident that these sharply higher purchases are made in support of military production programs-the annual tungsten supply now substan- tially exceeds estimated civilian requirements. Although a variety of military applications is possible, most of the tungsten acquired probably is earmarked for production of new munitions. The increased imports have coincided with large purchases of Western tungsten-related manufacturing technology suitable for military use. The Kuybyshev Drill Bit Plant (built by Dresser Industries) furnished the equipment, processes, and expertise for making high-purity tungsten powders. The Soviets have also legally acquired Western powder-metallur- gy pressing equipment like that used in the West to make tungsten-alloy penetrators for armor-piercing projectiles. According to current technical assessments, atungsten-alloy core for a steel projectile could increase armor-penetrating capability by about 20 percent over the steel-alloy projectiles now in the Soviet inventory. A solid Secret SOV 82-10/71X November 1982 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 tungsten-alloy projectile could provide up to a 40-percent increase in penetration. Deployment of these new projectiles, therefore, would signifi- cantly improve the capability of Soviet tank guns to defeat Western tanks, equipped with either conventional or special armor. We estimate (on the basis of our understanding of planning factors used by the Soviet military) that the tungsten imported during 1979-81 alone could support production of enough cored projectiles to equip the entire Soviet tank force by 1990. Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Secret Past Deficiencies in Soviet Tungsten Technology 5 Method for Estimating Soviet Tungsten Requirements for Drilling 13 Comparison of Major Civilian and Military Uses of Tungsten Method of Estimating the Amount of Tungsten Required for Kinetic-Energy Projectiles 2. Tungsten Required for Projectile Production During 1985-90, 7 Estimated by Deployment Scenario Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 1F'igures 1. Tungsten Supplies in the USSR Soviet Tungsten Supply and Demand Outlook, 1978-85 4. Potential Effect of Tungsten Alloy on the Performance of Soviet 8 Armor-Piercing Projectiles Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Secret Military Implications of Increased Soviet Tungsten Imports Supply of Tungsten Accelerated Imports. The USSR has recently been buying unusually large amounts of tungsten in the international market. Imports first began to acceler- ate in 1979, when purchases nearly doubled-to 5,800 tons of contained metal (pure tungsten) from 3,200 tons, the average level prevailing during most of the 1970s. Soviet imports peaked at some 14,000 tons in 1980 before falling to about 11,000 tons in 1981 (figure 1). imports m an represente a out 30 percent of the total reported world tungsten produc- tion during the same time period. The large outlays of hard currency committed to these purchases clearly reflects their high priority. The Soviet Union's tungsten import bill for 1979-81 amounted to about $600 million The USSR has been an importer of tungsten for many years. During 1960-67, its imports ranged from 2,000 to 8,000 tons per annum. China was the only source of supply for the Soviets during that time, and trade was conducted on a barter basis. Imports from China were halted during 1967-69 because of deteriorating politi- cal relations between Moscow and Beijing and Chi- na's desire to bolster its hard currency earnings by marketing more tungsten in the West. The Soviets resumed tungsten imports from both China and Western Europe in 1970. Beijing has limited its direct tungsten sales to the USSR to 700 to Figure 1 Tungsten Supplies in the USSR 1,000 tons per annum during most of the 1970s, preferring instead to market most of its output in the West for hard currency. 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X7 25X1 25X1 25X1 The Soviets also have been buying tungsten-most of , it of Chinese origin-through various metals dealers in Western Europe. 25X1 their purchases there ranged between 6,000 and 8,000 tons in 1980 and 1981.6 The Soviets also bought 500 25X1 to 1,000 tons of tungsten directly from Bolivia and Peru in 1981 and were reportedly seeking additional supplies in South America in early 1982.' Recently, tained several hundred tons of tungsten from sales of ~ 25X1 he Soviets ob- 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 US Government stockpiles by the General Services Table 1 Soviet, Chinese, and US Production of Tungsten a Metric tons of contained tungsten sources give no in ication of an increase in Soviet imports. For example, the Quarterly Bulletin of the UN Committee on Tungsten reports that total imports by all Communist countries amounted to about 1,800 tons in 1979-the last year for which complete data are available ~in 1979 the Soviet urchases alone were about 5,800 tons The market for tungsten, as well as other primary commodities, is weak. A tungsten surplus dampens the market reaction to increased Soviet purchases and reduces the visibility of these purchases Growing Domestic Production. The substantial growth in Soviet imports is clearly not compensation for a decline in domestic tungsten production. Annual production rose by about one-third during 1970-81 and, according to our calculations, is still growing. We estimate that output amounted to 9,400 metric tons in 1981-roughly one-fifth of total world production in that year and nearly three times the output of the United States (table 1). The Soviets' largest tungsten-ore-concentrating plant is at Tyryn-Auz (Northern Caucasus); others are at Dzhida (Buryat ASSR), Iul'tin (Magadan Oblast), Vostok II (Primorskiy Kray), and numerous scattered locations in Central Asia and Kazakhstan. output was roughly 4,000 to tungsten production in the Magadan Oblast fluctuated between 2,000 tons and 2,700 tons per annum during most of the 1970s. Fragmentary information suggests that tungsten production in all other regions of the USSR may have risen from about 1,000 tons in 1970 to between 2,000 and 2,500 tons in 1981. 1960 1970 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 n 5,400 6,900 8,100 8,300 8,500 8,800 9,000 9,200 9,400 13,990 5,470 6,710 5,660 6,470 8,660 10,130 Unknown Unknown 3,160 4,220 2,490 2,660 2,730 3,130 3,015 2,722 3,538 We anticipate that Soviet tungsten production will continue to rise during the 1980s, although possibly at a slower pace. Increased output will come from the Vostok II plant, which was commissioned in 1977 and may not yet be operating at full capacity. The Soviets have reported that they are building a second plant to exploit another deposit which has been discovered about 70 miles west of Vostok II. Increased output from these sources will offset a substantial loss of production in the Magadan Oblast by the mid-1980s, and total production probably will increase to as much as 10,000 tons per year by 1985. Resource Base. There is no impending decline in the Soviet domestic tungsten resource base which could explain increased imports. Soviet geological studies claim that the USSR's reserves of tungsten are among the largest in the world "-a claim supported by Western experts. According to the US Bureau of Mines and other Western specialists, Soviet reserves are between 150,000 and 260,000 tons, sufficient to support current production for 15 to 30 years." At the 25X11 25X1, 25X1 25X1 25X1 ~ox~i 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 upper end of the range, estimated Soviet reserves amount to about 10 percent of the world's total.15 Construction of new concentrating capacity also indi- cates that the proven tungsten resource base is grow- ing. Tungsten deposits were brought into operation at Ingichka in the Uzbek SSR in 1973 and at Vostok II in 1977, according to Soviet press and geological reports.16 Other Soviet press reports indicate that concentrating plants were built nearby to exploit these deposits. According to their published standards, the Soviets do not build a new tungsten plant unless it has a reserve base sufficient to support production for at least 20 years." The size of these deposits is unknown, but the Soviets claim they are "large." According to their system of mineral classification, "large" tungsten deposits con- tain at least several hundred thousand tons of ore.18 Depending on the richness of the ore body, these new deposits should ultimately yield several thousand tons of metal. Finally, the Soviets are continuing a large tungsten prospecting effort. The bulk of the work will be centered in Tadzhikstan, Kazakhstan, and the Soviet Far East. Because of the long leadtimes involved in bringing new deposits into operation (10 to 15 years), the present efforts can be expected to provide new tungsten supplies during the 1990s and beyond. Additions to Stockpiles. The Soviet Union's annual supply of tungsten-domestic production plus im- ports-averaged around 10,000 tons during 1971-78, according to our estimates. As figure 2 shows, annual supply rose to about 21,000 tons in 1980 and 1981 because of sharply higher imports. Assuming little or no increase in consumption (see discussion of demand, below), we calculate that Moscow will have added roughly 30,000 tons of contained metal to its tungsten stockpiles over the period 1979 through 1981." Even if imports fell to the 1970s level (about 3,200 tons) during 1983-85, the steady gains in domestic produc- tion would enable the Soviets to add 9,000 tons more to their stockpiles during 1983-85. Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Figure 2 Soviet Tungsten Supply and Demand Outlook, 1978-85 25X1 25X1 25X1 ^ 25X1 Demand for Tungsten Civilian Demand. Just as there is no impending decline in domestic production, neither are there any sharp changes in civilian demand that would explain 25X1 the sharp growth in tungsten imports. We estimate that actual annual consumption grew slowly during 1970-78, reaching only about 10,000 tons by the end of the period. Available evidence indicates that most of this was consumed in the civilian sector, with little going to military uses. We are confident that civilian consumption has grown little since 1978, and that no major new civilian uses of tungsten are being planned (see discussion on conservation, below). During the 1970s, tooling and mining uses accounted for most of Soviet tungsten consumption, reaching as much as 8,000 tons per year. 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 used 1,500 to 2,000 tons each year or t e mining industry. The largest share went for coal cutters, percussion and rock-drill bits, and blades and teeth for excavation equipment. An additional 5,000 to 6,000 tons per year went for a wide range of industrial processes and products such as cutting tools, die facings, high-temperature valves, and components for the chemical and nuclear industries. intend to accelerate the development of tungsten-free alloys using other metal alloys and ceramics. Accord- ing to their calculations, they will save as much as 650 tons of tungsten per annum during the current plan- roughly 7 percent of estimated production in 1981.21 The poor quality of drill bits has long been one of the major impediments to Soviet efforts to make oil and gas drilling faster and more efficient. During the 1980s, greater reliance will be placed on tungsten- based drill bits to carry out ambitious drilling pro- grams. The Soviets plan to drill about 300 million meters for oil and gas exploration during the decade, and we estimate that meeting this target will require about 3.5 million tungsten-carbide drill bits. Produc- tion at that level would require 400 to 450 tons of tungsten per year (appendix A). Thus, increased civilian use of tungsten in the USSR is likely to consume at most only a small share of the rapidly growing supply. This increase could be more than offset by continuing efforts to limit the industrial use of tungsten. As early as 1967 the Soviets decided to limit the use of tungsten for all but the most essential industrial applications-reportedly because of uncertainties sardine the supply of tungsten from China. by 1973 the Soviets had made remar a e stri es in limiting the use of tungsten for tools and steel alloys. ~as recently as 1979 the Soviets were continuing the efforts to cut their use of tungsten as an alloy, using instead molybdenum (a large portion of which is imported) and other combinations of chrome, nickel, and cobalt.20 The Soviets also are known in trading circles to use a large amount of synthetic diamonds for industrial cutting tools-for which tungsten is widely used in the West. According to statements made by the Minister of Nonferrous Metals, P. Lomako, in May 1982, limit- ing the industrial use of tungsten remains a priority objective during the current plan period. The Soviets Military Demand. In the West, tungsten has been used extensively in weapons during the past decade. The most common application is penetrator material for kinetic-energy armor-piercing projectiles. The newest types of kinetic-energy penetrators are essen- tially long rods fitted with fins for stability in flight. Most are either tungsten alloy cores jacketed in steel or almost entirely solid tungsten alloy. The heavy alloys used are often as much as 90 percent tungsten. Gun systems ranging from 35-mm antiaircraft cannon to 105-mm and 120-mm tank cannon fire kinetic- energy projectiles that use tungsten heavy alloy as a penetrator material. Other Western military uses of tungsten include fibers for composite materi superalloys for aerospace applications. In contrast, Soviet military use of tungsten probably declined during the 1970s. Kinetic-energy projectiles fielded during the 1950s for Soviet tank, antiaircraft, and antitank guns had bullet-shaped tungsten-carbide cores as penetrators, but the production of those older gun systems declined or ceased during the 1970s. In the early 1960s the Soviets fielded their first long-rod penetrator in the 115-mm kinetic-energy projectile for their T-62 tank. The penetrator material was alloy steel in a long-rod design which offered higher performance than that of the older Soviet projectiles with tungsten-carbide cores. The 125-mm kinetic- energy projectiles the Soviets later fielded with their T-64 and T-72 tanks also used long-rod penetrators made of alloy steel. Nevertheless, the Soviets did make some military use of tungsten for composite materials, superalloys for aerospace, and components for nuclear submarines. (Appendix B compares Soviet and Western civilian and military uses of tungsten.) Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Secret Past Deficiencies in Soviet Tungsten Technology Tungsten-alloy penetrator materials like those fielded in the West during the 1970s would have provided Soviet projectiles substantially greater performance. But their powder-metallurgy technology at the plant level-particularly quality control and nondestructive test equipment-was inadequate, and this precluded the production of long-rod penetrators made of tung- sten alloy. As recently as the middle 1970s, Western companies that tested the quality of tungsten powders produced in the USSR judged them to be unusable by Western standards. The Future New Military Uses. The increased Soviet imports of tungsten coincide with major purchases of tungsten- related Western manufacturing technology that has. potential military applications. For example, in the late 1970s the Soviets legally purchased technology that enabled them to develop and produce tungsten- alloy penetrators for their antitank projectiles. ~ In addition to this basic processing technology, the Soviets have already obtained, or have contracted to buy, additional manufacturing equipment and exper- tise of the kind used in the West to make tungsten- leading Soviet military scientific-technical journal, Tekhnika I Vooruzheniye (Equipment and WeaponsJ, described a US 105-mm armor-piercing projectile, the M735, which consists of a tungsten-alloy core sheathed in a steel body~The penetrator (core) material is 90 percent tungsten, alloyed with nickel and iron. The article reveals that, at a mini- mum, the Soviets are familiar with the design features of the M735 and suggests that they may have adopted some of the same design approaches. The Soviets systematically evaluate Western military hardware and designs to incorporate desirable fea- tures into their own designs. It is reasonable to assume that the Soviets will pursue development of an even more capable projectile made of solid tungsten alloy. In this projectile design the entire body, except for the windshield (nose) and fins, based penetrators. 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 ?25X1 L-ix i^ 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Secret Table 2 Tungsten Required for Projectile Production During 1985-90, Estimated by Deployment Scenario a Deployment Scenario Number of Gun Systems in Active Inventory in 1985 Total Projectile Requirements Kilograms of Tungsten Contained Tungsten Required per Projectile Manufacturing Requirements (in metric tons) (estimated) Tungsten-alloy Solid Tungsten Cored Alloy Cored Solid 125-mm guns in T-64, T-72, and newer model tanks 22,000 2,700,000 5.0 10.0 13,500 27,000 115-mm guns in T-62 tanks 15,000 1,840,000 4.4 8.8 8,100 16,200 100-mm guns in T-54 and T-55 tanks 13,000 1,600,000 3.0 5.5 4,800 8,800 100-mm T-12 series antitank guns 4,000 500,000 3.8 7.6 1,900 3,800 Total 54,000 6,640,000 28,300 55,800 a For a discussion of the method of calculating these estimates, see appendix D. functions as the tungsten-alloy penetrator. France, Israel, West Germany, Austria, and the United States have begun production of solid tungsten-alloy pene- trators in the past few years. The tooling and process- es they use to make such penetrators are essentially the same as those used to manufacture the cores. Manufacturing technology acquired from the West gives the Soviets the needed equipment and expertise. Estimated Production Requirements. We estimate that mass production of projectiles with tungsten- alloy cores is likely to be under way about 1985. The amount of tungsten needed would depend on the extent of planned deployment. For example, we esti- mate that in 1985 active Soviet units will have some 22,000 T-64 and T-72 series and newer model tanks. Production of the 2.7 million 125-mm projectiles needed to equip all these tanks would take five or more years and consume more than 13,000 tons of tungsten during 1985-90. More ambitious deployment options are possible. For example, if the Soviets chose to equip their older T-62s (we estimate that 15,000 T-62s still will be deployed in active units in 1985) with tungsten-cored projectiles, an additional 8,000 tons of tungsten would be consumed during 1985-90. In addition, we estimate that 13,000 early model T-54 and T-55 tanks will still be assigned to active units in 1985. It is unlikely that the Soviets would produce tungsten-alloy cores for the projectiles now fired by the T-54 and T-55, but if they did, it could increase the total needed by nearly another 5,000 tons. The roughly 30,000 tons of tungsten the Soviets have apparently added to stockpiles during 1979-81 would be enough to support production of up to 6 million projectiles with tungsten-alloy cores-enough to equip the entire Soviet tank force by 1990. Eventual produc- tion of solid tungsten-alloy projectiles probably would almost double tungsten requirements for the same number of projectiles. Because cored projectiles prob- ably will remain effective well into the 1990s, howev- er, the Soviets may not convert entirely to solid projectiles for some time. Table 2 shows how the total manufacturing requirements for tungsten might vary by deployment scenario. 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Battl~eld Implications. Tungsten alloy is substan- tially more effective as an armor-penetrating material than the steel alloy the Soviets now use in their long- rod kinetic-energy penetrators. Deployment of tung- sten-alloy long-rod penetrators would significantly improve the capability of Soviet tank guns to defeat Western tanks equipped with either conventional or special armor. According to current technical assess- ments, atungsten-alloy core for a steel projectile could increase penetration as much as 20 percent, and a solid tungsten-alloy projectile could increase pene- tration as much as 40 percent Z' (figure 4). Western tank armor developments probably are driv- ing Soviet efforts to improve their kinetic-energy penetrators. Special armor arrays, which offer West- ern tanks much greater protection, are likely to continue to improve. Against a given armor, on the other hand, tungsten-alloy penetrators offer the same penetration at ranges greater than are possible with steel-alloy projectiles. Combined with fire control improvements currently being made, this tungsten- alloy capability extends the effective engagement ranges of most Soviet tank guns now in service. Potential Additional Uses. Estimated production re- quirements for the kinetic-energy penetrators de- scribed above do not entirely explain the large quanti- ties of tungsten the Soviets are now acquiring. With their rapidly growing inventories of tungsten and the Western powder metallurgy manufacturing technol- ogy now in place, the Soviets can pursue further uses of tungsten in their military systems. The tungsten imports began to rise sharply several years before the date when, according to our analysis, the Soviets will begin production of their new tungsten-alloy cores. This early stockpiling, plus unconfirmed emigre re- porting, suggests that other military applications of tungsten may be already in train. Other production programs could consume several more thousand tons of tungsten. Figure 4 Potential Effect of Tungsten Alloy on the Performance of Soviet Armor-Piercing Projectiles Projectile configuration 125-mm BM-9/12 (steel alloy) (Soviet data) 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 Millimeters of armor penetrated Penetration estimated at 0 degrees obliquity and 2,100 meters range against rolled homogeneous armor; actual penetration against special armor varies. A number of Western munitions programs that make use of tungsten alloy are available to the Soviets as models of proven design approaches: ? Sweden has developed, for its Bofors L70 automatic antiaircraft gun, a 40-mm fragmentation projectile that increases lethality severalfold by using tung- sten-alloy balls rather than steel balls as its pre- formed fragments. The US Army recently adopted this projectile for its new Sergeant York mobile air defense gun. Combined with the improved proximi- ty fuzes that the Soviets are now developing, tung- sten-alloy fragments would make both their artillery munitions and their surface-to-air missile warheads much more lethal. 25X1 LJ/~'f 25X4 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Secret ? Sweden also has developed a new artillery munition, the Harald X-600, which uses miniature tungsten- alloy kinetic-energy projectiles (or flechettes) to penetrate the tops of armored vehicles. ? West Germany is introducing tungsten-alloy kin- etic-energy projectiles for use with its Gepard air defense assault gun. The projectile is intended for use against attack helicopters. ? The United States is replacing steel fragments with tungsten alloy in the conventional warhead for the Lance surface-to-surface missile. The Soviets may not be planning a munitions program like any of these. They simply may be unwilling to proceed with their major new tank munitions produc- tion program for tungsten-alloy penetrators before amassing large stockpiles of tungsten. Without ade- quate stockpiles, military production programs that require large amounts of imported material would be vulnerable to interruptions in imports like those for tungsten that occurred in the late 1960s. Another possibility is that mass production of tungsten-alloy penetrators originally was slated to begin earlier, but was delayed by technical problems encountered in development. Future trends in Soviet tungsten im- ports may provide some insight as to which of these explanations is more likely. Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Q Next 1 Page(s) In Document Denied Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Secret Appendix B Comparison of Major Civilian and Military Uses of Tungsten High-speed steel cutting tools High-speed steel cutting tools Tungsten-carbide cutting tools Tungsten-carbide cutting tools Dies and die facings Dies and die facings Light bulbs and electronic tube filaments Light bulbs and electronic tube filaments Components for nuclear reactors Components for nuclear reactors Refractory liners and electrodes Refractory liners and electrodes Tungsten in gas welding Tungsten in gas welding a Rock drill bits for gas and oil drilling Rock drill bits for gas and oil drilling s Blades, teeth, and cutters for mining equipment Blades, teeth, and cutters for mining equipment Superalloys for aerospace uses Superalloys a for aerospace uses Chemical catalysts and pigments Fibers for composite materials Fibers for composite materials Tungsten-carbide bullet cores Tungsten-carbide bullet cores Rocket motor components Rocket motor components Tungsten-alloy penetrators for: Tungsten-alloy penetrators for: Armor-piercing kinetic-energy projectiles Armor-piercing kinetic-energy projectiles for tank guns for tank guns a Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Next 2 Page(s) In Document Denied Q Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Secret Secret Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6 Approved For Release 2007/11/15 :CIA-RDP83T00853R000200070002-6