INTELLIGENCE MEMORANDUM THE REPUBLIC OF RHODESIA: ECONOMIC STATUS AND PROSPECTS FOR GROWTH

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
22
Document Creation Date: 
December 22, 2016
Document Release Date: 
October 31, 2011
Sequence Number: 
40
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
March 1, 1970
Content Type: 
IM
File: 
Body: 
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 -Seeret DIRECTORATE OF INTELLIGENCE Intelligence Memorandum The Republic Of Rhodesia: Economic Status And Prospects For Growth Sem at ER IM 70-40 March ].9 70 Copy No. 42 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31 : CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 WARNING This document contains information affecting the national defense of the United States, within the meaning of Title 18, sections 93 and 794, of the LIS Code, as amended. Its transmission or revelation of its contents to or re- ceipt by an nnauthorived person is prohibited by law. onovr i -~ IXC(.IITIYP ritOM AUTOMATIC TIOWN(IIIAUIN(, AN(I Ur:C 1.A NS119C A,nun Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 S ,CRE'r CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY Directorate of intelligence March 1970 The Republic Of Rhodesia: Economic Status And Prospects For Growth Introduction The British breakaway colony of Southern Rho- desia, which had declared its independence of Great Britain on 11 November 1965 but still maintained some residual ties to the crown, cut the final bond on 2 March 1970 and formally became a Republic. The United Kingdom and the United Nations have tried to bring down Prime Minister Ian Smith's white minority government through economic sanc- tions. The United Nations action taken on 18 March 1970 is the latest in a series of such moves that began in 1965. This memorandum examines the fail- ure of four years of sanctions to bring Smith to terms, the changes that have taken place in the economy, and the prospects for Rhodesia's economic growth in the 1970s. Note: This memorandum was produced solely by CIA. It was prepared by the Office of Economic Research and was eoovdinated with the Office of Current In- teZZigence. 25X1 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECRET 1923 October Southern Rhodesia becomes a self-governing colony of the United Kingdom. 1953 September Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland is inaugurated. 1961 December New constitution promulgated which removes most of the remaining legal controls held by the United Kingdom. 1963 December Federation of Rhodesia and Nyasaland is dissolved. 1964 November Predominately white electorate in a referendum approves independence. 1965 May Rhodesian Front party sweeps general election. November Prime Minister Ian Smith issues Unilateral Declaration of Independence and abro- gates the 1961 constitution. United Kingdom initiates selective economic and political sanctions making vir- tually all exports from Rhodesia nominally illegal and prohibiting the sale of British goods to Rhodesia. December United Kingdom includes oil embargo as part of selective economic and political sanctions. 1966 April United Nations Security Council authorizes the United Kingdom to blockade the Mozambique port of Beira to stop oil supplies from reaching Rhodesia. December Prime Ministers Smith and Wilson hold unsuccessful talks aboard the H.M.S. Tiger at Gibraltar. United Nations Security Council invokes selective mandatory sanctions against Rhodesia making binding on all United Nations members many of the voluntary sanctions that had been in effect for more than a year. 1968 May United Nations Security Council invokes comprehensive mandatory sax ;tions against Rhodesia; all United Nations members are enjoined from trading with Rhodesia except for trade in a few selected items, primarily medically related. October Prime Ministers Smith and Wilson hold a second unsuccessful round of talks aboard the H.M.S. Fearless at Gibraltar. 1969 June Predominately white electorate in a referendum approves the creation of a republic and a new constitution. 1970 March Rhodesia's republican constitution promulgated and parliamentary elections under the new constitution set for April. - 2 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 I SECRET Background 1. Rhodesia's declaration of Republic status in March 1970 formally ended some 80 years of ties with the British Crown. Rhodesia became a self- governing colony of the United Kingdom in 1923. In 1953, it formed a federation with Northern Rho- desia and Nyasaland. Preparations for independence by its members brought about the Federation's dis- solution ten years later, and in 1964, Northern Rhodesia and Nyasaland became the independent black- ruled states of Zambia and Malawi. Unable to reach agreement with the United Kingdom on the status of Black Africans under a new constitution, Rhodesia unilaterally declared its independence from Great Britain in November 1965. 2. The United Kingdom, in retaliation against Rhodesia's Unilateral Declaration of Independence (UDI), attempted to force its return to British rule by economic sanctions (see the chronology). A sharp reduction in Rhodesia's imports and exports, London expected, would inflict severe hardship on the economy and force the white electorate to come to terms -- essentially to move toward majority rule, which meant black rule. Sanctions became nominally more severe and comprehensive when, under UN aegis in May 1968, they were extended to vir- 1.ually all of Rhodesia's foreign trade and other economic ties with the outside world. On 18 March 1970, following Rhodesia's formal transition to Republican status, sanctions were further extended to include transport and consular relations. The key targets of the sanction campaign were Rhodesia's principal export commodities -- tobacco, sugar, asbestos, copper, chrome ore, and pig iron -- and a strategic import, oil. However, Salisbury's success in maintaining traditional markets (except in the United Kingdom, the United States, and Canada), in expanding other markets, and in re- structuring the economy has enabled Rhodesia to ignore UK/UN political demands. 3. Because they were not universally enforced, sanctions did not disrupt Rhodesia's economy. Portugal, which controls strategically located Mozambique, and South Africa openly refused to participate (see the map). Both countries con- tinued their trade with Rhodesia and both facil- itated Rhodesian trade with other countries by - 3 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SI~;C It.I I' JKI 1 J11n)11. , I urhu vPrm nl 1, NnnUnI. lU 1.bnu .. L'.Ulnd., bY,vllln Iol d~eh .._, .., rnnnnnhnln ! 1~Lwllnuilnu h ~. I V A 1IT 7 A du 7.ha l 1o.dn :anon" r OnuAl nnn01 K .. \ r'i. rl 1)GM m I U131 c., \ (` ?NUmlwn ~~ Iu`(!nrn N:tlnlu nmbnnnln Nahmnbn? 1 )I I II r?. Mn no? \. i / r4. ' I'n,llt frNn ' 1 I:.mumn~. ~ ~ Iln:un:nn ~ '" ~ - nlu r nn F, I rlrre:r.? Irl n n,n vir 1 t?1? ??_`?? 1 ? g"19.r`,r1 CON,O IWnI ~? ~~M.1?'. rlllnllnwllllNn r/ 1I nlllwnbn Chooy, / .Irl'r,....... ~, ./e 1 N,v I l b ra Mnr.hnQri' V11110 Irunln ,VI):;rgrn Pm b' 4MdIol i I;urI,. Magn m.dm \da Ilnndnba VIl. do l,l nhnnarr J J .. / { 1 \?Ylla Rntadnn \~ M n hrrl? Nn LOON, j / i '~.? II U c 1 . , Ar 1'?n yn,nr,n l ! ,,ono ? rr nnln ?., tl n .v _ 1 11- A N G ( ) I Irk \ VIn 1'' ona ' I'rnl ) _-' Jn :.lien. ," ~ .. ~.tl;unu Ilan.unMt,'" ?Ilvn rmlu wonsh (Ilnvfl i(hoollnnlnlni tiOl!(TII.WVIiti'I' C (In{)/~ 1, t'1'rrrhr,rvl Nnnb;l, ,.r.. ,?OMrhnndln Sw.Vunnwml /WINDIIOLB Gub.to W.10, II.v WAI:VIH BAY I)nhoboII, (Nor. of N. Al.) ., Mnnenlnl t~) \-1 L lidnn1)v" _Itrolmnn,luugr{~ -5nrllrunt-. ,\ N rnnlniv~" rorl NW1,41.. 111111 url:in,rj~,....w??.. Ir \ f Gwrldy `~.`,. % 01.41 Nn,rnN . _ Ndinm~ f. bll t \ Wlltnn Nrrlun ?wn.?I I/ DIlu4' -. ~ r r 1r/ ~.,.' / ~ r ~ l:r Mavv,l ~? lr `~ 1 ~l LuINI~Auhl rMm ,~lr! nmhn .~.~., r.l ?/.. v.'." f' Von ? ~ I I v ~ I',!I Irl u? J ; / ` M,,rmy;trJ. . r ' !c I oI `~l v + Mole ? ? ~ / ( I (:hlnl'uln ll. sll ...... Mmu nmb. Nnm ?' l Z , Cnbnl M-,unn r.. -? NdoIi ' . +1,- .~nrnnln' RIA1.A \VI I. Vn aILdn r:l Oh' { clnpn Ju ow r?n . A M llr4''A ~.?~ _..D1 1 q s {.. ~. :i? ?,Inrt Inter?Iuo ~?"~ 1. Nnbwr 1 ?.A 1 f eb~ne f'Y Q, ~??, yN.noln.u {VIM In Dnndo ru n {wW`?:rst / `\ tRU`:nltnn~ BOTSWANA / - ? 11C',Innb?r'?/ ~! V Iior us I .Malvrrmn r ... _~, ..t ort W. ton;{ V I'I.... ?;1,1110, m low~' v fi irlr.lln lA~ M nll.,lnlwn./); `.'??` ` I'irI , b0I ?~1, \{ ~r Jotrvmnnnr GAI1ORON[ 1or114m1n ???C.ngndn - S Nrl,lrnnm ~' \ In 11,10 `?'I/ 1?Vl It.. ln lob. . Rel 1 lobnt ;rj'lrrlu,t ~PRETORI~ v \ ~ LOURCN~O R1nR000G V' ~ ~ " ~, rn alr . ?pamlaon MR NE / ~' loMnnn6VrQ 1' SUdngf ?t: ~r ?.-.rtilnr. ' n t,u00?)s~~'R'1 Prl (nl:rl` NYfr Lll.\VI, N::rninnn ,Inlchv J~ Vnl,, n:.t? ?'1~I~nllnl A~ ?y Krnonttad VrrllarA? un:nQlml w,lrr:llrrr)J 1111(I.ln -- dr,lnrlh Nlmharl.V //.rr,~~^~~11qq 1`ln Rldamlont.ln /,6*,I13[RI) PI. (,n.IIIIKUM u {rtntlnyboK ' ( L1sI (Ililll I Ourb.n I na,F.. i 1 cot rr?tt Al;I1I['A Cnmmvml In Am? Ilv(N llhr nl wnl /.n asuv II:;IarlnnllUiff Wrlbstnn ? IrrrnirN' ~Nnrl, ' ~nll.ln l 1 V., lot'. Wa,l nJ ~, Iv:n:n 'MIAAnllrur~?, ) f ' IIrnoIn,I Wn,.l . Vrndanhrrr f 1'rup f r;l Ih,nR ; R- .r IImR 1V:IIInm's 16w1i~' Ent London Malmn,hurr / .-'nlurnl? 1'nlluwmulr r . ~''~ ~ ~ gmll,t:nnrn,. ~ y ( ? rnrl AIhed WI`rcrstnr - y.._._.. '?j P-11 Clh.b.lh - 4 - SECRET i \1` ~\-Vd. d. Mocub. SOUTHERN AFRICA RHODESIA Inlrrn.tional hound.:ry Nnllonnl rn nwt,l Ro,d Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECRET providing false certificates of origin or of des- tination and by mixing Rhodesian products with their own. 4. South Africa's economic assistance to Rho- desia, primarily providing disguised trade channels and a small amount of credits, has cost Pretoria very little. The two countries have no special trade or financial arrangements, nor has South Africa given preferential treatment to Rhodesian products. In fact, South Africa may have benefited economically from UDI and the subsequent sanctions program by the increased level of entrepot activ- ities and by the expansion of South African exports to Zambia and other countries seeking sources of supply alternative to Rhodesia. Should the need arise, however, South African authorities probably would be willing to incur substantial costs to maintain a white minority government in Rhodesia. 5. Although attempts were made by both the United Nations and the United Kingdom to enforce sanctions, most governments outside of the United Kingdom, the United States, Canada, and Scandinr.,?,ia merely paid lip service and did little to force their nationals to comply. The statistics of almost all major trading countries indicate a sharp drop in trade with Rhodesia, but many continue to trade in- directly. The subterfuge provided by South Africa and Mozambique has made evasions extremely difficult to prove, and there has been a general refusal to act against violators without adequate proof. The wide demand for many of Rhodesia's raw materials and Salisbury's willingness to cut export prices and pay import premiums have provided a remunerative field for foreign traders under the relatively safe guise of trading with South Africa and Mozambique. Agricultural Exports 6. Agricultural products, principally tobacco, sugar, cotton, corn, and meat products, accounted for approximately 40% of Rhodesia's commodity ex- ports prior to UDI. Tobacco, which alone accounted for about one-half of marketed agricultural output and for about one-third of foreign trade earnings, and sugar have been the hardest hit by sanctions. In part this is because of the world surplus of both commodities. Cotton, corn, and meat products, however, have found a ready market in South Africa, and meat has been sold to Portugal. - 5 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECRET 7. Tobacco sanctions have been particularly effective. Rhodesian leaf is identified easily, the crop was large relative to world tobacco trade, and markets were concentrated in a few countries, notably the United Kingdom. Prior to UDI, Rhodesia was the world's second largest producer of flue- cured tobacco after the United States and supplied about one-fourth of the world'market; since UDI, tobacco exports have declined from more than $135 million in 1965 to about $30 million in 1968. Rec- ognizing the insurmountable odds faced by the tobacco industry, Rhodesia has sought to divuarsify into other crops. Salisbury has set successively smaller quotas (see Table 1), and roughly one-half of the growers of flue-cured tobacco have withdrawn from production entirely. Those remaining probably will continue to suffer hardships because of sanctions, despite government subsidy, which has totaled some $90 million since UDI. 8. Sugar exports, Rhodesia's second most im- portant export crop, also fell markedly after UDI. As a result of earlier programs, production had been rising sharply, and this increase continued even after sanctions were imposed -- from more than 170,000 short tons in 1965 to about 290,000 tons in 1967. Following sanctions, exports fell well below production as markets were lost in Briten, Canada, and Zambia and the Rhodesian governmer.,c was forced to buy and stockpile sugar to prevent a collapse of the industry. Exports since have expanded, however, particularly to Portugal, now the most important market. With a cutback in output to some 150,000 tons in 1968, stocks are no longer rising and may be declining. 9. Rhodesia's other major agricultural ex- ports -- cotton, corn, and meat products -- generally have fared much better. Cotton production has risen from an estimated 40 million pounds in crop year 1966 to 170 million pounds in 1969. Approximately one-half of the crop is now exported, primarily to South Africa. Corn production similarly has risen dramatically as farmers have shifted out of tobacco. The 1969 crop, much of which has been sold to South Africa, was approximately one million tons, or roughly four times the 1965 output. Cattle raising also has increased considerably in recent years, and foreign sales of beef, primarily to South Africa and Portugal, are substantially above the pre-UDI level. - 6 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 1966/67 1967/68 1968/69 1969/70 1970/71 a/ 1971/72 2/ Domestic Quotas for Flue-Cured Tobacco, by Crop Year Weight (million pounds) Average price (cents per pound) Total earnings (thousand Us $) a. Scheduled. 200 132 132 132 100 100 29 33 33 3 3 66,000 43,560 38,280 43,560 33,000 33,000 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECRET Mineral Exports 10. Chromium probably is Rhodesia's only mineral product to be affected other than marginally by sanctions. At UDI, Rhodosin was the world's third largest chrome ore producer behind the Soviet Union and South Africa. Production in 1965 was 645,500 tons of mainly high-quality metallurgical-grade ore, most of which came from mines owned by two US com- panies: Union Carbide Corporation and Foote Mineral Company. The United States was the major buyer and took about 340,000 tons in 1965. Another 200,000 tons were sold to South African companies in 1965, but a good part of this tonnage apparently was stockpiled in Mozambique in preparation for UDI. 11. Rhodesia's chrome industry continues to operate at about 85% of the pre-UDI level. The Salisbury regime, which has virtually taken over the industry, has sought to avoid a sharp produc- tion cutback partly because this wuuld result in heavy unemployment at the mines. Since practically all Rhodesia's chrome ore shipments now are moving in disguised trade channels, exports are difficult to estimate, but foreign sales are probably about 400,000 tons a year. South Africa probably buys considerable amounts of ore, and reportedly Rho- desian chrome is being marketed in Europe and the Far East. Only the United States and the United Kingdom among the major consumers have sought con- sistently to enforce the chrome sanctions. As high- quality non-Rhodesian ore is in short supply, the Soviet Union, the principal alternative source, has raised its price to the United States and others from a range of $30.50 to $33.00 in 1967, the last year of legal Rhodesian chrome exports, to a current range of $55.10 to $59.60. The in- crease in price, coupled with an increase in ex- ports, has enabled the Soviet Union to nearly double its hard currency earnings from chrome ex- ports to approximately $55 million in 1.969. Asbestos, the most 25X1 25X1 valuable mined product, accounted for about one- fifth of total mineral output and nearly 10% of exports in 1965. Rhodesia ranked fourth in world asbestos production in 1965, with an output of 175,000 tons, and was the leading producer of high- quality long-staple chrysotile fiber. Production - 8 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECRET in 1966 reportedly was maintained at least at the 1965 level and may even have increased somewhat since then. While asbestos exports cannot be deter- mined with any certainty, Rhodesia almost certainly is selling most of its output. 13. Production and sales of copper and pig iron, two other important Rhodesian minerals, have been little affected by sanctions. New channels now handle Rhodesian copper sales in Europe, a function formerly performed by British firms, and exports probably are close to 22,000 tons annually, corn- parei. with 19,000 tons in 1965. Pig iron exports probably also are running close to the 1965 level of 235,000 tons. Most exports are shipped through South Africa, which in 1967 and 1968 reported pig iron reexports of roughly 170,000 tons a year. In sharp contrast, no reexports were recorded during the three years prior to mandatory sanctions. Japan almost certainly is the final destination. Imports 14. The oil embargo, once the most effective aspect of the sanctions program and the one with greatest potential impact on the economy, has be- come increasingly less effective. Formerly, Rho- desia imported crude oil through the Mozambique port of Beira, via pipeline, for its refinery at Umtali. Following UDI, the United Kingdom stopped most of these shipments, and the pipeline was closed. In the first year after UDI, Rhodesia experienced shortages of many petroleum products -- consumption declined 25%, from 3,349 million bar- rels in 1965 to 2,506 million barrels in 1966 -- but South Africa's supply efforts prevented a serious economic disruption. In subsequent years, Rhodesia has obtained its oil products almost en- tirely through South Africa, and consumption has increased about 4% a year from the 1966 level. 15. The comprehensive import embargo has been effective in a few specific cases. For example, automobile assembly in Salisbury and Umtali was halted because of difficulties in importing body assembly kits, and Rhodesia Airways has been unable to purchase Boeing 737s. Aside from such cases in which the import's origin is impossible to conceal, however, enforcement has not been very effective. - 9 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECRET Transport Sanctions 16. The extension of UN mandatory economic sanc- tions to ground and water transport will have a min- imal effect on the Rhodesian economy. Rhodesia's railroads, which are still the backbone of the transport network, make five international connec- tions, one each with Zambia, Botswana, and South Africa (through Botswana) and two with Mozambique (see the map) . Most of Rhodesia's trade moves through the latter three channels. As Portugal will not enforce sanctions, the Mozambique links are unaffected. The connection with Botswana and through Botswana with South Africa is Rhodesian- owned, and the Botswana are unlikely to sever this link, given their own requirements for transport access through South Africa. Contingency plans for building a direct Rhodesian-South African rail link exist in any case and could be implemented rapidly if necessary. The Zambian link facilitates Zambian trade more than Rhodesian trade, and its severance would impose substantial costs on the Zambian rather than the Rhodesian economy. Except for petroleum, the majority of imports and much of Zambia's copper exports still move by Rhodesia Railways. The only important non-Rhodesian trans- port routes now used are the Great North Road to Tanzania's port of Dar-es-Salaam and the Lobito rail route through Congo (Kinshasa) and Portuguese Angola, both of which are operating at capacity. 17. The highway and air systems, which supple- ment the rail network in international transport, will similarly be unaffected. The highway system has six international connections. The three that are important to Rhodesia's trade are to South Africa and Mozambique and will be kept open despite sanctions. The international air transportation system serving Rhodesia has been under economic sanctions since 1968. Airlines owned by South Africa, Portugal, Malawi, and Mozambique continue to operate effectively, however, linking Rhodesia with seven countries. Effects on the Economy 18. Economic activity slowed appreciably in the first year of sanctions, when real income per capita dropped almost 10% (see Table 2). Manufac- turing declined 11% in real terms as traditional - 10 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECRET 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 (Estimated) Million US $ Agriculture 189 192 204 172 206 Mining and quarrying 67 63 68 67 77 Manufacturing 186 170 189 209 230 Construction 45 44 53 66 71 Other 505 500 526 578 618 Gross domestic product at factor cost 992 969 1,040 1,092 1,202 Gross domestic product at factor cost in 1965 prices 992 941 990 1,021 1,093 US $ Per capita gross domestic product at factor cost in 1965 prices 221 204 207 207 215 GDP Price Deflator 100 103 105 107 110 sources of intermediate industrial inputs were denied and sales to Zambia, which in 1965 bought roughly 20% of Rhodesia's industrial output, fell sharply. Two major setbacks were the forced closing of the Umtali refinery and the two automobile as- sembly plants. Mining and quarrying output in real terms declined 9% as a result of the initial loss of foreign markets. - 11 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECRET 19. Output elsewhere in the economy initially was maintained at close to pre-UDI levels despite sanctions. A government program of sto---kpiling export commodit.es prevented an even sharper ini- tial drop in income levels and permitted output in agriculture, which otherwise would have been ex- tremely hard hit by the cutback in tobacco and sugar exports, to be maintained. Increases in stocks measured as a percentage of gross domestic product (GDP) rose from less than 1% in 1965 to 6% in 1966. 20. In 1967 and 1968 the economy recovered from the initial shock of sanctions, and economic activ- ity increased in real terms from the 1966 low at a rate roughly comparable with the growth in popula- tion. Despite tightened sanctions and a severe drought in 1968, the economy was sufficiently reor- ganized to maintain real income levels. The income distribution probably shifted slightly in favor of Europeans, however, while African per capita income declined. 21. The early months of 1969 marked a turning point. National income and exports began to rise, and mine output increased by perhaps $10 million as production began at the large new Anglo-American nickel mines. Manufacturing output, spurred by increasing import restrictions, grew about 10%, while agriculture registered about a 20% gain over the depressed 1968 level. Growth in real income approximated 7% in 1969, a rate greater than in any year since the Federation years of the 1950s, and, for the first time since UDI, there was a noticeable increase in per capita income. Invest- ment was probably higher than in any year since the boom years of the Federation. Employlent exceeded pre-UDI levels, with a larger percentage of the European population employed than in 1965. The percentage of the African population employed de- clined because population grew faster than employ- ment opportunities, although in actual numbers more Africans were employed (see Table 3). Price rises since UDI were only slightly more than 2% a year, as shown in the consumer price index for Europeans, which stood at 110 at the end of 1969 (1965 = 100). Inflation was controlled, in part, by draining off excess funds, which arose from import restrictions, through large-scale domestic borrowing to finance development projects and programs to counter sanc- tions. -? 12 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Population and Employment H Percent of Paid Population Population Employment in Paid Year (Thousand) (Thousand) Employment 1961 221 80 1962 222 80 1963 220 80 1964 209 79 1965 210 80 1966 213 81 1967 215 82 1968 223 85 1969 Percentage growth 1968/1961 1 38 Population Paid Employment Percent of Populatioa in Paid (Thousand) (Thousand) Employment 3,730 628 17 3,850 617 16 3,980 610 15 4,110 627 15 4,250 638 15 4,390 640 15 4,540 639 14 4,690 663 14 4,840 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 S1:E,C1.J '.L' 22. Some alteration of the economy's structure was necessary to lessen import requirements, partic- ularly for manufactured goods, and to produce mar- ketable export goods. Imports declined as a per- centage of GDP from 35% in 1965 to 28% in 1968, reflecting in part the rapid development of new import substitution industries. These new industries largely account for the recovery and expansion in manufacturing during the last three years and for the substantial rise in manufacturing income above the pre-UDI period. Diversification also has been extended to agriculture and, to a lesser extent, mining. 23- Most structural changes brought on and accelerated by sanctions probably would have been necessary eventually. The economy is now relatively more self-sufficient than formerly, and exports are more varied. Some of these changes are likely to remain, even if more normal trade should be rees- tablished. Prospects for the Economy 24. The economy, bolstered by a continuing sub- stantial rise in manufacturing and mining, is likely to grow more than 5% annually throe gh 1975, even if present sanctions continue in force. Mining output is expected by the government to at least triple by 1975 to more than $200 million annually as new mines are developed and existing ones expanded. The Gatooma and I3indura/Shomva nickel complexes, which began production in mid-1969, will lie major contri- butors, adding approximately $30 million annually to mineral output when in full production. Although mining will replace manufacturing as the fastest growing sector, continued import controls -- only 10% of import allocations are believed to go for finished consumer goods -- should provide the stimulus for an almost 10% annual growth of manu- facturing through the early 1970s. 25. Although agricultural income probably rose sharply in 1969 because of improved weather, further increases during 1970-75 will be moderate. While Rhodesia is emphasizing crops less vulnerable to sanctions, particularly cotton, wheat, and corn, recovery will continue to be retarded by tobacco sanctions ar.d generally poor alternative agricul- tural export opportunities. Tobacco stockpiling - 14 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 S1.4CAOIJ, 1' is likely to continue in the early 197013, but at reduced levels, as tobacco output declines. 26. Rhodesia's number one economic problem in the 1970a id likely to be a shortage of skilled manpower. Because most skilled positions tradi- tionally are filled by whites, economic growth is tied to the growth rate of the white labor force. 27. In the past the demand for white workers has been met in part through increased job partici- pation. From 1961 through 1900, for example, a period of slow economic growth, white employment rose 6% while the white population increased only 1% (see Table 3). Since white participation rates are now quite high, an increase in white employment will be possible only if the white population is increased substantially. 28. The Rhodesian government has sought to en- courage immigration, and even with sanctions, has reversed the net emmigration of the politically uncertain nre-UDI period (see Table 4). Immigration, howevcr, may not be large enough to meet require- ments. Some relaxation in discriminatory practices against black labor could well be necessary if a shortage of skilled labor is not to become a major economic constraint to economic gi)wth in the 1970s. European immigration and Emmigration Year Immigrants Immigrants Net Migration 1961 a/ 6,630 8,600 -1,970 1962 a/ 6,060 9,940 -3,880 1963 a/ 5,090 14,320 -9,230 1964 7,000 15,410 -8,410 1965 11,130 7,670 3,460 1966 6,420 8,510 -2,090 1967 9,620 6,300 3,320 1968 11,860 5,650 6,210 1969 10,930 5,8-30 5,040 a. E'xoluuivu of miyeation wit;: Zambia and Malawi. - 1.5 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SE X ;IrF,, I' II;t:Lancc_! of i'a sins i n 29. I;xpot: L!: dec.: .l.i trucl drat: L.i.c;ia..l y durincl t.llu ini- tial porn-UM puYlUd, I:;_111l.ncl from ;460 mia_.l..iort in :1.965 (incl.ud.i.nc_1 r(!(!xport:!: altd nt~l. clold naJ.'. n) to y300 million in 1906 .(nuu Tnl,.i(! 'Vhu dUc.l.incl con L.i.nuud in 1 96 7 , a l though ill it mode!: t r. ;I L(! , and aclain in 196f, Who'll hill wu;tLhor concl.i.L.i.on-; ;tdvur'nu].y affectod no:no expcrr.L crop!;. in .1966 LI-c, nhar.p fal.l in (xpor.tr; :na:in.ly roilect!t the !,0', reduction in tobacco na.1.en ;tnd it rc'cluc.cL.i.on in l:uyar coxpc,rtr:. , l;xpor. to of manu.l:,rc_-1.urc'(1 (hood!: t.:c, zarnb.i ;t n.l no [u]], contribuii ny Lo Lbe 1. c.1 i or' . i~hoc1c'n i an It,i I anc(! (d ]' ty!nc?nt.!; a/ FLi l I i on tit; .; 1 961`166 19 6 7 19613 I:xpc.,r: is .16O l:nport!t - 3'1 1 t;ervicen (n(.t) --1O Inventme:tt .i.nc(m(? hi(et) 'l'r.an!:far. (n(!t.) 1 Private capi t,tl (n(et_) -270 -.1011 --2'11 -17 ILLEGIB 30. Du rinct 1916t, for the fir:.t tir..e sincce U1)1, exports apparently increased ;ul!.tantially, prob- ably by more than 20c%. ;nickel from the new nickel - 16 - SF ( R I,.,I' Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 mine added appreclabl.y to oxl)ortri, but mot;L of tho increane probably ronulte(I from (lr.owi.n(l tiuccotiri in circumvent:inq aanctionn for moist exports. F xportn are likely to Continue to Brow in the .1.970n as min- oral production increa_lnen and nanct.i.onn become util]_ 101311 effocti.ve. 31. The (1overnmo;; t rv!i tri cted import!; after of i to love In compatible with export earn.i.n(in. Irocau11c ithodr_ni..a, normally h.u a "-or.y lar(le trade Uur.pl.u!;, however, imports di(1 not treed to be cut at.; much an expor.tn, and, except For a f'ew luxury connumer i.tomn3, mont import reyui r.ementu havv been met. 'VIic doc.l.1.ne halted after 1966, and by 1908 imporLrr were ap- proachinq pre-UU1. levc,in. Wi th improved f.orei(in oxchan(fe hold.ingn and fan ter. economic (IrowLh in 1969, import renLr.icLionu were rel.axr'cl, and import.; probably incroaned uti ll 1ur.t);r.-. Thr.ou(ih the 1070n the level of import!, in 1.ikeely to continue to rive with increanc.lz in income and export!:. 32. ithodenia'n net foreitin paynu nt. for u(~rvirc;; investment income, and trans: fern. fell f r()m $7`i mil- lion in 1965 to $40 million in 1966 but has since been increaninq (fradually. '.1'he sharp ini tial drop stemmed mainly from a halt in intcront and dividend paymentr3 on the rou(lhly :100 million in Iiriti .h investment!; in ithodr;;ia and from a (lecreane in freight and ire;urance exprndi ture? an. a con!;r(iuence of reduced trade. As trade expand!; and new fore i(In investrnmitt; b-!come profitable, net torei(in service payment3 arc: likely to continue to the i e~ic:~ The increase probably will be only yrach.lal, however, unless nanct:1On!i are' reiT1r+Ve'(1 clntl Ii, Le l.t_i L II1~i dlvi- dend paymentsi t(i the- t_)ni tod Kin(id-)m re;;u;'Ie. 33. The net balance on current ae('+)unt deLe,- riViiil_cd r+uihntanLiall', durrnoT 1`-C+`i-t'l but be(ran to improve by 1961 ' 0. 1'I-um a :?4:' million n.urplura in 1965, the balance foil to r(~tl(ih equality in the first year of indeprndeiice and then to deficits of $21 million in 11167 and : 77 million in 11168 as ex- POX-LE, and .t ? ,av!'ent L~ ....... .. .. .. - _... ~. ~-~~ ..... _~ increased. Serious economic probler,in were avoided by an unusually laroe.? capital inflow pr.im~arily fro.: South Africa, a nubritantial portion of which was diracted to the An(llo-American nickel mine n and tho Sable fertilizer project. A riot; in exports, in 1969, reduced or perhaps eliminated the current account deficit, and aurplunen may be achieved thanks to rising exports in the 1970s. - 17 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SEC.RE'i." 34. The reversal in the downward trend in ex- ports since March and April 1969 assumes special importance for the balance of payments. Had exports continued to decline, Rhodesia could not have main- tained an import level compatible with economic growth. The rise in exports was both an impetus to growth and a source of foreign exchange for im- ports needed to make this growth possible. If ex- ports continue to increase through the 1970s, as seems likely, and the deficit on current account is ended, Rhodesian national income and imports probably will rise. 35. The capital inflow declined in the first year of independence but subsequently increased substantially. A large net capital inflow, pri- marily private capital, tock place in 1967, and there was an even larger inflow in 1968. In both years these large inflows more than offset the cur- rent account deficit, resulting in some increase in foreign exchange resources. Private capital is attracted to Rhodesia by mining and manufacturing opportunities, and the inflow is likely to continue at a high level through the 1970s, although perhaps at a lower level than in 1968. Foreign exchange reserves, which probably amounted to some $33 mil- lion at the end of 1968, consequently should con- tinue to increase. 36. During Rhodesia's first three year,, of independence, economic sanctions succeeded in cur- tailing economic growth and in generating a growing foreign trade deficit. The Rhodesian population suffered little economic hardship, however, and, with South African assistance, the economic author- ities have been able to restructure the economy. The downward trend has been reversed, and in 1969 both real income and exports grew substantially as post-independence investments, particularly in mining and manufacturing, bore fruit. 37. The trade embargo, although inducing an initial decline in exports of more than one-third, did not prevent a substantial rise in exports in 1969. Except for tobacco and sugar, exports of agriculture, mining, and manufacturing have now - 18 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 ^.~ Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4 SECR1''..I' essentially reached or exceeded pro-UDI levels. The recently imposed -transport sanctions are expected to have little jr no adverse effect. Virtually no addi- tional economic pressure can be placed on Rhodesia so long as the United Kingdom and others are deter- mined to avoid measures that would result in con- frontation with South Africa. 38. The Rhodesian economy is likely to grow at a substantial rate in the early 1970s as mining, manufacturing, and tertiary activities continue to expand and agricultural diversification proceeds sufficiently to permit some increase in agricultural income. The structural changes brought on or accel- erated by sanctions are likely to remain, and they may provide a stronger base for economic growth than has existed since the boom days of Federation. 39. Substantial problems remain in the economy, however, the most important of which stems from racial discrimination in employment. Discriminatory labor practices have led to a relative shortage of white labor and a relative surplus of black labor since the black labor force is growing rapidly. The continued acceptance of a dualistic employment policy may prevent the economy from attaining the real growth of which it is capable. - 19 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/10/31: CIA-RDP85T00875R001600030040-4