SMALLER LDC DEBTORS: ECONOMIC SITUATION AND US INTERESTS

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
31
Document Creation Date: 
December 22, 2016
Document Release Date: 
August 18, 2010
Sequence Number: 
6
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
March 1, 1985
Content Type: 
REPORT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9.pdf1.16 MB
Body: 
Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Directorate of Secret Intelligence and US Interests Smaller LDC Debtors: Economic Situation State Dept. review completed Secret GI 85-10068 March 1985 397 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Directorate of Intelligence Smaller LDC Debtors: Economic Situation and US Interests This paper was prepared by Office of Global Issues. Comments and queries are welcome and may be directed to the Chief, Economics Division, OGI, Secret GI 85-10068 March 1985 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Smaller LDC Debtors: Economic Situation and US Interests Key Judgments The condition of many low- and middle-income debtors-illustrated by Information available Colombia, Egypt, Indonesia, Morocco, Pakistan, Peru, and the Philip- as of 4 February 1985 pines-requires increased attention. The potential for further deterioration was used in this report. has put their governments at odds with international creditors, the International Monetary Fund, and domestic opposition groups. Moreover, important US interests could be hurt by their economic and political problems. These debtors probably will face increasing difficulties over the next few years because of slowed growth in industrial countries; soft commodity prices; protectionist pressures in export markets; rescheduled debt, which will fall due in 1986-87; and rapid population increases. The United States, therefore, could face a new set of debt-induced commercial issues. LDCs strapped for foreign exchange probably will increasingly adopt counter- trade requirements that will hurt US exporters and undermine US trade policy. Moreover, developing country attempts to rapidly expand exports could accelerate protectionist pressures in Western countries. Although most of these debtor LDCs value their ties with Washington, worsening economic problems probably will move them to try to use these ties-particularly foreign policy and military/ strategic ties-to exact financial concessions such as increased aid. They could turn to Washing- ton's ideological adversaries if they feel the United States is not being responsive-even though they would meet limited success and receive primarily military assistance. The United States will confront difficult-or potentially difficult-eco- nomic and political conditions in its bilateral relationships with many debtor developing countries, not just the seven discussed in this paper. A steady improvement in the world economy and the adoption of rational economic policies by these LDCs would greatly help their financial problems. In our judgment, however, this combination of events is unlikely in the near term. iii Secret GI 85-10068 March 1985 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Philippines 6 Forces for Economic Improvement 7 Strategic/ Military 11 Foreign Policy 12 Opportunities for US Adversaries . 13 C. Economic/Social Indicators Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Smaller LDC Debtors: Economic Situation and US Interests The debt condition of low- and middle-income LDCs has been largely overshadowed by attention to larger, higher income countries such as Mexico, Brazil, and Argentina. In many cases, however, the debt burden of these countries relative to the size of their econo- mies is just as great as that of the Big Three. Seven countries illustrate the economic problems of these LDC debtors: ? Peru and the Philippines face severe economic and political crises. ? Egypt and Morocco need to reduce subsidies and cut budget expenditures. ? Colombia and Peru have the additional problems that stem from drug trafficking and guerrilla terror- ism, which are further eroding confidence in their governments. ? Indonesia and Pakistan, although not in immediate danger, are not on solid footing. Despite their differences, the seven countries are similar in their vulnerability to external economic conditions such as recession in industrial countries, fluctuating commodity prices, high interest rates, uncertain commercial. lending, and slowdowns in Western aid. Moreover, because these countries have linkages to key US interests, the problems posed by their economic slide go beyond concern for the stabil- ity of the international financial system. The 1981-82 recession in industrial countries, the contraction of world trade, and other external and domestic problems have heavily hurt these developing countries. Colombia' With its substantial mineral resources, varied agricul- ture, and growing industrial base, Colombia is better equipped than many of its Latin American neighbors Table 1 LDC Debtors: Rank and Magnitude of Debt, 1984 Philippines 17. Colombia 12 Egypt 18. Pakistan 12 India 19. Taiwan 10 Malaysia 20. Ecuador 8 to deal with its economic problems. In the late 1970s when prices for coffee, cocaine, and marijuana were high, Colombia opened the economy and enjoyed an economic boom. Now commodity prices are down and Colombia's inefficient industries still are being bat- tered by imports. Agricultural and industrial produc- tion has declined, and unemployment is climbing- now 14 percent. Even earnings from illicit drugs have declined from a peak of $1 billion annually in the early 1980s to about $400 million in 1984, according to press reports. The US Embassy reports that real GDP growth is projected to be 1 to 2 percent in 1984. To cope with the economic downturn, President Be- tancur's government implemented economic reforms in 1984 that tightened import restraints, accelerated the pace of the peso's mini-devaluations, and intro- duced a value-added tax. Colombia is relying on two new energy projects to resolve its economic problems. The world's largest coal strip mine began production for export in early 1985, and, according to the press, by 1986 Colombia could be self-sufficient in oil. However, Bogota's quest 25X1 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 c to Table 2 Smaller LDCs: Factors in Economic Plight r?. Price Trends for Key Weather Worker Remittances Military Government Policies/ Debt, 1979-84 Exports to OECD, 1981- Commodity Ex- Expenditures Political Problems 83 b (million US $) ports, a 1983-84 Colombia Coffee = 3.5 percent Egypt Petroleum d = - 15 percent Down 10 percent, About 1 percent of Narcotics trafficking; $6-12.5 billion; inter- 2,673 1984 (projected) budget guerrilla violence. est payments 2,613 doubled; debt-service 2,766 ration from 17 per- cent to 30 percent. Up 7 percent, 1984 13 percent of budget Food, energy subsi- $16.5-25.3 billion. 4,760 dies-$3 billion, 4,032 1982-83 (14 percent 3,664 of budget). Indonesia Petroleum d = Drought 1982-hurt c Less than 15 percent Subsidies on food, $16.8-32.0 billion. 21,650 -15 percent rice crop. of budget fertilizer, fuel; anti- 18,567 Rubber= Chinese riots, 17,698 -6 percent Orthodox/Muslim clashes. Morocco Phosphate rock = Drought since Down in 1983; exact Spends $1 million Food, education sub- $6.1-12.8 billion. 1,794 -25 percent 1981-hurt grain figures not available per day on Western sidies (9 percent and 1,788 production. Sahara war 27 percent of admin- 1,736 istrative budget); riots in early 1984. Pakistan Cotton = Poor weather hurt Down 5 percent, 25 percent of budget Demonstrations in $8.7-11.5 billion. 1,090 -9 percent cotton, wheat crops. 1984 Sind; Afghan 1,079 refugees; narcotics 1,115 trafficking. Peru Petroleum d = El Nino-drought, - 15 percent floods; agricultural production down 10 percent. 25 percent of budget, Subsidies on food, $9-14 billion; debt 2,556 .1983; Sendero Lu- energy, water; labor service ratio from 32 2,479. minoso insurgency strikes; narcoterror- percent to 75 per- 2,480 ism. cent. Philippines Coconut oil = Drought 1982-83- Up 74 percent, 1981- Communist insur- Subsidies on food, $13-26 billion; inter- 5,311 3 percent hurt rice, sugar, co- 83 gency; pressure for fuels, transportation; est payments 4,333 Sugar = conut crops. increased spending labor strikes, demon- quadrupled. 4,715 - 35 percent strations, opposition Copper = to Marcos. -8.4 percent a = IMF data, annual prices. b = OECD Data c Blank box indicates no significant information or development in this area. d = OPEC weighted average, crude. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Table 3 Smaller LDCs: Austerity Programs IMF program Currency Devaluation Foreign-Exchange Budget/Subsidy Cuts, Tax Reform Other Controls 1983/84 a Value-added tax. Import restrictions; barter counterpurchase requirement for 30 prod- uct-imports. Multiple exchange rates Recent crackdown on Will slowly reduce New consumption tax on Promises greater role for with gradual adjustment unofficial FX dealers; subsidies. luxury goods. private investment and in tourist and new regulations to countertrade agreement commercial rates. attract tourists/ required. remittances. $300 million standby (September 1983 to March 1985) 16 percent (1983) Pakistan Extended Fund Facility (1981-83) canceled a Extended Fund Facility (June 1982 to June 1984) canceled. Standby $344 million (April 1984) 53 percent (1984) Philippines $615 million standby (December 1984) 34 percent (since October 1983) Removed controls; multiple FX rates before IMF program. a Blank box indicates no significant information or development in this area. Cut budget deficit; elim- Tax increase. Ban on new government inate food subsidies; investment projects. raise prices for water, gasoline, electricity. Budget cuts; Tax increases; broaden a removed/reduced base; improve collection. subsidies on basic commodities. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Cut government spend- Tax reform: lower rates, Canceled/rephased ing; reduced subsidies on broaden base, simplify major development food, fuel, fertilizer. laws. projects. Reduced subsidies for basic commodities and education. Subsidies for basic commodities. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 for financing to support development projects has been stymied by "guilt by association." Because of problems with other Latin debtors, banks are reluc- tant to lend money for energy development projects, and they have refused to roll over Colombia's $3.4 billion short-term debt. As a result, Colombia is in a debt trap: it draws down reserves to service its $12.5 billion debt, and banker reluctance to lend increases as foreign exchange reserves fall Egypt Egypt lives beyond its means and relies on external sources of income over which it has little control: ? Petroleum exports are subject to declining prices and soft markets. ? Remittances from 3 million overseas Egyptian workers are vulnerable to changes in demand for immigrant labor in the Middle East. ? Suez Canal revenues are subject to slowed shipping traffic. ? Tourism receipts have not regained ground lost after President Sadat's assassination in 1981. According to Egyptian Government officials, income from these sources slipped in 1984. Following 8-percent real economic growth annually during the 1970s, the economy has fallen on hard times largely because of high consumption and unpro- ductive investment. The trade and current accounts recorded large deficits-$5.8 billion and $2.5 billion, respectively-in 1984. External debt climbed to over $25 billion in 1984, ranking Egypt eighth among LDC debtors. Although most of its debt is in official medium- or long-term obligations, Egypt's 1984 debt service totaled $3.2 billion-second only to Indonesia's among these seven countries. Domestic economic policies have contributed to eco- nomic dislocation. Agricultural pricing policies have discouraged farmers from increasing output. Food subsidies-for bread in particular-have encouraged consumption, requiring food imports of about $3 billion in 1983. The government also has held petro- leum and public utility prices to less than 20 percent of world prices, and consumption increases by about 15 percent annually. In addition, the country's infra- structure is decaying, urban overcrowding contributes to epidemics, and the housing shortage is acute. In the country's "race against time," President Mubarak has initiated economic reforms-without an IMF pro- gram-to reduce subsidies, raise taxes, and encourage foreign investment. The pace may be slow, however, because the government has met popular resistance in the past. Indonesia Indonesia is not now on the LDC economic sick list, but potential difficulties exist. Jakarta has stayed off the troubled debtor list so far because it undertook austerity early to prevent further deterioration of its external and domestic budget accounts when oil prices dropped in 1982-83 and other commodity markets softened: ? In 1983 it devalued the rupiah 27.5 percent to stem capital flight, boost reserves, halt currency specula- tion, and encourage nontraditional exports. ? The government also reduced subsidies on food, fertilizer, and fuel products, causing domestic fuel prices to rise 50 to 76 percent. ? In addition, the government reviewed 125 major development projects and decided to cancel or re- phase those with a major import content that would drain foreign exchange. These measures have reversed the external trends that had hurt Indonesia but have also severely pressured the domestic economy. The government is having to deal with nearly 2 million entrants to the labor market annually, and layoffs are adding to the problem. Official unemployment for 1983 was 4 percent, but the US Embassy estimates that 20 to 25 percent of the 60 million labor force is effectively unemployed. These unfavorable trends have led to some labor restiveness and an increase in wildcat strikes. Increas- ingly, union leaders have spoken out on behalf of members emphasizing the need for job protection and wage increases and decrying subsidy cuts for fuel and bus fares. The rise in unemployment also has led to an increase in violence, The government may have to deal with unrest among those hurt by austerity measures and with dissatisfac- tion among students and youth who see poor pros- pects. Anti-Chinese bomb attacks and Orthodox Mus- lim riots already have erupted. 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Morocco Morocco faces acute financial difficulties, many of which have developed from circumstances beyond its control: ? Severe droughts since 1981 have caused serious shortfalls in agricultural production-particularly of cereals-and required heavy grain imports. ? Collapsed phosphate markets have reduced export income; Morocco relies on phosphates for 40 percent of its export earnings. ? European trade barriers have restricted Morocco's traditional citrus and vegetable exports, and Europe's economic restructuring has caused the level of remittances from Moroccan workers-the country's largest foreign-exchange earner-to level ? Service payments on the country's $12.8 billion debt escalated because of high interest rates and US dollar appreciation and necessitated a debt resched- uling in 1983-84. War in Western Sahara is an added economic drain and costs the government an estimated $1 million per day or 30 percent of the government's administrative budget, according to the US Embassy. The government also faces social pressures caused by economic decline. More than 40 percent of the popu- lation is at or below the poverty line, and the number is rising because of falling real incomes. To ameliorate these conditions, the government provides subsidies for basic foods, which take 9 percent of the national budget; free universal education consumes another 27 percent. Despite high financial outlays for education, only 28 percent of the population is literate. To qualify for an IMF standby arrangement in September 1983, Rabat implemented austerity mea- sures. Efforts by the government to raise food prices and school fees as part of that program spawned riots in January 1984. The standby expires in March 1985, and negotiation of a new IMF program is necessary for Rabat to reschedule debts and receive additional aid. We expect negotiations to be completed by Pakistan Pakistan is not experiencing an economic crisis, but it is one of the world's poorest countries with formidable external debt servicing requirements. Real economic growth slowed to 3.5 percent in 1984, the lowest since President Zia took power in 1977. This was primarily because of a disastrous cotton crop and a disappoint- ing wheat harvest. A 5-percent decline in worker remittances in 1984-on which the economy relies heavily-also contributed to increased economic diffi- culty. Moreover, financial support for over 2 million Afghan refugees who have fled to Pakistan cost the Pakistani Government-according to its claim- $350-400 million in goods and services in 1983 and continues to drain its resources. Pakistan's debt-$11.5 billion-ranks it 18th among LDC debtors in 1984. Although 85 percent of the debt is owed to official sources at mostly concessional rates, the 1984 debt servicing burden was still over $1 billion. Despite several debt reschedulings in the 1970s and early 1980s, the country's debt service ratio was 22 percent in 1984-about average for many developing countries, but high given the number of reschedulings. The government's proposed 1985 budget does not introduce dramatic revenue measures that would hurt the populace. However, the US Embassy reports that Islamabad may need to cut social-sector investments for health, education, and population control. The need for reductions could be precipitated by an eco- nomic downturn resulting from a combination of events-such as bad weather or further drops in worker remittances. Peru The economic and social crisis in Peru is deepening largely because of three factors: natural disasters, world recession, and narcoterrorism. In December 1982 climatic changes caused by El Nino-a warm current that replaced the cold waters of the Humboldt Current-brought severe drought in the south and floods in the north. It left $1 billion in damage and dropped agricultural production 10 percent. The 1981-82 world recession contributed to plunging midyear. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 prices for Peru's primary exports-copper, silver, and petroleum. The resulting need to cut imports contrib- uted to a decrease in industrial production to about one-third of total capacity. Industrial unemployment and underemployment now affect two-thirds of the Narcoterrorism is the country's third major problem. Peru is one of the world's two largest coca leaf producers, and for the past two years Peruvian pro- ducers, with help from Colombian distributors, have moved aggressively into the market. According to the US Embassy, the growing narcotics trade has corrupt- ed important Peruvian institutions such as the police force and court system, and it is a temptation for a middle class trying to maintain its standard of living. A new difficulty is that terrorists-especially the Maoist Sendero Luminoso-are now operating in major drug producing areas where the level of vio- lence has increased and threatens the government's antidrug program. Adding to Peru's economic drain are: ? Pressures for increased military expenditures be- cause of the military's dominant political role. ? A thriving underground economy that robs the government of tax income and undermines the government's legitimacy. ? Peru's $14 billion external debt in 1984. The Embassy reports that 40 percent of the 1985 budget is slated for debt service. Lima had stopped interest payments on its debt in June 1984 but recently paid $50 million to keep from falling more than six months behind on servicing, according to press reports. Even so, Peru is $200 million behind on commercial bank interest payments, and negotiations with creditor banks continue to be bogged down while Peru seeks bridge financing. Because earlier reforms caused demonstrations and strikes, Belaunde's gov- ernment appears unwilling to take the austerity steps necessary to negotiate an IMF agreement before the spring elections. The US Embassy reports that auster- ity combined with prolonged economic stagnation will be socially explosive and probably politically untena- Philippines Despite abundant natural resources, a well-educated labor force-overall literacy is 87 percent-talented government technocrats and business entrepreneurs, and an open, capitalistic economy, the economy is in its most serious crisis since World War II. It currently has one of the worst growth performances in Asia; real GNP fell 5.5 percent in 1984. The inflation rate exceeds 50 percent, its current account deficit is nearly $1 billion, and it is the seventh-largest LDC debtor. Prices for its traditional commodity exports remain low, and the value of the peso has declined 34 percent since September 1983. The domestic financial system has also weakened with some banks going under. In response to these problems, the Philippines adopted an IMF-approved economic program as a prerequisite for a $615 million standby loan; the agreement was signed in December 1984. Before that, subsidies were reduced for the second time in 12 months on basic food items, petroleum products, and electricity. In addition, the Central Bank has lifted foreign exchange controls, and the government has canceled or scaled back major industrial projects and is raising taxes. The deteriorating economy has affected all sectors of society. Since 1983, financial credits for business have dried up, bankruptcies have increased, and factories have halted or scaled down production. As a result, unemployment has climbed, and workers' unemploy- ment benefits are running out. Philippine economists indicate that unemployment in Manila alone grew by 400,000 in the first 10 months of 1984. Real incomes have dropped and the income gap between rich and poor is growing. The press reports that nearly 80 percent of the population lives below the poverty level, and obtaining sufficient food is increasingly a problem for more than half of the population. Economic deterioration also has affected education where costs Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret have risen, and parents cannot afford to pay even nominal fees. In 1984, according to press reports, 60 percent of enrolled students were forced to return to the provinces from universities in Manila. The Philippines' economic straits are compounded by concurrent political pressures on the government of President Ferdinand Marcos. Political opposition spurred by the assassination of Benigno Aquino has coalesced with demonstrations against economic aus- terity. Marcos's health also has raised concern about the successor issue, and these simultaneous political- economic forces are contributing to a potentially volatile situation. To quell popular discontent, most of these LDCs, and many others like them, will resist needed changes in economic policy and management. Government subsi- dies for basic food and other consumer goods drain a large share of budget resources in Egypt, Morocco, Indonesia, the Philippines, and Pakistan. Many of these governments have committed to reducing or eliminating subsidies, which could cause strikes or other turmoil that could threaten these regimes. On the other hand, politically expedient economic poli- cies-such as food subsidies-designed to mollify restive populations could lead to equally destabilizing budget deficits and spiraling inflation. Although some military expenditures have been pared, the reasons for substantial military allocations are not likely to recede. Insurgent groups in Peru and the Philippines are gaining strength while Colombia is trying to counter terrorist groups. There is no indica- tion that Morocco's war against the Polisario in Western Sahara will end soon. Pakistan will continue to feel the need to allocate a large share of its budget to the military partly because it fears Indian intentions. Sociopolitical conditions in most of these countries will worsen without resumption of vigorous economic growth. Lack of jobs, unemployment, and underem- ployment probably will continue to be serious prob- lems in the wake of a continued need for austerity. Moreover, real incomes will continue to decline, and High population growth in all the countries-at 2.1 percent Colombia's is lowest-will exacerbate the unemployment nightmare as well as strain social services and resources. In Indonesia nearly 4 million are born annually and 2 million will enter the labor market every year. Pakistan is the world's ninth most populous country, and its population will double ap- proximately every 23 years. Morocco's population is expected to double by the year 2010. We estimate that Peru and the Philippines, respectively, will need to create 150,000 and 700,000 new jobs annually just to keep pace with population growth. While irrational government policies and demograph- ic forces augur continued problems for low- and middle-income debtors, improvements in the interna- tional economy could brighten their prospects: ? Economic growth in the OECD countries should expand an average 3 percent in 1985, although growth in the United States and Japan will slow from last year's rates; continued OECD growth will support some LDC recovery, but not enough to put the LDCs back on a path of sustained growth. ? The resulting expansion in world trade also should contribute to LDC economic recovery. GATT re- ports that world trade volume grew 9 percent in 1984, and a rate of just over 6 percent in growth is possible this year. ? Continued declines in interest rates also will ease LDC economic burdens. For the major LDC debt- ors, a 1-percentage-point decline in interest rates saves $2 billion annually in debt service. ? Lowered oil prices have helped nonoil LDCs curb spending for energy, and this trend probably will continue in 1985. It does, however, hurt prospects for the oil exporters in the group, like Peru and Indonesia. gaps between rich and poor will widen. 25X1 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 In the long run, adherence to economic adjustment programs adopted by some debtor LDC governments will be a primary factor in determining the extent of their recoveries. Some-Colombia, Egypt, and Peru-may undertake formal IMF programs this year. Should these governments maintain the political will to carry out needed reforms-despite probable downturns in the first year of austerity-the long- term prospects for their economies will be significant- ly improved. The possible consequences of these LDCs' economic problems-and of countries like them-could threat- en significant US interests that go beyond the stabil- ity of the international financial system. These inter- ests include economic, strategic/military, and foreign policy concerns that could be hurt if LDC economic problems lead to increasingly unstable domestic situa- tions. Commerce US trade and investment could suffer increasingly. The US trade deficit will widen in 1985, and these LDCs' economic adjustment programs will contribute to the increase. In 1984, US exports to these seven countries dropped below 1983 levels for all but Paki- stan and Morocco. Exports to Indonesia fell by $250 million or 17 percent; and by $148 million to Peru or 16 percent. These countries-especially Colombia, Peru, and the Philippines-will again severely curtail imports and promote exports in line with IMF stabili- zation programs and self-imposed austerity measures this year. These efforts will further dampen demand for US goods. In addition, these countries could resort to greater trade distorting policies, such as export subsidies, to stimulate exports and earn more foreign exchange. These subsidies will present increasing problems to US policymakers as the demand from US industries for offsetting protectionist policies will grow. Another concern to the United States is increased countertrade, that is, trade contingent on an exchange of goods and services. Countries strapped for foreign exchange are requiring countertrade arrangements. US Exports, Imports, and Investment Position, 1983 Legend ~ Exports = Imports Investment Colombia Egypt Indonesia Morocco Pakistan Peru Philippines Depending on the definition of countertrade, observ- ers estimate that it composes 10 to 40 percent of all Third World trade. Indonesia and Colombia now require countertrade for certain imports. These re- quirements not only burden US exporters, but they also undermine US policy efforts to promote open markets. Deterioration in the investment climates of these debtor countries also has constrained US investment- represented by bank lending and private investment- and has hurt earnings of the banks and companies involved. Although some LDCs now are paying lipser- vice to welcoming foreign investment and improving 25X1 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Table 4 US Interests Democracy. Moderate voice in Latin American/Third World issues. Promoted Contadora Group. Hosted Latin debtor countries. Camp David accords. Role in broader Arab- Israeli peace. Helpful on issues re- garding Lebanon. Strength offsets radical Arab states. Pro-West anti- Communist. Moderate, nonconfron- tational on North-South issues. Pro-West. Moderate in Arab councils. Helped return Egypt to Islamic conference. Strategic position in Caribbean. Support for US policies may depend in part on economic needs and re- sources to be gained from Arab ties; wants to reap greater economic benefits from US "spe- cial relationship." Malacca Straits and other Indonesian waters for military/commercial movement. Strait of Gibraltar, con- trols Mediterranean ac- cess; access and transit agreement; use of four airbases for training, emergencies; unrestrict- ed US Navy port calls. US exports = $9 billion, 1983, but dropped $400 million from 1982. US imports = $1 billion. New counterpurchase law. US exports = $2.8 billion. US imports = $0.3 billion. Relies on Indonesia for imports: petroleum, rub- ber, tin ($5.3 billion). $1.5 billion US ex- ports-growth market. Countertrade law for government-sponsored contracts. US Moroccan Joint Committee for Econom- ic Relations. US exports = $439 million. US imports = $31 million. US investment position = $1.9 billion. Trying to change restric- tive Andean Pact provisions. US investment position = $1.5 billion, 1983. OPIC = $2.2 million di- rect loans; $215 million, largest contingent liabil- ity for insurance. Investment position, 1983 = $3.04 billion; oil, manufacturing, forestry. US Moroccan Joint Committee for Econom- ic Relations. US investment position = $46 million (1982). $19.2 million, FY 1985 Control of narcotics proposal for narcotics trafficking-cocaine, control and military marijuana. assistance. $1.175 billion in military grant aid, FY 1985 pro- posal. $1 billion econom- ic aid, FY 1985 proposal. $155 million, FY 1985 proposal. $211 million military as- Largest VOA trans- sistance February 1983 mitter outside US. to February 1985. 25-year agreement to $84 million to upgrade build new VOA facil- airbase. ity signed in 1984. Development assistance since 1956 = $1.2 billion. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 fn Table 4 Investment position = Fourth-largest US aid Control of opium and $109 million (1982). recipient-$3.38 billion, hashish traffic from US-Pakistan aid agree- "golden crescent." ment for 1982-87. US investment position Largest US aid program Narcotics traf- = $2.3 billion; petro- in Latin America. ficking-cocaine. leum, banking. $110 million in food/de- velopment/disaster aid, FY 1984. $78.3 million, FY 1985 proposal. Investment position = $236.3 million, FY 1985 Immigration, legal $1.1 billion; banks, proposal. and illegal. manufacturing. Social Security and veteran benefits. Historical, colonial ties. US Interests (continued) a Blank box indicates no significant information or development in this area. Supports Soviet contain- ment in Afghanistan, Afghan resistance, and Afghan refugees. Moderating influence on Arab-Israeli issues. Sought to resolve Iran- Iraq conflict. Largest Soviet presence in South America. Growing appeal of Marxism. Approach to Third World debt does not support US policy. Pro-West, United States. Moderate on north- south issues. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Frontline state between Soviet-occupied Afghan- istan and Persian Gulf. Soviets providing easy credit for military purchases. Main line of defense in Pacific; Clark Air Base, Subic Bay Naval Com- plex; Five-year Military Base Agreement-$900 million. US exports = $812 million. US imports = $167 million: US exports down 18 percent. US exports = $0.9 billion. US imports = $1.2 billion. 10th-largest US export market among LDCs. US exports = $1.8 billion. US imports = $2.0 billion. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret investment opportunities, financial press reports indi- cate that little is changing to improve the climates for foreign investors. Despite increasing need for external capital, we believe that many countries are maintain- ing or introducing new investment performance re- quirements and linking bilateral trade issues to for- eign investment. In addition, other economic measures are stifling foreign investment in these countries. Exchange con- trols have curtailed profit repatriation; import restric- tions have impeded capital imports necessary for production; and greater poverty has shrunk domestic markets and sales. In many cases, these conditions have required the Overseas Private Investment Corpo- ration to pay insurance claims to US companies and the US Export-Import Bank to include its credits in rescheduling arrangements. In response to these conditions, a Council of Americas survey of 52 major US corporations operating in four Latin American countries found that corporate man- agement will make only minimum effort to maintain their investments. In particular, most indicated an unwillingness to add to their self-finance programs. This trend will hurt the US current account by slowing foreign investment income and will limit US export of products that US subsidiaries buy from the United States. The slowdown in the growth of US assets overseas, compared with increased foreign in- vestment in the United States, also will contribute to the trend that is making the United States a net debtor this year. Finance The United States also has a substantial financial aid investment in many of these debtor countries. Much of the development progress supported by US money has been eroded with the steady deterioration of their economies. In the case of military assistance-where Egypt, Pakistan, and the Philippines rank among the highest recipients worldwide-arrears on debt service have accumulated. Given their economic straits, most of these LDCs are asking the United States for increased economic and military assistance. For example, the United States provided the Philippines with a bridge loan following completion of the IMF standby agreement in Decem- ber 1984, and the Marcos government has requested increased military assistance to help resist the Com- munist insurgency. Egypt received $2.2 billion in US aid for FY 1984/85 but recently requested an addi- tional $1 billion to offset an expected drop in income this year from oil sales, remittances, and tourism, according to the press. President Mubarak wants to reap greater benefits from the US special relationship and contends that the United States has reneged on its commitment to maintain military and economic aid parity between Egypt and Israel. Because of this special relationship, Egypt also believes that the Unit- ed States should reschedule Egypt's military credits bilaterally, rather than in a multilateral forum. Grow- ing economic pressures in Egypt probably will mean continued requests from Egypt for more aid and debt relief. Morocco also has pressured the United States to forgive Foreign Military Sales credits as well as provide increased assistance. If the United States does not acquiesce, Moroccans could begin to question the close ties with the United States and blame King Hassan for not getting enough aid in exchange for military privileges. Like Egypt and Morocco, other LDCs pressed with declining economies will increase requests to the United States for greater economic and military assistance and will try to use whatever ties they have as leverage. Economic deterioration and rising debt burdens also may cause some developing countries to question their stance on external debt. Although most LDCs contin- ue to reject the idea of a debtors' cartel, the several meetings of Latin American debtors-the Cartagena Group-show that LDCs can form a debtors' organi- zation to talk about coordinating debt policies. If economic conditions become intolerable, the LDC governments might consider a debt cartel. Strategic/Military A number of these low- and middle-income countries provide strategic and military advantages important to the United States and its Western allies. These countries could use US interests as leverage for greater economic support. For example, Morocco's strategic position at the Strait of Gibraltar, the access 25X1 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Table 5 US Economic and Military Assistance, FY 1984 Worldwide 16,300.6 Colombia 11.3 Egypt 2,504.3 and transit rights it grants to the US military, the use of four former US airbases for training and emergen- cies, and unrestricted port calls by the US Navy could be denied if Morocco believes that the United States is not sufficiently forthcoming. In 1982 Rabat refused the United States permission for landing rights for US aircraft for a military exercise. According to a Moroccan official, refusal was linked to levels of military assistance. A similar situation could arise in the Philippines for the use of Clark Air Force Base and the Subic Bay Complex. Philippine economic needs could push the government to request more economic and military assistance in return for another Base agreement. Similarly, the United States relies on unimpeded passage through Indonesian waters, especially the Malacca Straits, for military and commercial move- ment. US strategic interests could be undermined if Indonesia hampered movement of US naval ships and aircraft across Indonesian waters. If Pakistan's econo- my were to deteriorate, it too could refuse further cooperation with the United States in resisting Soviet adventurism in Afghanistan and accepting Afghan refugees unless the United States provided increased Foreign Policy Many low- and middle-income debtors have been instrumental in supporting US foreign policy objec- tives. Three of these countries-Pakistan, Morocco, and Egypt-frequently support US Middle East goals. Pakistan has been a moderating influence in Islamic councils on Arab-Israeli issues and has sought to resolve the Iran-Iraq conflict. Morocco's King Hassan also has mediated between moderate and hardline Arab countries. Egypt is crucial for keeping the Camp David accords alive, offsetting the influence of radical Arab states, and encouraging a broader Arab-Israeli peace. If they perceive that their eco- nomic interests are better served elsewhere-for ex- ample, with other Arab states-they may not be as willing to carry the water for the United States in achieving its policy goals. In Latin America, Colombia has worked within the Contadora Group to resolve the Central American conflict. President Betancur played a direct role in arranging contact between a representative of the Salvadoran guerrillas and the US special envoy to Central America. Colombia also played a moderating role in the Latin American debtors' conference at Cartagena in June 1984. If the United States refuses to help Colombia overcome its economic difficulties as it perceives the United States should, Colombia may change its moderate stances on Central America and LDC debt issues. Other US Interests The United States has cooperative programs with Pakistan, Colombia, and Peru for controlling drug trafficking. For fiscal years 1984 and 1985, the United States allocated over $25 million to support control programs in these countries. If their economic and debt burdens become too great, the countries could abandon these efforts and put their resources elsewhere. Another fallout from decline of these economies will be increased legal and illegal immigration to the United States. This is especially true in the Philip- pines where over 375,000 Filipinos are registered for immigration under preference categories and where visa and passport fraud has become epidemic. 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Opportunities for US Adversaries Severe economic problems could force these countries to seek alternate sources of aid from US adversaries. For financial reasons, some-Peru, Egypt, and Morocco-already are seeking closer ties with the Soviet Bloc and other US ideological adversaries who, in turn, will seize the opportunity to increase their influence. The Soviet Union, for example, already has a substan- tial presence in Peru but is seeking to strengthen its relationship by offering generous credit terms for supply the Peruvian Air Force with spare parts and an AN-32 aircraft. President Belaunde recently indicat- ed to the US Ambassador in Lima that, if Peru could not get more financial help from the United States, it might look elsewhere. Other smaller debtor countries are making or have been offered increased Soviet ties: ? Egypt hopes to acquire more spare parts for Soviet- built weaponry in its inventory and, in our judg- ment, believes that improved Egyptian-Soviet ties will facilitate this. The recent exchange of ambassa- dors may lead to trade concessions and resolution of the military debt that Egypt owes the Soviet Union. ? The Soviet Union also has made overtures to the Philippines to increase commercial ties. Although the Philippines has not warmed to the prospects, its continuing economic crisis could force it to reevalu- ate its position-particularly since Mrs. Marcos has had favorable contacts with the Soviets. ? Partly for economic reasons, Morocco has moved to develop closer ties with Libya. By signing a union treaty, Rabat, in our judgment, hopes to gain financial aid, possible barter arrangements, and 90,000 additional jobs for Moroccan workers. Rabat also warmly received a Soviet trade delegation and gave the mission prominent press coverage. The United States has interests in other LDCs-such as Nigeria, Sudan, Jamaica, Kenya, Ivory Coast, and Chile-which face economic burdens and/or political-military problems that could challenge US policymakers. For example, Sudan could ask for more aid for its ailing economy and assistance against the perceived military threat from Libya, while in Jamai- ca, economic problems could contribute to the reelec- tion of the leftist leaning opposition party. A steady improvement in the world economy and the adoption of rational economic policies by these LDCs, of course, would go a long way toward solving their financial problems. In our judgment, however, this combination of events is unlikely in the near term. 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Appendix A Basic Economic Indicators Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Colombia Basic Economic Indicators Billion US $ (except where noted) Imports, f.o.b. 3.00 4.30 4.76 5.18 4.76 4.60 Gross domestic product 27.93 33.39 36.38 38.88 37.32 37.69 b Real growth rate (percent) 5.1 4.2 2.5 1.1 0.9 3.0 Inflation rate (percent) 24.7 26.5 27.5 24.6 19.8 18.0 Commodities as a percent of total exports c 68.0 72.0 64.0 62.0 66.0 NA a f.o.b.-"free on board," quoted price of merchandise includes the cost of loading the goods into transport vessels at the specified place. b Adjusted for inflation. c Coffee, cotton, sugar, and fuel oil; IMF data. Egypt Basic Economic Indicators Billion US $ (except where noted) Commodities as a percent 62.0 78.0 78.0 79.0 76.5 NA of total exports c a f.o.b. - "free on board," quoted price of merchandise includes the cost of loading the goods into transport vessels at the specified place. b Data changes beginning in 1980 from calendar to fiscal year. c Crude petroleum, refined petroleum, and cotton; IMF data. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Indonesia Basic Economic Indicators Billion US $ (except where noted) Basic balance of payments 2.29 5.01 1.55 -1.01 NA NA Current account balance 0.97 2.90 -0.61 -5.95 -4.20 -3.40 Merchandise trade balance 5.90 9.17 6.79 1.36 0.43 2.50 Exports, f.o.b.a 15.14 21.76 23.39 19.71 18.64 18.90 Imports, f.o.b. 9.24 12.59 16.60 18.35 18.21 16.40 Gross domestic product 51.50 72.50 85.50 90.0 79.2 82.6 Real growth rate (percent) 5.1 7.6 7.1 -0.4 5.1 5.0 Inflation rate (percent) 21.8 16.0 7.1 9.7 11.5 9.0 Commodities as a percent of total exports b 97.6 97.7 97.1 95.3 95.0 95.0 Official foreign exchange reserves (excluding gold holding) a f.o.b.-"free on board," quoted price of merchandise includes the cost of loading the goods into transport vessels at the specified place. b Crude oil, rubber, wood, palm oil, coffee, nickel, tin, copper, refined petroleum, and liquefied natural gas. Morocco Basic Economic Indicators Billion US $ (except where noted) Basic balance of payments -0.14 -0.06 -0.55 -0.57 -0.11 0.02 Current account balance -1.56 -1.47 -1.89 -2.06 1.13 1.15 Merchandise trade balance -1.34 -1.38 -1.56 -1.77 -1.26 -1.30 Exports, f.o.b.- 1.99 2.42 2.28 2.04 2.04 2.10 Imports, f.o.b. 3.33 3.80 3.84 3.82 3.30 3.40 Gross domestic product 15.9 17.8 14.8 14.7 14.8 15.1 Real growth rate (percent) 4.5 3.8 -1.3 4.5 0.6 2.0 Inflation rate (percent) 15.0 15.0 17.0 13.0 12.0 12.0 Commodities as a percent of total exports b 40.0 42.0 39.0 36.0 32.0 30.0 a f.o.b.-"free on board," quoted price of merchandise includes the cost of loading the goods into transport vessels at the specified place. b Citrus fruit and phosphates; IMF data. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Pakistan Basic Economic Indicators Billion US $ (except where noted) Current account balance -1.13 -1.15 0.99 -1.61 -0.55 -1.03 Merchandise trade balance -2.17 -2.52 -2.77 -3.45 -2.99 -3.33 Exports, f.o.b.c 1.65 2.34 2.80 2.32 2.63 2.67 Imports, f.o.b. 3.81 4.86 5.56 5.77 5.62 6.00 Commodities as a percent of total exports d 26.0 34.0 33.0 22.0 24.0 22.0 1982-84 are Pakistani fiscal years ending 30 June. Prior to 1982 c f.o.b.-"free on board;" quoted price of merchandise includes the the rupee-dollar ratio was valued at 9.9 rupees per dollar. The value cost of loading the goods into transport vessels at the specified of the rupee compared to the dollar has been declining since 1982. place. b Includes official assistance and debt relief. d Cotton and rice; IMF data. Peru Basic Economic Indicators Billion US $ (except where noted) Commodities as a percent of total exports c f.o.b.-"free on board," quoted price of merchandise includes the cost of loading the goods into transport vessels at the specified place. b Adjusted for inflation. c Including copper and oil; IMF data. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Philippines Basic Economic Indicators Billion US $ (except where noted) Overall balance of payments -0.60 -0.37 -0.73 -1.64 -2.12 -2.34 Current account balance -1.50 -1.90 -2.06 -3.20 -2.75 -1.15 Merchandise trade balance -1.53 -1.93 -2.25 -2.65 -2.48 -0.58 Exports, f.o.b.- 4.60 5.79 5.71 5.02 5.01 5.35 Imports, f.o.b. 6.14 7.72 7.96 7.66 7.49 5.93 Gross national product b 29.85 35.25 38.44 39.54 33.97 31.71 Real growth rate (percent) 7.5 4.4 3.7 2.7 1.4 -5.5 Inflation rate (percent) 17.6 18.2 13.0 10.3 10.0 50.0 Commodities as a percent of total exports 67.0 64.0 55.0 53.0 53.0 50.0 - f.o.b.-"free on board," quoted price of merchandise includes the cost of loading the goods into transport vessels at the specified place. b GNP growth rate based on the Philippine peso. c Copper, wood, coconut products, and sugar; IMF data. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Appendix B Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Colombia Trends in International Debt Billion US $ (except where noted) Egypt Trends in International Debt Billion US $ (except where noted) Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Indonesia Trends in International Debt Billion US $ (except where noted) Total debt 16.8 18.7 20.4 24.0 28.4 32.0 Official sources 8.4 9.4 10.0 11.0 12.5 14.5 Private sources 6.7 7.2 7.5 9.4 12.2 14.0 Morocco Trends in International Debt Billion US $ (except where noted) Total debt 6.12 7.81 9.34 10.36 11.30 12.80 Official sources 2.83 3.47 4.35 4.90 5.40 6.05 Private sources 3.87 3.87 3.99 4.63 5.10 5.95 Short term 0.42 0.47 1.00 0.83 0.80 0.80 0.99 1.34 1.59 1.65 1.61 1.89 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Pakistan Trends in International Debt Billion US $ (except where noted) Total debt payments 0.65 0.75 0.88 0.91 0.80 1.02 Debt service ratio (percent) 24 20 17 18 14 22 Peru Trends in International Debt Billion US $ (except where noted) Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Philippines Trends in International Debt Billion US $ (except where noted) Total debt 12.6 16.4 19.4 22.9 24.3 26.0 Official sources 2.3 2.8 3.5 3.8 5.7 6.5 Private sources 5.0 6.1 6.9 8.1 9.4 10.0 Short term 5.3 7.5 9.0 11.0 9.2 9.5 1.2 1.7 2.2 3.05 2.9 3.0 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86TOO586ROO0200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Appendix C Economic/Social Indicators Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Economic /Social Indicators GNP Growth and Population and Literacy Rate Unemployment Percent of Popula- Per Capita Income Growth Rate (percent) Rate (percent) tion in Agricultural Sector (percent) Indonesia 5.0 percent (1984) 169 million 64 20-25 66 $440 (1983) 2.2 percent -5.5 percent (1984) 55.5 million 87 30 47 $570 (1982) 2.3 percent 3.5 percent (1984) 96.6 million 24 NA 52 $320 (1984) 2.6 percent 2.0 percent (1984) 24 million 28 30 50 $640 (1984) 2.9 percent 7.1 percent (1982) 47 million 40 NA 45 to 50 $670 (1984) 2.7 percent 3.0 percent (1984) 19 million 72 60 a 40 $865 (1984) 2.6 percent 3.0 percent (1984) 28 million 81 14 26 $1,335 (1984) 2.1 percent Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Secret Secret Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2010/08/18: CIA-RDP86T00586R000200220006-9