VERIFICATION AND THE SALT II TREATY

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4
Release Decision: 
RIFPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
10
Document Creation Date: 
December 16, 2016
Document Release Date: 
December 10, 2004
Sequence Number: 
18
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
November 21, 1979
Content Type: 
PERRPT
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4.pdf1.04 MB
Body: 
"~'~Yt'Y'Y~* JJPP fl ffiYhY'S SPECIAL EDITION THIS PURLIC.ATION 15 PREPARED BY THE AIR FORCE AS EXECUTIVE AGENT FOR THE DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE. TO BRING TO THE ATTENTION OF KEY DOD PERSONNEL NEWS ITEMS OF INTEREST TO THEM IN THEIR OFFICIAL CAPACITIES; IT IS NOT INTENDED TO SUBSTITUTE FOR NEWSPAPERS. PERIODICALS AND BROADCASTS AS A MEANS OF KEEPING INFORMED ABOUT THE NATURE. MEANING AND IMPACT OF NATIONAL AND INTERNATIOI" NEWS DEVELOPMENTS. USE OF THESE ARTICLES HERE, OF COURSE. DOES NOT REFLECT OFFICIAL ENDORSEMENT. FURTHER REPRODUCTION FOR PRIVATE USE OR GAIN IS SUBJECT TO THE ORIGINAL COPYRIGHT RESTRICTIONS. INTERNATIONAL SECURITY REVIEW Page 160 Verification and the SALT II Treaty Robert L. Pfaltzgraff, Jr. Like the SALT I Accords, the SALT II Treaty provides (Article XV) for verification by "national technical means" and stipulates that neither signatory will "interfere with the national technical means of verification" undertaken by the other. Moreover, the Treaty states that neither the United States nor the Soviet Union shall make use of "deliberate concealment measures" in an effort to impede the other side's ability to engage in verification in accordance with the provisions of the agreement. Like the ABM Treaty and the Interim Agreement, the SALT II Treaty provides for use of the Standing Consultative Commission established in December 1972. Among the functions of the Commission (Article XVII of the Treaty) is consideration of "questions concerning compliance" with the Treaty. Verification by "national technical means" relates to the intelligence capabilities of the state undertaking verification of the activities of another state, and specifically to the technologies available for this purpose. In SALT, the objects of verification have been principally inventories, including production rates, of strategic nuclear systems, although arms control verification encompasses weapons from the R&D to the deployment phase. To assert that the United States can, or cannot, verify the SALT II Treaty is to pass judgment upon the quality of the American intelligence community both to monitor Soviet compliance and to analyze information collected in timely fashion to ascertain the existence of a violation. But intelligence is not synonymous with verification. The needs of the United States to collect and evaluate intelligence about the SovietUnion exist with or without the SALT Treaty, as Secretary of Defense Brown has pointed out. The SALT Treaty sets requirements within itself for verification by virtue of JAMM KILL. n~RKn. CMI ~1- IEtlYaaB~~Mpp 7 C R~1r~9p pQ 1 1 R9 o y~~,~{J, A iSTANT CHItF POR 1 rRl~7[~RIf III FARA1U~CgiF. GN~F~EXGUTIVOEEN~EOX 52884 Approved For Release2005%8?/1221 C-' 9-0~1~31R000400350018-4 t~ O w O O C m ~~ w l< ~. r"a O .>-"a E _~ C C C ;+ O V -O u y - w .C :a u as o E % O ro ':+ w O < 3 6~ O ., u d ro C C w ro C C . a ay. ro 1] u p m ! O w u '~ m E _~ >' O O G. 0) O 03~ d0 E' CJi Q sm >, > 21 C a O .?~+ a N m> T7 j> O v.? m m `~ ro C U L y _ m O a3 'b a~ m O~ 0 w m C E Icz O r. A m C O v o O ro o O C y p a '' ? o 0M CL U Q c c v c c o y U 3 ro c 0 CU En as 'G ti E y -, aCi y .sy+ O' ~" ro> y E, [ O C C ~~ O- C m 41 u E O .C 0> am.. y -> .J ro v Q7 O ro 0> a u Q. It ro , y ui cmi m O O C C3 1< O y G -0 aEi a~16. 0 c G C ?~ as O co C m 7 m U1 y 00 Op o a+ C '' 4 Z ' d v; v ^c a a 4- a' m y E ? a w _c > o v ro ~ ?w to -o O ?' E U C4 0 a ; v 3 .C 0 m m - C .. ~' E, w m > > -O a: i y u ++ a 'w O ,~ C O L` > W u ,~ C 3 ..> C O 6) ++ +' y C ro .C u ro u" ro v O C C .C -,. ., Z ro .~ C O .~ C .> " m E as C ,, C m ro u C 0o Op C ~- o E m ., c ?0 J o w ~' a 06 v G to O O 3 O> a~ a .~' C w ca 3 d C. L Qom' .C d '0, M m r ^~0 CIS ^ m c ro a = 0 y a, w So v -a (w o m W 3 0 ro> u N 'ro '0 v E 0 9i o 3 ro ~_ ?- s, .~ E 3 m m a~ c E ro m c m O y C ro O w m. a~ r/~ C a~ E .~ m w0 C w F" O C a o 'C co ti C DO y 17 aua V G 3 ti sn a' 7 O ro y o ~, E v -0 u ? o w ?' ' 0 ?^c ? g wC a w u C C Cn ro ro C E" u !] a u? .0 u C u m c nr 0 x.? CZ o~ > 0 E 3 a a = v a m~ 0Uj o 3 4mi "', "'y L. C ro u C p v w .C " >~ m O>? C' c. ~. SO E~ u > C o c E a -c " ? It c C C7 u/ C GS It C CO C -~ ?~ Q C ~+ as ro 3 .~. C y E 's. .+ 6) :a C C ro C O %It O y E y G a. to x _ ? ro .- C c, -C Q w m ro C at d a; Cn be E y l" .a > .~ U Cad n +a y E r w 3 v r. 03 03 03 00 C ro^ y C .. O b> y .3 w E c ~. ? v ? c. fn 3 = v> M cc C C' 3 -00 > a co a `?~ Q Q 67 >' nLl ..>>+ "C7 ~' C = }C 41 3 00 C CG Ol C 'A m C s. :A CJ Cd uj 6~ ~]0 4) x .`~. C C '> cti .~ ro - ?~.~ Q ' C.~ '-' O w d 7 y y '~ ,~ ,d _? p .tea w ,] L' u C 00 y .C y > "" s. O. a C7 ro u ..C ~a O ~.ui = CC 3 C y V!? ~ su.. .~ 'L7 w O O U v c ao a~ C C O C O w. ~, ` ro = o o ro .~' I, v 03 ?- y o O w m o Z Q C ?~ C o QZ0- a,0 c --- E-ct E~ >c..-?:a n+ 0? to ro? a~ cC ' w ,< C' 3 ty C E" u ++ O '0 Q a' C "' p 3 U v C x C cE m G C? O tw y o-i y u p ^L w +?= v . C sa' n ^p >' G y a ". v y u c nn at E c m 3 c E-^ ' C c o.> ro ?ce (j o c (U E ro w :c >,-?_?w ro m > a.'c > . o .. ~ vw ro ~ y o '~ o m -C a E .c rob L 3 c ro 3 .., c E n a~ ~=: w aEi 0. "0 -z; w co w a; C .a U v a x .~ 7 C m 47 C t, 7 O T p 67~_' ? "' m U C m ~' G' .. ro O o v o v? .^ c c+ u o w E a a~ s. 3 ca Z ca ..Q a~ - u O C U] e y E w O u O t>= C = u C m !r, `' co u v? ~A m .~ ro 3 w C `v ,, " C. ro y> ,, a~ > 06 ,~ C> O ,E O a~ d C u w ?+ Q G) O ro ,, .? O 3> a aC u nJ _" C r CU x. ro C On >> ? O t< U C> O na C o 0 > > C j a C V s y y ro d G y .O ro ~' v aEi C m G i. ro O > t, ro ? " ro W C C y .+ .; a' C m V :Z~ y .C 0 O O? w C > O C row, ro 3 _ E . ^ . y -~ ro `a a~ ro _ro ,~ E roc a -~ ~, .~ R u .~ a~ u, u t 4t u E+ C 61 y O n] .O 3 E 3 >. O ro 7 C C? O O ^c7 W ro O ..C ro ro b0 v y y O v" at y~ ' 3 >, O m" ~" U 'CJ w 6, O to CO ?' i. o > W ? y m u C c ?~' n '? c 7 m. a ro a 3 03 E- % at B: Q) > ?~ 3 E v " y v a O"> c 'E u 'E w o m ~c ai ro a c[ nr' y -~ ~, = c o- c c o c l o .~ nc ... 7:4 -a a C n a~ C C ro y C C S a % v. -C C y ., ^_ y C a - a~ .. O w y O CZ O y a~ O C !~ O "" y ro >> ro a r O '; u; IM y to >. V; O ai Cc z 0" O O C 2 ro O C c5 E ., a 3 u 3 U] :~ w v v 3 ro-0 co rn :.-.. u. C cr, O' :D o CO a x u Approved For Release 2005/01/12 : CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4 4, +. ++ 6) w G) s. +~ ?~ Ts cd f: " O U U a 4-1 ?+~^ ~ N c a G t a cd O y o CA 4-4 0 ;1 U A m p +~ ^? o o 00 (s, U m q 4- W CD 4 .- O N a -"~ o m U a) 'b ice' m 4 + U U] NO of cd U -6 m C f+ +U' ya~j ~O+ O .Ci p O "d ~T". ~N m U w U O tjo 4-4 w 3 o bJDm1 cd ~nE~ C C? ,0 m mw 0 0? a ?'?~' m .. +~ o t o v >, b to ? U r. m Cd U .. U Q) as 0-4 u P4 b0 "? sa 01 m m ^t3 > a? a') m A r. d p cd ~ m .d ?~ y o CD a C m C w bA O ^d m r?+ m +~ U cd m 0 r O 4) O O U '.. p 'bD U ..~?~ ., p, y s? O +~ cd ca w 00 m Cd R. o ?~ U O w y O >) p., , ao ~ f~ U o F. O- f3. O U (1) U o P. (2) m ai o m m m o a) ?o ?~ >~ b sue. ' s c CQ 0 c o y G m f-4 cd 0 cad [ [ ? -C o o ?) '0 ? W o N s?+ a~i :~ }*: w 4-.' i O m 0 ai C n " a~i O a? ~. 1 di Q ~+ r? m 'LS rU+ J.' m Do Q x $-4 >1 0 Y C~ cd W cd ai O o cd - a) N U '+ ?) 0 cd o ?~ ^C o 14.4 U U m G~ ~r y .V Cl] '-, m d o +a C+ a ?~ Cd r~ O ?.~+ O t". '~ Gl Cd o U U d GL s~ O - +o O A +~ o q m U O U d O m 0 m > +~ P. O TS - CIj N U r, ~. y +~ +' m A to f'' a +' m U U~ v ami rC m S 43 N U n C cd v +~ U G. Ui+ o 0 .~ E ai .~ $. 'i. U U +?; o o cd +, 0 m y m C > tG .?:.[ ? -0 -0 4 f3' U +, ; +~ O +a ac0i ?'. a +~i G' 0 d w +' 4) w A O b-0 CQ 4) ' ?) w o >, 0 aUi U ?, :o aki E w r- m u 0 ^C cd > ~ 'v) Cd r~ a Id co O U) - -- U +~ m Approved For Re 200 fiLTY'CtA]RbP8g 15W0'(O400350018-4 y +' cd '~ o 4) ~ o o++~ > edi 4) m d 4 'c a aw U m -C . -4j bA +[+ ' }'" ,? m ^C ~ 0rc $ . y 0 2 m 5 ~L +}"'. lm~ bJ) 0 > y E; o N o cd .d cd o b m e +' ate.) p w'~. (s.4 G ~.~?+ C?)Sr" b C ~"' '' A C .di m m p ?.~i "i3 -4j 0 -W >1 w (U cox c ~' [f cd cd V M C r 0+ .mot. U y y d) d m U U> y ~ ~m '-4- .2 cd d 4) 0 t4-4 4 *4 4) U U . bi) O F+ m' 3 O U d !A d +a > o cd cd w' ? a 4 m U1 +~ '~. ova ?? ~~ m ~?.,+~ ~~s m o a) >1 4) 4 S-o 4- +~'dF 4- N C ;N O p o o V cd G, r. [" C4 v 44.4 4~ 43 U C O .O Lt LZ P, 4 da m U U *0 , 0 U) Approved For Release 2005/01/12 3CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4 C w d y., m Approved ~16gi1iagd~b 1 4t : RbM81-?1Q15R000400350018-4 y? G, 'G 4~ j w , 'o q D a; >, Q v w o .G - w ,6 0 w a a. o E ~ io . .~ a ~ '~ m a -`~ w ;~ o: ~ +~ a a d .~ x ~ G4 a .~ -'~ ~ ~ '~ G4 0 bD .~ .s m a ro o ? + o o" w bD O 0 E h y a+'0 w .~ r? s0. ~ m ?" ``" >> ,p 4> m :~ o ~' w '-. a> 0- m > 'b .~'.e r~ y~~ 4 > O O m w m r,, 00 ~~ a m mJ+ IL O -,z ?~~' . .,. a ' v q S L~ +sV~ 10 E 42 44a XU >Q at E a3 G r >q w 0 CO m `-. w w 0 O S. C t! 0 awi .3 d v w Q3 m .a ,, 4; U~ ao `?+ c rj} 0 p, "O z a m 0 co a W V w cs m ar ?? w E a '~' -rs ' +3 E" >, o ar 0 0'6'0 c ~'? 3 A as ~+E o 4 j m 4 >y CL +~ am3aa,.a E vc.~ " ar. > 3a~ EE"-v ~w oa ate[?';-?~3=?`~c?ww>-?~,~,a.]~i~wa~ ? E ;~o a`?mQrs,~ C'mvmm w3v~m?.voa 0 m~~ E-4 m Co bo .c w w a ~, U] ~' ~, m ami as 0. a7 m ar .~ ;; ~,, ai 8i y ~+ .,45 V y,,, +a ?^' .G S to > y 0 a U] O .a Cs. ?~ m yap) m '`" ~, .C U~ 4+ ~'' O y0 ;, w }q -~'i E C m OG a .~ O F, CL m m m m .~ m m "~ "~ 'L7C. w w 6i w .m Cn O N 0 w +a f~. ^Q '~ i~ +' "C' t". 4 w' och u o y s r as 0 V. E 0 .0 ~V ?,~, M0 0-f -4'bn'wi awtJ~g w~aa~?v>' ~-Cat j - > cc CZ o 03 E " a s w p, ~ eo $ ~ 0.0 C v C 0 ?0 . m Ev 'E C ~? C ] w ~ m?g~.?" `?~' ?- a E'60 ( md'V s+ E E co E a.- tr. .0 A w w a a a .. M ova o w ~ w is is w oa 0 a E tw 79 b i a'~ E ~,"m Sm a; 0 o m o Q. > 2 av > my aw+ 0.8 S w oo a~ m m >> -~s 0 0 .0 ca cci (/] V w?.: E 79 3 ~;~ od E r, E 2 2E y ro O E .0 U .a E m 00 mCID w m = z E a cc hn 0 - 5 V r _O A A, f'_ w 0 W .a CL .o .a m O E0mm. . co > as > > : v CJ) . wo 4D(1)3 R wa 3 m 0 U E E aT w O ? w a.~ y w ' 4 yUyoEc.nw -b w V w -C > > o E 0 3 >, E w a= ami u as m :. cr a H x .a s. ~' G +, QGC 0 O Q `?' > att~ w w m m E w> m 2 o ~, E o 0 3 ?Oi m ~- c y G?r .tea 0 m V .. m O 3 .3 co 0~ ~, a m o U .0 m 4i m ai 0. co w s. 0 4' ( smi 3 v m 4) 0 ar .0 0_ o - w o m v a V w ++ m > m3v~?3 O 0 +~ d co EE c4C 1.., 13 Cd .~ Q a ^d o .~ c m ~a > 0 nc E .~ m V 0 bn .2 +a - ? .C s. V 6) 'O m cd G7 O in. 4W (a cam' E. E t? E yE s8awd;5aGqwo"0 0 .a 4' o c w E -o O O. E r B ?= c It: co o c. apq m a,"~. 0 3 0 a~ 4, 79 0.a U d 0 yw,. 2 -+ 0 E V a 0~' a n w oaoma~~~E,,m 0? "~ v o E (?_ m 4) a. 0 v m 0 a. ca 0- x w ^. G~a? -? E~.3pd Ecd0(4(40 :? a Approved For Release 200/01/12 : CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4 Special Edition--21 November 1979 Approved For Release 2005/01/12: CIA-RDP88.-01315R00040 0 p, w W O O w 4, 4-4 ^C D 4.5 p 0 ? a 2 4A U m "d O "~' bA -C -~ w ?.~+ e vi O .0 4 t,, 0 Q O C b0 O 'd n cc -- t .. v Ch "t 0,0 0 a) c ~ 3 cad -0 w d o o + 3 w " 'M, G A 4 vi C . Q) C -C ?~ +, aS O +, ~?+ E~ s+ y IZ w a) o ? 3+~ 04 W 3.~ aJ }, -C ai te-.0000 ? u o . o ti , O y 0 d +~ r, O :c G a e'"i ' > C 06 w s+ 4) zi +34 ~D 00 2 0- b0 , r ctl 4:-[CC4M ctl + i cti a) s > O+ A m C -d-d 7 C U0 a w TO , O .~ O +' U] -V? ..~. cd~ +O, f a O U V +, > cC O ? " -~ (~ O >1 $4 0 41 . w 3 a) Q, w o s+ O O > y ? cs+i Cd 00 +; "~~' a~i ?V. +~, d cd ~a', 44 0 >, ~~ ~~ ~V+ b m ai o O 0 ci 0 (U y -C O cti CJ~ ?, 0 -C + .o a~ a +, aCi v; +0' i s~' v -" O `-+ bA r0-, cd ^d V }+ O O O V c> C w .C [- ? N t w O 0 C O ^' >> 7U?, 00 ~~-, ~" -? O -Q .~ ~" .:i ~+ ~-" +'O., F, cd w U w b4 0 --i ~.+ y +~ O s+ O +~ cti w a) > 43 w? O y ? a C m r >1 Cd -+ r-, v t'?+ cd V O V +?., o w w m C r>' s, Cd a) 0-4 C* Cd C3 Lt C) Cd CL) V. > 4) O p mss., 3s~r~4 a?a,3 3 3 aa. 21 4j a) m M `V' ai C o? I o C 0? 0 C4 "44 4) Cd O Ey w a Iwo ~: 40) w? -Ca +~, w > C .~ O v L?i O 0) O O 4 o4? o U ~ U + pOp -6-D Cd 064 --~I OD NO 0 fj r. y a p C e~ w a4 E C G, o cad Ca a C) "d C > N > a G) 4.1 ~4 E-4 .. ~" O "d 0 N tN Q 3 ~Q) a d by Ey ' w c c? . 44 Q d 4 14-4 d) (D d U) y O O a ' a -Q O - by 040, W CD .+ N 4+ 'O O 4-, 44 0 A d 4) O d 4) - 0 sr ~ >, C"0 0 y -C 8 0 O V ? w cd 0 ?" O V '> ~/ -6j - y U +~., UU 'd UL." IUIJ C~l~ tVA U W SQ M 4) '~ al O M Fi U 4 w awi cd '> cad y aVi } H 0 > > +' r+ v O N V O ^o cC w G 15 .02 C aS Cd C!j w C) U q 0) 4.) a0i c?) 3 .ti o 3 " 1-4 U O U ~ TV .~ b U -C s, y 4-1 0 1--1 o ~ O Q, L c o Approved For Release 2005/01/12 : CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4 Special Edition--21 November 1979 Approved Fpor Release 2005/01/12: CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4 u ^~ ?a A ~' w 4~i ? 'O ad m C a w o C m -a chi, m_ d W o w W :t: W 5 m m a a ,,+ U O d CV a m m O w a] mm1 .+ n W cn 4y 1. m ~?` s. 4? r 0 0 dog 4, a? ca -cc - CL ?? o 7 0 C u d O CL > C C sm. ~" ami UJ > 0 _O, y o a ~? r o bo G C 4) b0 u > U 4, 4, C CV 61 m u 4) +C, 4? u C. F m :a C. E ca - U? O 4) N E m C m w a a) C u C v m 0 ,4.9 V w a o ?` o 4 >;E p 4? C x E 4, 0 0 w~~~buo~m.c c~~vm;vc 3 m C y' U a c w 4a A ?' c .o a0 a0 [> >1 m w ?4) c?mc > oaaou3a~o~"" o ~~ aia_.~ecs,; gig>cc?>w;m+ w 4? v r ~ w 4? .?~ .s .. y ai u C u" v a m C ~' C m~, as ?' V C " by a, Q C ,C It u w 10, m" rid a~? C ~? o u s. 0 .2 11 D o Owl w E a A C a 0 o > v E m m C6 a $ .~ a tri cu " LI- o ar o a. m C C? E .~ 3 C>^ ~s m 3 to 0, >, +, O C a) 0 m 4, ,- 0 4 ? 41 `? E u O cc Q C 3 40 a? C y O. y O m E? C 4) . V. C~ O ..~ m O .C _. . -63 hd we m oy fi> EaiC Gap.4co ~? o 3'0b a0 C to c C C A w w m H 3 'E fl. E m m C >> y ++ m V. a0 ' 43 a3 8 ad C' o L m m . .- 2 d m 0 -Cj >, CL. w w O >.V 4? O 4) m ., v O w C C y +, ~. ^C .C M L' ? co ^' ay > O ~. D U.0 0 .C. y m +, u 01 O C U v 6y "O ::, 12. U v .C O o0. a CA m.. 4S U cd C 4? r6a? w as C ' fL x C ?0 a m m ?~ ?u C a) d C a>i "d C O .m C m v Ow .c3 moo > C x Z~'. ? e s L Y a 4~~ +~ c cc U] > E as 4 3 C .. Lt, , a mi, .. u o. 4y CL cn O. a u cd t 3 C r 4,4) cti ;.a 4 .~ m o 00 4) 0 0 v 3 ao%4,- C u ai 44)) 0 V E .a om~w m m ;`, 3 o to ^v a?'" 2 -~ u , to C O a d ,^ xw " a . , m 4u? w a) .~ CL 4) .a, O C u >s CL U ~' C "C O r. ^C! ci aw 0 4i a aTy'v m+, m- N F ice. . 4Ci C* O w L ,w > C u O 7 ~ 00 .4 . O O E N CL aC m > 87 C. 40 to 0 . 0 ~ C W ? C 4, d 4) c 4) " 4? ... y - . ,C c c O 4> ~ i y .64 cc CQ N ;a'"j C > bo s y 4? C x C me C 4?,aV 4 o x-a a1 ? 4) m C C ?@ u _, cm? C O G4y E 0E 6? 3 a n.~ IV" 00 ?3? > O U 0 a E4? Cm , 4 y 3 EEC 11 C,,, a C 4) m 400 C O^O 4, 3 v oYF >; m O-Z N 4, m .G 43 C. 4) V C > a > O Approved For Release 2005'101/12: CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4 bD Cd U 4J O ,1"" E'" ?vJ '""'.. y Cd rp cd ... CrJ !?' E- w W CD ?~'? a> a as w o 3 ?m a 3 coi ,. > d 60 w Q) $4 w a) a> a o U y a> y a> r. u ~. cd o o a) Q a) o v7 -0 4 C3 dj r. ~ CO O OO 'Q o O ." cd a '. o a CD >I 0. w O b0 s$, Cd E-1.4 , 0 a 4~ 3- U ? .? S-Z U a ; W l) v] } bA C/] Cd W O +~ o O y 0 0 16. a) ^~o a Cd bj) 0 P. +^"a O Special Edition--21 November 1979 Approved For Release 2005/01/12 CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350o1R-a W bu o C "0 t CZ w biD d p o a> GL ~. ai m D U rOp C LO" 4^+ d0 ~ o ctl ~. S3 14 da V1 yU Cz I~it Cl) Cl) U 5 - U O ? a ? o a ,? ,; n H - m N CO ?v CD a>M 'C 3 c 44 0 a) 0 r a) w C() bj) O Cd a) a> 0 m ' C ? ": O ~.U a W (M 00 73 tA r, +a b d ~ O ?N y 3 U] ? ~; a> 0 di y, ai a> E-' 0 ' m IU, a> a) ~z U2 cUd -R . s. a> +~ . -N a> a a> O > C ni r - M U) 0 ~.A o a a> 'd b bA O 0 o c~ ~ M } -c U) C0 cad cad ~ txo a> ..+ y +~ 0 0 44 COD +4 c. d o '0 ~+ +~ v Cr' U y. y 4 U ,.O . . U. a CC C w'? ayi H 4, F d t'M Cz U 'd ??ri y, ? C o w E-+ .o ~; ago d m 'U < m Cdd y 'd ?~ y cd a +~ CD Cd 10 1-4 .rn o m E" m G -- -4j 0 (1) Cd 2 75 4) Approved For Release 2005/01/12 CAA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4 ~"?'"N.O+~ O rte' a) bD O bq ?+ O U U R, M"0 o~ p .d ~wa> m a o > o ) '- d o.0 o c,~ ai bU 0 0 a> A .~ +~ L{ y ?~ O ;L m ? U +~,~,..+ cd 0 a) w O -0 s. q 0 ia'oa a b o C ?_ - a> a> 41 p 3 0 O y O , oa v c a y cUd > ai -c.--C > a> y cad +' 4, U uj i, Cn 0 E bA y, ^d (Jl w 2 w o eo hA H d a c m ~ a, 2oE.oc- r ? I, 'R 4) E m Approved Flor ieleas 0 16 f/11 :NdI` 8#--bit%15R000400350018-4 .cam, u 7 G o a L d) 4) o :c E '0 OD 5 AD G C., C 4? m C > G r- -C V of O Ci 7 ^^p ~' F. a a~ m G w .3 m 0 .. `~ a0 o m a -E ?~ E ami 0. > 0 iL G, U +~ m ?~ 'TJ m eio y o 3 C 4) >1 ti) m c 0 .3 a) .b 0 acr m to ^b s. m r~ 0o a a f...L" U "[ a' w 0 0 a c > x. G m L m c y y G 00 U .a y G .. p MO .w. > r N b .r, O S 4. m 3? v' -~? m E s m o .. W > 1Q .0 U 'O CL m v1 0 cn o 0 A 4S O a m o .c ~00?cu :a m O 0 a) O N .C U .~ L1 ?r E E.) GO co o?" c .C .~ m , E ?~ m m . >1 c: C). o >- - 4 a, w ~? pq -a 0 -D .2 0 M M +Ua ^ y m 0 m .~. .- 0 _A v ^' 0 4' .i..~ w 0 co > a$i 4 v _m 0 m 0 C1~... ?^ 0 oso~cfl.w?_u)m mi" 4~ .,. L+ ? y+ O 0 m $ $ m G Er 0 a afi: i>0 2 O P a c' U 0 U 0 m . 0 E > t? 0 y.> CI W E m C m aka O G7 r"? 0j 6 .i. > O .C 0 r~ d 6U) 0 0 OE~ 'c c >1ME a ~, me wti6 o 4M > (D o y .. 0 0 ,0 G OGL m 0 0> 0 > y m y v 0 m ~; m bo 4i w 4? W 4) Cl) - C 4) 0 X a c >m -? 0 E v r xx m $ o ~b Eca I O u bob E~,v b..,d-- x.3' ~'ov 3 > o v 0wu~ ? a~ c .. w.c }.. co .:) 0 c x O 0. 0 (a o s U 4, E m o 4, 4 y7 u5 W G4 as to 0 .:D "O G a+ a+ . E Q m a) c a x G 0 0 m c V ? 10 E O ~ .0 w y ' c 0 O m a) cd -vE m a? C > c X O C6 0 w E cn as .4' O 0 v 0 a) - > IV 0) a) E a0) 'C x 0 Ut E, 0 c c~) 0w.2 ,,wpm 'v .C d > o ."', IW.~ O as C Lr +a -> co d 6) >1 Cd O y ^r3 w '0 W ?' 0 G 0 3 v.8 v a? U w 03 ~D 0 (4 > 0)) N y. O C O m w .c a 0 '~ c c m c~0Ewa m m o 0 'E c bo '% 7 G 3 G o'er m Approved For Release 2006/01/12 : CIA-RDP88-01315R000400350018-4 Approved For Ras e 2b015-1 21 CI R "bi316I 68O400350018- o C? O d U 0 "" 41 Q W 40, Lt E o m m cd >, 3 m sU. ~ > ^o ~ ~ y f3. v E ?~ c ~ ~ y ~ a}.i ^C E y m y c~ 'b a~ -0 14 0, 1-01 < ...E o ry ?~ ?U v O O O cmC 0 +3 ~' m ay ai E ~?, ,o +' >, m m as tdD 4-1 ~j Cd m p W cD E-4 oy ! 3 C O W f+ E y .d m Tf O Q m 44 0 m > a~ o y CU 4 Cd > V b C! U ^1 y O Fes' ai 0 E- w z ~+ rA d E,,, ty as O a ~ O ~~ oC W c y a s ~U a o,ai m ~ rn q o c b0 Ec? Fho 0- 0 (x, d d LT,~ c~~o rim GV ?ti s. ~p,U ~' o.~?^ o 0 .. rr W }r a) +a y +a m j'n 0-4 NO o ~ C+ 'd L+ a) 0 ~i m a~i . a a O 'c b o '~' o' '~ o U p y w d E ' ai zs' o v C3 'A c y o g G q >> m O y Ul U] e(`, Cl~ m ^d ai U ?3 m ?~ as o .~' 3 ... d a~ b as A w > ~- ?.+ O ~+ C5 L10 W ,' ~+~, wo ! a) O O M C cd W o >,.~ b U w W CL o ai m ~~, os w o. o U cd y c aUi E c~d U C+ o y y A CD y? ?: + v ..}'".i r-, b0 O U s!-! C 4) ~.. _ ? C: .y .n . _ .-i +~ U i., !~ . cn cd m _ m C O E 3 U; m 'T~ 'Cf '~ U " ti .t?+" .N ~" ^'" 7'~ a) r+'~?+ A s?. 7?. ~. > +' Ey "C a) ;~ ai w -N N +~ a~ o o O m> F w +?; o m 04 cc 5 a) 0 3 0 0 4-1 >1 0 .~ tt o ,~ y x U O 3 C 3 ,`7. ?? a> C m y cN *o' ~' Q U ro- m o U m 4PS o ? c a~i bA a' >I .0 E- O .o -b 2, eos Cl) aa) E-+ aa) d U cd -d Cd c ?~ .~ 5 A o w o-~.2 aai a, ? co 'ti m sa 0 boo y o > U cd m m m cd U +~ m ?~ '~ +~ y t, , p w cd a~ +, U y y o R, ... +?3 ... U c o a~ m m A s + U .a `~ +' ,fl Cl~ O ~o^a y td p f~' v w E> O V +o, " o C/~ ?' O O z 0> d 3`7 m U d a? 4 4) d Q ai o y ~4 .44 i a> ss- m > , o m-0 cd 4) o v o a z+ w tz -5 (z) 73 o 0 m ~ m a) a o ~ r. > U d O a, a~ v c w was -C o o m w aoi U" sU N U o pq +'' ai +a s~ ~+ as +a s, >~' o U ~"' o o > +, ?++.~ O ~+ ?"" Li S1,'+ ) o +~ .~ o y cd d . +~ 0 3 cd o cd > U o . ? > o +~ ruo y a5 .., 'b ^o .[ d t~ >, ... 3 o m m a o +' 4-4 ~j >> c0i o m 'LS "d o U ? (1) w? o C >> m . r, ay as > a~ o as U m U C~ m m U m 3 m +' " > A >> '" o 0 Cd $4 r Q) P4 >1 w 'O a U 3 ~? E o o a' o 0 0 0 -45 m $4 '- cUd O. r. oCs o vi is Cl1 U E U o U] U m m c+ N C b.v VC4 m -0 CS a CG ,. ro C 2~1 cu IS wpm Q'm o ~A w ocyy~ alb o3~-~.^c m o v) c -Z `~ m ?o>> Co 4oU N C/~ o .--, ai ,U .~ r' ?.N ,wo, O M'D ?~ ro o w bA w d CI V ~.~,rGc, d.~+'Wpa y d ++ E,o E-yq~ywc~ w p m~./~ s'' '~ o c? ?~'a~'?? ?~7~~?r!~ of i a~i o d cc ?' dcn Oa. G;ai ~.ovpy c 'a 3 ~ ?4C.) co ,atop obq m ,,.-o '1 Vim;? a) s, .b ~ csi w q O :-. Approved For Release 2005/01/12 : Ck ,A-RDP88-013158000400350018-4 Special Edition--21 t~ ,h rrrnvPd For Release 2005/01/12 : C`~i~ DPE8 173915R000400350018-4 CC tic ~'`a QQrn OV=.C UC C'C~? iC C~ 3a"S ~'>f~uy~~ ~~C?~d V y sC La te, 'v~~$Y O _C o< vaY a C my?v'>71 0 too ?c 0w $v~aag,~`7E ;~d i ce= E.b,rEn -t! 7C 'S y a v T~ u u .> o 5 L > ?' E h-0 15w d i T 4 C 0 c m m $ O 0.8 10-4 a ~oC `'jL.~ 0a v?-.a m ?E~ L ? s ff or my C m2 .- ~~ m ids v E~ ?' m 3 c o CO m~ L ? A CO d.2 L 0 > W gu~ ? mx1 -0w 0oyE.$v IC CO)~aU J '1w a~ T ' 0 C6 Q T 0 j N ra +U .,., u Q O .1p y t 'C G ... M 3 O -5 L Oa 4d y >.D WCEIi as'C Ey?.>'. ?US 3 C T ?~ ommC ' e" ca E O aaf . r. O - RUC c~Qaoa''iE`' a~uu$~ o?ow w= Eandc~uE? ter'. aCO 0. ' .:. U EE u L E^ my c.. ,~ ao c._.a n C$ u r C Os a m w w c-s-0.2 0Q'o m;Yv =u)? E~aw ZZ w.J??Em~~?- oma~Eu =>EemE ao~oy-"6- } v-)c~ aq ~v?a s C $aLo0o o?o> > L: > CQ ?~ E y? w :?.=arxE 3= c a? `' v y ~` C v " E m w ~ r n m ?- ;..~C ofOY a?3 T?` usa ww a3~ dw?.cr)mC 0 !-a m ~ E? C > v 0 d y mE" v~.? L o Q? r Voi y' - o. cn 08 m Lw oa~C C' as .~? ~_E v c?.emsd? 7 ~~ aoo =~ may.' '?' O tl~ 3 u 'C cm 0 ,, o < v~uYEtn a?6it'-~? a eca. o E oc yE ~r l 0 - ya,?,~Ew Nu3~-m =Ena ''~ w 'p. W y > pm ? . .7 x .w6 w a .,Ca y 0.5 M Ca Cn p' r ..+ C u 0 0 O y u y Y .... G O .. u 'C w w L w O y v S a n `~` . .. C m v v a m W 3 ~} a a o+ 07 C m =6 ?' Ga -79 i m? u y w E m~ Boo ? a $ G O.y y p~0, > v L c 0 4; p>> L m. a L y d> tu. > Q? y>,m.C.y`' 41 -C? 4 Qa Ems. ~ % ma ~ mcn a r.F.~ a E I o .,- $>, E m T a_ c m < as >, C Tt0 Et ad o m m a4 mY cc ~3 ::- o?-~ E c= v c ? ap m as ,, mC1 c os ~v]4 ?u w$' a a ' su v bra Q9 w~~,aIIam~a.,E Ywwaa1 "'awE>~ aLE , 'O UU so , ~~ T t~OfN T a~ L ~~Q {S ~.~[z $ 001 a O C - J'L CJ) rD C~ C ' G @ a U'0 ~ c E v-a 6' ~.) ' ? O i . L m m w as c O C 3 w C C s" 'b C a C ,w. y cn o v Q G f? .i L of w t -v `4o.c_y poi '-0 mE E..1~ bT .. wL..w C6 a $ w QL us ~ aQ w 3 .o -0 0 y a v s Opi C W ?.L. Q m c L q o ' w G ~ .a pv J L w L a_ w . OL ~. N w L v as y a . > o .s 0'' Y p C t0 Y :1 u l :n 3 e! v ' c p O) C as . L' a a w O v w z E~,y n iCn k~_ C d?^~ Cmi 0 a0 a GZ E ffi? E".7CR> C,~'Ot 4? w O~t1. y 0 a O3 EX ~' "'~U) C a t u~a ~' N~ mSE~ ar i Q a >'~'" ? C oT~ Gc.d'ea i t 6: w4E'.`"E LO atsaE cviw>, ao~cE~e`? ~?"_ L9n' tam?r V ? LT$ca u m$o .U]~~,u, a y E 6E.,~n~a= xdm r 03 u V " . ~' c~ o yy m .9 = = t; w m "a a r W~.+ ? .j U 33 5 o ao D m r oe. 0 3 c~ C Y y a U u m C v a a} - o c ai > .. a v= v o? L a 4= Q c .E E .z C ~ V ? n:7a[/)aamao >E3EOo 3v aE w.C Zm4 W o.5 -8: m 3 0~. Approved For Release 20051,91/12 : CIA-RDP88-01315R0004003500184