GADHAFI TARGET OF SECRET US DECEPTION PLAN

• Document Type: CREST
• Collection: General CIA Records
• Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
• Release Decision: RIPPUB
• Original Classification: T
• Document Page Count: 6
• Document Creation Date: December 22, 2016
• Document Release Date: November 7, 2012
• Sequence Number: 25
• Publication Date: October 3, 1986
• Content Type: MEMO

25X1
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
Next 3 Page(s) In Document Denied
Iq
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
 I
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
The Washington Post'
2 flrtnher 1986 - P Al
Gadhafi* larget of Secret
U.S. Deception flan
Elaborate Campaign Included Disinformation
That Appeared as Fact in American Media
By Bob Woodward
washinstoa Pot scat! writer
In August the Reagan administration launched
a secret and unusual campaign of deception de-
signed to convince Libyan leader Moammar Gad-
hafi that he was about to be attacked again by
U.S. bombers and perhaps be ousted in a coup,
according to informed sources and documents.
The secret plan, adopted at a White House
meeting on Aug. 14, was outlined in a three-page
memo that John M. Poindexter, the president's
national security affairs adviser, sent to Presi-
dent Reagan.
"One of the key elements" of the new strategy,
the Poindexter memo said, "is that it combines
real and illusionary events-through a disinfor-
mation program-with the basic goal of making
Gadhafi think [word underlined in the original]
that there is a high degree of internal onnositicm
to him within Libya, that his key trusted aides
are disloyal, that the U.S. is about to move
against him militarily."
It was an elaborate plan: "a series of closely
coordinated events invblving covert, diplomatic,
military and public actions," according to Poin-
dexter's memo. Military officers expressed some
reservations about the plan, and intelligence spe-
cialists were deeply divided about its potential
efficacy. The plan was the latest phase of the
administration's policy, first adopted last year,'to
try to topple Gadhafi, a .known instigator of ter-
rorist acts targeted by the administration as a
threat that has to be removed.
Beginning with an Aug. 25 report in The Wall
Street Journal, the American news media-in-
cluding The Washington Post-reported as fact
much of the false information generated by the
new plan. Published articles described >;enewed
Libyan backing for terrorism and a looming, new
U.S.-Libya confrontation. But U.S. intelligence
officials had actually concluded in August that
Gadhafi was "quiescent" on the terrorist front,
according to the Poindexter memo. The only
"confrontation" was the one generated by the
administration plan, according to sources and
administration planning papers.
During September, however, U.S. intelligence
agencies assembled evidence that Libya had
begun planning a significant number of terrorist
attacks, and some senior officials are concerned
that this is in part a response to the administra-
tion's latest campaign against Gadhafi. Of great-
est concern to U.S. officials are reports consid-
ered reliable but still inconclusive that Libya had
a direct hand in the Sept. 5 attack on Pan Amer-
ican World Airways Flight 073 at the Karachi
airport in Pakistan and provided logistical sup-
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
port for the terrorists, according to informed sources.
When the administration's secret deception plan was
launched in August, officials acknowledged in internal
memos that it might provoke Gadhafi into new terrorist
acts. But senior officials decided that the potential ben-
efits of the operation outweighed this risk.
The objective of the plan was to keep Gadhafi "pre-
occupied" and "off balance" and to portray him as "para-
noid and ineffective" so that, as the memo put it, "forces
within Libya which desire his overthrow will be embold-
ened to take action."
Press Told of New Intelligence on Terrorism
Poindexter's three-page memo to Reagan outlining
the plan was drafted in preparation for a National Se-
curity Planning Group (NSPG) meeting convened to
consider the next steps the administration would take
against Gadhafi. The NSPG is the key Cabinet-level
forum in which Reagan and his top aides discuss and
make decisions on the most sensitive foreign policy
matters.
The president, Poindexter and nine other key offi-
cials met at the White House to discuss this plan at 11
a.m. Thursday, Aug. 14. Sources said the basic plan
was approved and codified in general terms in a formal
presidential decision document. Details of the plan were
left to Poindexter, the State Department and the Cen-
tral Intelligence Agency.
Soon after the meeting administration officials told
reporters that the United States had new intelligence
indicating that Gadhafi was again stepping up his ter-
rorist plans, following a four-month lull after the April
14 American bombing raid against Libya.
But Poindexter's memo to Reagan just before the
Aug. 14 meeting painted a less alarming picture: "Al-
though the current intelligence community assessment
is that Gadhafi is temporarily quiescent in his support of
terrorism, he may soon move to a more active role."
Other sources confirmed that there was no signifi-
cant, reliable intelligence in mid-August to suggest that
Gadhafi was stepping up his terrorist plans.
But the State Department and the CIA concluded
that it might be an opportune moment to execute the
coup de grace against the Libyan leader.
A White House planning document sent to CIA Di-
rector William J. Casey before the Aug. 14 meeting
said: "Gadhafi's aura of invincibility has been shattered,
his prestige is badly tarnished and his grip on power
seems precarious."
But administration analysts evidently were of. two
minds. The Poindexter memo to Reagan written at the
same time said: "Most intelligence estimates conclude
that in spite of new tensions and Gadhafi's own shock,
depression and impaired performance following the Ap-
ril 14 raid, he is still firmly in control in Libya."
Mining Libyan Harbors Weighed, Rejected
Senior administration officials have been frustrated
that Gadhafi has been able to remain in po%ver despite a
presidentially authorized, year-long CIA effort to oust
him.
Over the summer, the administration considered but
rejected mining the harbors of Libya, sources said. The
anti-Gadhafi forces that the CIA had been supporting
proved weak and disorganized, the sources said. All of
the efforts against Gadhafi were apparently thwarted
by his personal security force and a network of inform
ers in Libya and among Libyan exiles.
Officials acknowlec.aed in their internal discu1.10ns
that the deception plan was risky. "Gadhafi may lash our
against Americans and regional friends with terror and
subversion," said the White House memo sent to Casey.
But the administration concluded that potential benefits
outweighed any dangers. "There are risks," that nteino
said. "However, the benefits of a successful policy de-
mand that every appropriate effort be made to achieve
our objectives."
Senior officials said Reagan, Casey and Secretary of
State George P. Shultz are particularly determined to
remove Gadhafi. As Poindexter said in his August
memo, the purpose of taking additional steps against
Libya was to deter terrorism, moderate Libyan policies
and "bring about a change of leadership in Libya .... "
The administration has concluded that, as the Poin-
dexter memo said, "any alternative leadership to Gad-
hafi would be better for U.S. interests and internatin! al
order."
The mid-August plan approved by Reagan did nut
specifically call for the planting of false stories in the
U.S. media. A State Department planning memo, how-
ever, did provide that "U.S. government backgrounds
media on 1) three-ring circus in Libya with infighting
among groups jockeying for post-Gadhafi era, 2) threat
of resurgent terrorism ......
The secret plan also called for "foreign media place-
ments'S by the CIA.
When a report appeared on the front page of TI;:!
Wall Street journal on Aug. 25 stating without cic;,;i-
fication that "The U.S. and Libya are on a collision
course again," it was embraced publicly by Poindexter
and White House spokesman Larry Speakes, who cailyd
the article "authoritative." On the basis of tlrosee en-
dorsements, other news organizations, including The.
Post, carried reports summarizing the information that
initially appeared in the Journal. In subseciuei't
administration officials both affirmed and rk,nicd nijnt
there was new evidence of Libyan-backed terrorism. or
that a new confrontation was in the offing.
Yesterday, in response to a question to the
House about stories published in August on Libya, one
official said: "The media deceived itself and the stories
were hyped. There was no intent that the adntinistra?
2
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90BO139OR000100090025-3
tion's actions in military exercises and so forth become
public."
The Journal's Aug. 25 story reported as fact various
administration plans that were actually part of the de-
ception plan described in the August memos. The re-
port did not mention deception, the key ingredient in
the plan.
The paper quoted "a senior U.S. official" as saying of
Gadhafi: "There are increasing signs that he's resumed
planning and preparations for terrorist acts." According
to the Poindexter memo to Reagan, there were no such
signs.
Contingency Plans Were Months Old
The journal wrote: "The Reagan administration is
preparing to teach the mercurial Libyan leader another
lesson. Right now, the Pentagon is completing plans for
a new and larger bombing of Libya in case the president
orders it." In fact, the administration only had contin-
gency plans for new military action that were several
months old, and nothing new was being done, sources
said. -
The journal report said that the administration was
considering action through the African country of Chad
to put pressure on Gadhafi, who has annexed a portion
of Chad with about 6,000 Libyan troops.
According to the Journal, "The deputy commander in
chief of the U.S. European Command, Gen. Richard
Lawson, quietly visited the poverty-stricken desert na-
tion [of Chad] earlier this month to see whether [Chad]
President [Hissene] Habre, with U.S. and French help,
might be able to expel the Libyans."
In August, a State Department planning paper on the
deception plan said: "Lawson's trip to Chad later this
month provides an opportunity for disinformation to
reach Gadhafi that the U.S. and France are developing
contingency plans for a 'Chad Option.' "
Lawson visited Chad on Aug. 12 and 13, but State
Department officials said recently that the United
States never formally had discussions with France
about joint action against the Libyan farces there.
France has tacitly accepted the partition of Chad.
The Chad aspect of the deception plan apparently
grew out of a National Security Council memo dated
Aug. 7, proposing thatt to United States attempt to
"shame France into asserting itself' in Chad, a, former
French colony. The document suggested communicat-
ing through "military-to-military channels and not
through the political channels which failed earlier this
year .... Given the stated desire of some [French]
general officers to cooperate with us against Gadhafi,
we might actively encourage them to sell the proposal
to their civilian leadership."
After the Journal and other news reports appeared ?
describing the purported U.S. proposal to take joint
action in Chad, sources said, the French voiced concern
to the State Department. Instead of frightening Gad-
hafi, sources said, the disinformation scuttled possible
cooperation with the French on Chad in the near future. .1
'Overburden and Spook Libyan Defenses'
The August plan had a high-visibility military cwn-
ponent. The White House memo to Casey said: " (hart
DOD [Department of Defense] operations will also he
required to give credibility to rumors that the U.S. in-
tends to take further military action." The memo said
there would be "unilateral and joint exercises designed
to deceive, overburden and 'spook' Libyan defenses."
U.S. and Egyptian forces conducted military exer-
cises, called "Seawind," in the region in August. Sources
said that the exercises were carried out in a particularly
provocative manner, sending aircraft into the Tripoli
Flight Information Region so they would appear on Lib-
van radar, though the most provocative action, crossing
Gadhafi's self-proclaimed "line of death" into the Gulf of
Sidra, was not undertaken.
"There's a fine line between harassment and prov-
ocation," said one source who considered the August
initiatives potentially dangerous.
The administration plan specified that two U.S. dip-
lomatic missions be given an anti-Libyan spin. One was
a visit to European capitals b,v Vernon A. Walters, the
U.S. ambassador to the United Nations; the other a vis-
it by Assistant Secretary of Defense Richard L. Armi-
tage last month to Libyan neighbors Algeria and Tuni-
sia. Walters' mission, which followed the publication of
the Journal report and Speakes' description of it as "au-
thoritative," was billed as a briefing on the new U.S. ev-
idence of Libyan sponsorship of terrorist acts. In fact,
European sources told Washington Post correspondents
in London and Bonn, Walters offered no such evidence
to the Western allies.
The Armitage trip, according to a planning memo,
would provide a "similar opportunity for disinforma-
tion."
Other portions of the plan included attempts to make
it appear that the United States was flying across the
"line of death" by using deceptive radio communica-
tions. Another aspect of the plan involved deceptive air-
craft carrier operations to mislead Libya about the in-
tent of U.S. forces to operate near its territory.
The CIA undertook placements of false information
in the foreign media. Otht.r covert techniques involving
communications, U.S. aircraft and submarines ` ere
planned.
One planning docunu'm said that the tale inf'rrnta-
tion should incluuc atticles showing that the Soviet
Union was planning a coup in Libya. It said. ''Libyan is -
telligence should be provided photographs of L.ibv:in
dissidents meeting with Soviet officials in Paris, liagh
did. etc."
'File U.S. intelligence community has been sitarp!v %:i-
vided over the new tactics against Gadhafi, according :o
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
 i
- Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90BO139OR000100090025-3 -
informed sources. Some Libyan experts in the CIA are
concerned that the administration's psychological war-
fare against Gadhafi will backfire, or already has. In this
view, the U.S. plan is only feeding Gaclhafi's desire to
be at the center of events, and has likely-fueled his ter-
rorist schemes and plans to extend his rule in North Af-
rica beyond Libyan borders.
Adm. Crowe Voices Concern About Plan
steps, then failing to follow througn. Crowe argued that
this would lessen the deterrent value of the April 14
raid and any other ongoing efforts to deter Gadhafi.
Though a variety of reservations was voiced during
the hour-long meeting, sources said that the strong
anti-Gadhafi sentiment in the administration overrode
other considerations.
At one point, according to a source, Reagan made a
joke about the Libyan leader's well-known proclivity for
wearing ostentatious and colorful clothing. The pres-
ident quipped, "Why not invite Gadhafi to San Francis-
The possibility that Libya did promote the Sept. 5 hi- co, he likes to dress tip so much."
jacking of the Pan Am jetliner in Karachi is cited by Shultz rejoined: "Why don't we give him :\IDS!,
some specialists who fear the consequences of the U.S. Others at the table laughed.
deception plan, though there is no evidence that U.S.
actions triggered the hijacking, which is the sort of ter-
rorist act that Gadhafi has organized in the past.
Sources stressed that U.S. intelligence agencies do
not yet have conclusive proof of Libyan involvement in
the Karachi hijacking, but said there are ominous signs
of such complicity. Salman Taraki, an Arab with a Lib-
yan passport, was arrested in Pakistan five clays after
the hijacking, and an intelligence report said that he had
claimed he was on a "special mission" for an operative of
the Libyan intelligence service. Taraki apparently was
stranded by accident in Pakistan and unable, as planned,
to leave the country before or after the hijacking that
left 21 persons dead, the sources said.
Taraki and the four hijackers are in Pakistani custody
and are undergoing interrogation. Sources said that
Pakistan is supplying the United States with some in-
formation.
Reagan has publicly promised to take military action
again against Libya, as lie did in the April 14 raid, if that
country is directly connected to other terrorist acts
against U.S. installations or targets. The week after the
raid, Reagan said, "If their government continues its
campaign of terror against Americans, we will act
again."
At the Aug. 14 meeting of Reagan and his top nation-
al security affairs advisers, Adm. William J. Crowe Jr.,
the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, voiced concern
about the plan, according to sources, questioning
?hether it was an appropriate use of military resources.
He said that there was great da:.ger in saying or imply-
ing that the United States was going to take dramatic
Staff researcher Barbara Feinman contributed to this
report.
Il~all Street Joltrltal Managing' Editor Say.'
'Me Knew .Nothing' About Ailli-Lil)Y(In I'/()\'
Asked yesterday about The Wall Street Journal'.,
Aug. 25 report on Libya, the newspaper's managing co-
itor, Norman Pearlstine, issued this statement:
"On Aug. 11, Washington bureau chief Al hunt ap-
proved a proposal by John Walcott for a story on the sit-
uation in Libya, in anticipation of the Sept. 1 anniver-
sary of the Gadhafi revolution. Hunt suggested involv-
ing Cairo correspondent Gerald F. Seib.
"The reporting which produced our Aug. 25 stun
came from multiple sources in multiple agencies of the
U.S. government as well as several foreign govern-
ments, including material gathered by Seib. The report-
ing turned tip much indisputable information, includin.,
the plan to send an emissary to Europe to seek nu.v
sanctions, and discussed the difficulties in pinning th,-
exact blame for terrorist events. The Journal subse-
quently revealed in a story on Sept. 2 that the
planned to 'promote reports in the Middle East of grov'-
ing opposition to Gadhafi.'
"If our government also mounted a complex di.;infor-
niation campaign, involving multiple sources her.
abroad aimed at the U.S. press, we knew nuth:u; :ti,:,
it. If, indeed, our government conducted Silk ii it tic disinformation campaign, we were anloitg it.5 t'
victims."
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
 25X1
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3
Next 6 Page(s) In Document Denied
Iq
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/11/07: CIA-RDP90B01390R000100090025-3