UPDATE ON CARNEGIE-MELLON

• Document Type: CREST
• Collection: General CIA Records
• Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2
• Release Decision: RIPPUB
• Original Classification: U
• Document Page Count: 4
• Document Creation Date: December 23, 2016
• Document Release Date: August 16, 2012
• Sequence Number: 1
• Publication Date: November 17, 1986
• Content Type: MEMO

Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/08/16: CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2
ADi4I!I:i; -LLL U;A: OJUY,
ROUTING AND RECORD SHEET
SUBJECT: lOptionol)
zUpdate on Carnegie-Mellon
ROM:
Wtllimm F. Donnelly.
Deputy Director for Administration
--
-..
EXTENSION
NO.
DATE
8 December 1986
_
TO: 10fRair designation, room number, and
building)
DAR
OFFICER'S
INMALS
COMMENTS (Number omit conim?M to thaw from whom
to whom. Dom. lino owns column after Gooch comment.)
RECINED
FORWARDED
1. .?
Executive Director
1 : L
,
c 7
Jim:
Attached
Attached
information.
Att :
Note fm
rett
provided for your
'!
2.1, kl
FX_k b 2 ?k-c,'
/$86
111
it
94_
3.
A 9 D A
William F. Donnelly
1 DA
15gre
5.
i
7.
V ?
S.
/
?
611
,..
9
9 fr,
12. a
13,
'
A
14.
15. .
*
61-011014,
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/08/16: CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/08/16: CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2
ADMINISTRATIVE RNAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED
Artificial Intelligence Staff
MISG/OIT
7:17 PM, Monday, 17 November 1986
Note To: Edward J. Maloney
From:
Subject: Update on Carnegie-Mellon
The purpose of this note is to update you on Carnegie-Mellon...
happening with it. Eind I visited Carnegie-Mellon
discuss the giu_ye.ar's trainiq_in Al, per your (Ed) guidance.
summary comment, the visit was qTte successful and everything
good shape.
i.e., what's
last week to
As an upfront
looks to be in
and I met with three professors from the Computer Science Department,
including the Department Chairman, a Dr. Habermann. All three profs were quite
receptive tothe4dea of a special program of study, and they are flexible in
terms of custom-tailoring it to meet Agency needs. I might also add that all
three seemid-to be "lriendly" towards the Agency, so to speak. Here's some
relevant bullets from our discussions:
- I would work in the expert systems area, and a faculty advisor has been
tentatively identified. This looks to be particularly interesting as this would
plug me in as a working member of John McDermott's overall organization.
McDermott is well-known throughout the Al community as one of the top two or
three bonafide heavyweights in the field. (Among other things, he is the
creator of DEC's well-known XCON expert system.)
- I would also take a series of courses to broaden my background in the
underlying theory of Al. The Department Chairman suggested several CMU courses
which I made a note of and will plan to make a part of my program.
- They were all three insistent that I not start.uptilthe Fall Semester, '87.
CMU runs a series of familiarization/orientation/standardization courses then
(and only then) which all new students must take. (Actualy, the "Fall" starts
in August.. .for planning purposes, this means I would be leaving around 15
August or so.)
- Dr. Habermann suggested I visit CMU again for a day sometime in the Spring.
The purpose would be to do some advance planning with my faculty advisor. I'll
thus plan on doing that.
- CMU impressed me in a positive way as #4 having a rather unique (for a
university) approach in that they emphasize the practical/hands-on as well as
and in coordination with the theoretical. In line with this, the Chairman
recommended I take a LISP course prior to my arrival so I will plan to do that
as well.
As it turns out, Dr. Habermann was previously the Acting Director of CMU's
Declassified in in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/08/16: CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/08/16: CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2
? ADMINISTRATIVE - INTERNAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED
Software Engineering Institut* (SEI), which is a DOD-sponsored activity designed
to improve overall software productivity. While SEI is technically separate
from the Computer Science Department, there is clearly a close and incestuous
nelationship between them. The Chairman offered to broker introductions to
whomever I'd like to meet within SEI. I expressed strong interest in doing so
at the appropriate time.
- One of the professors I talked to is doing some interesting work in
"knowledge acquisition", which is a key element in building a successful expert
system. Coincidentally, I had met and talked with him several months ago at an
ORD-sponsored Al forum in Rosslyn. This little coincidence didn't hurt in'the
least.
- By way of setting up a program, what seems to be a logical progression would
be to spend 6 months or so in the expert systems area, followed by 3 months in
the knowledge acquisition area and then to wrap it up with 3 months in the SEI
ifeL (I think in reality I'd end Up starting off in the expert systems area
and then, after I got to see things first hand, adjust the program as
necessary...I want to be sure to keep the "practical" emphasis and not get
sucked into a purely academic mode.)
- The question of money was brought up by the Department Chairman pretty much
as you (Ed) had outlined it to me back in our intitial meeting on CMU. Dr.
Habermann stated that the true cost of educating a graduate student in CS at CMU
is approximately $33,000 per year. When corporations or the Government sends
them someone on a special program such as this, CMU's policy is to charge the
true costs at a minimum and it's customa to provide a fellowship as well. The
initial cost estimate given t over the phone was $75k. The
understanding we left with after ta ing ? person was $35k "fellgwiblefundn,
plus the payment of normal tuition of approx $10,600.
- On the question of funds, I thought it best to get the dollars nailed down in
writing so that there are no misunderstandings come next Fall. I told Dr.
Habermann that the next step would be for the Agency to send Carnegie a letter
of understanding. After I returned, I then met with to discuss this.
He has kindly agreed to take this one for action, and to coordinate with OGC and
OL.
- With all of the foregoing in mind, I don't see any major problems which would
foul this up.. .everything really seems to have fallen into place. I'm most
excited about the program and, as I've said before, I feel most honored to have
been selected to represent the Agency at Carnegie-Mellon. Be that as it may, I
have a personal item to resolve that relates to my wife and some of the factors
that affect her by virtue of this whole matter...i.e., an employee couple type
thing. I don't want to get into the nitty-gritty here, but FYI I plan to get on
Gary's calendar (in your absence) to discuss this to see what the Agency might
be able to work out in her case (i.e., she has some concerns about what happens
to her recently renewed career as a DI Intelligence Assistant if she goes to
Pittsburgh with me, while being simultaneously unenthusiastic about the impact
on the family if I were to go to Pittsburgh by myself.) I'm hopeful this can be
resolved in some reasonable way, so I'm optimistically plugging ahead. --
CC:
UNCLASSIFIED
? ISILMVVIRITI%Iyrn VLIT,PINVTAT rfer. AMT1.,
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/08/16: CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2
STAT
STAT
STAT
STAT
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/08/16: CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2
ADMINISTRATIVE - INTERNAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED
Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release2012/08/16: CIA-RDP90G00993R000300010001-2