EXPERIMENTAL PARAPSYCHOLOGY: A REVIEW AND INTERPRETATION

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
K
Document Page Count: 
17
Document Creation Date: 
November 4, 2016
Document Release Date: 
July 13, 1998
Sequence Number: 
15
Case Number: 
Content Type: 
FORM
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3.pdf2.52 MB
Body: 
Approved For Rase 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-0W7R000400100015-3 SG1I SG1I =SG1I SE.NDEP WILL CHECK CLASSIFICATION TOP AND BOTTOM "UNCLASSIE IF.Df~i7C_()NI'II)ENT'1AI ,SECttE:T OFFICIAL ROUTING SLIP TO NAME AND ADDRESS DATE INITIALS 2 3 4 5 PLS RETURN TO 6 ACTION DIRECT REPLY PREPARE REPLY APPROVAL -- -~- DISPATCH RECOMMENDATION COMMENT _ - FILE RETURN CONCURRENCE INFORMATION SIGNATURE _ .~~~.. _~ - ....~w __._.._ . . . . . . _ . . . ,__._ __. .._ _.. _ ,-- Remarks: This second chapter in the book by RAO seems to offer useful background and guidelines for the kind of research we ought to start focusing on when and if we obtain the kind of validation we are seeking in the current project. Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 65--27587 Rao, K. R. Experimental Parapsychology: A Review and Interpretation Springfield, Ill. Charles C Thomas, Publisher 1965 SG1I 8-1o-65 Approved For Release 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3 Approved For Release 2001103/07: CIA-RDP96-0078f!4664bdI6801` '3 Chapter 2 THE SUBJECT IN PSI TESTS The Psi Triangle I N A figurative sense, the experimental situation of psi seems to be basically triangular-the three angles being the subject, the experimenter, and the target. The analogy of the triangle is used simply as a convenient device for the categorization of the psi factors and consequently has no validity besides its usefulness as a descriptive phrase. For the purpose of this study, the subject angle consists of those studies that are concerned with ascertaining the physical and mental states, inherited or acquired, transient or stable, that are associated with the significant success or failure of subjects in ESP tests. These include the studies relating to the personality and physiological correlates of psi, the effect of the subject's at- titudes on his performance, hypnotic and relaxed states of the subject, and the general observations on the subject's health, age, sex, intelligence, etc. The target angle involves those studies that are relevant to the role of targets in psi tests. It includes studies involving target variations aimed at discovering what types of targets are most suited for psi tests. There are several studies relating to the physical and psychological aspects of the targets. The agent in a telepathy or a GESP test becomes a part of the target angle insofar as he is the target person. Furthermore, the studies in target conditions, such as those concerned with the effect of space and time on the performance of psi subjects, are also in- cluded in the target angle. The experimenter angle is concerned with the rcl? of the experimenter-his moods, attitudes, and abilities that are essen- ti l to elicit psi as well as his methods, designs. and experimental conditions. This angle also includes comparative studies of the experimental methods and test conditions. While the experi- menter is independent of his methods and the methods involve the whole complex of the testing situation, the convenience of categorization leads us to the inclusion of methods in the experi- menter angle. There are other studies involving the interrelations between these three factors which may be described as the three lines joining the psi angles. The subject-target line is the one concerned with the subject-target relationship-the attitude of subjects to targets, the dual aspect target situations, and the attitude of the subject toward the agent in GESP and telepathy tests. The sub- ject-experimenter line is concerned with the interpersonal rela- tionships between the subject and the experimenter and with the reactions of the subject to the experimental conditions. The teacher-pupil attitude studies are along this line. Finally, the experimenter-target line deals with such studies as the suitability of particular types of targets in particular situations and with the experimenter's attitudes towards different targets. It is recognized that these lines are arbitrary and may overlap occasionally since some of these relations, such as those which include the method, may have all around implications involving all the angles. The subject is obviously the most important angle of the psi triangle. The search for gifted subjects has always been an im- portant concern of the inquiring parapsychologist. The ' studies concerning the personality correlates of ESP, the attitudes of the subject conducive to psi manifestation, and the mental and physi- cal states of the subject constitute a major portion of published literature in the field. Is psi an individual gift or a generic one? What kinds of people are the most successful subjects? Do the health, age, and sex of the subject have any effect on psi? Are there any personality characteristics or patterns that are particu- larly associated with psi functioning? Do the attitudes of sub- jects toward psi help or hinder it? Are there any natural or induced states of mind that are helpful to psi? Are there any physiological states that are related to the parapsychical phe- nomena? These are some of the questions that are raised, if not Approved For Release 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3 Approved For Rese 2001/03/07: CIA-RDP96-OOZY- CPYRGHT ~ O bA V o A O v .O v :ti .5 .~ 1,14 COD Q + C1. R' O r,4.D ; ^d o O 'C3 U Cy. 0 V C a m C) bA S7 at _ ^O y AA as O ~;-I w at bA Oy - i". fn a 0 0 4 0 44 V 0 an O (t. 4 .~ a) CC3 O' m cd O 'L7 4, G w G a a~ vii '~- .Q 14 0 y co bA u L'i 44 L~ t Pl- zoo .t; w a U a a C ai 4~ cd M a ? - 'C7 + .O ) an a 0 '0 *4'0-4 0 a w r a w 2 +a.+ 0 41 0 WV v a w u o.o.~J? bA ? ??+ rn n ?? ) > +C a y 0 4~ 0 a cc00 aai :5 o 0 ,ate 4 h V '~~`U 'a ^pia. ~. o U (z O Q ; fd . 1+ -4 a w 0 T! O .G " an cry .O y O 0 p O v O a S1. ~ O a C ~ v., flu o ~ a cd cv.~ ,s V 110 LO d y u a .. a cd a .L? to . Approved For Rese 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00U7R000400100015-3 CPYRGHT ;>" 'O cu O Vl 'd F+ G ..F-i 2 cs G -O ^C , . . .C c H O v to a cA 'd +' M 'C7 - 0 00 Ov - a u .v q a u O tl 0 ca N .4; W) (13 to 4 10 m I> to CIS -3 O ' " ? N w " O +a+ V] a Cuj a cw p C r; .C a to a :d v `~ U z3 w V O o ":5 '~ W W c}a - 4w O 'O a+ ro- '- 0 ^ a" a O. 0 y Qr O r m ++ O m S:" U G Q ?- cn + .~ 'd ? 0 V W3 m ? N " U m . F, U cd w 'C7 p W U O m R! O +-+ ?~ ~.+ ,Hi O, N ?~ O U m ~. .C, ~ y ct! m m a =,.~ m m m w o m to 11jy a ~?. w a Vt~~ a . cC 4H ; bA 'v SO, 'a0i c v O !3' ~+ ~~y .C TJ ct! ' 7 O H 4Z 0 G a.+ 47 G G W 4 n .u ?N 7 ~ a r O U 4J 41 ri U plz~ y.y G U U 3,x V .~ > o ^ 0 ^ o j 4 run .~1 W ?r. G ~ ~I N ~ SH 4~ En S-4 ~j @f7 $ Q Cy.~ H if-; y~.J V u .-- i. O co bA ``~' c '0 4 ~j 4J C) cu M V M >1 4-1 Ilu 0 C) 4 4" V 0, bA .0+ 0 Lr. s~ `n G ro 0 s~ m ~+ O U c i d .'~"+ O y .0 ro w F" 41 . ?aoo~ Z u a~ q bn s o ~; y o ~; ~, zy r, a4 fu M u x 4 'C -5 G V M .0 G t~ U .~ Q j G F+ U M vJ O? H br ro SC .- v, S". ~." a G .O ti > 'S"" 'CS u G O G- ?.O. GGr W O f. ro y O m O V 0 'C OU W s-, cd Li U LW G ro G ro r, U O .0 i.., ~i Qy O O 4-1 U 4-1 A ro ut "n y V] U y W id ro LW m G by .O .U. ro rg bC r F+ C O 0 ro t+4 45 rA 4~ 4 4 a ~, ~. U CZ '~ O a G 3 G .~ w o .; a~ G O U ro ro ~A Fro+ " co w G 'b ^ 'U ro b O 'U C O Ln) U '" o o r. a U Q y.a U) Q y 14" u C-' O G .U 0., ro m a, c, u (U ~4 t,4 G G 9 O ce1 2 O H O a> cz S Q O ro p G -O ro W Z bC O M G O ~ 2 'U ar V ro V Q 4-J c a a o w y h ro Q 'V ro 4 > 'C3 G a O OJ ~ N bA G 0 roc In. cd .0 'vJ V by G .t~ Gv U ro :n Q m cv u ?- r Q Q U ?. C?.' Q H O v :a bO P-4 ~ro 0 Abp 0 Fa+ + .0 by LCi .O A"A-g ? G G a ro o o bo c-i V A. 0n y G V " a 0 G V U "0 'Ly G 0 O CVJ . p Fr. V ro . U V .O o cd G 'ty ^ 00 br,a G u Approved For Release 2001/03/07 CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3 Approved For Ruse 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-OOZ,07R000400100015-3 CPYRGHT a u N y v 0 a a +, bo 'u ? v v o. v! ? bA 'O Rt CIS y. _.._ _ ,... n v G ?N a r.+ n ,q,i aJ W n w r, "d O _ ? 4+ '~ y a~1. F" O a y ,p R3 - L V .- = w t v .- O -'4 w . am a 4 .w : , 5 ~3 ?y g" w ~7 U z .. -C1, v ? 'CS .2 Y? 4+ ?t. R! ed vi ": 0 a .- O M 'p - . C CU 41 C) r L64 k ? ca, , V o ?a ' > ? ,t"A U " o v >' ? - V ? ~ + , O (U cl -4 Cli y ~' ~. w 5 ~' +~- 1" a a 5? ~' r. O .ter. ? ? S~ O v W ??? v 3 nr'a. '~? tr V V 4.a n .. t" ? r" L" a O +-' - +_+ r.S' `nq, .t~ "~. CL `'~ a ? U Q a .Gi 64 O O ~n ~C1 Cd M nt O U bA ? LMi p FU N C'd ' a U vi ~ T) >=i . ~" S'" ?a.a v ?-" A . rrr ere .Q^ .li ? v :-. U U ., ~"~ .- a Rt O a ,.q L94 . r-i U y di L. ~+ RS ~" 'tj '~? ~?r q~j 3"r ?d " O '?"dti ~' .~"..r ?~A -M - v~ O .C v" .a ti O Qr Ct P-4 ~? CJ F' 0 F7 ro .0 -d 0 10" ya u n- n h ca u v v 61 0 7 3 y F, P4 v cl b s, U 0 0 0 o ? y y W ? 0 X; G1 M v .--i -P C, U dA Fa w ;~ ~ %+ 'v) v ?~n, '`~~ ? o'~?.d N ' bob V tfj 0 N V ..v~ U ' y [7 L: U vvi ? Ri ' f~l w rI~i ? A w . v 0 ( O O" cC w v v ro ~d v "5 0 164 L64 at m y cv p., 0 O Z m u a M 0??? h w 0 to . V o ~i ~?I .i~?.V ~-+ CZ ?---I v w W y ? .I.A ~i 1.7', ~Cy 0 w s. a~~.n 3 U y mow. hi u.~. ?}r N 5Sf Ci lJ O Cl, u Q1 V u A ro a1 v U v v 'ii 4 g 0 ,...,? O 0 ,., Cut v 1 d yJ ? 4-1 8,0 0 C's 0 O U U bO C'd m? . 0'~ U nro a c c aA q p "r~ y ?.i 0 u C s. y n ~-! ~ s. tci ro v o .O m "C 4 ~, C's 4-1 C14 9- m y P v "O O O +4 cn W ? U r. 0{j q rl ;-J bA 0 y y O sn "U u U U j; r 'U ?~ v cli v I E 0 v 0 v? O U w0 '0 v U Q-, .,., v R, 0 bi0 i ++. C .-, y '~ y "~' ro ? ' V 0 h u /. , bb O m tti, A v ix 0 w O. r, ry 0 v, .O Gli ? 0 .." '" ? r~ ro v t' v x' 601 a01 O ~p^ chi 0 U U O 0 v C 0 ..- v cci 0 H '?a` a~ V Z v ~ + 0 cu 0 U v y M y O? - M 61 U N 0 0 O ?- g a bjD a U s '> ~.byyA O P.'--i C'S r, a., Q0q M 0 H 4 4~ H 0 v iva .Q w . , ~~" N jy Vy) 0 td ^y 0 'd ai W a`~ r~ 0 v' A, U y v v. ) CS F, U ro y v v v y o 0 0 ~+ y .O v 0 .Q v P, U U O V U cd ? O Approved For Release 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3 ?~ ? 0 ? ?`}}-,,~ n ? ``'~ '~'~ y 0 b v ~' k o ro . 41 C'I r C ~1 :b v G v vU o n - v .~ cv 6v~ 03 U cr~ Cc) O U 0 U 'O v U) CIS "Q `i' ; O . c 0 U t.. bA m all ?, X 4; Q) aVi 0 v v; 0 '- a1 ?C ' "C o v y ccz O +- O 0 U v V V 0 bn o v > cUC 61 v .C 14 0 R, go ? r? y bA y'~i CCU! b0 b 0. U u o , o " .o ? `~ ? ? rv~a~ v C? ;.mac cli 10 y O ? r~ vv .~ 60i O" .~U Q . ] r cCj '.~,~ ' ' iui y0.,+ RS r~ 0 SC:. '..~ t% v ay+ S?i C' ~-?+ .~ ? Y ro ~ .a bA y 0 x y v_ c O ~; bvlJ R (tl ro 0 b ?U 0 `~ y 'yam O 0 bA +~ v o v o -O 'Q. O Z r~ O vJ 5 4= a + i + + O .U (U u o ., .C 9C v sa. O bA ni O O ro y +' ~ v bA R ar a r2 a; v CIS MO 00 V C) O U v ~ ' a; ro V) . .- a) 't 0 v v yj Approved For Re se 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00 7R000400100015-3 CPYRGHT s ~ v , ~ .. h . O Ca..~. O }~ C) 4 U p bA O Car Ui, ?^ WD p ~r O QJ ~"" 'y O C % C9 w (U 'd aai cyc o [ ? ? m o q O Q 3 ccv col vy ' m u u 72 En V U s- a E y U N r~ U '" Car n ,~. H y v O ? U y ~? ' b U 'C aUi ~A > 'v, j u y a+ O O aJ V y a ~" 'L3 D. ~", a 'C bA +-~ Q O ?G O U, w s~ O y y a~ s~ U 'C a O U U 'v - r 0 'c~ t0 O jn1 a~" cU) ~t a: n .~fi O V M, bb 7 U U QJ ? ~J y 4~J , ~i 'G a Q Cy" yj y ~j?r V +~- ? ~+ ' U a% N QJ ki tlJ Car ~,' u v 'Cf ~-~ 'v r..r OJ ?'~,,,~ U O O 4-4 (U -n w ? .C,~ ? > i(r O ? p rLn W) O.~ cl O .~ O ^' M y bA '~ c a bA A Lr. O P-4 ~ C1. '~ '~' ro CJ ?~ O C a v bA ? Q) N ? y 4JQ4+ v ~. 7J O y y O 00 O + O Cd aO '~' 3 , :~ u it C', [E-' QJ W CCi U N u C ?'O ~~ {{ p bA TJ , c i .. i ' y Car b ' ~y ZS .~ bJa R, u U F. n . . G Cr. .u ~. ry L\I '~ S? GJ_ .-s 'f! OJ CJ .. n ... _ ~` ar y '-" bA CJ U y F bA bA U +- w v ++ r? to 4 u u 'd O, y 'd U ''" O v O y O O Q~ v O Lz, O C. U n ^[i Q y U ' n r~ p Q+ ? Q COD cn ?"' y, y 4J O 4a [~ ~j +.' i?-i '+-' ?a'".~ rti" y y v, .O ~ T3 ~ 'b y W ?+ pA 0 y O N aa bA w3 v cn ?' CV Q ?~ = c . .+ O, If] h O '7 ry O ' ? y .- V) cz t- 0 'd .C y > > o 00 4 ? m -, ;z A ? A ;Z v by ?~ +v .. i ? Car O bA ~~ ?~ W W Ui S"n. ? 'C3 y ~' .~ G ~v t4 00 a ~.. E- tr a?1 ~,y c~rV ? Mrs` ice, +4J+ r7`. Cy" 'v~i O v' GJ R.. fn ? a {=. J (U q) 'cl ct x U ~ '~? ;1- G C O v~ C.J. .Li m 'C~.., to Cad Oa '`'' O U C." a~.' .~ h ?QJ / 'a u V ? ? O C''. Ci Qd ? ^+ ~' () y r?~ '.~ ,La ' O 4' ff, UO w C y u to v cG ~~ as v 'O~ O w -r W 0 0 X ? Qr a bn ? O U y . Ur O V V a] m LUr Q CIS u GO) U N O v bA " .C O >C v v W TO .sa C) O 4 ;t -S r-, ... ~, +~ Ct to .' CSC OJ N ?~ ?H', QJ v~i ''.' .A-. O 0 y bA 0.7 .5.: f- Q eci . v w 'Ci + .O p, ` '" V O Q O ' y cd 'A q QJ+ O C~ 'C3 w .C Q O U C) bb ~` y O w ctr O y sir A. u a m a C) cd 0 0 GV a~+ G. O O bA a) cz r' O V) U 0 D N V 'Cy y v M O O ?.~ :3 cn ~ `'`% v v +~ Car U Carp Y b0 5 " {-, v 1~' '4~ W ~~Qr~I ?^~ rV ''4d ?'V ?~Uy ?~ ._ (CS y~ VN ~Q) ? ~ ,_?i ? y n V ^ u m ? 1~ . N?, W, u P~ -0 ..C Cad w .,r " CC :~ y .-~' ^V '~ U y ?.w-~ O ,4.+ w N y("'? ' V 1- ^? C\t y U u V ct bA Ok +~"+ ' r COO rte. " 41 +yU In v E V V' "J' L". p ['?' -- p ~+?+ O.7 ' Cyr' '~ ?.`'' 0 a) u O h O Cd CJ ,. ~'a >4 y LO P ' SUr rEn .v 44 W vi . v '~'.' fC1 O ?'" 10 TJ w r., ?~ fd U C/] O N 0 v C: QJ C't 'C3 4! ... G oo OJ r-i O W U ? + O U v", Q~ .., O ~. ...d w br, ,d ivy .0 O y fSi ?F~ Ca. Gr bdJ Cj y O bA S" vn QJ +^ ?H ll:j O O O `n ~~, U p O U'' " .y 4-1 2S O p cd Rr u Cd t- a+ Cr" tti v 1 .ti C ~, cv W Rt .~ 2 - m u 3 u i o C ' 001 15.3 v~ C6 ? v - b O C" r Approved For ReS se 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-0&7R000400100015-3 CPYRGHT .- +.~ +..~ r+ Z 4) - 0 err' x C 4J ~' o a3 a u o U o ?' a v v V UO U of 1, ran 44 H U O tUr O 14M4 ? ~~r 0 q ' U+ C ?+.i T7 yO~ 4-4 U J14 (U 4~ 'n bf) 0 cn N v' 4) 4^ "v, wO C Qr ' ' O O . - ?p r- C) .. 4) 'Q ^ [~ r?~? G +"' 4^1 U O rn 'm 't3 _L." 4J 'U 0 (U cz U L" 4a 4-1 tM 0 c aJId +W y yO h ?N F+ avd i4 ~,+. 4J ,.C] ft1 ~i .ti -::?:~ O 4J 'v~i ? eQ Cr3 0 fCj y h~ ~+ ^9 a~ 0~ ^c7 Sir bA O U 70 .= 4J V - .N rn O bA ?-+ L" _ al 0 n v m 2 GJ i~+ ?.??i ~y + to L-i .'L _ ....y vi ~i ..r a+ +.+ y -r ?'C! C's q F'i PI O ? W W "'Ci r" ~/7 ? ~~rr ? v - ftS 1' ..Ci .L~ rti `' ... .` +'' rj W F eQ +~.+ Q~ cn v, 0 ?v, re 'v 4) 'i: U v .~~ , bA V "~ ~ L3 bA Rr +' QJ 'O 4) 4) ? w +J ? yr 4, .e+ F+ .-r 4.i a 4J O b ..+ ti O + O 4) p fSi h U $+ O p 0i O aU .. L+',' ?, _ _ ? [:. ? _ , "?: d. ? ?~?+. vU, .rt " _ .~~. ~'" e O .'emu ? , . + fC ~" 4J ?.H $'"'' V .0 ?J Q ~' ,~~, 'raj- O ~? C's '~.~i i47-r 'r' ? V _c4 0 ? G" ?.+ a.+ .+~1 e~. 1 +~. ? , CTS ~; `~ ? S: U ~+ + 1+ ~ UO rA 'C'.+ ., 'C , A `Or O Ou ? (u w +J O v' +~ ,.Ui .vr O m A ?r ? Sr" O .^U. SCI ivr O 4J b"A'd GO y '~ h b0 O C C/ e-, . ~ "" ?U fCS ti r :O +.+ F+ O rU ti O cE+ ~-'~ it M G 0 y. U G" .O ' I v, ? U O "~ O . e~.r 4J 4) y, Cr' (~ ~? ~+ U ~" "CS w 4) O a,,,O.+ .~ ,~.~ U U u v U O cd F-4 -bO 41 4 rd V) 0 bb V w .cyV ~" C1+ O ~` O +v O ~yN, 04 O In. 7U " p y .O q bA p O ~? v im CG +, b?!j P Qr a r '- 0 O bA O 00 z O f"+ H arU. yAj+'~ C, +V - 0 + h 2 'CS rr I~ y. 4J ht 4) s n 4-J w Z.+ aL r,' i. .~ C's o ~ v U v o 2y a~ cz+ o o ? A u -4 u > g L 0 ;O o 'd w $-+ a U a&, ~' s+ O , x ?' Qa, ^d U 14 u a wO .L"i Ly_" V 2,z .u ,,,~ v +,U.,~ W O v rrt n +'~ -' fd U ~+'"J.+ tnr, .-+O"' 'TS "C3 O O V pr %1;4 U ~~?? ? ~-~ .~ O .;4 4) ? $- (~ ^ .'~~ ti bA ~+ cd p ,,'y/`` ^p ir-+ ' v~ ? r+-~ 4 J O h ' ?.? ?b U C4 >- w O +'. .f? ..L"i +-+ w ?"" "'' C1 cOJ c~'r N , O rrn? 0 :C m ^C3 4) ?~ .~ 4) Obn R3 O e[ O ' ? F y CRJ " , , ~ G ~"+ ^ V +~ q - Sr" cd --, ? x]., "o ? E..4 +z + O +~+ '1 V -5 r v, (11) rr C4 CJ v~ .O U v~ + a C ~ ! C. _ . ~"'~ LLr Fa ~ 0 ?v~i v, ~" .N 4) v M-+ 'v ++^ C,6 V 0 N a.r ` - `^ .L," +L Cdr Ar bA H 'r~n ti O 4?? i e~"i D ' O n .L .sod N N r ' ? y V) In ?LS p, v 0 q~j n y N ; e~ _r~ 4J O 1i'+ ml w O Cld RS QJ a+ &-I 0 rn n Sir +=+ y o 0 GV ? O N ~ ?u P nn7R~Rnnfl ~~ U o C U u w Ar '? y G v y c; 0 QJ w OJ QJ rr'~t "r / n C3 V Approved For Rise 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00,J7R000400100015-3 -r w q a ~' ,~ v s~ 0 r a ' 0 a 0 a O ." a u O w P w v a~J v H `' O 14-4 O'~+, O IV, 0 a a O A O" a0i p a >~ yaj u 4 .0 cv b o a ~ 'p p w? h V U a il. O ' v v '140 M o O 4? a rJa "C cri ._ "C3 ees Q r~+ 4~ ?f" TaJ C "rJ ? C's 0 r .C O O ?-1 a rQ O a yJ Q.~ ,+-~ ~i Q '~i (?..i y "q ?~ ~' tn , O m a vs U a H .., a . a O O y H cV a O % UO O RJ U a s Q y a u "C R O ++ H HO w U cC} 'bA C11 a 0 4J .4v y ~~ .] baA'0 ccz to 0 ~a+ O U S~ ri O O c",`n" ?~ S~ !r W c~i v~ '- cz ?"" = O O ' a y a o h 4 "C ? m .- O & Ra a t~ t~ ~, .0 r7 c- r ,' N h crf N "~ ." ~+ W V a /~ h U a 0 as to U u Z~ .r ti a? A.; bn 9 y. "',~ .0 V a ?.a a ~ " V3 a "C c F" M V) w h M 10 z Q 4J rr Cu a ' ~ ~ u+ O bn cCS a t ,~j r~'+ F . N a u 'c: w 'C7 v A v ayi a ,~ O .~L a s O U .y v $ w >~ '~ .a P O ~' w v a .~ O U C~s tf ? O U a O a rti O 0 to >- (U (U 9 ?~ v OH SU.' ,, 4 .a mu HO w v 0- V a a it vi Q +~-+ O O O U w a~.~ .?-"N ~ a' a m C U ~ J ? - Q r1 Q, pa .a- w IS u 0 O 'L3 O O v .Q+ -4 y O O a CS a 4' 4~ ctt O, a 00 ti H U CIS GA O p c-d vQi F a 4~' N y O 0 w (LI O O a_ .O ~] '~ .a Q a n U v a U O .O O a y r~ 'L7 > 4J 70 S ?U G, "Q i~" .c" 'a 'L1 u v~ R. a a 0 a a C r- e- V a '~ aar a. i co~ Q a . . t +? 0 (r y y c '~ r''? a La iii a 'C 'LS Q aH' O O ?L" U +~+ E-d Cl O C3 O O .Q ~-, 0 0 >C O .~ U O O a v a? Q p ro O? a cti U O U O n V. 41 C4 u h y ~"' O vUi 4 O fii CCS rj a It +' 0. r~~ ? a 'C7 ? .r v~ v~ v V O 4- a U""..' O ctS O b?A "~' u a + ^va U r 0 v V H v~ H m U bA. "y ~~ W 7` +' ,~ vi `U bA ZC'd ! cq ,"J y cry a .au a M bA v~ .w vii bA ?f? ^d y _ C. ~n c'J d" tom" ?.r v, ..r ..t='i ~' ..~ 0 0 ~ m a '_'.' '" ?~ to bA ( U v) 0 p?. U ' y ,?~"" ,~ t1. ZS cd O a.' W U > y cQ2 v 'ts is a? V y ,a V. -- V o Z s~ 4 a 3 w Q 1-4 C's m C', 'CS co 4.1 erU" '." v .c 4 .a ` " 4- a Z1 7d bA.k C W l. n !! ,, v o g s~ bA W a~ "" Zs o z7 v ?' "d W ci b a c~ ri .., U "d cd .t~ a O bA O." a a O 'LS .~ u s 4J ~. .> ti W a b sa Ri in O Q ~" Q , N 41 O U a Z$ "O it v' U ~/ ?~. a O H a S;." v' ' ? ~ ' a v ..O a ' ~n C.7 .Q n w ?'.? v O J i1, a a+ `*-i .-, Q O H a -~ O 1~ .C a au > O G C1 C, Q m w i. :. ~~/ i`+ ., q O a ti y 'U a CC cu ; cd w Q .O ~. u X a) . h a F, u u R1 Q N ? j to v~ '.~ u a a GV .O a C" '^? e"., ~., v to ,? -u 'b ~1 H y O a a " O a m a u I? (U u (W 4! .~ 'Fry.' ^~' W y ice' ?~ c'-' y RS bA^~i i`~i U ,i?a r.0 +?~ v "'. ~r 4: :l OA . q _L U Q G ? a zso "o 3 M G w .ry o n .a _ a ri ^ Z7 > S: O y n cti .ry V) i cn "S L V] ^ S" y Z a a R a U O U O v .'n .O 0 O U 'C bp m ri (U ?n U G U b , 1Z w cud yyj ,`~ A a ,.. V V bA 00 v ' n ?bA 'C n v~ 2 yA ^ C." br) cd .-yam . r ZS (u 0 v ? ~' ^C+ry U cd 'a ? r cOV a a a O a rd cv a bn z - ;5 (Id V) 1.4 0 u -0 41 .0 41 S C'S .C U H w0 w a v O v (U Q V bb tw o .~ 9 ?d y A 3 q 'lu " O 0 + CIS + a w+ N y a CL A .G.O ,~ O v r C.0 o t~ 'c V Y~ a + V ~+". ~'. ~?+ to - FN ,' i-i ?-r it !~ ?C' A M C14 0"+ Ln r, C's y+i ct fCS blJ D V - ?E H , O 4 . U w O U X 44 U rte, U (.?" v' a a h R"~ ?N a ta../ H ~?~0 U ?C.' y v: " i ', t~ tC u (U O ra 0 roved For Release 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3 Approved For Remise 2001/03/07: CIA-RDP96-00ZNR000400100015-3 CPYRGHT a. ?.C a, b u o, C~ r ".3 > a `j v' C"i Cd W a ;p q a, o _y R~ W p yS O y ~: V v,U.q ai y O a V -[ a a b0 0 0 bA F: V bb 'D (ld x v ~Vp E ? a h o O n v .d .y ~' p 0 a y 4d o p a a ?~ o n a c {o y 0 ~i cz *~ O cis 3 yj c~ V r~ d x zt +~ a .C a 'des v ox a o a 4~ wu -w ii V ri C bn y o ?~~' a Q) ?~. .y y'~ C V o a v o y o u "' a Q, N U .~ a a 0 -+ rn O d p cut 4- U O O ,7 s+ a O 4-1 L" O ii v cd Z7 '~ (U 44 u d mo , p a d v a s " y .. o ?d r. w Z ra fa v ;-4 4.+ ' .n aai a O ~+ a O v o car ?' 4" -" VO N o E .d bn 1. ?- a w '> a O O 7P a a ~+" Qi u ~ "~. 401 .~''-? ?i wv~S~i aO.i p+ a a a 'd O m '~ + f ?y '.~ ~ .~~ a'O..? +~-+ H ate.. Oa" .ti 6UJ ?.i ,.~-~ ~"" ~ ?" C~"d c Q v bpn- 0 a fi rn rS~ a x C s C. a -. d W s k p a p SOE' 4 UO u" V 0 a sac p?, yU mn r~??' a .LZ tr '. O Fai it - O bbA O H b a O bbn O N w s~ U o H O O ,4 51 r7a t" a O b ' v u v O N 0 4 0 g fi a 0 0 a O CIS 4-d O a Tr" a .~ U ~r Va A. em U r o o H h a r. 0 r. O ?~ U rd `. ~' C.'"" T3 U ti '~ Q. a s a h y 13, u. C N cc_ M bn v 14.1 . U 'Q Q M ?d u. OU a a a? O 8 2 Rf O'~ F i O> O U ?C U vOi y '~ N .O O "CJ 0 {, O 91) > iai G. ~r w . G a~+ 4- ; ,u u .C p. .a r b-I U a v U O .C `~~, q U zj a 6n o a a H ^d ya O .C., R" 0 ca", O 7 bn O U 'q' dety "0 0 V V a bA 3 ~ ~ O 4 bn v: ate, ~' ' C7 y-~ bn' a a, .+ sj a O .~ C '" cam, ~ ~ " V"J 7-+ a On P y O O .C .0 C C' u S" a .i+ U - 4J O O O U y .~ O 0 s> . m a v fa, O Y 0 0 cz4 G a 'rJ rs ... cli u c. 0 a m .a H o=-. n e 2001/03/07 : CIA-RD.P96-00787800040010001 .::ate' - -~~.,.,.?..,..a..~.aca.,.s.xvse~ewoa.-s.,a,rnenn~+Y4st%Ma",,~C"r4 c_ ,zm, ~ a~ a Cr d Q7~ 0' d O O'd v a O _O ' LS `H a ~n z o? a 'i ~. .C ?". RS ~" a~ U r, .d s'ue. ,.+ O r! d I -C 45 rl aRi" p W s 'mod U .' V ce 0 , C U- M O O cad - V .19 ' V ,, h a O a O O m N n c x 'r. q ~, ~, a bn C + CPYRGHT Approved For Remise 2001/03/07 CIA-RDP96-00 TR000400100015-3 Cl LO 4a clj . 8 S. O a CIS U 0 PG t~. 114 a) o O to 8,0 0 `v ?~ U v Cl ?M k .~ U o .N ?~ V j-4 ~JD .C y w U UO v 0 O sU. y` v Cd 4.1 +-~ m u> bA U y W ;~ cO Rs a, U , e~ ? ~ ."+. td Vi lc~ 0 i_I h 4V ? -' Q~ v O U ?j yU y .~ '~ v O C "iz sm, ~ U ?~ O d d ~' U ~' U U bq r .,, .. _r. .fl ? i - CO, G p n y CIS c RJ U U 4 U V U C's .O ai U Cld U U 'v U +~ w 0-' 0 ;3 (-3 V ~ "C$ r. -~ p a-) SP 0 V ILI 01, bn 0 vO "Cl O y 3 ~. O y. ~ ~ vi cd O ?.y- ~ y .C vVi h .may Mp (Cj YV ,.0 '~vl y . .C W '~N' y + H vv `'s >, 3 ;o . o 'n U p U ? C" c3 O aJ O y" v i 0 Pr. 4), m V a u y O r3 G 4-. o 0.c W o o .OO ( 3 ~a ~r bp cn bq 44 aL~J y 4~ v 3 o G> ++ ? aj = G7. y N. O. n', U Cl N t?! w ?'+ C bA U U aJ y (u V) a~ 44 0. v y a' i .9O' p cti N r v ..+ ,??, 41 O V ~' y bQ 3 y rni u v bl) aCLC1. ~. r v ;, N b~ W i Q cJ] v L7 td bA as O .u ?.?~ O U v -= bl) U N ?o cca o +- U y ar ,, O -O p. N 'O 41 5u (u O v sU C ?u -Cj v V to n U(u ,L` O i n-fl O U O aQj OfD y o U .~ lei V ? ti .Li U S-1"' O bA F". aJ % .cti r- H a) ,o Approved For ReFse 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-OOR000400100015-3 "f y '.. N ?~1r C ? Q + ~" Cr' bU y'~ 'v'i a GJ O M h ~" .L" CJ rn .~". fj O N~ ???i .~''-i vvi JUi C"?, fkd ~ ?"" Ri ?O '~ h b~lJ 4J :~ aU+ r'' y-i a~ / R1 C a+ O w .`~+ U V y G1 V O ? W 'h U Fr ~ r". O CC 0 r U 4cd ri tl W bQn 4 a ? V m V W 41 C 5. V O (U vV 15 ?`' ? ?~^ a+ a a+ n !?" V C], w a .d ~. V ~. y va O M V s+ .. Ct U U O c3 v v w G CZ A" V > w N 14 O +J VV+ O H bA V 4~1 O V ? p CCf ' (U mbj)Z4~ x= Qr V CV C V U FV. " y bn U ^Cj C1. a! .~ '~ G bVA ?+G " '+- -, .O bA .Q ~" r bn b v 'C Cts U C3 U 4~ 4J LW V) s.i ~'?? ...i .ri .~ y-i r^.? .,~?'-i Ri ?~-~ jQ.~ Si r.~ 14-4 O i.r CJ ft3 O 'L"i f" '+"' .j"i- ?a.- 4J 04 c1d 4P 'C7 p ? 0 ,p C: u N 4, U S" ro .C H 3 O C1, Q "C y uU " ,~, Vk+ U U O~ ?v a ~ GJ 4J vi D. ~+-. V fi a..i a.~ Sn_ .'~ .,Ci .f' ~" .^1. U ~-"i G.7 ?- ..-~ . ub3 "L3 VJ ~, RY t! bA ' H u t) ~ ? (u ~' v V t~ - '" O t V ctS + v O ~t .C1 n 'L7 bn " O ~V+ w -r4, ^G .~ yV vUi ?LS bOn VS G > :~ as OC) T7 a~ V bVD p V y v ca V ," 7 V ?a~., V V - ~~O++ ;~ a' ~i ~" ~'. '-" fti G3, CJ ^O cl ^L"' .~ ~'' F+ "L~ ?yC '~ .+,,, bn aJ F,4 O U S. ? V U GJ . V N ~" ~ +~~ G bq bn . +- U U n > C's H =~? C ,y. ..C'. i_,+ ?N ~., m y O R+ ~"' d) ~" RS .~" ?.y .-r !~.' +.+ .ry n ^ ~+. _n Cd ~" ni ?r `~ ts. a) ?' u &, CU u v v .ti C), 4j o ~ o N V) 'd bn O V ~ ~r t~ ~ 0 ? ti-~ ~"' ,`~ v) ,'F' :: {~ .~".. ~'" ' QQ H .f,V+ V i-i '.a a.C""..~ ?-" Vii y + V ,n h n. ., h '+~ p ++O 'C of ? ^" a~ "+ a a~ (~ CJ .L rn h ' ^' s ? 'LS -+ c cti n V W O U ~. w Q G V U O G .Cr ,. cli rn O a V V .L" ,~+ C1. C~ O P. h id .t j u U O A a~ 'C3 ~ u O v .a [-i aui U 41 cri w h vVi V) bA Q. r+ 41 C~. U H .r h Cl, G p tV, H VVj V v V G 3 V? O A V) cts ww o V > o,o y o C's o u 3; ? v 0 0 C1 ~, V of L1, ~. :N (~ U U V u a n o .o ro bA A. aVi o C'S v G O . ~ 0> ai S., 'j u 4 '~ :? Cy Oy U O O V ~ CC 7r _ tcj O ~+ -may "0 "tj o V O "O v Lr' 'v CU V O V~j [ C~ a+ q v bn V O a v n O" .C C~i UU'? u N ~4J+ a7 'v ?y.+r Qd . O 1 m 4 0 V , rJ V .-..d bA ca = lu L3 u cd ?.+ V O ~U-+0 csS Q , a~ .C ,~ V G U Q) x 4! V S r+ > a.) V V ,?p ? ~ O bA V A" ?. h 'a"~ U ? . ~~-, , a ' C O O y, '~ c~ u V '" V o w o ~n 4-4 CIS cn 0 (U (U ci -CS bvfj 44 A. G! a y V O ? '"' O p z t O vi rn ?_ V yr +~ ;7 ctl p >. >. p C3 y cd '0 SC p ar p v O at v a~ O 'd t1 iV c~~i ~+ ' bn 'Cj C7? O V O a'' U cti > 4~ C-0 bo ?.~' O V ~y~ .?' 4' V> Q rn v~ ~~. v V O u (u (u td O E } L4 O Ctl '' tc1 -5 O V ? .a w u V R'~ r! 'Q u p aUi q .~ ~y cOa U, 0 Cj Q) v' d S" C13 ? bn O u V O O Q 0 V U L: b 'LS CJ C. O V." O V - 'O 'CS aJ O n "C~3 v V p[ Cc "p _ y O CU 114 ~" "'` V V N fir" U G7 M U ' En + + p CC! ~", ^-, ? V bVl) v a O 174 V O? ~- O w O y 4J ? V V a "3 (U V bb Approved For Release 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3 Approved For ReI se 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-OO WR000400100015-3 CPYRGHT 11 ~ >u }~? Q V i~ a~~ ~~ U bA ..V G~J ? 3 Ulj ~n "~. ~, ran ~ti` ?LS L3. v 41 b4 QN+ .t] W v~ 'v~ 41 O T3 .C~ G' G .O V ~] p '+ - 0 (U In (U ~v UO .6 tN Cd ?~ 0-y v E .i U by , p O V 0 .G 3 ~0 "a 41 > " a+ y ~J n Ci U CCf O v5 .?ti V Z . 4 O ?4 'a'" CC! 0 Z L.i W O O a y P, (C! O +-` ?; ~+" c~V ~` Q) .""'' 0a ?-Ya F" L . ; m Rf r~? Q 'n 0 C~ y~ '~ ? ti (CI v~ v 4Z ~',~"'5'd L.+ ?y .~ ~~ ft3 U ,y,, v~ '~,~ iS~," S-+ CJ r?'S O k V O v O n2 0 O 0 .C d ?.> rvti T3 L, 'm C: , M O ?~ ?.?+ Q) i.., 41 QJ 0 'd '-" O Q) r. ." q Q" (L) m y .`'~,,,,. ? ^U-i o r'; : ', ^"A V c"d cl ~' T3 +' Oa h > CU U r> ?i SS 7 .Q Q+ V > 0 C > O 4~ 4-4 fn -N cu V CIS CZ " {; ;tl CV cl - .04 44 O f--4M . U .L " .L2 " " 'v n Q) o .~ Q1 LS O? p, a O O n bbo 0 ccz O> vWi o "d O O 0 U A. t O O .n M H ' U c b0 3 ~' O .?..n a`'i a .C ? G1 CIS S ? " ,..a c ;., qd w QQj C3 .Sr" u n .:a ~?i :~ 'LS ^+ to y '?'" CCf ~", y P" 4J V 0 (u 0 44 '~;y / O 4J Q) ?~ .n ., 'd Q! p. 0 ?~ Z O cl .w+ C. .' bA'~ u v 'Ci as '~ v 2s /~ v y h ~, cd a~ ?' n o v ~. G 'yes ,. +.+ N Q) ?'+ Oi - V .-" Q) C '7r 0> , G~J 4) v1 U Q) ,_.,~ ~" .d i~ ?a""+ O ~'' Ri ~ U J Lyi .., 0 a 1 O ~ o o ~{y W V ~Ny y ,y Q fV y.{ i.`i V t% '~ bU .+-? tUir 'p CIS 0 ? ?'~' O .. O bo e U $:: 4-1 0 z 4 m> m e~ v En Cl M v O tl .C n `~ "0 C: a O O O v ~b 0 O V v N O Q) 0 0 .a V Q) O "d g 'u W) Z acSl .H ." Q) QyJ y"~?~ 'L" O G .~ 4 CIS U 4 ?" in, Q) 05 U 0 ,% O Q1 Q) y 0 ~'+ A-i 41 QJ cd V O ~ / y~ V ~I ?i+iM V y,~ ,J (~( 'h 4C Q h U '. O v .O O O Q! tn >, 41 cv O N 0 0 ,~?~ .~ r CC O .'L'-i ?~` 41 ?--~ W F=~ cz h ..C~ ?''S i-~ vii ir. V 4J O y v C1' 4.1 0 w i b~q .yi O O Q) u aV 11 .4.1 u U v 0 U w O n .o "d G v V h ^O 0 .O C O iV+ 0 'a ro a m "yyQ~ O Ql u bA O yyd Fi ~' ^O P4 u Ui m C's Cd Q) Q CC r% 0 r > G rd w r. 0 U 'n ." O _ QJ M .O Q) ct3 .~ O C(Li O U 0 >1 U Q (~ r.+ a+ '~.~` '~ iQ+ U fti Fi cCS Q) ~? bO u ~"\ O ftl r.Q. .'~ r0 v~ ,~i jr' ~i ~. CIS G12 QJ ~ti (U ,O vi ??'Sn ?~ V > V ? V O V V cC LO +-' ~~'?".m C's ry v O o .] O V? ~~nrrr ^d O O G? v i v p .O aJ Q) !'. O v, ? r O QOM R G 4 y a.Q 41 V J C. ?4 +-+ Cd (U Q) 4.P > Or "d ?~ ~ ~~ OA O N bA ;-4 ~J COV ^~ d U " 0 ?:c C 2 'a 6 v 'd .d 0 u - y .14 (U 0 V tJ Qy O v~ C cC :4 0 Q) W Q) U ?d 0 r V Q.. a h .L ,~ a O ."~ ? w V7" 7V. v M O ..-c O > C,3 4'.' "a 0 r-.? ,N fd FW-i V 4-1 ftj QJ rn "/~ QI V " .:w i ?.y t! }. .N v y0i C7 S", i, 0 O Lt ~, ai O ~~ cc; '" V P" u v x x QJ G [..i O cd Q) 0 n tr CCi r U EH n a ti- u n C a, O ' .d c d O 814 C~ ~ O " "d + O V P" O O O 0 L r., C .~", r i . , QJ O tiJ v .U< Ql / ..C". rn v l G~i CO 0 Ri c~S+i CU M M v1 M 0 +.' O V Q1 ' C1 4-4 > vi s , is bA ~" all WW+ O U CZ p 4 u N U v . bA O ter +~ O lzz~ w QJ O O? F n a O cC M '44 V zU O ? ti QJ a O O w 0- 4~ 0 OM v0 Z U O O 41 'r3 'C O V) ro y. Q) O V U O 0 C O CIS In Qd V) crs oPa o y ?a v 3. 3 w CIS c c a.) O U U , ... a. L . ~-~ a' u y. '+ o c V 0 O n p h ~. V 0 V) (U 41 O ~" ~" r. r o~0Q?,- cd U c 0 0 ,O P-~ roved For Release 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00787R000400100015-3 0 w O y.. .0 H - U BO C L ~ ctt `a' 4-0 Approved For Redse 2001/03/07 : CIA-RDP96-00,l7R000400100015-3 ~ ayye J "y CSS 3 Ob' QJ bA F"i .+-I pa.y H (~ Q) i-I ~-I .Ld V V /? Q) CZ pr cst ? ~ O der U bA p O v 4~ c] a~ ' 0 U cn 44 V 4i to O p O ' ~ Q O c ' .C sv'~W ? ,1 U rn p 0 v +.+ F a p CJ O y+ M 44 C) COD kQ, +a U ~Cd .ti cV U v W b1J v~ ar f h-y." Q~ U y (V O tUi M O ` O F 1:~ 04 C) 0 C) 4 CIS _ W bA Qa Q~ ? r O It O n. Q) I ca.., U :., Cd r". P-. C'U ., _ `.3 0VJ a ~ ~ ' C j ~ ~, v i U O " ~ QJ Q ) O CIS by v~ ~+ r ~' C1 ~" S," Ca v' ,~~" L~ C CU w ~ yr CU Q1 'Ll 14-4 ~' o y O "C ai O cdQ ' OA p '~ ? O 'd s (I '~ U v y a ~~ y~ 'u + 'G v p o d p ~~ a bA 00 m + QHj y ~" 'p^~ vUi p ? d 'DV bOA 4J '' n ^O` . rlb, . in 4-4 '~ I3 "s., .C cti }'+i h H v C QJ +'' 0 ::5 O O Cl, CG 04 ~t SO a A ca CCt 0 {cz V U fd U+ n C Zvi O ?C H .ZJ O ~" ?ZJ O qQj p -S o '~ i .C Q~ V O U C1r Sr Q) O Q) 1-. QJ V QT n O~J ^+ n v L" bq Cn ,~ N +J ..r ?--~ Q) cd Q) R1 .,.. Cd ,.t.a 'd QJ ...., ?.-~ V V cu ro 3 o a 0 0 v M 0 u ? o rte': ?' Z 4:4 7F (u U