REVISED AGENDA AND DISCUSSION PAPER FOR PRC MEETING ON RHODESIA, APRIL 12, 1979

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP81B00401R002000050002-6
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
C
Document Page Count: 
81
Document Creation Date: 
December 15, 2016
Document Release Date: 
May 21, 2004
Sequence Number: 
2
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
April 11, 1979
Content Type: 
MF
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP81B00401R002000050002-6.pdf2.51 MB
Body: 
25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Next 35 Page(s) In Document Exempt Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Next 2 Page(s) In Document Exempt Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/01FPRI-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 DCI Briefing Notes RHODESIA I. Elections. Mid-April. Case-Javits determination. II. GOR making all out effort for big show. Will be portrayed as compliance with western terms for black rule and will lobby hard for recognition and lifting sanctions. Preparations extensive. A. Police and military leaves cancelled and reservists called up. Military force of 75,000. B. Assisted byabout 10,000 ex-guerrillas and local recruits of black coleaders Muzorewa and Sithole. C. ZAPU and ZANU committed to disruption. 10,000 guerrillas inside. Thousands more before election. Intimidate voters stage incidents. Rhodesians likely strike again at bases in Mozambique and Zambia. D. Whites, vote 10 April; blacks ,vote during a 5 day period after 12 April. Security forces rotated from one military district to another to provide maximum security. III. Rhodesians hope for 60% turnout. Pressure. Say is valid if only 20% of blacks vote. Will directly elect 72 blacks and 20 whites; 8 whites indirectly. Separate districts and rolls for white and black members. A. Most likely victor is Muzorewa. Should win more than 1/2 of 72 black seats. Sithole has lost ground. Less than 1/3 of votes. B. Despite results, Whites will control military, police, judiciary and civil service. Smith's Rhodesian Frait Party is unopposed. Uncertain what role Smith will play. C. Most whites not enthused but saying Let's try it. In January emigration reduced to about 1,000/mo. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 IV. Election will not end war, nor will government win widespread recognition. Question is will accession of black government, albeit one with limited powers, alter the power balance. A. By itself answer is no. But election can't be looked at as an isolated event. Must be viewed as part of complex equation. - Deepening Mugabe-Nkomo rift. - Dissention in ZIPRA ranks. Nkomo political decline. - Hardening South African attitude. Throwing weight behind int. settlement - Growing western support for internal settlement. US Congress and Thatcher. V. These factors account for growing confidence by white Rhodesians. Risk is that it will also harden their attitude and reduce chances of a political deal among blacks that could lead toward an eventual solution. VI. Muzorewa will move to strengthen ?relations with whites, establish control in countryside, and induce defections from ZAPU and ZANU. Will probably also try to split Patriotic Front even further. A. A Shona-based alliance between Muzorewa's party and Mugabe's ZANU. About 75% of blacks are Shona. Has already approached Mugabe about joining government. B. Muzorews and Nkomo could cut a deal. While different tribes, white resistance to Nkomo alliance less than Mugabe. C. Many obstacles to both these deals; biggest impulse comes from mutual fear by Mugabe and Nkomo that other will cut a deal first. D. Neither of above alignments would tip balance sufficiently to end fighting, but could change complexion of war from one of equilibrium with prospect of growing strength on guerrilla side to one of momentum for internal solution. 2 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 VII. Election will create hard choices for the External Players. A. Front line states will continue to support guerrillas, but intensification of fighting could force Kaunda and Machel to accept open-ended commitment to Soviet and Cuban presence. Don't want. They also face prospects of supporting rivals in civil war. Thus, must support a deal under appropriate circumstances. B. Soviets presently backing Nkomo. Risk alienating Nyerere and Machel who also want Mugabe supported. If Nkomo cuts a deal with Muzorewa they have to choose between ZAPU and white allies or to shift to ZANU. If support both groups they retain credentials with Front Line states, buy risk becoming involved in civil war. VIII. Even larger dilemma faces US and UK: A. Western recognition and the lifting of economic sanctions would: 1. Strengthen the position of the new government. There would be greater white resolve to support the black-led government and more willingness among whites in the military to defend it. Government could attract significant number of defectors from guerrilla forces. 2. Improve the chances of stemming Rhodesia's economic decline. Worldwide demand is increasing for many goods produced by the Rhodesians such as copper, chrome, and gold. 3. Provoke a serious erosion in the "special relationship" that the US has fostered with black African leaders -- particularly Nyerere, Kaunda, and Obasanjo. They would conclude that the Anglo-American Plan for Rhodesia was dead and would come under increased pressure to seek a military solution in Rhodesia. 4. If the US and the UK pushed for the inclusion of ZANU and ZAPU in the new government, this might appease some of the African leaders. A call for the adoption of a new constitution providing for a quicker transition to black majority rule and approved by all Rhodesians -- not just the whites -- also might dispell some of the anger. This option, however, still would risk a major escalation of Soviet and Cuban involvement on the side of whatever guerrilla group is excluded from the government. 3 Approved For Release 2004/07/0.-RDP81B00401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 B. If West opts against recognition and lifting sanctions and continues to press negotiated settlement involving all parties to the dispute: 1. The internal government's ability to take hold would be weakened. Emigration probably would increase. White extremist attitudes gain currency and last ditch military stand becomes only alternative. Deals between blacks more unlikely. 2. The Front line states and Nigeria would continue to support the Anglo-American efforts toward a political settlement. They would regard the election merely as one step in a process that eventually will involve the guerrillas in a negotiated settlement. 3. But Soviet and Cuban involvement with the guerrilla forces and in the host states would still increase. IX. In sum: A. Everybody confident now -- Whites, ZAPU, ZANU. Pre-election struggle will provide test of military strength. Elections could shift center of gravity .slightly away from guerrillas if Whites maintain security. B. Once in power, Muzorewa is likely to make overtures to either Mugabe or Nkomo, but we doubt at this point that the white leaders will show sufficient flexibility to allow Muzorewa to cut a deal attractive enough to bring either guerrilla leader into the internal settlement. He may, however, be able to induce significant defections. A successful all parties conference or agreement to hold UN supervised elections are not in the cards. C. Short-term prospects are for a continuing stalemate, particularly if South Africa opts to commit its resources in support of the new government of national unity. D. Over the long run, time probably is on the side of the guerrilla forces. The continuing struggle will provide expanding opportunities for the Soviets and the Cubans and prove costly for the West. Even if whites collapse after prolonged struggle, we anticipate turmoil as blacks compete for power. 4 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET UNCLASSIFIED Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 RHODESIA: ELECTION TIMETABLE 10 April White Rhodesians vote for at least 4 of 20 directly-elected white members of the House of Assembly. 17-21 April White and black Rhodesians vote for the 72 black members of the House. Hours for the fixed polling stations are from 7 to 7. Hours for the mobile polling stations are from 7 to 3. 18 April The white Rhodesian Front Party caucuses to select at least 16 nominees for the 8 indirectly-elected white seats in House. 23 April Counting of votes for 72 black and 20 white seats begins. 26 April Whites meet, if necessary, in an electoral college to pare down list of whdVe nominees for indirectly elected seats to 16. 27 April Electoral results announced by this date. 7 May The newly elected black and white House members elect 8 white members to House, bringing the total House membership to 100. 15 May Nominations for 10 black and 10 white Senators are solicated by nomination court. 17 May Council of Chiefs elect 5 Shona and 5 Ndebele chiefs to the Senate. 23 May White House members elect 10 whites to the Senate; black House members elect 10 blacks to the Senate. Parliament is disolved. The new parliament is formed and the Speakers of the House and the Senate are elected. Approved For Release 2004611ffi59ei-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 UNCLASSIFIED Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 * Parliament puts forward nominations and elects a "non-executive" President. * President appoints a Prime Minister and a cabinet acting on the advice of the Prime Minister. 4 Date not set. -2- Approved For Release 2004/107016531laRlIDP81600401R002000050002-6 RHODESIAN PARTY SYMBOLS Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 United African National Council President, Bishop Abel Muzorewa Zimbabwe African National Union - Sithole President, Rev. Ndabaningi Sithole Zimbabwe United People's Organization United National Federal Party 410President, Chief Jeremiah Chirau President, Chief Kayisa Ndiweni Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 RHODESIA Problems of corruption, fraud, and statistical manipulation: Given the importance of the election to the internal government and the unstable security situation in many rural areas, some electoral irregularities can be expected. We doubt, however, that there will be any large scale fals?ification of the results. --The election will be supervised by a serious and competent group of civil servants who are said to be doing what they can to preserve the fairness of the vote. --Nevertheless, government pressure to produce a large turnout and particularly voter intimidation by the black parties and their auxiliary forces which are already taking place, are in themselves irregularities. Others, such as the counterfeiting of the ballots and the busing of supporters to different voting districts, could also take place, but probably on a limited scale. --Each voter's hand will be dipped in a colorless liquid that will remain detectable undera machine for one to two weeks. This will not prevent electoral officials from looking the other way if it benefits their party to do so, but monitoring procedures will probably be strict enough to avoid widespread abuse. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP811300401R002000050002-6 RHODESIA International Recognition of New Rhodesian Government To our knowledge, no state is planning--or even seriously considering-- recognizing the new Rhodesian government to be elected later this month. --Some states, such as South Africa, Malawi, Gabon, Ivory Coast, and Zaire, might decide to establish diplomatic relations if and when the new government demonstrates a capability to govern and looks like it might survive. --Many of these states, and others such as Botswana and Zambia, will continue to trade with the Rhodesians. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 ; t)L.:.L.1?L I Approved Fig;-Lease 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP8113004Q002000050002-6 Rhodesia: Economic Situation and Outlook I. The economy, a source of strength to the government 25X1 25X1 of Prime Minister Ian Smith during most of the period since independence, has deteriorated in the past three years. A. The contraction in national output that began in 1975 shows no signs of halting. 1. Reduction in output in the last three years has been around 15 percent. 2. Real GNP decline in 1978 probably equalled 1977's seven percent rate. 3. GNP will undoubtedly continue to slide in 1979. B. The economic slump largely reflects: 1. increasing burden of defense -- defense spending has nearly tripled in the last three years, 2. erosion of the middle class market by white emigration, 3. waning business confidence due to persistent guerrilla activity and hiOly uncertain political prospects, and 4. weak international demand for Rhodesian products, in part related to *economic sanctions. ER M 79-10213 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved F&SeIease 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP8113004.11(002000050002-6 How the blacks come to power and how they treat white economic interests wiil, of course, have a decisive influence on the country's future and will determine whether the economy suffers a prccipitious decline or whether a turnaround can 25X1 be achieved. 25X1 ? A. A worst-case scenario would involve the departure of most Rhodesian whites accompanied by large- scale civil war. 25X1 1. This would create chaotic economic conditions similar to those of post-independent Angola and Mozambique. 25X1 2. Whichever guerrilla faction emerged as the winner of the civil war probably would adopt disruptive economic socialization policies, particularly in farming areas once reserved for whites. B. From an economic point of view, the best path to black majority rule would be along the lines of the Kenya model in which enough whites remain to assure a stable economic environment. -2- Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 , 25X1 ? ? .1 Approved or Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81BOOUR002000050002-6 1. A smooth transition accompanied by quick improvement in the country's security situation and international standing would probably reverse the economy'o decline; even then they will need amounts of financial assistance. -3- Approved For Release 2004/07f08':;CIA-RDP811300401R002000050002-6 Approved FlbrRelease 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP816004c1R002000050002-6 Rho&?.sia: Enforcement cf:Lanctions I. Weak international demand for Rhodesian raw materials, in part because of economic sanctions, has contributed to Rhodesia's economic decline 25X1 since 1974. A. In the late 1960s and early 1970s, the impact of economic sanctions was mitigated by strong world demand and by Africa and Portugal of Rhodesian goods. B. As world demand the 1973/74 oil probably caused proportionately. the willingness of South to facilitate the flow 25X1 slumped in the aftermath of price hikes, the sanctions Rhodesia to suffer dis- 25X1 1. Rhodesian mining output dropped 8 percent during 1974-78 as many firms in developed countries turned to alternative suppliers of chromium, nickel, copper, tin, and 25X1 asbestos. 2. Chromium exports also were hard hit by: a. the loss of the lucrative US market, which accounted for 25 percent of chrome sales prior to the March 1977 repeal of the Byrd Amendment, and FR M 79-10213 - 4 - Approved For Release2004747101r:, r.13F-RDP81B00401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1 b. a new metallurgical process (argon- oxygen decarburiEation, or 7=) which reduced the cost competitiveness of high-grade Rhodesian ores in the production of stainless steel. Sanctions enforcement is far from airtight: 25X1 willing to pay profitable fees to South African, Swiss, and other middlemen, Rhodesia apparently still 25X1 has little trouble in selling and shipping exports. A. South African businesses, which have substantial investment in Rhodesia, undoubtedly provide the principal conduits for Rhodesian trade. B. All overseas Rhodesian trade is transported over road or rail connections with South Africa. 25X1 III. The current strengthening trend in international markets should result in increased demand for some of Rhodesia's minerals. 25X1 - 5- , Approved For Release 20 4107/Ct8: CIA-RDP811300401R002000050002-6 25X1 1 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 :.CIA-RDP81130049R002000050002-6 A. US stainless steel producers reportedly have exceo.flod their AOD capacity and are-turning to older electric furnaces that require high- grade ferrochrome produced from ores that are available principally from Rhodesia and USSR. B. Copper prices are up about 60 percent over last year's average price to about $1 per 25X1 pound. C. Record gold prices ($240-$250 a troy ounce) have pushed earnings from gold exports to well over $100 million a year. 25X1 IV. Despite the sanctions, Rhodesia continues to get adequate petroleum supplies. A. Rhodesia meets its requirements either by purchasing products from South African re- fineries or by importing from third countries through South African ports. B. The increases in international oil prices since the Iranian political crisis have spurred Salisbury to raise retail gasoline prices by almost 30 percent to over $1.30 a US gallon; Rhodesia already has gasoline rationing. -6- Approved For Release 2?04/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For ReleaseUZZCIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Zambia: Food Situation and Dependence on Rhodesian Rail Outlet I. Zambia has been hard hit by the drought in 25X1 25X1 25X1 ? 25X1 Southern Africa. A. The government -- perhaps optimistically -- is predicting that this year's maize harvest will equal only one-half of annual domestic consumption. B. To cover the shortfall of this dietary stable, Zambia expects to import 350,000-400,000 metric tons. 1. This will place added financial strains on Zambia, which is already short of foreign exchange. 2. Possible suppliers of maize include: a. South Africa. Facing a poor harvest itself, South Africa has turned down a Zambian bid for white maize, which is preferred for human consumption, but has offered yellow maize. b. Rhodesia. Although haiwests will be down this year, Salisbury probably would not refuse a Zambian request. For political reasons Zambia would ask Rhodesian assistance only as a last resort. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 :TFIIA-RDF5e11t(164IY1:t0bHdOb50002-6 SECRMI! Approved For Release 2011i= alauRDP81600401R002000050002-6 c. Kenya. Harvests are aood and Nairobi may be able to suplolv some of Zambia's needs. d. The EEC, Mexico, and the-US. Some Western diplomats have expressed the opinion that Zambia will wait until the food situation reaches "disaster proportions" and appeal to Western governments for emergency relief. Of landlocked Zambies four export/import routes, the Rhodesian rail outlet to, efficiently run South African ports is the most expeditious. A. The Tazara plagued by 25X1 backlogs, B. The "Great ? (ranzam) railroad to Tanzania is 25X1 25X1 25X1 inefficiency, derailments, strikes, and East Road," a rail and road route to Mozambique, is limited by congested ports and slow turnaround times. C. The Benguela railroad to Angola has been closed since 1975. III. Closure of the Rhodesian route would cause a sharp drop in Zambian copper exports and would reduce its ability to import food. A. The Rhodesian route is targetted. to handle 1,000 tons of copper exports per day. Approved For Release 2004/07/08: CIA-RDP81 B00401R002000050002-6 C try z C 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 r uccp?Ej- Approved For Release 20040 . - DP81600401R002000050002-6 B. Now used principally to handle imports of fertilizer and coal the route would be needed to handle grain imports from out- 25X1 side Africa. IV. Because.of its importance, Zambia is concerned that: A. Rhodesia may close the route to bring economic pressure on Lusaka. B. Rhodesian guerrillas (mainly ZAPU) may interdict the line. Approved For Release 2004/07/08. iCIA-RDP81B00401R002000050002-6 I 'SFr!? FT 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approlgsr elease 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 23 March 1979 ESTIMATED STRENGTH OF THE RHODESIAN DURING THE APRIL - Army SECURITY ELECTION 6,000 12,000 FORCES Regulars Active Duty Reservists Total Army 18,000 Air Force 1,500 Police and Paramilitary i' Regular Police 8,000 Reserve Police 35,000 Guard Force 6,000 Paramilitary Guard Units 5,000 Dad's Army (50-59 year olds mobilized for security duty during the election) 1,000 Total Police and Paramilitary 55,000 Auxilaries Loyal to Sithole 2,000 Loyal to Muzorewa 8,000 Total Auxilaries 10,000 TOTAL FORCES 84,500 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP811300401R002000050002Tp5xi / or Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81B00401R0 25X1 Approved 02000050002-6 30 March 1979 RHODESIAN EQUIPMENT INVENTORY (as of 30 March 1979) Ground Forces Tanks none Armored vehicles (Ratels, Elands, Ferret) 60 Artillery (25 pounders, 5.5 inch guns) 24 Anti-aircraft artillery none Surface-to-air missiles none Air Forces Bombers (Canberra) Fighters Hunter Vampire Counter-insurgency 4-5 10 11 0-2 14 SF-260 12 Trainers (SF-260) 12-22 Transports DC-3 Islander Helicopters 12 6 AB-205 8-11 Alouette II/III 42 25x1ppr0ved For Rele SP 2n0410710R ? ('.IA-RnpRi Rnr4oi R002000050002-6 Approved For Rele ZA.PU ase 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R 02000Mq2-6 30 March 1979 GUERRILLA EQUIPMENT INVENTORIES - SA-7 surface-to-air missile - 60mm mortars - 82mm mortars - 122mm manportable, single-tube rockets - 8-10 82mm recoilless rifles - RPG-2/7 anti-tank weapons - 14.5mm anti-aircraft machine guns - a variety of Soviet small arms - may have some light field artillery pieces ZANU - may have a few SA-7 surface-to-air missiles - 60mm mortars - 82mm mortars - 120mm mortars (a few) - 122mm manportable, single-tube rockets - B-10 82mm recoilless rifles - PRG-2/7 anti-tank weapons - 14.5mm anti-aircraft machine guns .- a variety of Communist-bloc small arms Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81B00401R002000050002-5xi Approva8V$r Re lease 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 23 March 1979 ESTIMATED STRENGTH OF THE ZIMBABWE AFRICAN PEOPLE'S UNION AS OF MID-MARCH In Rhodesia 2,500 2,800 200 7,000 2,000 12,500 Other Trained Hq, Staff, Training Support Camps In Botswana Holding Camps Total Under Training 7,500 In Zambia Mulungushi - 5,500 From Angola- 2,000 In Ethiopia 500-1,000 In Angola 2,000 Elsewhere 1,000 Total 11,000 Available for Training In Zambia 8,000 In Botswana 9,000 Total 17,000 TOTAL 42,500 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP811300401R0025W0002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1 23 March 1979 ESTIMATED STRENGTH OF THE ZIMBABWE AFRICAN NATIONAL UNION AS OF MID-MARCH. In Rhodesia Other Trained Personnel Under Training 8,000 7,000 Tanzania 3,000 Libya 500 Ethiopia & elsewhere 2,500 Total Available for Training 6,000 10,000 TOTAL 31,000 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP811300401R00205M002-6 Approved For Release 2004/0 25X1 MEMORANDUM 7/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 2 April 1979 SUBJECT: South African Arms Potentially Available for Rhodesia I. South Africa has the strongest military force in sub- Saharan Africa and a wide variety of modern weapons and military equipment. A. We estimate the the following: army equipment inventory includes 280 tanks 2,000 other armored combat vehicles 160 Centurions 1,200 Eland armored cars 100 Shermans 230 Ferret scout cars 20 comets 280 Saracen APCs 100 Ratels armored vehicles 200 light personnel carriers 200 artillery pieces 48 Sexton 25 pounders 132 25-pounder howitzers 25 3.5 inch guns unk unk unk antitank weapons 3.5 inch rocket launchers Entac missiles SS-11 missiles B. We estimate the following: 5 light bombers Canberras This Strategic addressed 25X1A mortars unk 81 mm mortars 423 3-inch mortars unk 60 mm mortars 100 air defense artillery 16 3.7 inch ADA 24 40 mm Bofors 60 35 mm Oerlikons Air Force inventory includes the 32 all-weather fighters 16 Mirage III memorandum was prepared in the Office of Research. Queries and comments mry be to 25X1 Approved For Release 2C 04/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 51 fighter-bombers 30 Mirage Fl 16 Mirage III 5 Buccanner 76 transports 43 C-47s 9 Transalls 7 C-130s 17 others 385 trainers 229 Impalas 126 T-6s 30 others 25 reconnaissance 7 Mirage III 18 Piaggio 53 transport helicopters 39 Pumas 14 Super Frelon 94 utility helicopters 90 Alouette Ills 4 Alouette IIs Approved For Release 2004/gFRFIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 RD/FRD Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Next 2 Page(s) In Document Exempt Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 NIO WORKING PAPER FOR PRC 11 April 1979 SOUTH AFRICA-US Relations 1 The short puff of South African good will toward the US that followed Secretary Vance's visit to Pretoria last fall appears to have vanished and the South African government is reverting to the anti-American posturing that marked the 1977 parliamentary election campaign. --Prime Minister Botha believes that South Africa was deceived in the development of the UN Secretary General's report on Namibia and the government is currently making public attacks on US UN Ambassador McHenry. The South Africans probably genuinely feel they have been diddled, but they also may find that adopting this attitude is a convenient excuse for further stalling on the Namibian negotiations. --The anti-US pronouncements may also be part of internal political maneuvering by Prime Minister Botha's government to heal the party rifts caused by the revelations of the Information Department scandal. The onus would be ,off the government to some extent if the underhanded dealings of South Africa in the US could be justified as necessary evils to combat a hostile United States. --Some of the rekindled animosity may also stem from South Africa's successful management of its current oil crisis. The long dreaded spector of sanctions may seem less frightening now that the country is actually coping with the effects of a massive oil cutoff. Approved For Release 2004/07/0B :ECclia-RDP811300401R002000050002-6 st I SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 2. The South African government is reviving the Southern African regional cooperation policies of both the Verwoerd and Vorster eras. The Prime Minister talks of non-alignment and a "wall of steel" (presumably South African military might) around a group of states that is to include Rhodesia and Namibia. In readjusting its foreign policy, South Africa is again making clear to the outside world that it is pivotal to progress in the area. 3. While publicly rejecting the West, South Africans still hanker for Western acceptance and they have not given up hope of being taken back into the fold. In this context they view the prospect of the election of a conservative government in the UK as working to their advantage. They continue to feel that, despite what they perceive as negative results in much of their dealings with the US government, South Africa has a wide sympathetic audience in the United States whose opinions are not reflected in current US policy. -2- Approved For Release 2004/07/08.? C1A-RDP811300401R002000050002-6 SLCKL I SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 NIO WORKING PAPER FOR PRC 11 April 1979 SOUTH AFRICA: Policy Toward Rhodesia 1. South Africa's basic aim in Rhodesia is to encourage the establishment of a stable, peaceful majority-ruled government that will gain international acceptance and will cooperate--rather than merely coexist--with South Africa, partidularly with respect to Pretoria's overall design for an eventual Southern African regional economic and military alliance. --South Africa will at least continue, and probably increase, its economic and military support to Rhodesia through the period of the elections and the establishment of the Government of National Unity in the hope that the GNU will take hold and gain some form of international acceptance that will end sanctions, brighten the economic outlook, and bolster white morale enough to keep the white infrastructure intact. 2. Pretoria has successfully played a waiting game in its long dealings with Rhodesian independence machinations. Having come this far, the South Africans may not necessarily see the GNU as the final independence government in Rhodesia. --An "all parties settlement" that would include the Patriotic Front and thus stop the guerrilla warfare would be more in South Africa's best interests. The risk of increased Soviet and Cuban intervention would also be decreased. Approved For Release 2004/07/0eW-RDP81B00401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 --South Africa could view the coming election and the establishment of the GNU as steps in an ongoing process to secure a permanently workable government in Rhodesia, particularly if the process continued to ensure white tenure. 3.. Pretoria does not appear to have formulated any plans toward Rhodesia in the event of a GNU collapse, beyond those to evacuate whites if law and order breaks down. --For now South Africa feels that the GNU is the best bet in working toward stability in Rhodesia, and it would see no advantage in weakening the new government's chances of survival. --Although South Africa will not give immediate diplomatic recognition to the GNU, it will not withdraw the South African support that will be needed to keep the new Rhodesian government afloat. -2- Approved For Release 2004/07/14ERik-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Next 2 Page(s) In Document Exempt Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For lease 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401 25X1 R002000050002-6 DCI PRC Briefing 9 April 1979 I. Is a Muzorewa-Mugabe Alliance in the Cards? A. Probably not, at least over the short term. --Bishop Muzorewa would prefer to see ZANU's leaders return to Rhodesia and participate in the political process under the terms of the new constitution. Muzorewa's recent feelers to ZANU probably have been motivated less by a desire to seek an alliance than to draw Mugabe's support among the Shonas to himself. --The Bishop is playing the divide-and-conquer tactics that have characterized Rhodesian politics since the days of Cecil Rhodes and that have been practised so ably by Ian Smith. These tactics are based on the premise that you destroy your opponent by undercutting his support rather than by directly confronting him. B. From Mugabe's standpoint, the April election will not change anything--except the political positions of the players with whom a settlement will ultimately have to be reached. --Mugabe will not be interested in participating in the post-election political process because he rejects the legitimacy of the con- stitution on which it will be based. --So long as time seems to be working on the side of his Mugabe will see no need to make an accommodation with the new government. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 --Mugabe will probably stick to this position unless the new government not only takes hold but also is able to attract large numbers of ZANU guerrillas to its side. -2- Approved For Release 2004$6M3T: CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 A3A)63ed For Re ease 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81B0C 401R002000050002-6 DCI PRC Briefing 9 April 1979 I. How Would Nyerere Respond to a Muzorewa-Mugabe Deal? A. Although Nyerere is currently well-disposed toward the U.S. Government because of its role as intermediary with Kenya during the Uganda conflict, he is not likely to agree to an American proposal encouraging a Muzorewa-Mugabe alliance. --In his eyes that would legitimize a black-led government in Salisbury which is only an extension of the sresent white-dominated regime. --Although Nyerere's personal sympathies probably lie with Mugabe, he remains committed to the Patriotic Front in that he believes both ZANU and ZAPU must be accommodated in any settlement if civil war in Rhodesia is to be avoided. B. Nyerere apparently has concluded that white dominance in Rhodesia willAive w#1,ATIL112111IELIspand to work for a deal between Muzorewa and Mugabe would weaken Mugabe's position--Nyerere would have to accept such an arrangement if it were presented to him by Mugabe as an accomplished fact. Approved For Release 2004/07/DBC:RCTA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 DCI PRC Briefing 9 April 1979 I. How Would Nyerere Respond to a Call for UN-Supervised Elections in Rhodesia? A. Nyerere initially would be cool to such a proposal and would wonder why the US was moving away from the Anglo-American Plan and toward what he would perceive as an overly-complicated approach to a settlement. --He would not agree to UN-supervised elections on the basis of the present constitution. --He would not take the lead in encouraging the Patriotic Front and the other frontline presidents to accept negotiations or UN-supervised elections, partly because he believes the US and UK would be unable to convince the Salisbury government to participate and partly because of his m6re immediate concern with Uganda. --He probably would go along with UN-supervised elections--the Namibian model--if negotiations between the Patriotic Front and the government in Salisbury resulted in new ground rules for an election. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07 /08 : CIA-RDP8 25X1 1 B00401R002000050002-6 DCI PRC BRIEFING 9 April 1979 I. Would Bishop Abel Muzorewa be receptive to a US call for UN-sponsored elections and negotiations with the Patrotic Front? A. Muzorewa, at least over short term, would not be receptive to such a call. --If, as now seems likely, Muzorewa emerges from the election as the head of the new government, his primary concerns will be consolidating his leadership, winning international acceptance of the election, and improving his government's military position. He is considering offering an amnesty to attract guerrillas to return to Rhodesia. --Although he might invite some prominent guerrilla leaders to participate in the new government, we doubt he would seriously consider entering into negotiations involving any redistribution of power in Salisbury. B. Muzorewa told US Ambassador Low late last month that after the April election there would be no point in holding further elections. --Although he said he would not categorically reject the idea of UN-sponsored elections, he is unlikely to consider this option unless forced to by military pressures. Approved For Release 2004/07/aCkEIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 )401R002000050002-6 25X4pproved F or Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81B0 DCI PRC Briefing 9 April 1979 I. Nkomo's Prospects Over the Longer Term A. Nkomo's reputation has slipped badly. --Once he was regarded by the international and African communities and by Rhodesian whites as the father of Rhodesian nationalism. As such, his political position transcended his minority Ndebele ethnic base, and he was the logical nationalist with whom to reach a settlement. --In recent months, Joshua Nkomo's stature has diminished as ZANU leader Robert Mugabe's has increased. --Revelation last fall of his secret talks with Prime Minister Smith seriously damaged Nkomo's credibility as a nationalist leader who would resist a settlement on Smith's terms. --The subsequent shooting down of two Rhodesian civilian airliners by ZAPU guerrillas has made an accommodation between Nkomo and the Salisbury regime much more difficult. --Nkomo faces the prospect of a further deterioration in his position because the Ndebeles, who make up only 18 percent of the country's black population, will have to find other leaders to represent them in the new government Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004MB81 CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 if they are to protect their interests. B. Nevertheless, ZAPU continues to expand in terms of numbers and the military support Nkomo is receiving from the Soviet Union and Cuba strelhens his demands to be included in any political settlement. --Thus a new international initiative would significantly help to revive his political fortunes. --Any future role for him in Rhodesia, however, is likely to be as an Ndebele politician rather than as a national leader who stands above ethnic ties. -2- Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET l2Ek pproved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RD81B00401R002000050002-6 DCI PRC Briefing 9 April 1979 I. What progress has the transitional government made in areas of geniune concern to blacks? A. Our information on this subject is rather spotty, but thus far change appears to be slow. The repeal of laws allowing racial discrimination (e.g., in public accommodations, schools, hospitals, and land ownership) has not been followed up with any meaningful social changes. Although valuable white farm land can no longer be reserved exclusively for whites, the government has yet to provide the means--by arranging substantial credit--for blacks to buy land. Muzorewa has expressed an interest in what are alleged to be as many as 10 million acres of underutilitzed or vacant land for re-distribution among the blacks, but we do not know much about the quality of this land or whether Muzorewa's thoughts on the subject have advanced very far. Some blacks have moved into residential areas previously reserved for whites, but most blacks lack the means to buy or rent in those areas. A number of blacks are now enrolled in private schools, but the new multiracial educational system is not scheduled to go into effect until May. For many years, however, Rhodesia has had a relatively good record in providing educational opportunities for talented blacks. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 CONFIDENTIAL QUEIDEN_TI Approved For Release 200kutiod : u1AAL-KDP81600401R002000050002-6 In the military, the pace of recruitment of blacks for officer training is accelerating, but this is essentially a continuation of the policy adopted by the Smith government prior to the internal settlement. B. In sum, the government has thus far moved cautiously and conservatively in implementing changes. -2- Approved For Release 2004/eci4fgbECNIfkraDP81B00401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Relee R002000050002-6 25X1 5X1 se 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401 DCI PRC Briefing 9 April 1979 Namibia: Status and Prospects (Revised and Updated) 1. South African Prime Minister Botha and his foreign minister met with Namibian political leaders on 2 April to discuss results of the New York proximity talks on Namibia in mid-March. (See attachment for major Namibian political groups.) --Botha asked the Namibians to decide within a week whether to accept Western proposals which partially meet South Africa's objections to the truce arrangements which the UN Secretary General announced in late February. --The tenor of Botha's meetings with the Namibians suggests that he is preparing for further hard bargaining with the Western sponsors of a Namibia settlement. --This signals a significant shift from Foreign Minister Roelof Botha's stance at the New York proximity talks, which implied that South Africa would soon proceed toward an internal settlement unless the SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 UN truce plan were substantially revised to: -Provide for UN monitoring of SWAPO forces in Angola and Zambia. -Exclude any possibility that guerrillas inside Namibia after a cease-fire could maintain armed bases under UN monitoring. 3. Consultations among the Namibian political parties are continuing, but the consensus urged by Prime Minister Botha does not appear likely. --There is broad agreement that a truce should provide for effective monitoring of SWAPO guerrilla forces in neighboring countries, and should not allow SWAPO to maintain bases inside Namibia. --The basic disagreement is between the members of the Constituent Assembly, who want to proceed toward independence without a UN-conducted election, and the other leaders, who hope that further negotiations will yield adequate truce arrangements. 4. Prime Minister Botha very likely could persuade most of the Namibian political leaders to back one more round of negotiations, focused primarily on measures for disarming any SWAPO forces that emerge inside Namibia after a cease-fire. --As long as negotiations show progress, the Constituent Assembly probably can be held to merely planning for eventual independence. --If negotiations prove fruitless, the other leaders are likely to feel compelled to participate in an "internal settlement." -2- Approved For Release 2004/02RIIREUIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 5. SWAPO military commanders probably will continue current efforts to step up guerrilla infiltrations and small-scale terrorism until South Africa unreservedly accepts a UN truce plan and the frontline governments press SWAPO to do likewise.* --Although SWAPO Vice-President Muyongo pledged at the proximity talks to cease infiltrations as soon as a cease-fire agreement is concluded, he parried calls for pre-truce restraint. --SWAPO President Nujoma and other long-exiled leaders who do not want to face an election probably will try to disrupt Prime Minister Botha's temporizing strategy as long as possible. --Neto and Kaunda may withhold additional support for SWAPO as long as truce negotiations appear promising, but they are unlikely to actively restrain SWAPO's cross-border operations until a cease-fire agreement is concluded. --Under these conditions, it is unlikely that SWAPO can much extend the current pattern of guerrilla activity (mostly in Ovamboland, near the Angolan border), but some small guerrilla bands may infiltrate white areas and carry out small but politically pro- vocative attacks. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81B00401R002000050002-6 -3- SECRET 25 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 --If SWAPO extends its recent strategy of sending some guerrillas-- reportedly newer recruits--farther south with orders to remain inactive until a cease-fire, many could then appear in areas where SWAPO has never operated effectively and thereby establish claims to maintain bases under UN monitoring. 6. The series of South African "lightning strikes" in early March against SWAPO forward bases (mostly in Angola) was primarily intended to preempt a surge of guerrilla infiltrations before an anticipated truce took affect. 25X1 --No significant South African strikes into Angola or Zambia are known to have occurred since shortly before the New York proximity talks and the simultaneous start of UN Security Council sessions on the Angolan protest of recent South African strikes. --Strikes apparently have been suspended because the immediate military objective was achieved and because Prime Minister Botha decided to avoid further provocations while the South Africans were seeking more favorable truce terms. --Botha may intend to restrain the military hawks who want to strike deeper into Angola as long as he believes that restraint will influence the Western Five--especially the US--toward meeting South Africa's demands on truce terms. -4- SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 --At the same time, Botha probably will take whatever military measures he considers necessary to prevent any significant increase in guerrilla activity inside Namibia. -He probably believes--with good reason--that even a few assassina- tions of prominent Namibians or other impressive guerrilla "exploits" would undercut South African influence in Namibia and exacerbate his government's current domestic embarrassments. -5- Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004837/106CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 MAJOR NAMIBIAN POLITICAL GROUPS COMPOSITION A South Africa-backed coalition of 11 ethnic-based parties: one white, two mulatto and eight in black tribal groups; nonwhite participants are mostly traditional tribal chiefs. NAME Democratic Turnhalle Alliance (DTA) South-West Africa People's Organization (SWAPO) Namibian National Front (NNF) SWAPO-Democrats (SWAPO-D) Action Front for the Preservation of the Turnhalle Principles (AKTUR) The nationalist organization rec- ognized by the UN General Assembly as sole legimate representative of the Namibian people. Dominated by the Ovambos, who constitute about half of the Namibian population. External wing operates out of Zambia and Angola. Internal wing has engaged openly in nonviolent political action. Loose alliance of one liberal white and a number of nonwhite political parties. The Hereros, Namibia's third-largest black ethnic group, predominate, but NNF also has some broad ethnic support. Formed in mid-1978 by former SWAPO members who are disaffected with SWAPO head Sam Nujomas' leadership. Conservative, predominantly Afrikaner party. Formerly associated with the ruling National Party of South Africa. Note. The Namibian Constituent Assembly, elected last December, has 50 1 each from 3 miniscule parties (2 exclusively white). CURRENT STATUS Winning 82 percent of ballots last December has made DTA fairly confident that it could defeat SWAPO in UN-run election, provided discreet but substantial support from South Africa continues. High voter turnout in December (80 percent of registered voters) despite SWAPO's active boycott has eroded confidence that it would win UN-run election. Internal wing is more willing to face polls than external leaders. Quietly boycotted December election. In an open election, NNF might win enough seats to play pivotal role between DTA and SWAPO. Loosely affiliated with NNF. Quietly boycotted December election. Although still embryonic, in an open election SWAPO-D might attract many Ovambos who have followed the original SWAPO internal wing. Apparently is leading party among white residents, who constitute only 12 percent of Namibia's population. Retains some influence in National Party of South Africa. members: 41 from DIA, 6 from AKTUR, SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1 25X1 Approved For DCI PRC Briefing Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81B0 0401R002000050002-6 9 April 1979 Angola-Cuba: Some Strains but No New Developments 1. Despite periodic problems between the two countries--signs that the Angolans are becoming more dissatisfied with the Cubans and indications that Havana views its military role in Angola as increasingly burdensome-- Cuba has a large stake in supporting the Angolan Government, and Angola remains basically dependent on Cuban (and Soviet) military and technical support. 2. Both Luanda and Havana probably would like to see a reduction of Cuban troop strength in Angola--if conditions were to allow it. --Neto probably would prefer that the Cubans maintain their present military strength in Angola--approximatley 20,000 men--and, instead, reduce the number of civilian technicians there. The performance of the Cuban civilians has not been satisfactory. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 3. Angola will continue to depend on Cuban troops for both external and internal security--and for training the Angolan military. The Angolan Government believes that the recent attacks against guerrilla bases by Rhodesian and South African forces demonstrate the continued need for a substantial Cuban military presence. --Indeed, Angolan officials can claim with some justification that "the Cuban presence is necessary to preserve Angolan independence." --If the Namibian problem could be resolved, Neto might be willing to see some of the Cuban troops withdrawn. 25X1 25X1 4. 5. if an adequate air defense system is to be established in Angola, the number of Cuban military personnel may even increase slightly. Approved For Release 2004/o/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 affirm his commitment to socialism. and Neto continues to 6. Luanda would like to reduce its dependence on Cuba (and the USSR) and within the last eight months has made an effort to expand its political and economic ties with the West. --The Angolans are dissatisfied with the quality of Cuban economic and technical assistance. --Neto would like to obtain economic and technical assistance from the West, including the US. Neto also would like to obtain the diplomatic and political prestige of having ties with the US. 7. The Neto government is disappointed that no tangible results came out of the visits to Luanda last year of senior US officials. The Angolans are determined not to give in on the US condition linking diplomatic recognition to a reduction of the Cuban military presence in Angola. --Inasmuch as the Angolans may believe that the US could influence South Africa to stop the raids and also put pressure on those governments that Luanda believes are aiding UNITA, the Neto government's suspicions of the US may have increased since last fall. 8. If Neto sees his country becoming increasingly beleaguered militarily from within and without--and Angola's economic and social problems also continue--the President may step up his verbal attacks against "imperialist and colonialist" countries that he charges are seeking to undermine Angola. Approved For Release 2004/07?18 : CIA-RDP811300401R002000050002-6 SFCRFT SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 --In the face of continuing adversity, Neto might also become less cooperative on other southern African issues that involve Namibia, Rhodesia and the Frontline countries. 9. Despite minor shifts and periodic problems between Angola and its Cuban benefactor, there is no clear evidence to suggest that a new trend has developed that would significantly affect the US. -4- Approved For Release 200 O3 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2 004/07/08 : CIA-RDP816004 25X1 01R002000050002-6 .? Angola: Western Economic and Technical Assistance Angola is seeking to expand trade and technical and economic assistance ties with the West. Since independence Angola has dramatically increased its trade with Communist countries and has received substantial economic assistance from them. Nevertheless, most of Angola's foreign markets remain in the West and western manpower, capital and technology are needed if the country hopes to stem its economic slide. In an attempt to expand its economic and political contacts with the non-Communist world, Angola since last summer has: ? Hosted EC Commissioner for Development Claude Cheyson. 25X1 o Obtained observer status at talks to renegotiate the Lome Convention -- a trade and aid agreement linking the EC to over 50 developing countries. O Discussed economic and technical assistance with Belgium, France, Holland, Italy, Japan, 25X1 Norway, Portugal,, Spain, West Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States. Accelerated negotiations with foreign oil companies, mainly American, for offshore oil exploration and development, 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600 25X1 401R002000050002-6 Despite increased Angolan interest, western and technical assistance to Angola should remain small for the forseeable future. economic 25X1 o Foreign companies and expatriates are un- likely to return to Angolan until the economic and security situation shows signs of improving. Poor living conditions and possibly screening of political backgrounds by Angolan .and Portuguese Communist Party officials limit the number of Angolan expatriates that are likely to return from Portugal. o Western countries remain suspicious of Communist advisers who occupy key positions in the economic ministeries. Q Even if political obstacles are overcome the United States cannot participate in any international aid consortium until arrearages on US Export-Import Bank loans are settled. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 ease 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP8160040 25X1 Approved For Rel MEMORANDUM CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY NATIONAL FOREIGN ASSESSMENT CENTER 2 April 1979 25X1 1R002000050002-6 RHODESIA: LOOKING BEYOND THE APRIL ELECTION [1] 25X1 Key Judgments The election later this month of a black-Zed government of national unity in Rhodesia will bring substantial pressure on the US and the UK to recognize the new government and to lift economic sanctions. --The Rhodesians will make an all-out effort to ensure adequate security and a large turnout for the election. --Although the Zimbabwe African National Union and the Zimbabwe African People's Union will try to disrupt the election, neither guerrilla group will be able to prevent it from taking place. Bishop Aluzorewa is the most likely candidate to emerge as the head of the new government. --He will seek to consolidate his position by strengthening his relationship with the whites, establishing greater control over the countryside, and inducing defections from ZANU and ZAPU. --He may try to split the guerrillas further by offering to strike a separate deal with ZANU or ZAPU. --We doubt, however, that the white leaders will show enough flexibility to allow Muzorewa to propose a deal acceptable to either guerrilla 25X1 leader. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 The election of a new government, coupled with a continuation of the fighting, will create some hard choices for those states most closely involved with the Rhodesian problem. --The frontline states will continue to support the guerrillas, but an intensification of the fighting could force some presidents into an open-ended commitment to an increased Soviet and Cuban presence in their countries. --The frontline states might also have to consider the possiblity of supporting one guerrilla gro against the other in the event of a civil war. If the Soviets and the Cubans continue to favor ZAPU over ZANV, they risk alienating Tanzania and Mozambique, who would like to see more support given to ZANU. --If they agree to support both groups, however, they could become involved in a civil war. --If Nkomo makes a separate deal with the Salisbury government, they might find themselves to throw their support behind ZANU. The US and the UK must decide whether to recognize the newly-elected government and lift economic sanctions. --A positive decision would strengthen the position of the new government, but provoke a hostile reaction from the black Africans. --A negative decision would undermine the viability of the new regime, but not deter the Africans from supporting further efforts to reach a negotiated settlement. Approved For Release 2004/07/a: CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET 25X1 25X1 25X1 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 PPosr,e3Ts for a successful all-parties conference or agreemen7 ~n the part of the internal government to UN-sponsoref". -.Elections are exceedingly dim. --S-ern prospects are for a continuation of staZemate, particularly now that South Afe.: ;las promised to provide substantial mili=?i and political support to the new go7,==ent. --The f:-:-nting certainly will continue, providing exnar.g opportunities for the Soviets and the =.:.27,ans.. 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/0RaEICIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X6 25X1 25X1 .LLKI Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 The Rhodesian government is making an all-out effort to ensure adequate security and a large turnout for the election. Government pressure and intimidation by the black parties and their auxiliary forces should result in a fairly high turnout. The government estimates a total black turnout of about 60 percent, with the highest percentage being urban blacks and blacks living in white farming areas. Over 70 percent of the eligible white voters turned out for the constitutional referendum last January and at least that many should vote in the election. All military and police leaves have been cancelled during the election period and all civilian reservists have been called up to provide security and to police the polling stations during the election. We estimate that a manpower pool totaling some 75,000 Rhodesians will be mobilized. These forces will be assisted by about 10,000 ex-guerrillas and local recruits who are loyal to internal black leaders Bishop Muzorewa and Reverend Sithole. As the election approaches, Rhodesian security forces will intensify their raids on guerrilla camps and staging areas in Zambia and Mozambique, and possibly in Angola, Tanzania, and Botswana. (See map on page 2.) By forcing the guerrillas to relocate their command posts further from 400 the border and to disperse their camps, guerrilla communication links and supply lines will be lenothened.resulting in an erosion of guerrilla 25X1 capabilities and morale. Although ZANU and ZAPU are committed to disrupting the election, it is unlikely either can prevent it from taking place. ZANU and ZAPU now have at least 10,000 guerrillas inside Rhodesia and several thousand more guerrillas are to be infiltrated before the election. Both groups plan to intimidate voters, attack electoral officials and polling stations, and possibly stage incidents near the polling stations to,diOrap,t the security forces. Nevertheless, we believe the Rhodesian snattY forces will be able to maintain sufficient control to proceed with the polling in most if not all regions of the country. 25)(1 ZAPU is planning major attacks into Rhodesia along its northern border with Zambia, but we doubt it possesses the necessary command and control capabilities to launch a major coordinated offensive. The number of guerrilla attacks on "soft" targets of psychological and economic importance to the whites, however, is certain to increase. 25X1 The Election Process White Rhodesians reportedly will go to the polls on 10 April to elect 20 white members to the House of Assemby. Four of these seats are contested by independents, but Ian Smith's Rhodesian Front party should Approved For Release 2004/07AGREMA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Principal Military Forces Involved in Rhodesian Conflict* Gabon Congo Brazzaville *Kinshasa Cabinda\ (Angola) 4Luanda Angola 1 ZAPU 2,000 CUBANS 19,000-21,000 SOVIETS, 1,000 Approximately 20 Soviets and 200 Cubans at/vise and train ZAPII personnel.' Zaire /ZAPU 20,000 /CUBANS 65-75 SOVIETS 5-15 Rwanda * igali Burundi Bujuinbura Zambia *Lusaka Namibia *Windhoek Walvis Bay / (S. Al.).1 Atlantic Ocean Botswana ZAPU 200 Gaborone -\ - South Africa Salisbury* Rhodesia *Pretoria *Nairobi Kenya 0 8 t\1 \ *Bar eel; Salaam Tanzania ZANU 3,000 SOVIETS 120 No Soviets are involved with ZANY. 11/191awi Lilongwe ZANU 7,000 CUBANS 850 SOVIETS 250 Most of the Soviet and Cuban advisers are engaged in supporting government defense forces. Mozambique e* *Maputo Swazilatr-, Maseru Lesotho *Totals for ZANY and ZAP!] include trained guerrillas and those under training. (There are 2,500 ZANY and 500-1,000 ZAP!] guerrillas in Ethiopia and 500 ZANY guerrillas in Libya under training.) ZANU 8,000 ZAPU 2,000 Rhodesian Army 18,000 Rhodesian Air Force 1,500 Police, Paramilitary & Reserves 55,0130 Auxiliaries loyal to Muzorewa 8,000 Auxiliaries loyal to Sithole 2,000 OVIGII5J 4-19 OA -2- Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 have little difficulty winning all 20 seats. The 72 black members of the House will be elected sometime after April 12 by both black and white Rhodesians. The election probably will be held over a five day period beginning 17 April. Security forces will be rotated from one region of the country to another--possibly by military district--to ensure maximum security around the polling stations. Both the white and black members will be elected directly from party lists established for each consitutency.* A party must win at least 10 percent of the vote in a given constituency to qualify for a seat. Parliamentary seats within each constituency will be allocated based on the Proportion of votes received by the parties in that constit- 25X1 uency. 25X1 The 72 black and 20 white members of the House then will caucus to elect 8 additional white members from a list of 16 candidates chosen by the white members of the present parliament. The Senate will consist of 10 blacks elected by the 72 black members of the lower house, 10 whites elected by the 28 white members, and 5 Ndebele and 5 Shona chiefs elected by their tribal counterparts in the Council of Chiefs. Both houses jointly elect a "constitutional" President who then appoints as Prime Minister the person "in his discretion, he considers to be best able to command the support of the majority of the members of the House of Assembly." The President also appoints the cabinet. actina qn the advice of the Prime Minister. (See chart on page 4.) I I 25X1 Although the new parliament will be numerically dominated by blacks, the whites will retain substantial--if not controlling--influence over the new government. Continued white domination of the military, police, judiciary, and civil service will be ensured by the constitution, which establishes criteria such as senior rank, longevity, and "efficl suitability" for appointment to top positions in these fields. J I 25X1 *Maps of the white and black electoral constituences and the five military operational areas appear at the end of this memorandum. -3- Approved For Release 2004/0gME-p1A-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 ? CIA-RDP811300401R002000050002-6 Formation of Government of Zimbabwe Rhodesia 5 Ndebele and 10 Blacks elected by 10 Whites elected Senate 5 Shona Chiefs elected by Council black members of House by whites of Chiefs ar. .- Council of Chiefs 604104 House of Assembly 72 Blacks elected by black and white voters 20 Whites elected by white voters Voting Constituencies for Black Assembly Seats 8 Whites elected by 92 other new mem bers of parliament from list of 16 white candidates selected by the 50 members of the present parliament. Voting Constituencies for White Assembly Seats Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 President Chosen by electoral college community of the members of House and Senate Prime Minister Appointed by President Cabinet Selected by Prime Minister 25X1 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Moreover, none of the important clauses in the new constitution can be amended or deleted without the approval of all 72 black and at least 6 white members of the House of Assembly. These so-called "entrenched" clauses, which guarantee the whites 28 seats in the House, will remain in effect for at least 10 years, after which a commission--consisting of three whites and two blacks--will be established and empowered to recommend changes. The constitution also states that posts in the cabinet will be allocated according to each party's strength in the House of Assembly, thus guaranteeing the whites at least four positions in the new cabinet. Most whites probably are not enthusiastic about a black-led government taking power in Rhodesia, but they appear willing to give the new government a chance. White emmigration dropped considerably this year after a dramatic rise last fall--peaking at 2,937 net departures in December. Net departures for January and February totaled only 1,073 and 592 25X1 whites, respectively. 1 25X1 Muzorewa on Top Bishop Abel Muzorewa should emerge in a strong position of leadership in the new government of national unity, with his party winning at least half the black seats in Parliament. (See chart on page 6.) His closest rival, Reverend Ndabaningi Sithole, has lost ground in recent months, and his party probably will win less than a third of the black seats. Chief Jerimiah Chirau, the other black leader in the internal government, lacks broad popular support but should pick up a few seats. Chief Ndiweni, who broke with Chirau last November to form his own Ndebele- based party, has not developed a strong political base but his party could win enough seats to gain a post in the cabinet. 1 25X1 Muzorewa hopes to establish more government control over the countryside by augmenting the size and expanding the role of the auxiliary forces. He also-hopes to attract more black supporters--including guerrilla defectors--by offering land and social services. The Bishop is expected to announce a major amnesty program soon after taking office that would encourage the guerrillas to return, but not require them to turn in their arms. The government is hoping that many of these guerrillas would agree to join the auxiliary forces. 25X1 Muzorewa has already entered into negotiations with the white leaders, focusing on cooperation between their parties and a possible modification of some clauses in the new constitution that work to the disadvantage of the blacks. The Bishop realizes that he will need white -5- Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 ? CIA-RDP811300401R002000050002-6 Probable Distribution of Seats in New Rhodesian Parliament Prime Minister Ian Smith (Rhodesian Front) Under pressure from some whites to leave politics, but so far has resisted. Most if not all, RF candidates are running unopposed. Bishop Abel Muzorewa (United African National Council) Most likely candidate for Prime Minister but would rather place himself above partisan politics and could opt for the Presidency. Reverend Ndabanings Sithole (Zimbabwe African National Union/Sithole) Broke with ZANU external organization in 1977. Popularity appears to be on the decline inside Rhodesia. 604105 Chief Kayisa Ndiweni (United National Federal Party) Broke with Chirau and the transitional govt. early this year to form a Ndebele-based party. Would be a stalking horse for Nkomo in the election. Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Chief Jerimiah Chirau (Zimbabwe United People's Organization) Genekally considered a "stooge" of the whites but recently has taken a more independent position calling for an all parties conference before the election and the disbanding of all auxiliary forces. SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 support for his government and wants to meet with the white leaders before the election to discuss possible ministerial appointments, to plan future government policies, and to map a joint strategy for obtaining international recognition for the new government. 1 1 25X1 Once in power, Muzorewa should be able to capitalize on several trends that have become apparent in recent months, including: --A deeping political and military rivalry between ZANU and ZAPU. With the virtual collapse of negotiations for a political settlement, each group has come increasingly to perceive the other as a rival in the struggle for control of a black-ruled Rhodesia. --Continuing disarray within the ZAPU leadership that has weakened Nkomo's position internationally and within his own organization, making it almost impossible for ZAPU to implement its more grandiose military plans. --The decline of Nkomo's appeal to whites in Rhodesia since the downing of two civilian airliners by his guerrillas. --Growing weariness in Zambia over the economic and political costs of the guerrilla struggle, which could eventually lead to a political backlash against President Kaunda. --Growing support for the internal settlement in the US Congress and the British Parliament. --South African promises to provide substantial political and military support--short of military intervention--to the new government of national unity. The South Africans have also said that they no longer would press Prime Minister Smith to withdraw from politics so long as his presence does not hinder the new government's chance of success. Prime Minister Botha has indicated, however, that South Africa will withhold diplomatic recognition from the new government; we expect Botha to wait until the new government has won some international acceptance and demonstrated a 25X1 capacity to govern. These factors account for a growing confidence among whites that the internal settlement eventually might succeed. A continuation of these trends could lead to a hardening of white attitudes and a growing -7- Approved For Release 2004/07/08S.Ea-TRDP81B00401R002000050002-6 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07k?C.18IrA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 reluctance to seek a political deal with the guerrillas. Given the probability that the level of fighting inside Rhodesia will escalate, however, most whites probably will continue to support efforts to negotiate a political settlement with the blacks. 25X1 25X1 Possible Realignments The formation of a black-led government will open the door to more jockeying among the various players in the Rhodesian situation. Muzorewa, in particular, probably will try to split the guerrillas further by seeking a separate alliance with ZANU or ZAPU. Joshua Nkomo might try to preempt such an alliance by seeking to make his own deal either with Muzorewa, or with the whites, thus bringing the Ndebeles and the Shonas into a single government. White Rhodesian politicians would favor such a coalition because they see Nkomo as a unifying force and regard Mugabe as too,radical. The pressure on Mugabe or Nkomo to consider joining forces with the internal government is likely to mount the more each leader perceives the other as trying to preempt him in reaching a settlement. Neither of these realignments, however, would tip the balance of power in Rhodesia sufficiently to bring an end to the fighting because each excludes a major participant who could attract enough foreign support to continue the guerrilla war. Nevertheless, either could change the complexion of the war from one of equilibrium and growing strength on the uerrilla ' side-to one of strength for the new government in Salisbury. 25X1 Hard Choices Ahead The election of a government of national unity, coupled with a con- tinuation of the fighting, will create some hard choices for the parties involved with the Rhodesian problem. The frontline states will continue to support the guerrillas, but an intensification of the fighting could force Presidents Kaunda of Zambia and Machel of Mozambique into an open-ended commitment to an increased Soviet and Cuban presence in -8- Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET 25X1 25X1 25X1 25X1 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Population Distribution in Zimbabwe Rhodesia POPULATION Persons per square kilometer 0 o 13 39 65 104 Persons per square mile Source: 1969 population census NDAU Selected Shona-speaking group TONGA Other tribal group 624875 3-79 SENA ?Wankie Gwelo Fort Victoria ? alawayo SItcpastal ft4 R G _\__/ VENDA Bette*, ETHNIC GROUP PERCENT OF BLACK POPULATION Shona 75 Karanga 25 Zezeru 21 Manyika 11 Ndau 6 Korekore 5 Other 5 Ndebele 14 Kalanga 7 Other (Tonga, Venda, Sena) 4 Approved For Release 2004/07/0- CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 their countries. (See graphic on page 11.) Kaunda has consistently resisted any augmentation of the Soviet and Cuban role in Zambia, but he might feel forced to reverse himself if it appeared this was the only way to resolve the conflict and remove the military threat posed to his country by the Rhodesians. Machel is less concerned about the Soviet and Cuban presence, largely because of his ideological commitment to ZANU, but he probably is anxious to prevent it from endangerin pragmatic economic ties he has established with South Africa. 25X1 In the hope of minimizing the military spillover into their countries, Kaunda and Machel might consider urging Nkomo and Mugabe to strike a separate deal with the government in Salisbury. Such an approach, however, would risk seriously antagonizing the other frontline states. The frontline presidents also have to consider the possibility of supporting rne auerrilla Grout) aaainst the other in a contest for power in Rhodesia. 25X1 25X1 The Soviet and Cuban Role 25X1 The common objective of Moscow and Havana is to secure influence in a black-ruled Rhodesia, and they have decided that backing ZAPU leader Nkomo is the best means to that end. The election of a government of national unity will not force any immediate changes on the Soviets or the Cubans. The fighting will continue, and they will support the guerrillas, hoping that the military pressure will bring a settlement favorable to Nkomo. They will play on African fears of Western recognition of the new anvernmrnt to maintain the momentum of the military option. Beyond that, the options available to the Soviets and Cubans have not fully taken form. They will take their cue from the response of the Africans to efforts by the new government to entice the guerrilla leaders to return to Rhodesia. Should Nkomo return, Moscow and Havana probably would prefer to support him. Even though Nyerere and Machel would dis- agree, the Soviets would weigh the opportunties to improve their credibility and influence with Zambia against the belief that any friction with Tanzania and Mozambique would only be temporary. I 25X1 Nevertheless, Nkomo's return to Rhodesia carries with it the risk that Nkomo would cut his ties with the Soviets and the Cubans in the process, thereby leading them to support ZANU. This assumes that ZANU's military effort does not evaporate as a result of large-scale defections to the new government. At the present time, Moscow and Havana cannot -10- Approved For Release 2004/07/(AtRA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81B00401R00200009110fi2cfnia Patriotic Front Nyerere, Julius Patriotic Front Mozambique Nkomo, Joshua Kaunda, Kenneth Mugabe, Robert Machel, Samora Rhodesia Sithole, Ndabaningi Muzorewa, Abel Smith, Ian 7 1.) ' Chirau, JS. United National Federal Party Botswana Ndiweni, Kayisa South Africa Khama, Seretse Approved For Release 2004/07/0 -11- ( 00401R002000050002-6 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 support both ZAPU and ZANU because of the rivalry between them and the potential it holds for an eventual contest between them for power in 25X1 Rhodesia. El 25X1 Pressures on the US and the UK The newly elected government in Rhodesia will press the US and the UK to recognize it and lift economic sanctions. It will argue that the election meets the demands of the US and UK for a transferwer to a black government on the basis of one man, one vote. Recognizing the new government and lifting sanctions certainly would strengthen it. There would be greater white resolve to support the black-led government and a greater willingness among whites in the military to defend it. Government prospects for attracting large numbers of guerrilla defectors could also be enhanced if the economy improved 25X1 sufficiently to allow til l government to improve social services for the blacks. The lifting of sanctions would improve the chances of stemming Rhodesia's economic decline and would provide substantial economic benefits and give a major psychological boost to the internal regime. Worldwide demand has been increasing for many anndc nrncuced by the Rhodesians such as copper, gold, and chrome. I 25X1 At the same time, such a decision would seriously erode the "special relationship" the US has fostered with black African leaders--particularly Zambian President Kaunda, Tanzanian President Nyerere, and Nigerian President Obasanjo. They would conclude that the US and the UK had chosen to support the "enemy" and thus would come under increasing pressure from the guerrillas and the Soviets to pursue a military solution 25X1 in Rhodesia. I 1 Such a basic policy shift would also weaken the credibility of Western support for the UN transitional program for Namibia in the eyes of both the Africans and the white government in Pretoria. In fact, the South Africans probably have already interpreted moves to send US observers to cover the Rhodesian elections as evidence of a general weakening of US determination to pursue the UN transition program for Namibia, giving them more room to push a final settlement on their own terms. 25X1 While some African leaders might support lifting sanctions if it were followed by US and UK efforts to include ZANU or ZAPU in the new government, the frontline African leaders would be further antagonized -12- Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 SECRET 25X1 25X1 SECRET Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 by such a strategy. A call for a new constitution--providing for a more rapid transition to full black rule and approved by both blacks and whites--might dispel some of the frontline president's resentment, but it would still leave the US and the UK very much in disfavor. 1 25X 1 Faced with a refusal by the US and the UK to lift sanctions, the internal government would have difficulty taking hold. White emigration probably would increase as the level of fighting escalated. Whites in the military would begin to question why they were fighting for a black-led government that was unable to win external support. The frontline states and Nigeria would continue to support Anglo- American efforts toward a political settlement, on the basis that the election was merely one step in a process that eventually would involve the guerrillas in a negotiated settlement. They probably would remain highly skeptical, however, that such efforts would succeed. Meanwhile, regardless of what the US and the UK choose to do, Soviet and Cuban involvement with the guerrilla forces--and with their hosts--would continue to grow. 25X6 25X1 -13- Approved For Release 2004/07W8CPETA-RDP81B00401R002000050002-6 25X6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Constituencies for the Election of 72 Black Members to the Zimbabwe Rhodesia House of Assembly 624873 3-79 Estimated voters 188,000 Seats Wankie. 383,500 roe ? Kariba 419,500 'Bulawayo 191,000 264,500 -15- ?Gatooma otlue Clue Beitbridge 188,000 Bindura. SALISBURY 588,500 Marandellas? Fort Victoria ? 389,000 ?Rusape Umtatio 403,000 Chipinga Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Constituencies for the Election of 20 White Members to the Zimbabwe Rhodesia House of Assembly 624872 3-79 Estimated voters 4,360 Seats .Wankie 3,200 Kariba 4,360 Plumtree 5,700 4,090 4,860 Gwelo. %joule. Hartley ? *Gatooma Bindura. ''5,030 .Enkeldeorn 3,450 'Fort Victoria 3,690 3,640 -1 6- Beitbridge 3,50 parandellas 3,000 ?Rusape Utotali 4,580 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Operational Areas in Zimbabwe Rhodesia 624874 3-79 CIA -17- Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 25X1D Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6 Next 1 Page(s) In Document Exempt Approved For Release 2004/07/08 : CIA-RDP81600401R002000050002-6