TRANSMITTAL OF REPORT ON SYRIAN USE OF YARMUK RIVER WATER

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
14
Document Creation Date: 
December 22, 2016
Document Release Date: 
August 10, 2010
Sequence Number: 
2
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
December 29, 1983
Content Type: 
MEMO
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3.pdf2.19 MB
Body: 
Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 I I Central Intelligence Agency 29DEC1983 MEMORANDUM FOR: Robert Pelletreau Deputy Assistant Secretary for Near Eastern and South Asian Affairs Department of State SUBJECT: Transmittal of Report on Syrian Use of Yarmuk River Water 1. Attached is the an use of the Yarmuk River that you requested from on 30 November. As you will note, we found that Syria is already using much more of the basin's water than any of us had expected and is continuing to develop additional sources by drilling new wells and building additional surface reservoirs. These developments seem to raise questions about Jordanian Israeli plans for downstream use of the remaining flow. 2. contact Divisio If you have any questions on these materials please ief, Near East Branch, Geography Office of Global iss -es Attachment: The Yarmuk River: Increasing Syrian Water Diversion Cause for Israeli and Jordanian Concern GI M 83 10283 December 1983 25X1 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 SUBJECT: The Yarmuk River: Increasing Syrian Water Diversion Cause for Israeli and Jordanian Concern OGI/GD/NE, (16 Dec 83) Distribution: Orig - Addressee 1 - SA/DDCI 1 - Executive Dir 1 - DDI 1 - DDI/PES 1 - NIO/NESA 1 - CPAS/ILS 1 - D/NESA 1 - Ch/NESA/AI 1 - Ch/NESA/AI/I 1 - Ch/NESA/AI/L 1 - D/OGI 1 - DD/OGI 1 - Ch/GD 1 - Ch/GD/NE 8 - OGI/PG Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 I I Central Intelligence Agency The Yarmuk River: Increasing Syrian Water Diversion Cause for Israeli and Jordanian Concern SUMMARY Syria is increasing its use of water originating in its portion of the Yarmuk River watershed. Since 1971 twelve surface storage dams and six smaller catchments have been constructed on tributaries of the Yarmuk; six of the dams have been built since 1979. Two additional dams are under construction. We estimate that Syria's annual use of Yarmuk sources may now be in excess of 200 million cubic meters--nearly 50 percent of the Yarmuk's Syria's increased use of Yarmuk water has resulted in a corresponding reduction of the water available for the tw downstream users, Jordan and Israel. Jordan's development plans for the East Bank will be severely disrupted if it is unable to rely on a Yarmuk flow significantly larger than it presently uses. While Israel uses on average only a small amount of this water for the Yarmuk (Adasiyah) Triangle, a reduced Yarmuk flow will inevitably complicate the dispute between Jordan and Israel. FI This memorandum was prepared by Issues. Comments and queries are welcome and may be directed to th e Chief, Near East Branch, Geography Divsion, GI M 83 10283 December 1983 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Background The longstanding dispute between Israel and Jordan over sharing water from the Yarmuk River has focused since early 1982 on the diversion of water from the lower end of the river into Israel's Yarmuk Triangle and into Jordan's East Ghor Canal. During recent months Jordan has expressed concern about the unusually low flow in the Yarmuk, following a winter and spring when precipitation in the drainage basin was much above average. As a consequence, both Israel and Jordan have speculated that Syria may be increasing its diversion of the river's sources at the expense of the other two riparian states. This study attempts to identify the amount of river flow that is being used by Syria and to determ~' e if this amount has changed notably during recent years. The Yarmuk Watershed The Yarmuk watershed occupies an area of about 6,800 square kilometers (km2) of which 1,800 km2 (25 percent) is in Jordan and 5,000 km2 (75 percent) is in Syria (map 1). The Syrian portion is about the size of Delaware. The basin drains roughly the area stretching from the Golan Heights to the Jabal ad Duruz, east of As Suwayda in Syria, and from Irbid to Al Mafraq in Jordan. Most of the area in both Jordan and Syria is used for rain-fed agriculture, mainly grain crops. 0 The Yarmuk River is only about 55 kilometers long, but it is fed by an extensive network of longer tributaries, most of which are intermittent streams (wadis) which carry water only in winter and spring; a few streams are perennial and are at least partially fed by springs. The river's average annual flow, based on measurements from 1927 to 1975, was 450 million cubic meters (mcm) as measured at Al Adjsiyah near where it enters Jordan's East Ghor diversion canal. Of this flow, about.200 mcm was steady base flow at the rate of about 6 cubic meters per second. The remaining 250 mcm comes from winter and spring flood flows, which ranged from 40 to 600 mcm annually during the period of record. (By comparison, the average annual flow for Washington DC's Rock Creek is 55.5 mcm). The Yarmuk's most important tributary is the Nahr ar Rugqad/Wadi ar Ruqqad which drains the area of highest rainfall, (Golan Heights from Mount Hermon to Fiq). Its average annual flow measured at Ar Rafid was 7 Z 3 m c Precipitation, mostly rainfall is the source of th , e watershed's water supply-, and varies from over 900 millimeters (35 inches) on the southeastern slopes of Mount Hermon to between 200 and 300 millimeters (8 and 12 inches) on the lava plateau 'The average annual flow was less--about 400 mcm--from 1954 to 1975. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 west of the As Suwayda (map 2). The average for the entire Yarmuk drainage basin is almost 400 millimeters (16 inches) annually. Although no precise figures are available, the higher average rainfall on the Syrian portion of the basin suggests that as much as 80 percent of the Yarmuk's flow, or more than 350 mcm, originates in Syria. During the decade of the 1970s Syrian use of water in the Yarmuk watershed increased to a 1980 level of about 180 mcm annually--about 40 percent of the Yarmuk's annual flow-~ Syria, moreover, has the potential to control at least 350 mcm of the Yarmuk's total discharge, about four times as much as the 90 mcm allocated annually under the Johnston Planl--which is often cited as the official sharing arrangement by Israel, Jordan, and Syria, when useful to their arguments. the Syrian Ministry of Irrigation stated Syria's belief that all the waters of the Yarmuk originating on Syrian territory are Syrian. (C) 25X1 Although we do not know if Syria actually intends to make full use of its Yarmuk sources and can neither confirm nor refute the claim that it was using 180 mcm of Yarmuk sources in 1980, substantial evidence is available to show that Syria's water use has increased significantly since the 1970's. Since the mid- 1970s the Syrian Government has sought to improve the country's agricultural productivity by increasing the amount of land under irrigation in Syria's dry farming areas. While the 1981-1985 Five Year Plan emphasizes dryland irrigation in the eastern part of the country, improved productivity in the moister areas, including the Yarmuk watershed, is recognized as of increasing importance. Specific plans include the continuing construction 25X1 of Yarmuk basin dams and associated irrigation networks and the increased drilling of deep wells northwest of Dar'a. Although 25X1 hundreds of wells are reported to be in use within the Yarmuk basin for irrigation, no data are available on their total output or on the affect of well pumping on the Varmuk'c f1nw_ The affect of dam construction can be more readily documented and tends to support the Syrian contention that they are using a significant share of the river's N 'The Johnston Plan was a United States initiative, in 1953-55, aimed at seeking an agreement with Israel and the neighboring Arab states on a plan for the "diversion and use" of the waters of the Jordan River basin, and possibly, the internationalization of Jerusalem. It was named for President Eisenhower's special representative on this matter--Eric Johnston. Although most elements of this plan were eventually agreed to by all riparian parties (Israel, Jordan, Lebanon and Syria), formal agreements were never concluded. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 flow. Prior to 1980 Syria had built six storage dams, all of 25X1 which were constructed after 1971 e en constructed on all of the major Syrian tributaries to the Yarmuk, adding significantly to Syria's cancer;i-ir j-? ^--4--., iL_ _ r and six smaller watr catchments in the watershed (table and photos). Since 1980 six additional surface storage dams have b to the east of the United Nations Disenga ementaObservergForrceust (UNDOF) area. wA oat4,.,-4- ? 5 uiscnarge. Two additional dams are under construction th capacity of more than 60 mcm. Their actualuitmpactCon theolned Yarmuk's flow is probably greater than this amount because they 25X1 are used to provide irrigation water for Syrian agriculture during the winter and s ring at the time of maximum stream flow. 25X1 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 most of these storage dams are fed by surface runoff; a few are partially springfed. During the summer of 1979 most of the larger reservoirs were dry, and consequently had no effect on downstream flows at that time. In July of 1983 the reservoirs were full. This suggests that the effect of the dams on the lower Yarmuk flow is most eable during wet years such as 1983. To date Jordan has made little use of its part of the Yarmuk watershed other than the diversion of water into the East Ghor Canal; only one storage dam has been constructed on a tributary near the Syrian border. Jordanian plans to increase the diversion into the East Ghor Canal have so far been thwarted by failure to obtain Israeli agreement to proceed with work in the Yarmuk river bed to improve water flow into the canal. We estimate that total Jordania aw s rom the Yarmu are less than 150 mcm annually, considerably below current and n1annaa rcrrni rc,,,o..~c The Israelis, who in their occupation o the Golan Heights control a small part of Syria's Yarmuk watershed, have, built two large storage dams since 1971 on tributaries to the Yarmuk River. One is at the Israeli settlement of Merom Golan and the other is in the southern Golan near the Israeli settlement of Avne Etan. The two reservoirs' combined capacities probably exceed the 3.5 mcm that a 1970 Israeli plan suggested Israel would withdraw from Yarmuk tributaries on the Golan Heights. In addition, Israel receives 25 mcm annually from the lower Yarmuk for irrigation in the Yarmuk Triangle area and pumps a large but unknown quantity of water from the lower Yarmuk during the high w*ter season for storage in Lake Tiberias. Implications of Increased Syrian Water Use Jordan is already experiencing a precarious balance betweel limited water supplies and growing water demands for agriculture and urban consumption. to between 500 and 600 mcm annually. Plans to relieve urban water shortages and to improve and expand irrigation in the Jordan Valley depend almost entirely on the use of at least 200 25X1 mcm of additional water from the Yarmuk by building the Maqarin storage dam and improving inlet facilities to the East Ghor Canal. These plans are at present being stymied by failure to achieve Israeli and, secondarily, Syrian agreement to work on these structures. Although these political problems have been 25X1 the most serious Yarmuk water issue up to now, the preemptive Syrian water use is probably equally harmful to Jordan because it is practically irreversible. Any Syrian use of Yarmuk sources Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 that exceeds roughly 100 mcm annually will require a corresponding scaling down of Jordanian plans. The implications of the Syrian actions for relations between Israel, Jordan, and Syria are more speculative. The 25 mcm of the Yarmuk's flow that is presently provided annually to I l' srae s Yarmuk Triangle is not large and would presumbly be continued by Jordan under any eventuality. Probably more important would be Israel's reaction to a further reduction or the residual Yarmuk flow that is not used by Syria or Jordan. One result of increased Syrian water use, consequently, may be th at Israel will harden its opposition to Jordan's plans to improve the East Ghor inlet and construct the Maqarin dam. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 STORAGE DAMS IN YARMUK BASIN, JULY 1983 Year Nearest Town Daml Built Coordinates (Dam name) Stream/Wadi 1972-74 33?08'N Merom Golan2 Tributary to 35?46'E Wadi ar Ruqqad 2 1983-u/c 33?06'N Al Qunaytirah Wadi ar Ruqqad 35?52'N (Ar Ruwayhinah) 3 1980-81 33?01'N Al Hajjah Tributary to 35?56'E (Al Hajjah) Nahr al Allan 4 1983-u/c 32?56'N Ar Rafid Wadi' ar 35055'N Larger dam; built by Israelis; full. Larger dam (2 mcm) being built on site of a previous small water catchment; 1 km from UNDOF. Larger dam (3 mcm) ; full. Ruqqad Large dam being built 2 kms from UNDOF 5 Pre-1967 32?55'N Yonatan Tributary to 35?51'E Wadi ar Ruqqad 6 1980-81 32?53'N Tasil 35?58' E (Ghadir al Bus tan) Syrian-built reservoir; appears heavily silted and in disuse Nahr al Allan Larger dam (6 mcm); full. 7 1980-81 32?52'N Ash Shaykh Nahr Al Harir Largest of 36?07'E Miskin newlybuilt (Tasil al- storage dams; Shaykh Miskin) full. 'Dam numbers correspond to numbers on map 2Dam numbers 1, 5, and 8 are in the Israeli-occupied Golan Heights; dam no. 32 is in Jordan Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 (Cont'd) Dam Year Built Coordinates (Dam Name) Stream/Wadi 9 10 11 12 1974-75 Mid-1970s Mid-1970s Mid-1970s 1980-83 32?48N 35?46E 32?49'N 36 ? 06' E 32?49'N 36?05'E 32?47'N 36?01' E 32?45'N 36?02'E Ash Shaykh Miskin (Ibta, large) Ash Shaykh Miskin (Ibta, small) Tafas (Gharbi Tafas) Tributary to Nahr al Harir Tributary to Nahr al Harir Nahr, al Harir Larger dam built by Israelis; full. Larger dam (3 mcm) ; full. Larger dam (1 mcm); full. Small catchment; full. Larger dam; full. 13 Mid-1970s 32?43'N As Suwayda Tributary to Smal catchment; 36025 ' E Wadi adh Dhahab full. 14 Mid-1970s 32?42'N As Suwayda Tributary to Small catchment; 36?22'E Wadi ad h Dhahab empty. 15 Mid-1970s 32?43'N As Suwayda Tributary to Larger dam 36?49' E (Rum Hawilayn) Wadi abu adh (4.6 mcm); Dhahab mostly spring fed; full. 16 Mid-1970s 32?41'N As Suwayda Tributary to Small catchment; 36 ? 29' E (Al Aslihah) Wadi ad h Dhahab full. 17 Pre-1968 32?39'N Wadi adh Small catchment; 36?34' E Dhahab full. 18 1979 32?37'N Rasas Tributary to Larger dam; 36035 ' E (Rasas) Wadi adh Dhahab partly spring fed; three- quarters full. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 (Cont'd) Dam Built Coordinates (Dam Name) Stream/Wadi 19. Mid-1970s 32?41'N Al Musayfirah Wadi adh Small catchment; 36?20'E Dhahab one-quarter 20 1980-81 32?41'N Al Musayfirah Wadi adh full. Larger dam; 36?17' E (Ghariyat ash Dhahab one-quarter 21 Mid-1979s 32?40'N Sharqiyah) Dar'a Wadi adh full. Small catchment; 36?05'E (Uthman) Dhahab less than one- 22 - 32?42'N Muzayrib Tributary to quarter full. Spring-fed 36?01' E (Lake Wadi ad h natural lake 23 Mid-1970s 32?35'N Muzayrib) Dar 'a Dhahab Wadi az Zaydi with local irrigation system; level normal. Oldest large 36? 06' E (Darla) dam (15 mcm) 24 Pre-1968 32?33'N At Tayyibah Tributary to in watershed; full. Small catchment; 360111E Wadi az Zaydi empty. 2.5 Pre-1968 32?33'N At Tayyibah Wadi az Zaydi Small catchment; 36014' E empty. 26 Pre-1968 32?34'N Jizah Wadi az Zaydi Small catchment; 36?16'E empty. 27 Pre-1968 32?32'N Busra Ash Tributary to Small catchment; 36?29' E Sham Wadi az Zaydi one-half full. 28 Pre-1968 32?32'N Busra Ash Tributary to Small catchment; 36?29' N Sham Wadi az Zaydi one-half full. 29 Pre-1968 32?32'N Busra Ash Tributary to Small catchment; 36? 31' E Sham Wadi az Zaydi empty. 10 Pre-1968 32?33'N Al Qurayyah Tributary to Larger dam 36 0 40' E Wadi az Zaydi enlarged from small catchment in 1979; nearly full. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 (Cont'd) Year Nearest Town Dam Built C o ordinates (Dam Name) Stream/Wadi Comment 31 Pre-1968 3 2 ?30'N Al Qurayyah Tributary to Small catchment; 3 6? 36'E Wadi az Zaydi one-third full. 32 Mid-1970s 3 2? 28'N Al Mafraq Tributary to Larger dam; 3 6? 15'E (Jordan) Wadi az Zaydi only dam in Jordanian Yarmuk water- shed; one-quarter full. Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3 Mean Annual Precipitation in the Nahr al Yarmiik Basin Lebanon Sidon J rte/ *DAMASCUS I/ Shaykh' 200 Precipitation in millimeters Drainage basin boundary 0 20 Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2011/08/17: CIA-RDP85T00287R000700020002-3