SOVIET INDEBTEDNESS TO THE WEST

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
S
Document Page Count: 
17
Document Creation Date: 
December 27, 2016
Document Release Date: 
April 10, 2012
Sequence Number: 
3
Case Number: 
Publication Date: 
November 1, 1970
Content Type: 
MEMO
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5.pdf694.79 KB
Body: 
Declassified in Part -Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10 :CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 17 DEC19~0 ~ /~ O J ~ / q Secret XX DIRECTORATE OF INTELLIGENCE Intelligence Memorandum Soviet Indebtedness To The rest Secret ER IM 70-163 November 1970 Copy No . '~ f"~ ~~ J Declassified in Part -Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10 :CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part -Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10 :CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part -Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10 :CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET CENTRAL INTELLIGENCE AGENCY Directorate of Intelligence November 1970 INTELLIGENCE MEMORANDUM Soviet Indebtedness To The West Introduction Soviet indebtedness to the West, accrued from medium- and long-term credits, has grown rapidly in recent years concomitant with an upsurge in imports of Western plant and equipment. Soviet indebtedness reached more than US $1 billion by the end of 1969 and will go higher this year. This memorandum describes the developments in the growth of Soviet trade and debt with the developed West and examines the prospects for the near term. The Genesis of Soviet Debt 1. Soviet use of Western medium- and long-term credit is a recent phenomenon in Soviet history. During the first four decades of its existence, the USSR conducted virtually all of its international transactions with the West on a cash basis. The practice stemmed in large part from its treatment as an outlaw by the Western powers in the 1920s when the Soviet state was refused credit of any kind. By the end of the 1920s the USSR was able to attract some credit, but on short terms only and at very high interest rates. In the main, however, the USSR paid cash and exported gold to meet its debts when export receipts were insuf- ficient. Throughout this period the USSR was careful to meet its commitments on time and, by the late 1930s, it had established for itself a reputation as a trading partner which met its commercial obligations. Note: This memorandum was produced soZeZz~ bz~ CIA. It was prepared b~ the Office of Economic Research. SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET 2. The exclusively cash basis of conducting international commercial transactions with the West endured after World War II until the late 1950s. Gold sales continued to be the basic means to settle deficits in its international accounts with the West. Persistent deficits, however, resulted in a moderate drain on Soviet gold reserves which fell from a high of about $3 billion in 1955 to $2.5 billion four years later. With the ambitious seven-year plan (1959-65) coming up and the decision to purchase large amounts of Western plant and equip- ment, Khrushchev decided that Western credit could help bridge the gap between exports and imports. With the easing of East-West tensions, the promise of a growing market in the East, anal increasing competition among Western suppliers, the time was ripe for the USSR to elicit credit from the capita- lists. 3. Between 1959 and 1965, trade with the West as a whole grew at the annual rate of nearly 11~, exceeding $5 billion in 1965; Soviet hard currency trade with Western countries grew at a rate of more than 19$, imports growing at a more rapid rate than exports (see Tables 1 and 2). This growth came at a time when almost all of the major trading part- ners of the developed West had returned their currencies to a convertible basis.* 4. In line with Soviet policy a sizable deficit developed in trade with hard currency countries. in the early 1960s, as imports of industrial goods rose rapidly. In 1963 and 1965, however, poor grain harvests forced the USSR to import substantial quantities of wheat (roughly $1.2 billion in 1963- 65 alone) from hard currency countries. As a re- sult of these unexpected imports, the hard currency trade deficit increased to an average of $350 mil- lion a year. In 1963-65 the USSR resorted to sales of gold which averaged more than $500 million per. year (see Table 3). Gold reserves, which had continued declining in 1960-62 to a level of about * BzZateraZ clearing arrangements with the USSR were rapidly terminated. In the early 1960s only Austria, Finland, Norway, and Sweden remained as Soviet clearing partners. Norway and Sweden re- turned to hard currency trade with the USSR in 1965 and Austria will do so in 1971. - 2 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET $2.1 billion, fell by more than $1 billion during 1963-65, reaching a low of about $1 billion by the end of 1965 (see Table 5) . 5. To prevent even larger deficits and further drawdowns on depleted gold reserves, Khrushchev's successors reduced imports of industrial goods and expanded exports at a faster rate after 1964 than in the previous five years. Short-term borrowing was also increased.* 6. During 1964-65 the USSR cut back its orders for Western plants and equipment (see Table 6). These orders had been partly financed by medium- term credits from the West, but by 1963 mounting repayments had more or less offset new credits (see Table 4). The reductions in known orders from the West in 1964-65 were made despite an increasing Western willingness to furnish medium-term or even longer term credit during this period. Soviet failure to take advantage of these easier credit terms probably stemmed from Soviet uncertainty about crop prospects and about its ability to expand exports. Recent Developments, 1966-69 7. The cutbacks in orders and industrial im- ports from the developed West and the expansion of traditional Soviet exports to that area brought the USSR its first hard currency trade surplus in a decade in 1967. Machinery and equipment imports from the developed West, however, had returned to their earlier high level in 1966 and increased to a new high of $670 million in 1967. This trend was more than rising exports to the area could match, and Soviet trade with the hard currency countries returned to a deficit position in 1968. * Soviet use of short-term credit Baas continuous throughout the 1960x. With the cessation of large Soviet gold sales, hozvever, the USSR has placed in- creasing reliance on such facilities to help finance deficits. The USSR also has been active in the Eurocurrency market and is typically a net borrower. - 3 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET 8. In 1969 the Soviet hard currency trade deficit rose to more than $300 million. Soviet exports have continued to increase but at a sub- stantially lower rate than imports. The deficit has been financed through both short-term and long-term credits, with the USSR continuing to husband its gold. There have been no signifi- cant sales of gold by the Soviet Union since 1965. Soviet gold reserves increased each year in the 1966-69 period, reaching an estimated $1.~6 bil- lion at the end of 1969. Soviet Policy on Credits from the West 9. The USSR under Khrushchev financed def- icits by drawing on gold reserves and using only a moderate amount of medium-term credits. Once the volume of new medium-term credits leveled off, however, repayments soon caught up. The sharply increased drain of hard currency brought on by the grain crisis threatened to decimate the Soviet gold reserves. The current leadership, having first ended the gold drain and brought a measure of stability to the Soviet hard currency payments position, more recently has been able to boost industrial imports through the use of. long-term credits. This spurt too can only ~be temporary, as the credits will eventually have to be repaid. 10. Annual drawings increased from an esti- mated $60 million in 1959 to $180 million in 1962 (see Table 4), but they then varied little until 1966 when they jumped to about $275 mil- lion. By 1969 they had almost doubled again, reaching $525 million. New drawings, which were just balancing repayments by 1963 because of the rapid growth of repayments with the use of medium- term credits, increased sharply in 1965 and after- ward when .long-term credits became the principal form of Soviet borrowing. Thus the Soviet debt to the West, which grew from about $50 million to $380 million in the seven years 1959-65, rose to almost $1.2 billion in the four years 1966-69. The average duration of outstanding credits had changed from five years in 1959 to eight years in 1969. - 4 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET 11. The rapid growth and present size of the Soviet debt to the West indicates that the cur- rent regime is willing to incur substantial foreign debt to obtain Western equipment and technology. At the same time, the USSR seems intent on rebuilding the gold reserve that had fallen to about $1 billion in 1965. The USSR thus has added some $600 million to its reserves, but at a cost of adding about $800 million to its long-term debt to the West. The level of indebted- ness is not so great as to impose a serious finan- cial burden on the USSR. The present regime demonstrated in 1964-65 that it will not hesitate to curtail orders and imports from the West if it believes that its international financial solvency is threatened. Nevertheless, this debt does impose an additional constraint upon the USSR, which plans to continue to increase imports of Western plants and equipment but which has had considerable difficulty in meeting plans to expand exports. Recent Credit Activities 12. Recent Soviet credit contracts have shown an awareness of the need to generate exports to the West if the hard currency debt is .not to be- come an eventual drag on imports of technology and hence on the economy. The USSR has sought increasingly to tie the repayment terms for major plant and equipment orders to deliveries of the product from the resulting installation. An example of this type of contract has been the Soviet-Japanese timber agreement of 1968 in which $133 million in Japanese equipment to exploit Siberian timberlands was to be financed by Japan on a five-year credit, with repayment tied to deliveries of wood products to Japan. Other examples of this type of credit arrangement have been the gas-for-pipe contracts the USSR has signed with Austria, Italy, and West Germany. Basically these contracts call for long-term (up to 10 years) credits for some ..$650 million in Western pipe and pipeline equipment with repayment usually tied to Soviet sales of natural gas to these countries. Soviet gas sales to Austria and Italy will involve sizable hard cur- rency earnings for the USSR over the 23-year and SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET 20-year periods of the gas contracts because the pipe and equipment which made possible-these sales will be paid for by gas delivered through 1977.* 13. The Soviet Union has also proposed a. number of cooperative arrangements with Western countries calling for Western long-term credits for equipment to exploit Soviet natural resources. How serious the USSR is about these proposals, which have been made to Japan, the United Kingdom, and France, is uncertain since most have-been overly ambitious, calling for credits in the hundreds of millions of dollars, longer terms than usual -- some from 10 to 20 years -- and deferred payments in the form of deliveries of Soviet goods produced by the projects. None of these deals seem likely to be completed until the scope and terms become more realistic for the proposed Western partners. Prospects 14. Soviet hard currency imports of plants and equipment in 1970 are expected to continue at the high level of recent years despite the fall-off in known Soviet orders of plants and equipment from the West in 1969. Helping to keep these imports at a high level are the normal lag be- tween orders and deliveries, the delivery of items held up on Soviet request in 1969 (mostly items for the Soviet FIAT plant), continued large deliveries of steel products, and the increased. deliveries on the pipe contracts. 15. Orders for industrial plants and equipment continue to lag in 1970, totaling only about $200 million through August. Several major proposals in the process of negotiation have dragged on with no decision.. Among them are a French * Soviet earnings from gas after 1977 are ex- pected to be about $24 million per year from Austria and $67 million per.year from Italy. The West German pipe contract, by far, the largest at .$330 million, could involve some hard currency outlay by the USSR, since it calls for repayment in 10 years, but this would be recouped in the hard currency earnings during the Zast 10 years of the 20-year contract. SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET pipe-for-gas proposal, a Japanese proposal for $350 million worth of equipment in exchange for Soviet pulpwood and wood chips, and a number of proposals for Western chemical plants. Uncer- tainty on the shape of the new five-year plan (1971-75), a decision not expected before early 1971, may be responsible for this delay. Unless orders pick up soon, plant and equipment deliver- ies may be down in 1971. Such a development, however, probably would have a short-term effect. The USSR seems likely to continue its import program and to reach agreement on many of the above proposals. Further evidence of Soviet in- tentions to import at a high level is a proposal in the $500 million import range for a truck plant on the Kama River now being discussed with Western countries. 16. The Soviet debt to the West probably will increase in 1970 because of the large deliveries on the Italian and German pipe contracts, while other plant and equipment deliveries apparently will remain at about the same level as in 1969. These deliveries are expected to bring drawings in 1970 close to $800 million and to increase both net credits and indebtedness by about $400 million. Soviet indebtedness to the West will stand at approximately $1.6 billion by the end of the year. Pipe and plant equipment, as well as steel deliveries, should remain high for the next few years -- even if deliveries dip in 1971 -- and the debt should continue to rise, although possibly at a reduced rate. For the longer run, Soviet ability to service this debt will be a function of their ability to generate and sustain increasing exports. Imports of plant and equipment under contracts specifying long-term exports of the ensuing products will help to provide that capability. 17. Soviet exports to the hard currency area, which have failed to keep pace with the rapid growth in imports from that area since 1966, are unlikely to show any unusual rise in 1970. Net exports of petroleum, traditionally the largest hard currency earner, are not expected to increase and may decline, and there is no indication that other traditional export items SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET such as wood and cotton will rise substantially. Exports~of diamonds, which have enjoyed a sub- stantial growth in recent years, probably will not grow as rapidly this year because of substantially reduced demand. The hard currency deficit in 1970, thus, may be on the same order of magnitude as in 1969, but it almost certainly can be financed with- out gold sales. Conclusions 18. More than a decade ago the USSR embarked on a program to modernize Soviet technology by increas- ing imports of machinery and equipment from the developed West. Khrushchev's initial policy was to pay for these imports by borrowing from the developed West and by selling gold when credits were un- available. The grain failures of 1963 and 1965 forced large gold sales and also compelled the USSR to cut back on imports of industrial goods from the West. 19. When the need for grain imports declined and the Soviet hard currency trade balance was restored, the USSR again increased industrial imports from the West. The present Soviet leadership has chosen to rely to a greater extent on Western long-term credit to finance these purchases. Soviet debt to the West rose by about $800 million from 1965 to 1969, and will probably be about $1.6 billion by the end of 1970. During 1966-70 Soviet gold sales will have been negligible. Gold reserves vtill have risen from a low of $1 billion at the end of 1965 to about $1.8 billion at the close of 1970. 20. Soviet trade with the developed West seems likely to continue growing in the next several years, with the help of Western credits. Neither the USSR nor its Western partners seem to regard the present size of the Soviet debt to the West as un- manageable. The USSR has sought arrangements with the West calling for even longer term credits and repayments in Soviet goods produced by the instal- lations. financed by these credits. Optimistic Soviet demands for huge credits and extended length of re- payment have resulted in few completed contracts in 1970, but the USSR seems determined to pursue this line of economic policy. - 8 - SECRET Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Soviet Trade Turnover with the Free World a/ Million US $ 1959 1965 1967 1968 1969 Total 2, 602 5, 067 5, 866 6, 543 7, 604 Hard currency countries b/ 1,126 2,877 3,292. 3,900 4,531 Developed West 1,636 3,039 3,668 4,195 4,725 Hard currency countries 854 2,455 2,997 3,518 3,993 Less developed countries 845 1,756 1,768 1,833 2,287 v~ ~ ~ Hard currency countries 282 481 331 410 567 ~ ~ y Unspecified 121 272 430 515 593 a. Because of rounding, components mazy not add to the totals shown. b. Total adjusted to exclude Soviet economic aid deliveries to Zess developed countries and aid repaz~ments from these countries made in goods. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Exports Imports Exports Imports Exports Imports Exports Imports Exports Imports Total a/ 538 588 1, 331 1, 546 1, 688 1, 604 1, 896 2, 004 2, 109 2, 422 Developed West 494 360 1,169 1,286 1,580 1,417 1,737 1,781 1,893 2,100 Less developed countries 54 228 206 275 132 199 172 238 231 336 ~ ~ Ci7 C) o a. Total adjusted to exclude Soviet economic aid deliveries to Zess developed countries and aid repayments ~ ~ from these countries made in goods. H Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part -Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10 :CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 SECRET Soviet Hard Currency Trade Balance, Wheat Imports, and Gold Sales Million US $ Year Hard Currency Trade Balance Wheat a/ Imports Goldb/ Sales Est> cLra ~ep,~ ~ ~ae.g~}Q~q ~.~ed~~~_ 1959 - 50 12 303 ~? 1960 -278 0 149 12S ~ ~~ 1961 -193 31 310 1962 -267 0 239 ~ ~? 1963 -310 187 523 ~ ~0 1964 -533 570 520 / ~ 1965 ~ -215 409 490 Q ~ 1966 -266 495 45 r- Z~~ 1967 + 84 147 10 ~~~ 1968 -108 110 10 ~ ~~ 1969 c/ -313 10 Negl. ~~~ a. Including wheat flour; excluding transportation eos is . b. Minimum estimates. For de tai Zs on Soviet gold production, sales, and reserves, see Table 5. c. Preliminary. SECRET Declassified in Part -Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10 :CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Table 4 Estimated Soviet Drawings and Scheduled Repayments on Western Medium-Term and Long-Term Credits a/ y Million US $ Outstanding Estimate Scheduled Net Debt at the ~r~d / Drawings Repayments Interest Credits of the Year 1959 60 12 0 48 48 1960 125 37 2 86 136 1961 165 70 6 89 231 1962 180 106 10 64 305 1963 140 130 14 -4 315 1964 170 147 15 8 338 1965 190 149 17 24 379 1966 275 149 20 106 505 1967 305 152 29 124 658 1968 435 206 38 191 887 1969 c/ 525 248 59 218 1,164 a. Estimates of drawings are based on data derived from contracts indicating deZiverzU and credit terms and on Soviet imports of maehinerz~ and equipment. In general, early contracts (1959-64) involved 80%-85% credit and 5% interest. A large number of contracts since 1965 have involved 85% credit and 6% interest. Repaz~ment periods for the earlier credits were usuaZZz~ three to five Uears following down- paz~ment. Tz~picaZ terms since 1965 have been eight nears following delivery of equipment. .b. These credits are not comparable with those- given in the NATO report series Credits Granted by NATO Countries to Communist Countries because of the differences in methods of calculating these totals. NATO credits are based on reported ex- tensions rather than estimated drawings, show onZz~ government guaranteed credits, and do not include Japan, Sweden, and Switzerland. The NATO series shows an outstanding credit total for the USSR as of the end of .1969 of $1,545 million. c. PreZiminarz~. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Soviet Gold Production, Sales, and Reserves Million US $ Year Production Net Consumption a/ Other Additions Reserve Sales b/ and Withdrawals Balance ~/ 1955 101 18 70 ~ +11 d/ 3,040 1956 104 20 154 , +Negl. e/ 2,970 1957 104 21 275 +21 dj 2,800 1958 109 22 182 +14 f/ 2,720 1959 116 24 303 ~ +18 f/ 2,530 1960 124 27 149 ~ ~~~~~' N.A. 2,480 1961 133 28 310 N.A. 2,270 1962 143 30 239 ~ N.A. 2,140 1963" 153 30 523 N.A. 1,740 ~ 5 3 ~ 1964 164 32 520 ~ N.A. 1,360 1965 176 34 490 ~/ N.A. 1,010 1966 188 36 45 N.A. 1,120 1967 200 38 10 h/ -10 i/ 1,260 1968 207 40 10 N.A. 1,410 1969 219 42 Negl. N.A. 1,590 1970 ~/ 233 44 Negl. N.A. 1,780 a. Net consumption is the gold issued to the domestic economz~ for use b~ industrz~ and the arts in excess of that returned by the domestic economy for refining and eventual reissue. b. Minimum estimates. c. At the end of the near, rounded to the nearest $10 million. The range of error is 20%. d. Total output of North Korea and Communist China. e. Total output of North Korea and Communist China Zess a Zoan to Poland of $12.5 million. f. Total output of North Korea. g. Including a reported $180 million in Soviet and East European gold sold to Italian banks for debt service. h. Soviet sales of industrial gold to West Germanz~. i. Loan to Hungary. ~. PreZiminarz~ estimates. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Table 6 Value of Soviet Orders for Plants and Equipment from the Developed West, a/ by Category Million US $ 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 Total 290 397 233 554 319 264 904 564 678 403 Motor vehicle manufacturing N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 462 47 78 b/ 52 Chemical and petrochemical 148 101 63 175 226 118 123 94 c/ 90 c/ 83 Ships and marine equipment 67 111 100 313 32 35 24 75 139 2 Timber and wood processing N.A. 70 40 10 5 19 69 6 143 21 Textile manufacturing N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 59 106 9 4 ~ Food processing 4 89 5 N.A. N.A. N.A. 52 41 31 9 ,~~ Metalworking and metallurgy N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 17 22 34 30 CrJ ~.] Oil, gas, and pipeline equipment N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 19 12 35 132 Electronics N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. N.A. 10 20 9 22 Other d/ 71 26 25 55 56 92 68 142 110 49 a. Exc u ing Fin an which is on a bzlatera c caring basis. Because of roun Zng, components may not add to the totals shown. b. Including a plant valued at $54 million to manufacture rubber products. The plant could also be subsumed under the category chemical and petroclaemicaZ. c. Excluding several known contracts for which values mere not reported. Inclusion of estimated values for those contracts, and the $54 million rubber product plant contract, mould increase the values shorn above for chemical and petrochemical equipment to $105 million in 1967 and $145 million in 1968. d. Including a wide variety of plants and equipment with consumer orientation -- for example, for production of footwear, home refrigerators, and supermarket equipment. The category also includes printing, mining, and medical equipment and other items. Declassified in Part - Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10: CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Declassified in Part -Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10 :CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5 Secret Secret Declassified in Part -Sanitized Copy Approved for Release 2012/04/10 :CIA-RDP08S01350R000602020003-5