VOICE OF AMERICA BROADCASTS TO CZECHOSLOVAKIA

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
0002653697
Release Decision: 
IPPUB U
Original Classification: 
Document Page Count: 
8
Document Creation Date: 
June 24, 2015
Document Release Date: 
March 25, 2011
Sequence Number: 
Case Number: 
F-2011-00412
Publication Date: 
May 20, 1952
File: 
AttachmentSize
PDF icon DOC_0002653697.pdf810.19 KB
Body: 
_, CLASSIFICATION SIXRE'T/ INFORMATIO SUBJECT Voice of America Broadcasts to Czechoslovakia PLACE ACQUIRED DATE ACQUIRED BY NO..OF PAGES 9 NO. OF ENCLS. (LISTED BELOW) SUPPLEMENT TO REPORT NO. May 52 (b)(1) (b)(3) APPROVED FOR RELEASEL DATE: 14-Mar-2011 1. One of the most in,. ortant aspects in the East-west struggle is the right approach to the people behind the Iron Curtain. Much more attention should be given to the most important means of anti-Communist propaganda for such people, ie, radio broadcasts beamed to those countries in the Soviet or::it. Listening to Voice of America broadcasts in Czechoslovakia tolay is truly nation--aide; about 70-80 per cent of the adult population listens regularly to at least two programs a week. In the news vacuum of the Soviet orbLt, such broaucasts play a decisive role, which, in my opinion, is still not fully realized by the US. VOA?s one competitor is Radio Free Europe, which is regarded by the :;zechs almost as their own station; RFE seems to understand the difficult ife in the CSR and the desperation and hopes of the people. If RFE could overcome some technical difficulties, it would lead VLA by a .ride margin, but at present, I think t' at VOA has a considerable edge over RFE. Generally, the great majority of the Czech people like most of tie VOA programs quite well. They look eagerly to VUA as a source of information on the free '.rorld., a ready reporter of world news, defender and promoter o-' American interests and the American way of life, and the interpreter of American opinion on the activities of the Communists in t} at Dart of the .a,-rld behind the Iron Curtain. There are only two small groups in Czechoslovakia that do not, .1.i.sten to i orei-n broadcasts; the "hard core" Communist Party members, and the small. group of over-intellect- ualized individuals, who hate Communism but have no faith in .iestern democracv~ The latter group is very dangerous; checking its growth depends on he e fectiveness of VOA and other foreign broadcasts. N REPORT 2. The number of radio sets in use today throughout: Czechoslovakia in' proportion to the population is one of the highest; in the world. During the parliamentar debate on the 1952 budget (reported on Radio Prague, 16 Mar 52), a member of parliament; stated that during 1951 the number of radio owners who had registered their sets with post office authorities showed a 5.3 per cent increase over the previous year. This means that at the present time `;here are well over two million radio receivers in operation, acids up to about one set per family, includine.; those in Slovaki.:,.. I think that the figure may well be as as three million- since many sets captured from the Germans are not registered? The regime seems to encourage this wide-spread use of radio sets, pr? s-_:mably in the hope that more people will. listen so Radio Praga:= ether Communist broadcasts. Actually, I heli. _ %e ?h.a-, the add1_'.. e~o~ I. radios mean an increase in the number of l.is *,o Czech broadcasts from abroad. 3. The quality of VOA recent .on as good. Reception is worst during the i.mpor, T,.: r a ._. l: .p lar pro- grams, "Report From America" ?0 `-oars .-w-no Calling Czechoslovakia" at 1830 hour.: , ,::;arose mos Cz:_::;h radios are of fairly high quality (even the i -,we- r-prices] shor wave bands), the people can usua:Ll ) find at.. least; on . band ,,'-.ere the broadcasts can be heard. Jaruminrr seems to be i ,.!.a.s i ep ic. strength as well as in the number oi' way.: _ recent months I have noticed that inter i'c : e::: ?:i tr, VOA l :L.; in direct proportion to the content. Gf t:. 1: U(;ra!rts ; i r:'. l _.'.clc !1~.,_ was very slight during the daily new-, hn':. the n;cn;c:nt : ornrn~ r.?.t.ary on purges in Czechoslovakia hct_;..Ln, c .i4.mTieg '.: :,?..: l;ror,g that it was not possible to hear being iit .. As ; ic. I-ening to the medium wave band is pr::Vci.ir_.a:.] l;lr irri,oUrsikle heavy and eor4stant jamming, I belic:'i pc _~:l_ i _ cr. short Nave. The broadcasts of BBC and arc seldom jammed because of their i concen- trated on the broadcasts the Communists - those of VOA and RFE. 4. In my opinion, the timing of VOA ?:.roa;_!ca ;s to z -.:noslovakia is satisfactory to the majority of l1SI.: ne e, ,";' ough I do think some improvement could be made. T - shout. d Us r:-:.s.;r,bered that the people in Czechoslovakia go %-.o b,:,,i ear'_y ; a.rc x:: JC hours) from sheer physical exhaustion; in the rural :areas pe.op e retire even earlier. The main shift in industry begins at 0600 heelars. As most workers do not live near the f::l.( ?:~rie0, .h-,.,Y t up before 0500 hours. Further, Czech broadcasting stations ease operations at 22415 hours; the one exception is, the new 1-:on,., ra ave station, used for disseminating propaganda abroad, wh.'cch stays or. the air until around midnight. This bait on laic e evening brc; ordered in January 1952, increases the danger of 10_ le liptening to VOA since even the tuning-in of f,,reign stations i s often accompanied by sharp sounds in the speaker. 5. The programs beamed to Czechoslovakia prolre t.hai; VIAL has much good, factual material about the CSR. Bat one gets ~?he l;npresSion that VOA does not have up-to-date information concerning F.r.e people, ie, their state of mind after three years of Communist prco~ a.~?, sea and mental pressure. This lack of understanding seems to rte to be the major cause of difference in the reaction of listeners to RFE and VOA. This lack of understanding on the part of VOA be caused by isolation or by Insufficient contact. In this respect, RFE has a tremendous advantage in having its headquarters cause to the Czech border; it is able to establish direct contact; wife, refugees, and can "eavesdrop at the Iron Curtain". It appears to me that VOA, loc- ated on a distant continent, either does not get enough intelligence reports about the people of Czechoslovakia, or such reports reach VOA through such complicated channels that they arrive too late to give an up-to-date picture. 6. A few years ago it would have been. impossible to try to describe the state of mind of the average Czech citizen. The years of oppres- sion, however, have united the country as never before. First of all, the nation as a whole feels a certain amount of guilt for what was allowed to happen in February 1948. It is important that VOA take this into account when dealing with exiled Czechs and Slovaks. For those left in Czechoslova.lcia, there are no symbols of liberation or resistance movements, either at home or abroad, Those movements symbolized by Thomas Masanyic during World War. I, and by Dr. Benes during World War II were accepted with. patriotic enthus4asm as symbols of liberation at the time. But now such movements simply do not exist in the hearts of the Czech people and any attempt to use a group of exiled political leaciers for such a psychological approach would be met with cold di C. tt, do not mean to rule out future possibilities in this respect, but at this time, I would set a strict limit on the speeches exiled political leaders used on VOA. The Czechs see these exiled politicians as very lucky individuals, who somehow managed to get out. of the country in time to go to "paradise" as the Czech:-, call he free world. These exiled poli- ticians are not directl l :i.:mc for the Communi.s ;s' rise to power, but there Is a strong that as leaders they did not fulfill their obligation, tha,; they did not do everything they might have to prevent the tea" d Above all stands the fact that not a single shot was fi ,ect thr;t the Red coup was followed by the chaotic desertion of. J:-:inocr&t_c leaders who had not attemp- ted any organized or even symbolic resistance. It is easy to see that this sac r: ! _ .['.:c i; is in the minds of all the people. Life under the Communise. its slavery and terror, is considered by many of the ;a.:; a '"cleansing bat-h". They feel strongly that moral guidance mi :;i; come from their own ranks and not from .emigrants . This Fact; should always be kept in mind by VOA when preparing programs with or shout exiled political leaders. The people of Czechoslovakia urn aci-.n in vain for new moral leader- ship for the nation, in tnccy can put their filth. They dis- trust big words and empty :c,pee?chc?.; about democracy. No longer are they willing to listen to "old faL;hioned" speeches containing empty phrases which sound patriotic. Naturally, speeches made by exiled Czech politicians often fall in this category. Such broadcasts have no good effect and often are damaging to the cause o the West. The people in the CSR have not for otten Munich in 1938 or what happened in Prague in February 1948; both are considered by the Czechs as complete failures on the part of the Western democracies. This sho~zld not be interpreted to mean that the Czechs no longer believe in democratic ideals. Quite the opposite is true, but the Czechs d.fferentiate between empty speeches about democracy and rea)1 democracy, the philosophy of free men. I think It is true that the Czechs have a high level of education; moreover, the majority pos- sesses the ability to think independently. There is no danger that the population would not understand or would riot listen to quota- tions from the Bible, Loncoln, Masaryk, or an expose made by Dean Acheson before a session of the UN. But they will not swallow the preachings of a self-righteous US Senator, for example, even les's will they accept the words of exiled Czech politicians. Most, such politicians cooperated with the Communists and'then?left the country without attempting any sort of defense for democratic ideals. This is a bitter pill in our history, and it should he taken into consideration, not only by VOA writer;; but also by the policy- making body of VOA. 8.. I think the people of Cz:a:.hoslcvakia tom: aid .apprec :ate It; if the main theme of VOA br.?oa tc=ast's were no`. jbe advertising of the American way of life (which, by way, the Czt~(;hs wholeheart,-dly admire, but at this time consider `:.:.c:+ " ;: trot = f Tantalus"), but rather the theme should be moral her, for survi?a' To a people under Soviet domination such as the echs, the Ar_er~c-an nay of, life is not of primary interest; the nos impcrt?a_at is their own survival and liberation. They want- to near abca: ; ll.e stre-_n??tri of the West and concrete comparisons between the Iron. C'.urta.ir,. -tn free countries. The Czechs must be appro:a~?.::_d by 710.4, witlz absolute sincerity; any "all-wise" teaching or r1i-.._.:h.ir!;: she :! be eli:rin.a ;ed from broad- casts. The Czechs rir'e up '.~..h'advio=. The persons pre- paring; VOA progra*;:-, :.o put sherneelves in the frame of mind of the lister.:er r~ too stiff, as if they were being read the nrograms lack the h,)man offering hop '?, but ' i_'.?__ ui :V .,;:i;y hl i T? 1.:hat would weaken the spiritual u_ni,t.y of .he p ec;ple m. y .!.r.'olude information on the political 1--1;. ea::a r c .: y: t: _i t any attempt on the part of these , " op 1 home what they should or st:.: ?.._d ...c .:. _. ~~t. ;:zi s stage. Instead, much, he Czechs that they have not bee:-,. ttc: The main purpose of VOA broadcasts, the Czechs how to keep up their :, ... _.r i-.... i , ...... ;,.r..:. rens t,hez their spiritual and r-eC;ime. Programs based on such a y needed by people behind tine Iron; .....,1r' '(tit VOA broad- casts, as a gener'a':. 'NC ""OUps and prepared under tea : _z, _ _.:. ... . . "c,, t r : ? ;:;..e pc: iicy for programs directed i C one for those behind the Iror. C~. r a great ma jori ;,y are strongly oPl`ca: c., in saying that :r::' ;:.a::._.. x >.ri 'rOA on the subject, and no comments what v.oe i r r ::~;ec_?ding C4cati interests. The people of the CSR are of the opinion that no answer is an answer too, and that something is being done of which the US and the West are ashamed. It is true that the German question is not the number one piioblem facing the Czechs today (of first impor- tance, of course, is how they can throw off the Communist yoke), nevertheless, it still remains of fundamental interest to the people. There is complete confusion in the minds of the Czechs as to the position..(-.,t' the US regarding the German problem; one often hears the remark that the 'US is willing to satisfy all German aspirations without retard to the smaller nations, especially the Slavic. If it were properly aired, I believe the people of Czechoslovakia would understand the role -,f Germany and her importance in the common :itruCcg:le t,.gainst CaanmurAism, 12. New; coverage by VOA Is ;very good, particularly the coverage of world event+, which finds no criticism among the listeners; it is this cove t'Til;e_ of world new,3 which glve,3 VOA such a 'large rt U :l fence . The report;int; i s curr-.:n.t, exact, and objective. It. is no e.caggeration to c!a.t whole CSR d,epeudcs on VOA for world neew:-. T;lc.t so good, hove r, _1c? VGAts co;.re.r'age of' Czech domestic It must be r. an is n+1:;cirrcl that the Czech press and radio do not lce c-p the people in- forru(,ri either world happenings or domestic event. ;;. VGA should not c;acr.i.f'y.cc: its world coverage but ,should pay more attention to new:, and problems.. It seems to me that if' VOA could uti"l .:: r: ii;; iaa~rerrsr. ?at reports on Czechoslovalc.ia without breaching would 1)avfe an excellent source of new i and comment. refficient for VOA to prepare news based on w:-;at is ri~)1'o important, great at;tent;ion _ihc?-1).ld be givers t;c tth~'. ibill t' for the effects of the t.b1. ?oadoas.c:3. I would ' liko to two examp1 ec of VOA t ,; reporting whl.h, in my opinion, r,l' knowledge of the s:ttua Lion in Czechoslovakia as r.-o_:11 of foresight, politically spf:aking, on the pa:ot (:t' the t)ri'cc r; (r~) On .,; ?; :~.r'~t +. oc:~. a; . ,;ts in September 1951, VOA reported prepara- tions for reset;"t 1uat~;:;.'L of the refugees from the famous Tv:--Lin". As I recall, the VOA announcer said o,,;r.ething to this effect "...and eight passengers from the Freedom Train were refused iamnigration visas to Canada for security reasons, The group, led by Dr. Svr:c, has to remain in Germany while the rest of the lucky, free people are on their -way to Canada and the USA, etc..." From the comment that f o? :!.owed this news, all listeners could. readily recognize that the writer and even the announcer were pleased that, former CP members were rejected for security reasons and had to remain in Germany. For most Czechs, having to stay in Germany is like "Daniel in the lion's den". As a result, of such reporting, the ma J'ority Of the members of the OP, although strongly oppcac.:d to the r'e1r'lru, feel that they are forced to stick it out with the Party until the last moment since they see no other way out; fz'::ei the VOA they can discern no trade of hope or enr.ourageirient, and certainly no ad-vantage in defeating to the West. In effect, this broadcast undoubtedly discouraged defectors from the Soviet orbit. I do not m;: an that VOA should falsify the news,, but in this case a politically acute writer would simply have stated that some of the people were going to Canada and tho 'U:> and that the others wo,o.;d be resettled in o'ther parts of the world. (b) Another ex?uaj,lc .:f harmful reporting: recently a Slovak arch- itect c,;::al;c?J. aith h.i:3 farnily and a friend across the Morava River into ~V!._." r?:i.-a in an old amphibious jeep. The refugee man- aged to i_vruce a Co:>in-nunist official, either through bribery (probably vdth black market meat) or alcoholic means, to help him get the jc::p into the restricted area at the Morava River border; the full name of official was broadcast over VOA: and this probably resultcd in the death penalty, What sort of official this man was is not important; what is important is the effect of such a broadcast on other officials., such peon?.e Re border guards, wnir., ri-tight have purposely missed when they fired at fleeing r;;fingees. If threatened by public denunciation via VOA (to wii?i(.-h the officials probably listen in secret), the numbez- of pole assisted or "allowed" to come across the bovde::;?:; rrii-l decrease to nil, -'here are other Communist of fl.c:ials, :L am s.iro, who would consider helping people flee, but if i;L:.; ir.Ili have to face such compromising revelations, they ai.:andon any such ideas, In such cases, serve no useful purpose, If such a in-the--wool" Communist, his day of recokon_:n,; will c~ z:t ..Wily come anyhow. The chances are, however, that he, has tai_en his one opportunity of "kicking the Red Regime in the seat of the pants". Such reporting only increases the ruth7.essnesr3 with which Communist orders are carried out because there is no doal.)t that corrective measures will be taken to insure that similar happenings do not occur in the future. The fact that UP, AP, or INS made the original report is no excuse for VOA. B,:,a?der guard? and Communist officials, with the cxec:, ion of rl.os in the higher echelons, are never allowed papers, so that the only way they learn of is from foreign broadcasts. I was not in ; t i.ine of the above: incident, but I can well that svic:, t the nation when they heard on VOA are not so good. The commen- tator shoii:Ld in the position of the unhappy, desperate listeners; L;i.,re the impression that he is speaking from a sense of, ci :[;l.?, li:: ir_. reading from a dry textbook. There seems to by a J.:.:,_.ic of optimism in the broadcasts. I do not mean that VuA c:_-1cor? its programs so as tc eatablish unfounded hopes. The C-,,,~_-_,i is eager to hear more comments on domestic issues, such as si e ::hc:s of Red leaders, meetings of parliament (as well as oth:x ~ff`i.cia7. meetings), articles in Red newspapers, etc. The programs of Radio Prague could serve as a rich source not only for commentaries, t:iwt also for Jokes, questions to Red leaders, etc, all of which woulo he eagerly listened to by the Czechs. ' I am continually ;surprise(! that VOA does not exploit the stupidity of the Communists as exhibited by their lies. Some quite Important events art- left without comment by VOA. A striking example of this was the reply by the US Department of State to official Czech pro- tests regar:tine; the r?ea.i,ming of West Germany and encouraging Nazi elements anong C;er~ruxn expellees from Czechoslovakia. Of, course the answer front the US was not mentioned by Czech newspapers or by Radio Prague. In my opinion, the US reply wa3 masterfully written, stating clearly not only the policy of the US regarding the re- settlement in Germany of three million Germans expelled from Czechos- lovakia but also about Lhe progress being made in the program. The US no doubt felt- that Czech fears had been allayed and that they had not irritated the Cl ormans , But this important statement of US policy hardly reache-L the Czech people because VOA did not even broadcast in its entirety the official statement. Such an item should have been broadcast several, times and included extensive acid serious comments. SARBT'/I 15. In my opiniors too much time is devoted on VOA to programs of little or no inter es , t Czech aisteners . This is especially true of the various speciali;: ar:d entertainment programs. The idea behind the speciallze.i p ;rams is goody but some could be shortened and others eliminated and mor< desirable programs substituted. A good example Ls the regular weekly broadcast for short wave radio hams. With the exception of t, very few Trade Union "Clubs" used to spread Communist propaganda, there are no radio hams in Czechoslovakia. Excepting these, arnatrur radio broadcasting is strictly forbidden. I think it as a good idea (;o weed out almost all music as well as drama from the VOA schedule. To believe that programs for youth should Con.r1:3 only of jazz nrasic and sports news is a mistake; I never heard of ~rotazgcrter in the CSR who listened to jazz on VOA. Music on domcsti: staf;icnis much easier to hear and is not ao potentially dangerioua tt) the 11stener. Even when VOA programs are not jammed, tochni.cal ifficulties make good reception of music difficult. I'.,; n.:/ not b" knot: outside of Czechoslovakia that records of Arner?i.c r, ,Jaz, , made in the CSR, can be easily purchased in Prague; tl3iey cell frr about 50 pcent more than records of "non-Western" made by such favorites as Duke Ellington and Bean:r Good:r!an c..ui be obtained without any difficulty. 16. I would 1:1k : o ;suLrr :ot he followi,r:r ideas for new programs that would he of rI-i...i.').r :In.tere t to the people in Czechoslovakia: (a) I thi!i& L I. ';c 1t: L :. ~ .:r'y !2;ood ~ ~~ i .?, once ;a ;~ree!cr the main organ- .:a :Lc.na h ..Uci;jito the CSR, le, VOA,, RPL, BBC, Radio Pario ;r,ii_J. r;;,,,; program at the same time over all ,....:.; ,'; - F ,_. c: '-~=::;i;.r;,,h7:r pro!rrrrrn could h~_? scheduled during the woeke3);iy iJ.!.d ,ha; 1u('i Ln half an ~ , :? our, ;z summary of the weekc main ,ormriepts. The preparation o.t' such a progr fhe r az ticJ.p an ;s. Such a broad- cast: ~ oVic' ; :t c rtant t.,e the 1133ccrrers since the effectit,'7.a.;c;.; of i,: ; n3u1d be draatie:ili.,y reduced by so many ;i;at;ic.:a' bo;c:i ;i; :.' at 'the same time. In addition, such coordla ;i 7 c!.: -ou .d cot ;;r~: rely de!.ronstrate the unity of the demoer-ai;a?':r ?d ii:: i;l: :i;ht against Communism, as well as the 'urlifi..c, ,. , ;X o.:'? ,c there people under Soviet domination. (b) As I hatru r;_..t;:I.or.cJ' the i rst popular p-aar;;. the ones cransr~iit;i;,..~j; I, , ~programs are ].OO h;,rr, ( Report From America) and at 1830 hours (A,rrj :a Calling Czechoslovakia") . Rather than repeat hro .r,,:.sts of these programs during the night or in the early mrrui.nl, I thin.' a completely new program at 2215 or 2230 houj's woulcr be highly desirable. This is about the time when most of the people are returning home from the numer- ous meetings, etc hat; they are forced to attend. The program need he only a l5 minute rl,ail,y news resume plus the best excerpts fry.,n all previc'u programs of 'tl;.e day. (c). The Czech p: ople are hunr;ry for entertainrneri; based on politics. Political saL;i.r?e 1w ;;h form of jokes, dialogues, or satirical articles, rood. siron1y, b',' a good announcr~a' would be most acceptabl: i; , thO Cai:eh 5 i ten.ea In my opinion this should be the only !-pe f. e;i':.er. tainment program on VOA. (d) I suggest iw titutlnL; a program, called perhaps "Czechoslovaks Abroad, roru,iatinnot of reports on the activities of polit- ical exiles, but ratacr news about the resettlement of the thousands of Czech refugees, A similar program aired by RFE about life in C'se-h eon!nunit.1.es in all parts of the world is one of the moot pc,uJ.ar in Czechoslovakia, 16. (e) A weekl? program should be devoted to the progress of science in the 'Free World". The people of Czechoslovakia, hermetically sealed off from the West, are eager to learn about the latest technical and scientific developments. Such a program would give the people added confidence in the growing strength of the Western World. (f) I suggest that a weekly program be directed at Communist Party member during which the Party would be attacked relent- lessly. Purges of long standing Party member, their offenses and threatened punishments should not only be reported but also made the subject of commentaries. The life and deeds, promises and lies of Communist leadero ehould be publicized. By the same token, rank and rile CP members should be warned, but it ahould be pointed out that they will be jwdged by their deeds and not just by Party nembership, Such a program would cause chats and disorganization in Czechoslovakia, and increase passive resistance on the part of the Czechs. (g) It is my opinion that all :w.-,ortant news published in news- papers in the CSR, particularly items concerning achievements of the regime, cooperation rith the USSR, etc, should be explained in detail and the true picture given by VOA. This should be done regularly. In conclusion, I think I speak for the average person in the CSR when I say that the Voice of America i:' a part of the daily life of the millions in Czechoslovakia; indeed the whole nation tries to tune in VOA every day. The greater the nu.uber of people listening to VOA, the greater the responsibilit: .7f these making these broadcasts. A great deal of harm can br clo!u irresponsible broadcasting. Ir: this connection I would like. oh4LLsize the following points: (a) A greater sense of respoiAsJhi lity should be adopted and more care should be devoted to factual reporting. (b) More emphaeis should bo placed on the survival of people behind the Iron Curtain and less to the American way of life; ie, more attention should be de~rutc;a t. events and problems in Czechos- lovakia (c) More of the human touch arid more optimism should be included in programs. (d) The Communist Party should be more severely attacked; govern- ment leaders should be assailed, but not to such an extent that the plain people would be forced to stick with the CP out of desperation. (e) The people of the CSR should be convinced of the growing strength of the West; VOA should keep harping on the backwardness of the Soviet orbit in all field? of science. (f) All programs should be prepared with the thought that the Voice of America 1s playing a major role in shaping the future course of history during this crucial struggle.