<SANITIZED>OFFICE OF POLICY COORDINATION 1948-1952, VOLUME I

Document Type: 
Collection: 
Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): 
01066718
Release Decision: 
RIPPUB
Original Classification: 
U
Document Page Count: 
296
Document Creation Date: 
March 9, 2023
Document Release Date: 
May 14, 2021
Sequence Number: 
Case Number: 
F-2020-00661
Publication Date: 
February 1, 1973
File: 
Body: 
Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 CIA HISTORICAL STAFF OFFICE OF POLICY COORDINATION 1948-1952 VOLUME Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 (b)(1) b'(3 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 � � Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 I Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 I Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 (b)(1) (b)(3) Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET OFFICE OF POLICY COORDINATION 1948-1952 I. Introduction The Russian-actuated Communist movement gath- ered a great deal of momentum in the era immediately following World War II, slipping stealthily into the political vacuums created by the toppling of the Ger- man, Italian, and Japanese fascist movements. As a result of shifts in power after the war, Russia looked upon the United States as the leader of an opposite camp. Within Communist ideology, democracy was an ultimate target for destruction. A whole series of inimical actions engineered from Moscow served to engender a state of apprehension within the American body politic.* Modern day gurus often refer to those years as the "McCarthy era." As a consequence, his political reprehensibility is generally projected without ade- quate exposition of the unallayed anxiety that ex- isted at the time in the public mind because of the aggressive actions of the USSR. To some, the manipu- lations of Senator Joseph McCarthy appeared more as a product of the existing public trepidation than as a cause of it as alleged by others. SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET In September 1946 an important state paper was prepared by Mr. Clark M. Clifford, an aide to Presi- dent Harry S. Truman, on the subject of US relations with the Soviet Union. It supplied the President with every past detail of the wartime relationship with the USSR. More importantly, as it turned out, it charted the postwar prospect with startling presci- ence outlining the shape and thrust of Truman's sub- sequent programs, namely: the Greek-Turkish aid legislation or Truman Doctrine; the Marshall Plan; and the North Atlantic Alliance. Clifford's memo- randum summarized the situation as follows: The gravest problem facing the United States today is that of Ameri- can relations with the Soviet Union. The solution of that problem may de- termine whether or not there will be a third World War. Soviet leaders appear to be conducting their nation on a course of aggrandizement de- signed to lead to eventual world domin- ation by the USSR. Their goal, and their policies designed to reach it, are in direct conflict with American ideals, and the United States has not yet been able to persuade Stalin and his associates that world peace and prosperity lie not in the direction in which the Soviet Union is moving but in the opposite direction of 2 SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET international cooperation and friend- ship. 1/* Postwar US foreign policy, shaped by aims toward world peace, awakened only slowly to the dan- ger of the Russian threat at home and abroad. At home, a tocsin was sounded in 1948 by the exposure of the extent of the Russian espionage that had been conducted in the United States. Featured prominently in all of the media was the indictment of Mr. Alger Hiss of the Department of State. The related confessions of Mr. Whittaker Chambers and Mrs. Elizabeth Bentley were disconcerting disclo- sures of the perfidy of a wartime ally. Overseas, the organization of the Communist Information Bureau (Cominform) in September 1947 marked a resumption of the process of international revolution which purportedly had been discarded by the dissolution of the Communist International (Comintern) in 1943. This subversive formation was viewed by the American people as a portent of aggres- sive Russian intentions. - 3 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET The Communist efforts to disrupt the political- economic system of the Western World were reach- ing a crescendo by 1948. France and Italy were be- leaguered by a wave of Communist-inspired strikes. Italy was facing its first national election and the threat of a Communist victory. Greece was fighting the Communist guerrillas in its northern provinces. The Communist coup in Czechoslovakia in Feb- ruary 1948 was followed by a total blockade of Ber- lin and its subsequent relief by American airlift. In China the defeat of the Nationalists by the Com- munist armies was impending. In the Philippines the Government was under continuing guerrilla at- tacks by the Communist Hukbalahaps. US leaders were convinced that the Russian regime and its satellite satrapy were completely untrustworthy and, as later voiced by Premier Niki- ta S. Krushchev, out to "bury" the Americans. There was ample evidence to conclude that Russia aimed at hegemony over the industrial potential of Germany, France, Italy, and all of Europe. It was apparent that the Cominform was preparing to capitalize in 4 SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET the undeveloped countries on the political uncertain- ties brought about by the voluntary and involuntary decolonization of territories previously occupied by the European powers. With the imminent end of US nuclear monopoly following the explosion of an atomic bomb by the USSR in 1949, the US leaders did not know how far Russia might go Truman Doctrine icy came out in nism. This, of to attain its objectives. With the as a takeoff point, US national pol- favor of the containment of Commu- course, amounted to a decision to bring about a political confrontation with the Russians. It was to be a peaceful confrontation; but should Russia react with hostile moves, it was deemed prudent that the United States should quietly prepare itself for any eventuality (1 July 1952 was a target date frequently mentioned). Diplomatic and economic mea- sures would be the means of outright confrontation. The Marshall Plan and the North Atlantic Treaty fol- lowed on the heels of the Greek-Turkish aid provided under the Truman Doctrine; but it was recognized that these measures could have little lasting impact unless the subversive aggression of Communism could be halted. - 5 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET To gain ascendency, alternatives to the Com- munist ideology would require the strengthening and building of institutions of independent thought. At the same time, individuals and groups abroad moti- vated by political aspirations contrary to those of the Communists had few resources to advance their cause. They would need a strong source of secret support, financial, material and moral. It had to be secret to allay possible charges of foreign poli- tical meddling which might defeat the very purpose of the support. If covert aid of this sort were not forthcoming from the United States, it appeared that the Cominform might proceed unhampered in its pro- gram to envelop the world with Communist ideology. To this end the United States decided to stem Soviet underground subversive operations and to cre- ate a clandestine agency for that purpose. This would have to be a new organization in order not to militate against the clandestine collection of in- telligence and counterintelligence already assigned to the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) by the National Security Act of 1947. On 18 June 1948, by directive of the National Security Council (NSC), -6- SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET the task of confrontation on the clandestine front was assigned to the Office of Policy Coordination (OPC), then called the Office of Special Projects. OPC was formally established on 1 September 1948 and continued operating until its 1 August 1952 merger with OSO into a combined directorate which became the CIA Clandestine Service. The NSC directive which created OPC in 1948 gave it a loose charter to undertake the full range of covert activities incident to the conduct of se- cret political, psychological, and economic warfare together with preventive direct action (paramilitary activities) - all within the policy direction of the Departments of State and Defense. This authority superseded a previous and much more limited directive whereby the Office of Special Operations (OSO) was to engage in certain secret psychological activities along with its existing commitments for the conduct of espionage and counterespionage. The new 1948 di- rective took cognizance of "the vicious covert acti- vities of the USSR" and reflected the high state of arousal existing in US Government circles at that time. OPC was placed in CIA alongside OSO with an - 7 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET adjuration by the NSC that it was to operate as inde- pendently of the other offices of CIA as efficiency would permit. The head of OPC, Assistant Director of CIA for Policy Coordination (ADPC), was to be nominated by the Secretary of State (General George C. Marshall at the time) on the basis that he was to be acceptable to the Director of Central Intelli- gence (DCI) and appointed by the NSC. The appoint- ment was made in the summer of 1948. By collateral accord with State and Defense the DCI, Rear Admiral Roscoe H. Hillenkoetter, agreed that their policies would flow directly through de- partmental Designated Representatives to the head of OPC. When Lieutenant General Walter Bedell Smith re- placed Hillenkoetter in October 1950, he put a dif- ferent construction on the NSC directive. Thereafter, State and Defense policies reached OPC only through the DCI, who effectively installed himself in control of its operations. During the corporate life of OPC, the top of- fice of ADPC was held by just two individuals, Mr. Frank G. Wisner (1 September 1948 - 23 August 1951) and Colonel Kilbourne Johnston (23 August 1951 - - 8 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET 1 August 1952). Wisner, a man of intense applica- tion with a solid background in secret intelligence work, was a singular choice to create a covert or- ganization from scratch; and Johnston with much man- agerial experience was well qualified to organize that establishment toward a more orderly existence. Wisner was promoted in 1951 to become the Deputy Director for Plans (DDP), thereby assuming general direction of both OSO and OPC operations; and John- ston was General Smith's choice to succeed him as ADPC. The scope of the OPC effort and the mainten- ance of its relationships with the highest levels of State, Defense, the Joint Chiefs of Staff (JCS) and other governmental agencies was a tremendous challenge to these men and their staffs, and a heavy burden as well. Operational requirements em- anating from State, Defense, and JCS taxed OPC capa- cities from the very moment of its establishment. As the US Government increased the pace of peaceful confrontation (the cold war), OPC grew faster and ex- panded further than initially anticipated. Operational directives issued from the NSC in � 9 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � � � a seemingly unending stream to the Departments of State and Defense which in turn called on OPC for covert support. Its relationships with these de- partments and with the JCS were salutary on the whole. There were however some temporary moments of tension with State's propaganda office and with the psychological warfare office of the Army, as well as with the Far East Command. Generally, they were all soon quieted, but one particular point of discomfort persisted. In 1949, inadvertently preci- pitated by CIA, a security and loyalty investigation of Mr. John Paton Davies, a senior Foreign Service Officer on State's policy Planning Staff, created considerable fanfare.* It generated extensive com- ment in the media over a period of several years and came to be a cause of chagrin to OPC. To the United States and to OPC the conduct of political and psychological warfare in peacetime was a new art. Some of the techniques were known but doctrine and experience were lacking. OPC was to learn by doing. By 1952 OPC had built an organization - 10 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET capable of executing covert action on a worldwide scale. It had gone through a period of rapid expan- sion in terms of both people and money. The secret war provided an im- mediate area of confrontation and, as a consequence, there was much governmental pressure to "get on with it." Operations grew apace, some successful and some not, as revealed by a quick look at what happened during the 1948-1952 period. In the years 1948 to 1950, OPC concentrated its efforts on Europe and the West. Its representatives were placed first in the Western European countries excepted); then in some of the Middle East- ern states, and South Asia; and in the Far Eastern coun- tries. South America and sub-Sahara Africa were low on the priority list. At first most of the OPC sta- tions and bases had only skeletal staffs. Their capa- bilities were limited; but their very presence was a SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) (b)(1) (b)(3) Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � cogent factor. Local individuals groups, and intel- ligence services quickly came to understand that there was a force abroad in the world around which they could rally and gain support in their own opposition to Communism. OPC began working with foreign intel- ligence services at an early date, The objective of the liaison was war planning, and, to a limited degree, political and psychological (PP) operations. Highest on the Department of State's list of priorities was the need to deal with the political leadership of the countless thousands of refugees and emigres who had fled to the West from Russia and the satellite countries. The immediate problem was to deal with them outside of the Iron Curtain. These leaders could not be endorsed to head govern- ments-in-exile for the realities of the situation ultimately demanded recognition of the Communist regimes that had assumed power; but they could be employed in the conduct of PP operations behond the Curtain. As a consequence, the National Committee for Free Europe (NCFE) was organized in 1949 with OPC support under the aegis of prominent financiers, � 12 � � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET lawyers, industrialists, and savants in order to give the political energy of these foreign nation- ality groups some direction. The main activity of NCFE centered on Radio Free Europe (RFE) with broad- casting facilities directed toward the satellites. Another project involved the organization of the American Committee for the Liberation of the Peoples of Rus- sia which established Radio Liberty to broadcast to Russia itself. RFE and Radio Liberty were still operating in 1971 and had figured prominently in the press. The Cominform, following its formation, con- cocted a number of wide-ranging front organizations (so called because they provided a facade for Com- munist indoctrination), including the World Peace Council; the World Federation of Democratic Youth; the World Federation of Scientific Workers; the In- ternational Union of Students; the Women's Inter- national Democratic Federation; the International - 13 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Organization of Journalists; and the International Association of Democratic Lawyers. These international organizations spoke out in favor of peace and solidarity in order to prepare the unwary for subtle indoctrination into the Com- munist ideology. As instruments of psychological warfare, their announced aims were so estimable that it was difficult to devise a means of defense except in kind. Principally although not exclusively in the West, OPC became active in sponsoring rival in- ternational organizations of a non-Communist hue, specifically in the cultural, youth and student, veterans', women's, labor, and lawyers' fields. Certain labor operations had been instigated by the Economic Cooperation Administration (ECA) be- fore OPC came into being. As a consequence, OPC in- itially concentrated its efforts within the circum- ference of the trade union movement with the assist- ance of the ECA which had certain counterpart funds available for the purpose, - 14 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET produce a significant opposition to the Communist- dominated syndicate which, it appears, would have become overwhelmingly dominant had it gone on un- checked. In France, the democratic unions, although their leadership was weak, were able to bring about the failure of the Communist-inspired port strikes called to prevent the off-loading of the first ship- ment of US assistance materials. Some of this activity extended outward toward East Germany, Czechoslovakia, and the other satellites. In Munich, RFE established its programming headquarters and a part of its broad- casting equipment; other facilities were in Lisbon, - 15 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Portugal. The US policy of containment was soon tested by Communists when the Republic of Korea was invaded on 25 June 1950. Up to this point, OPC's responsi- bility for preventive direct action or PM activity or unconventional warfare as it came to be known - had been limited to staybehind networks Much of this effort Treaty Organization countries had been undertaken - the plans and preparations for in the event of a future war. was in support of North Atlantic (NATO) planning in the European Much of the preparatory work - 16 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Korea precipi- tated a call for immediate PM operations in support of US participation in the United Nations (UN) in- tervention. OPC's effort in the Far East had not made much headway up to 1950 except for certain nascent psy- chological operations directed against the and against the Communist revolutionaries in Southeast Asia. This was due in part to the problem of an overburdened staff. A principal obstacle, however, was the fact that Gen- eral Douglas MacArthur was as chary of CIA as he had been of the Office of Strategic Services (OSS). Now he wanted assistance from wherever possible, including OPC. Having reached a modus vivendi with the Far East Command (FEC), OPC's Pacific operations ex- panded rapidly. Korea provided a testing ground for the support of conventional warfare with unconven- tional methods. The Americans had learned a great deal about unconventional offensive tactics in World War II but the Communist states had learned from the - 17 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Soviets a great deal about defensive tactics. As a result, unconventional warfare in Korea was some- thing of a standoff. Some American aviators were recovered by "rat-line" operations.* A number of harassment operations, conducted overland and by small boats in coastal waters, were carried out suc- cessfully. It was quickly apparent that the Com- munist regimes knew a great deal about how to deal with their internal security; consequently little resistance by the civilian population could be lo- cated in the north on which either intelligence or action networks could be constructed by OSO and OPC respectively. * Specific routes over which escapers and evaders are passed through safe houses and safe areas to neutral or friendly territory. - 18 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 19 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET - 20 - SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Sometimes errors were made because officers were bemused by their own creative urges and ventured too far into activity that was overt by nature and not OPC's business. Ill-starred ventures into the production of motion pictures demonstrated this point. There were many sound decisions and some injudi- cious ones; but the margin for error, it is clear, decreased as experience was gained. When Smith became DCI in October 1950, he was perplexed, if not dumbfounded, at the wide-ranging responsibilities of OPC. A few months before his appointment the NSC had decided to expand US PP ac- tivities. Encouraged by some apparent cracks in the Bloc structure, there was even talk of separating the USSR from some of its satellites. OPC had been told to accelerate its activity but no one knew how far it was to go or from whence were to come the means to get there. At an early moment, Smith deliberated on the - 22 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET merger of OPC and OSO but deferred any action for fear that the self-revealing activities of OPC might interfere with OSO's long-range espionage and coun- terespionage (CE) mission. He decided to bridge the duality of their overseas representations by super- imposing Senior Representatives of his own choosing and reporting to him. In May 1951 Smith decided to seek further guid- ance from the NSC as to the scope and pace of OPC operations. He requested that the NSC initiate a com- prehensive review of covert operations in light of the increase in their magnitude, that such review re- state the responsibilities involved for US covert operations, and that if the review should reaffirm CIA's covert operational responsibility, he should be provided with a way to obtain the necessary sup- port from other agencies. He received half an answer from the NSC. The operational responsibility of CIA for covert activity was reaffirmed. But the review of operations and methods for the provision of their support was placed in the hands of a committee - the Psychological Stra- tegy Board (PSB). Evidently Smith was to have the - 23 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET satisfaction of answering his own question, for he soon became chairman of the PSB. Separated from the making of strategic policy as it was, the PSB proved to be a frail reed, but it was the beginning of a process whereby mechanics were later established for better relating the conduct of covert operations to US national strategy. The answer from NSC, unsatisfactory though it was, may have been the turning point in General Smith's considerations of merging OSO and OPC, a course urged on him by his deputy, Mr. Allen W. Dulles, and his operational deputy, Wisner. At least he knew that for the foreseeable future he would be privileged or saddled - depending on how he looked at it - with the responsibility for conducting covert operations. A number of actions began to take place within OSO and OPC and between them, looking toward integration. By the time of the 1 August 1952 merger, OPC was active in all spheres of covert activity and, under the NSC direction and within departmental policy, was expending a major share of the CIA budget In terms of the tools of its trade, it had acquired many installations and - 24 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET facilities at home and abroad and had accumulated against planning contingencies for wartime a huge stockpile of ordnance items. It had acquired sub- stantial numbers of aircraft for support purposes and the Air Force had undertaken to allocate to OPC support four air wings, again to fulfill planning contingencies. In strength levels OPC had overtaken and passed OSO. In the course of its growth, OPC had found it necessary to undergo several major reorganizations. By 1952 the leaders of CIA were of the opinion that OPC had grown to a point where a period of consoli- dation of its resources was in order. On the eve of - 25 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET merger, a review board of senior OPC officers was ap- pointed by General Smith to reduce OPC's monetary commitments by as much as one-third. It quickly be- came known as "the murder board." Although many projects were earmarked for termination, their li- quidation was found to be a complicated and some- times painful procedure. Further sorting out, it ap- peared, would have to take place after 1 August 1952 within the framework of the merged service. In concluding this introduction to the history of OPC's tough encounter with the Soviets in the covert action (CA) field, it would be exciting to say that OPC emerged as the winner, but the most one can say is that the contest was a "see-saw" affair. The Soviets were ready at the end of World War II with an aggressive game plan and had taken an early lead. OPC, a new organization, was faced with trying to plan a catch-up game from the very start. No one can say how and when the contest ended - or if it has ever ended - but the Soviet Union no longer had the field completely to itself. - 26 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET II. Enabling Directives and Related Actions A. Introduction (NSC 4-A) At the end of World War II, CA operations car- ried out by OSS and other agencies during the period of hostilities had come to a standstill with little indication as to when, how, or if they might be re- sumed short of another war. The secret intelligence and counterintelligence (CI) activity of OSS had passed into the trusteeship of the Strategic Services Unit (SSU) on 1 October 1945. Its uncertain future was partially resolved when President Truman on 22 January 1946 directed the coordination of intelligence activities, includ- ing the formation of the Central Intelligence Group 3/ (CIG). � This directive contained certain phrases that were ultimately to have significance in connec- tion with the future conduct of covert operations. The DCI was directed to perform those intelli- gence-related services which could be accomplished centrally with more efficacy as might be determined by the Secretaries of State, War, and Navy. The DCI - 27 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET was also to "perform such other functions and duties relating to intelligence affecting national security as the President or the National Intelligence Author- ity" might direct. Although it was not clear that this clause envisioned the future conduct of covert activities, the same language was repeated in the National Security Act of 1947, which among its other provisions established the NSC and under it CIA to succeed CIG. Whatever the original intent, the NSC was to interpret these words as sufficient authori- zation to place the conduct of covert activities in CIA in tandem with OSO which was the office within the new CIA structure already conducting espionage. 4/ and counterespionage on foreign soil. As US leaders in the postwar era came to rec- ognize the need to repulse the underground attack by the USSR, countermeasures received the consider- ation of an interagency committee consisting of State Department and the Military Services which emerged as the State, Army, Navy, Air Force Coordi- nating Committee (SANACC).* Based on its deliberations The State, War, Navy Coordinating Comittee (SWNCC) formed 29 November - 4 December 1944, was renamed SANACC on 4 November 19471 and was terminated on 30 June 1949. - 28 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET a decision to engage in covert psychological action was secretly formalized on 17 December 1947 by the NSC through the issuance of NSC 4-A. (See Attach- ment B.) This directive placed responsibility for covert operations on the DCI, directing him "to in- itiate and conduct, within the limit of available funds, covert psychological operations designed to counteract Soviet and Soviet-inspired activities." The DCI, Hillenkoetter, who served from I May 1947 to 7 October 1950, was not altogether convinced as to the advisability of conducting covert psycho- logical operations in combination with secret intel- ligence operations. It was a responsibility, more- over, that he was ill-prepared to accept, as he was then deeply involved in organizational problems in- cident to the establishment of CIA. Nevertheless, Hillenkoetter, shaped by military tradition, de- ferred to his superiors in the NSC. B. OPC's Basic Directive (NSC 10/2) The Department of State apparently felt that it did not have enough influence over the burgeoning ac- tivities of the Special Procedures Group (SPG), the CIA operating component which Hillenkoetter had - 29 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET established within OSO in response to NSC 4-A.* State, moreover, looked with a jaundiced eye on the planning activities then taking place within the JCS with respect to secret psychological and political warfare. Regarding itself as the prime source of policy in these matters, State was ready to jump at almost any chance to put a check-rein on the JCS, even to the acceptance of some joint vehicle for the conduct of covert activities. At the same time, sen- timent for a more encompassing program of covert ac- tivity was growing at Cabinet level. The.concate- nation of all of these factors led to the issuance of a far-reaching directive on 18 June 1948, set forth in NSC 10/2, which established within CIA the new Office of Special Projects (OSP) "to plan and conduct covert operations." (See Attachment C.) This was the basic directive leading to the es- tablishment on 1 September 1948 of OPC, an innocuous title replacing OSP included in the initial wording of NSC 10/2. It stated that the OPC chief was to When established on 1 January 1948, this unit was called the Special Procedures Branch. It was re- designated Special Procedures Group on 22 March 1948. - 30 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET report directly to the DCI, but to the maximum de- gree consistent with efficiency, OPC was to operate independently of other CIA components. Policy guid- ance as to covert operations was to flow from the 0(' senior levels ,aiState and Defense, and the JCS was to be consulted on the planning for covert activi- ties in wartime. However, on the question of the responsibilities for the conduct of covert activi- ties in wartime (as opposed to planning them), the document left considerable room for argument. The external channels of OPC guidance and di- rection deriving from this directive had resulted from the fact that State and Defense were both deter- mined to provide certain policy signals without ac- tually playing in the secret political and psycho- logical warfare game. CIA was again specified as the agency within which the instrument for these opera- tions was to be housed. Both the Hoover Commis- sion's working committee on National Security Organ- ization under the chairmanship of Mr. Ferdinand Eberstadt and NSC's Survey Group reviewing the na- tional intelligence structure, comprising Messrs. Dulles, Mathias F. Correa, and William H. Jackson, - 31 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET which were active during the months that NSC 10/2 was in formulation, voiced the opinion that all clan- destine activities to whatever end should be con- ducted in concert. Since CIA was already carrying out secret espionage and CE operations, both commit- tees concluded that it should conduct covert acti- vities also. Their advice was followed. There is ample evidence among the historical documents of the time to indicate that interdepart- mental rivalry in relation to the conduct of the bur- geoning cold war was rampant and had its impact on the method whereby policy guidance to OPC was con- 5/ stituted by the NSC. OPC was on notice that it would have to walk the fence between its two mentors, State and Defense, with a delicate balance.* The established cover story of OPC was based on the presumption that its existence would soon be known, or at least suspected, as its operations There is one document in the OPC files which reveals a high level of arousal within State caused by the discovery that the JCS were about to submit a psychological warfare plan to the NSC. This ap- pears in an internal State memorandum dated 3 June 1948, handed to Wisner by Davies sometime after the former's appointment as OPC head. 6/ - 32 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET unfolded. Its presence within the CIA structure might then be imputed. It appeared advisable there- fore that a fable be formulated in such fashion as to substitute vagueness for any strenuous effort at total secrecy that might not long be sustained. That was the thinking behind the choice of the name: Office of Policy Coordination. Its respon- sibilities were covered under the following legend: OPC was established to coordinate the activities of CIA with national security policy as adopted by those agencies of government responsible for the formation of such policy. 7/ It was felt that in this role, as a sort of a middleman, OPC might legitimately and logically eval- uate both the intelligence and planning aspects of various covert activities. In explaining the OPC role to persons with a legitimate interest, no men- tion was to be made of action programs; only its planning, intelligence coordinating, and defensive aspects were to be stressed. To the greatest extent possible, contacts were to be arranged through se- cure cutouts, with no reference whatsoever to OPC. The "covert operations" to be handled by OPC were defined by NSC 10/2 as all activities (except - 33 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET as noted) which were to be conducted or sponsored by the US Government against hostile foreign states or groups, or in support of friendly foreign states or groups. They were to be so planned and executed that any US Government responsibility for them would not be evident to unauthorized persons. If uncovered the US Government was to be able to disclaim plausi- bly any responsibility for them. Specifically, such operations were to include any covert activities re- lated to: propaganda; economic warfare; preventive direct action, including sabotages antisabotage, de- molition and evacuation measures; subversion against hostile states, including assistance to underground resistance movements, guerrillas and refugee libera- tion groups; and support of indigenous anti-Communist elements in threatened countries of the Free World. Such operations were not to include armed conflict by recognized military forces, and excluded espionage, CE, and cover and deception for military operations. The exception noted in the preceding paragraph referred to a statement in paragraph 4 of the direc- tive which stated: - 34 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET In active theaters of war where American forces are engaged, covert operations will be conducted under the direct command of the American Theater Commander and orders there- for will be transmitted through the Joint Chiefs of Staff unless other- wise directed by the President. This language was foredoomed to be the cause of much contention between OPC and the JCS as to their re- spective roles in wartime in regard to the conduct of covert activity. C. Understanding of 6 August 1948 on Implement- ing NSC 10/2 On 6 August 1948 a meeting to clarify the im- plementation of NSC 10/2 was attended by: DCI Hillen- koetter; Colonel Ivan D. Yeaton, and Mr. Robert Blum, representing the Secretary of Defense; Mr. George F. Kennan, chief of State's Policy Planning Staff; Ad- miral Sidney W. Souers, Executive Secretary, NSC; and Wisner, Deputy Assistant to the Secretary of State for Occupied Areas who was about to take over on 1 September 1948 as CIA's Assistant Director for Policy Coordination (ADPC). It is reasonable to conclude that before taking that office Wisner was asking for an agreed interpretationJof the parameters of the task - 35 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET he was about to undertake. A memorandum of conver- sation and understanding was agreed to and initialed by those present. (See Attachment D.) Within the context of the understanding reached, OPC was to be given considerable latitude to operate independently of the CIA machinery of command and administration, with the proviso, however, that the DCI was to be "kept informed in regard to all important projects and decisions." "Important" was not delineated and as it turned out, the determination was largely left up to the head of the new instrumentality for covert activities. It was clear, moreover, that depart- mental advice was to flow to the ADPC directly, not through the DCI.* Wisner was installed as ADPC on 1 September 1948. The relationship of OPC to CIA during the period when Admiral Hillenkoetter was DCI is described by Dr. Edward P. Lilly, an historical observer, in the following terms: OPC was in CIA administratively and with a strict reading of NSC 10/2, the Director of CIA would have control - 36 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET over its policy and operations. When it commenced to operate, how- ever, because of the personalities in- volved, because OPC received instruc- tions and guidance directly from the Secretaries of State and Defense, and because of the special sensitivity of its operations, there was a general agreement among the officials involved that OPC should be a separate and inde- pendent entity within CIA. Independ- ence even went so far that OPC's intel- ligence requests were handled by CIA as requests of a separate agency. OPC, on its part, was reluctant to tell the intelligence side of CIA about its op- erations even though the DCI had been given the responsibility of policy co- ordination and of appealing to NSC if policy disagreements arose. The prac- tice developed, however, that the de- partmental policy representatives only consulted with OPC, and the DCI was initially left out of covert planning. This procedure initially gave OPC a relatively greater freedom of action, but removed the single responsible authority who could decide if a parti- cular covert operation was in accord with American policy. 8/ D. Financing OPC - 37 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Early in 1949 legislation highly important to the conduct of covert activities was enacted. Al- though the National Security Act of 1947 had given statutory recognition to CIA, it did not include enabling legislation authorizing the DCI to acquire 9/ or administer CIA funds in his own right. He continued to depend upon allocations from the Depart- mental Secretaries and tenuous understandings with Congress, the General Accounting Office (GAO), and certain other Government agencies as to the purposes for which available funds could legally and properly be expended. On 20 June 1949, Public Law 110, 81st Congress, was approved "to provide for the adminis- tration of the Central Intelligence Agency, estab- lished pursuant to Section 102, National Security Act of 1947 and for other purposes." This legisla- tion provided specifically that: . . . the sums made available to the Agency may be expended without regard to the provisions of law and regulations relating to the expendi- ture of Government funds; and for objects of a confidential, extraordinary, - 38 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET or emergency nature, such expendi- tures to be accounted for solely on the certificate of the Director and deemed a sufficient voucher for the amount therein certified. This would appear to have given the DCI the authority to set up an organizational system to con- duct clandestine activities in any way he saw fit, subject only to the rule of prudence and good sense. However, since established patterns of governmental procedure appeared to present the minimum risk to future interpellation, Admiral Hillenkoetter and his advisers chose not to pioneer. E. Revision in the Understanding on Implementing NSC 10/2 General Smith replaced Admiral Hillenkoetter as DCI on 7 October 1950. He was the appointee of President Truman and had direct access to the Presi- dent when required. Smith, differing from his pre- decessor, held uncompromising views with respect to the authorities and responsibilities of command. He determined that OPC would be an integral part of CIA responsive to his policy guidance. Three years later, in 1953, General Smith was to describe his views on NSC 10/2 to the Senate - 39 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Foreign Relations Committee in a hearing on his nomination to the post of Under Secretary of State as follows: The Office of Policy Coordination . . . was set up under rather pecu- liar circumstances. It was created as a result of the recognition that something had to be done in the way of the cold war, and it was created at a time when, as you know, Secretary Johnson was Secretary of Defense, and Secretary Acheson, Secretary of State.* � Anything that was created at that time in that field inevitably had to be a sort of compromise, and that was what this OPC thing was. It was cre- ated by an order of the National Se- curity Council, which I thought was not a particularly sound order when I read it. It put in the Central Intelligence Agency this entity which was actually in but not of the agency. It took its direction largely from a policy group of officers of the Defense and State Departments. Admiral Hillenkoetter felt he did not have very much control over it. Smith was somewhat hazy in his chronology. These positions were held respectively by James V. Forrestal and General George C. Marshall when OPC was created on 1 September 1948. Johnson was ap- pointed on 28 March 1949 and Acheson on 21 Janu- ary 1949. - 40 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET On the other hand, it was the place where the money was spent, and all the rest of the agency was sus- picious of it. 10/ Smith was advised by senior members of the CIA staff to seek modification or amendment to NSC 10/2 to eliminate the provisions which served to act in derogation of the DCI's full authority and responsi- bility for covert operations and to clarify its most controversial provision which pertained to wartime planning and covert operations in military theaters: Smith was not prepared to move in this fashion. At the same time, he found it impossible to accept a situation wherein the authority of the DCI to allo- cate resources was being hamstrung by the fact that the Departments of State and Defense were directing OPC policy without his prior approval. Smith felt secure enough in his position to conclude that he could bring OPC under his full con- trol by a change in existing procedures without open- ing up NSC 10/2 to modification. Accordingly, he instructed Wisner, OPC chief, to advise State, De- fense, and the JCS that the 6 August 1948 memorandum was no longer applicable or effective in the light of altered circumstances (apparently altered in the - 41 - � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET sense that he was on the scene). Wisner's compliance with this instruction was reported to the DCI on 12 October 1950. (See Attach- ment E.) Wisner advised the representatives of State, Defense, and the JCS that General Smith saw no immedi- ate necessity for a revision of NSC 10/2 in order to accomplish the full integration of OPC as an element of CIA under the authority and command of the DCI. Wisner explained that the advice and policy guidance from State, Defense, and the JCS would not thereafter be regarded by Smith as placing any or all of them in the position of giving orders or instructions to OPC. Such guidance thereafter would be considered as com- ing to CIA as an organization and not merely to OPC. Smith then proceeded to take direct control of OPC, and OSO as well, by means of an internal reor- ganization which arrogated the principal supporting functions to a deputy director for administration re- sponsible directly to the DCI. Thus, by taking con- trol of resources (money and manpower) through a channel reporting directly to him, General Smith in effect took control of operations themselves. - 42 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET F. Revision of Paragraph 4, NSC 10/2 By October 1950 controversy between OPC and the JCS over the interpretation of paragraph 4 of NSC 10/2, aggravated by the ambiguity surrounding command relationships in Korea and the Far East, had become so egregious that Smith was persuaded to re- verse his previous decision and to seek a modifica- tion of the directive. The interpretation of the paragraph was, according to Wisner, "the subject of more divergent views and conflicting constructions than any other portion of the paper." From the van- tage point of 20 years later, the divergent construc- tions may seem somewhat recondite; but a sense of reality is restored when it is recognized that the interpretations were being made by dedicated plan- ners who believed that the United States was living in imminent peril of World War III. Following conversations with Smith, Wisner on 23 October 1950 wrote a memorandum confirming the need for and reasons behind a definitive and autho- ritative interpretation of the troublesome para- 11/ graph. Wisner pointed out that the basic dif- ficulties lay in the fact that nowhere in NSC 10/2 did it - 43 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET specifically provide that OPC was to be "responsi- ble for the conduct of covert operations in wartime." Related problems involved were: first, the specific participation of OPC planners in both peacetime and wartime preparation of plans for wartime covert op- erations; and second, the delineation of the manner in which covert operations would be set up and di- rected in military theaters.* Paragraph 4 was suspended on 14 December 1950 by the NSC at the suggestion of General Smith in or- der that a supplementary draft directive tentatively designated as NSC 10/3 could be considered, incor- porating a rewording of the controversial paragraph 4 along with certain other changes.** The JCS found NSC 10/3 unacceptable and at the 11 April 1951 NSC meeting it was withdrawn when a rewording of paragraph - 44 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET 4 proposed by General Smith was approved, as fol- lows: In time of war, �or when the Presi- dent directs, all plans for covert operations shall be coordinated with the JCS. In active theaters of war where American forces are engaged, covert operations will be conducted under the direct command of the Amer- ican Theater Commander and orders therefor will be transmitted through the Joint Chiefs of Staff unless otherwise directed by the President. 12/ G. Scope and Pace of OPC Operations (NSC 68); NSC 10/5 and the Psychological Strategy Board NSC 10/2 remained in force with this revision until 23 October 1951 when it was supplemented by further NSC action with regard to the "scope and pace of covert operations" through publication of a document identified as NSC 10/5. In early 1950 US policymakers had determined that a more rapid buildup in the basic potential for waging cold war should be undertaken by all relevant branches of government. Thus, the formulation of a cold-war policy and appraisal of the assets neces- sary to wage it was undertaken by the NSC, culmin- ating in the issuance in April 1950 of NSC 68. - 45 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET NSC 68 provided for a nonmilitary counter- offensive against the USSR and for recapture of psy- chological initiative in the following terms: In regard to U.S.S.R. and satel- lites, offensive operations short of war, including intensive overt pro- paganda, encouragement to and organ- ization of exiled groups and defec- tors, energetic prosecution of ap- propriate covert operations within the Soviet orbit, and vigorous exploi- tation of favorable opportunities as they occur, e.g. Korea . . . [were to get underway.] 13/ A State representative on 19 April 1950 briefed a number of top OPC officials by citing the particu- lar NSC 68 provisions applying to the planning and operations of OPC as follows:* At the same time, we should take dynamic steps to reduce the power and influence of the Kremlin inside the Soviet Union and other areas under its control. The objective would be the establishment of friendly regimes not under Kremlin domination. Such action is essential to encourage the Kremlin's attention, keep it off balance and force an increased expend- iture of Soviet resources in counter- action. In other words, it would be the current Soviet cold war technique used against the Soviet Union. The underlining was made by the State repre- sentative, Robert P. Joyce. - 46 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Tasks relating to the OPC mission were described as: Development of programs designed to build and maintain confidence among other peoples in our strength and resolution, and to wage overt psychological warfare calculated to encourage mass defections from Soviet allegiance and to frustrate the Krem- lin design in other ways. Intensification of affirmative and timely measures and okperations by covert means in the fields of economic warfare and political and psychologi- cal warfare with a view to fomenting and supporting unrest and revolt in selected strategic satellite countries. 14/ In the course of its considerations, NSC called for budgetary estimates constituting a six-year pro- jection for the period beginning 1 July 1950 and end- ing 30 June 1957. The assumptions conveyed to OPC in May 1950 in connection with the formulation of these projections were briefly that the US Govern- ment had decided to make a major effort in the field of covert operations; that there would be no overt hostilities during the period under consideration; and that, if the measures espoused by NSC 68 were successful, a shooting war might be avoided. None- theless, preparations for a shooting war (overt hos- tilities) were to be made and the year 1954 was - 47 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET regarded as crucial. 15/ It was readily apparent that the pace of the cold war envisioned by the policymakers called for a more rapid expansion of resources than OPC had theretofore been able to undertake. A memorandum 7 written in November 195;.. commented on the fact that such broad and comprehensive undertakings as delin- eated by NSC 68 could only be accomplished by the establishment of a worldwide structure for covert operations on a much grander scale than OPC had pre- viously contemplated. It would be a task similar in concept, magnitude, and complexity to the crea- tion of widely deployed military forces together with the logistical support required to conduct mani- fold, complex, and delicate operations in a wide variety of overseas locations. 16/ These considerations had led Smith to seek clarification from the NSC. In a paper dated 8 May 1951, entitled "Scope and Pace of Covert Operations" sometimes known as the "Magnitude Paper," he com- mented on the extent of the resources which would be needed to accomplish the mission apparently envi- sioned under NSC 68 and concluded that a program of - 48 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET 17/ such magnitude required further review by the NSC. He recommended: (a) that NSC should initiate a comprehensive review of the covert operations situ- ation in view of the magnitude issue; (b) that this review should contain a restatement or redetermin- ation of the several responsibilities and authori- ties involved in US covert operations; (c) that if the review should result in a reaffirmation of CIA's covert operational responsibility, then CIA should be provided the necessary support from other govern- ment agencies to insure the successful discharge of the responsibility, with certain specific assurances as to policy and planning relationships and provi- sion of the needed quantities of personnel and lo- gistical support; and (d) that guidance for covert operations of concern to more than one department should be coordinated and issued to CIA (and to other participating agences) by the newly created Psycho- logical Strategy Board (PSB). PSB had been constituted on 4 April 1951 by Presidential Directive.* It was to be responsible � 49 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET for the formulation and promulgation of over-all national psychological objectives, policies, and pro- grams and for the coordination and evaluation of the national psychological effort. There was reason to doubt, however, that the PSB would be able to muster the authority required for the proper discharge of its responsibilities. NSC 10/5 was issued on 23 October 1951, re- sponding to General Smith's "Magnitude Paper" and calling for an intensification of covert operations. (See Attachment F.) It "reaffirmed" the responsi- bility and authority of the DCI for the conduct of covert operations under NSC 10/2 subject to the ap- proval of the PSB. NSC 10/5 established the general order of emphasis for covert operations: (a) to place maximum strain on the Soviet power structure; (b) to strengthen the orientation of the free world toward the United States; and (c) to develop underground re- sistance and facilitate covert and guerrilla opera- tions in strategic areas. The role of the PSB was defined as follows: (a) to determine the desirability and feasibility of covert operational programs and of individual major - 50 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET projects; (b) to establish the scope, pace, and tim- ing of covert operations and the allocation of pri- orities among them; and (c) to coordinate action to ensure the adequate provision of personnel, funds, and logistical and other support to the DCI for the carrying out of approved operations. NSC 10/5 di- rected that the development of underground resist- ance and the conduct of covert and guerrilla opera- tions should wherever practicable provide bases on which the military might expand military operations in time of war within active theaters of operations. The directive called for the advice and collabora- tion of the JCS in the formulation of PM operations during the period of the cold war. As it applied to OPC, the purpose of NSC 10/5 was to provide through the PSB an authoritative as- sessment of the covert activity being conducted and to furnish policy guidance as to the future extent of such activity. It is evident that the PSB fell short of this purpose. As the "Jackson Committee"* was later to find, the creation of the PSB was based - 51 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET on a misconception that psychological warfare strat- egy could exist apart from the total national strat- egy. H. Summary NSC 10/2 was the basic national directive un- der which OPC was constituted and covert activities begun. NSC 10/5 was intended to refine the earlier directive by providing the method whereby OPC could receive guidance as to the scope and pace of those activities. It fell short in this respect but did reconfirm the fact that responsibility of CIA for covert activities was to continue. In addition to these basic directives, there was a steady stream of NSC policy guidances with respect to specific areas of the world or to speci- fic problems. Sometimes CIA was called upon by name for covert action but generally CIA's role was more indirect through its provision of covert support to articulated courses of action assigned to State and - 52 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Defense.* NSC 10/2 was, in effect, a treaty between State and Defense to define how US covert activities were to be conducted. Whether it was a sound idea to place the instrument for conducting those activi- ties in CIA was thought to be beside the point. The executive arm of the Government was convinced that immediate action had to be taken to forestall "the vicious covert activities of the USSR."** CIA pre- sented the only vehicle immediately available for undertaking such countermeasures without instituting action by Congress which would certainly make for de- lay and might in the long run prove to be unobtain- able. Like most treaties NSC 10/2 contained certain seeds of discord, such as: � 53 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET a. The requirements placed on OPC by State and Defense were widely disparate. One involved the.conduct of political and psycho- logical warfare; the other, plans and prepar- ations for paramilitary operations. This dichotomy of interests immediately posed a problem in priorites to OPC. It did not have either the personal or physical resources to meet both demands. b. With Hillenkoetter acceding, the di- rective permitted the uncanalized admission of policy. direction from State and Defense into OPC. With this shortcutting of command channels, the relationship between Hillen- koetter and Wisner became an uneasy one at best. In a memorandum dated 19 October 1948, General Counsel Lawrence R. Houston pointed out to the DCI a number of debatable provi- sions and interpretations deriving from the NSC 10/2 paper. 18/ Houston argued that there were no means under the existing law by which the Director could divest himself of, or be separated from, his personal responsibility � 54 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET for the expenditure of unvouchered funds. Houston suggested a further clarification by NSC to the end that the DCI should have full administrative control of OPC personnel and supplies, final authority over the expendi- ture of its funds, and the right to initiate or veto its projects. In the alternative, if control and responsibility were to remain out- side of CIA, then it should be made clear that the Director's responsibility was specifically limited to that of affording housekeeping sup- port only. There was no clarification of NSC 10/2 until General Smith handled the matter to his own satisfaction by taking over full con- trol of OPC. c. Hillenkoetter made an accurate fore- cast in arguing that the proviso permitting OPC to operate independently of other CIA com- ponents would lead to continued argument and bickering over financial management. That in fact turned out to be the case.** - 55 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET d. Until the controversial paragraph 4 was changed by mutual consent, the original wording led to endless negotiations and de- bate between CIA and the JCS on issues of "cold war" versus "hot war" responsibilities and prerogatives. e. Covert operations pertaining to eco- nomic warfare were to be conducted by OPC "under the guidance of the departments and agencies responsible for the planning of eco- nomic warfare" but where such responsibili- ties finally rested never came to light. f. NSC 10/2 was an adequate document to get covert operations under way. As time went on and operations multiplied, however, it became clear that some determination would have to be made as to the extent and source of the resources to be devoted to the covert effort. An attempt to remedy this deficiency within the provisions of NSC 10/5 fell short of the mark. In fact, the creation of ma- chinery to supply high policy in this cate- gory involved a whole historical episode in - 56 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET itself, extending far into the future after OPC disappeared as such. - 57 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 58 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 59 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 60 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 61 - SECRET , Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 62 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 63 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 64 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 65 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 66 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 1 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 67 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 68 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 69 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 70 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 71 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 72 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 73 � SECRET , Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 74 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 75 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 76 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 77 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 78 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 79 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 80 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 81 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 82 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 83 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 84 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 85 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 86 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) - 87 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 88 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 89 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 90 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 91 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 92 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 93 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 94 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 95 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 96 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 97 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 98 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 99 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET - 100 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 101 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 102 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 103 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 104 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 105 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 106 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 107 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 108 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 109 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 110 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 111 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 112 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 113 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 114 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 115 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Amenomor Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 116 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 117 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 118 SECRET pproved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 119 - SECRET pproved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 120 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 121 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 122 � SECRET pproved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 123 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 124 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 125 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 126 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 127 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 129 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 (b)(1) b)(3) - 130 - Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET renamed divisions instead of staffs. The Programs and Planning Division was split internally into three staffs: Staff I, with a supporting secre- tariat, was given the responsibility for policy planning and review, for war mobilization planning, for liaison control, and for intelligence support; Staff II consisted of a new geographic planning structure with area branches paralleling those in the operating structure; Staff III encompassed the seven previously existing functional program branches The Operations Division consisted of the five pre- vious area branches plus a sixth Foreign Branch F, added in the March reshuffle, responsible for opera- tions originating in the United States. The Oper- ations Division also acquired a supporting staff, more in the nature of technical advisers than a staff, which was named the Operations Special Staff consisting of five groups, that is, Air Operations, Operational Security, Cover and Deception, Signal Operations, and Naval Operations (See Figure 3, page 132.) The modification made at the end of 1949 brought to OPC an organization that was much - 131 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 - SECRZT Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 133 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 134 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 135 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 136 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 138 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 139 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 140 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 141 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 142 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 143 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � � � I � 145 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 146 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 147 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 148 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 SECRET � 149 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET - 150 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 151 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 152 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 153 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 154 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 155 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 156 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 � 157 � Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 158 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 159 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 160 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 161 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 162 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 163 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 164 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 165 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 166 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 167 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 168 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 169 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 170 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 171 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 172 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 173 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 174 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 175 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET - 176 - SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 177 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 178 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 179 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 180 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 181 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 182 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 183 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 184 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 185 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 186 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � � � � 187 � SECRET I Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 188 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) - 189 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) - 190 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 191 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 192 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 193 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 194 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 195 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 196 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 197 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET 198 � _ SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 199 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 200 � SECRET , Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 201 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) - 202 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 203 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 204 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 205 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 206 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � �207 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 208 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 209 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 210 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 211 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 212 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 213 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 214 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) - 215 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 216 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 217 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 218 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 219 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 220 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 221 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 222 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 223 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 224 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 225 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 226 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 227 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 228 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 229 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET : (b)(1) (b)(3) - 230 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 I Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � � � 231 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 232 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 233 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) � 234 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 I Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � � � 235 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 236 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 I � � � Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 237 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 238 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 239 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 240 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 241 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 242 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 243 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 244 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 245 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 246 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 247 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 248 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET 249 � .... SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 250 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 251 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 252 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 253 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 1 SECRET [ (b)(1) (b)(3) - 254 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 255 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 256 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 257 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 258 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 259 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 260 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 261 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 262 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 263 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 264 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 265 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 266 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 267 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 268 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) - 269 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 270 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 271 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b (b - 272 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 273 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 274 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET (b)(1) (b)(3) - 275 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 276 - SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 277 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 SECRET � 278 � SECRET Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718 Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 CO1066718 Secret CIA Internal Use Only Access Controlled by DDP Secret Approved for Release: 2021/05/14 C01066718