COMMENTS BY CIA 'COORDINATING' PROCESSES WITH IAC AGENCIES

• Document Type: CREST
• Collection: General CIA Records
• Document Number (FOIA) /ESDN (CREST): CIA-RDP67-00059A000200120026-8
• Release Decision: RIFPUB
• Original Classification: S
• Document Page Count: 4
• Document Creation Date: November 16, 2016
• Document Release Date: April 18, 2000
• Sequence Number: 26
• Content Type: LIST

Approved For Release 2000/05/04: CIA-RDP67-00059AO002001
1. Pre *nt
ebs officially oonourm . In by the
agreed statement of substantial 61
nt; not nsteelyr those of (.LA;
2. Worhed out in practical de ail, this directive entails:
k over end above their awmal duties on the pm.
t CIA Reports and Estiaates shall
k on the part of CIA parsow+ l;
n of CIA publications.
It to beliMed that the ehtsf reasons advaneed to justify Int -
Considerable paper work for all depar co lerned;
fg. A delay
departmental. ooordimtior are:
hom greater conf idiswo in a re
god;
Tee or shall earry an
nter a dissenting opinion on
arthoritee to whom they are
be offered in opposition to the a
usttfiable waste of time for them affected by it;
of di
to Confuse
of the estaa .
me, US intelligee. is facing a most
folding of information which played
disaster. T f better personnel we
needed in CIA, they should be trensfs*red to
Agencies oars
Approved For Release 2000/05/04: CIA-RDP67-00059AO00200120026-8
F`r'om a broader
tion of reports after their tins of
ooi.nlons on intelligence estimates
aid the person who to called on to
nded disenesion of this subject.)
following objections might be raised:
f;a CIA report does, in fact, make we of all the inte'l.ligefoe
acilities of the Gove rareat In that every source of int lligsnoe
Coo dinsted reports are Isriwed fear all Intelligence
us agency is o n coneumntly to CL as wen as the
n ire -mans a are either to CIA or avail ab'l e
? hs ag+insies. (If t above pow are Dot
 Approved For Release 2000/05/04: CIA-RDP67-00059AO00200120026-8
-0 2 r
,k. The very assn tton that connwring oplujoes from the IAC
Apr*tsa fiend wi t to CIA reports ftnies the *el, principle
Cj;noy. The presupposes
C
are all assumptim
ly antommmm. if
the wait i e D t interdepartmental
w b*, and *"n, as Indicated above,
as withholding of information or f aisi-
ndt departmental ieweste. In short,
be actually the ventral intelligence agency
a sned,
any estimates it publishes should
t
,
,,
ibis and to be correct insofar an Una 'tntell
not, the US is, as in 1941, with a
l gen e,
ten teals to divide responeibilitr: CIA,
bee not have to stand solely rssponsibt e
MW point of Tim to allow tlr agog
tionai inte113ge to r4sbbed. bn the
should not be sailed up to bear part of
asW faulty intelligence re-ort pub _ishod
It sbou' d be noted that CIA will
probably
turity it dwpzA certain' y have until
or forced to stand on its "M I
test.
Approved For Release 2000/05/04: CIA-RDP67-00059AO00200120026-8
 Approved For Release 2000/05/04: CIA-RDP67-00059AO00200120026-8
A quie' check indicates that the tAO Agsneies have found it neewseotary
to enter contrary opinions on abet ens fam'th of 46 published t estimates.
one Agency
o>s;l
d
t
p
ee
,
With two emcep!tions in eneh of #teb two agencies dissen
has dissented an m W single raper. The Department of State has been the
wont dissenter.
Tb. ton dissents referred to below we reps aentative. It would be
herd to show that any of them represents a direct and =avoidable disagreews
with a as jor con zlvsi L+r . r' e"#11 to see how any of the dissents could be
helpful to a person using the st .S* for official purposes. Any of then
"
night lead to confession on his par
The abstracts below are not of course, eoncelusive but are intended to
give at least the in tenor of. the average dissents
-"Conseque,
Gre ! Awe'. "...d
Of Certain Courses of Action with Respect
+t agree with the general tone of extreme
AIM..
MM 9-,48. *Cuban 1'o " iti sal Trends" STATE. *...the somewhat alarming
is not justified."
d tae Ar eratimes Cean ra-ssieanal E'? eetions" State.
n
y
e
serented by such an 4msVApt. esas....ean I; a !aY
aun g~....:. .....air.... 4: 4+-.1u+1
Legal .- 41iY.L - . ?.J.?. __-
atirse predictions derived free the &sa msption...The sitaaatien
Au*. M (The
l l
'
b
. C 6-48. meonsequenese of Coeeessmeist Accession to Power in Italy by
_ - . -_ i.ek. A.+-r e l A
VQ sUUh a atndy.
that Peron would continue to cooperate with the US after the eleeetionss.
This conclusion to not denied in the dissent.
jPIFU'v- save -
W t +.Ma on leaves out, its conclusion was
esln
Nei roe
1 ffi aext an estini 1i its of. the Peroniste party whitish is "central
no one can be sure that events will o ur in the future, as
of a possible future event.)
I'S XHem1v W vvwyi ~ - -,--- -- - - -
detailed fort tact of events " (It is clearly pointed out in the paper
that the assumption of no W oomt$raction was necessary because CIA
' peat prejudge the US reaction" to such sh event go Ceessntiit control
of Greece.)
m
eDee
A. WPAO 69. s e s STATE. Objects to the assunptiegn
the Absence of US Cen aikreeets3m?
that the IDS would take no counteraction and therefore finds it nrreeeseary not to 5di"osociate itself r"tleye ptper_! _ ~'i *w.'~..v _sr
arsntses of Co mist Control, of Greece in
ibl Cedteset
sP
Approved For Release 2000/05/04: CIA-RDP67-00059AO00200120026-8
 Approved For Release 2000/05/04: CIA-R
D14P67-00059AO00200120026-8 -tt
.0 - R5
$? GIM 6a5. wThs Vanes r1.am ELeetions of lh Dasember 1%-7.0 .
Believes AWWLM+4UA is tot a -f o rt party as .ntat d
by CIAO, an that present ' eec tirra With the t
represents w~tenc7. * 'mss first t is a direct diaap rwent I the
$saw ;xints out ghat Is alaoet a1WVM trae of the aotisna of any
political party-*
Vie." S'1'. . Believes
St 4%&n c 3"fnpat bb4 ations to u1sewl? ea eons dlrtaila
Tram's Woven';
9.
grm of Mons.
Ow of the quences of C mint do*t tioxt of
r tbs death or d
do e in office for so
to that * as e
.se-tio yn
the bar, of power !as Sevi.et xeeuc ors p
radiation will require considerable
w1be C e Situation In ?ranch North Afriea." STA 1. Die-
-P
r to to
' 't
1
!
paps
7
.
that the "eusulati'ra effect" off
'P aeibi?- tl of D oat Sowist Military Action Dwtag 19 ".
at a 8et^iat?initiatecl war ' s
-.,..
i-' days. ...an extension of this estiearte
_...,r
,y e rpsxdant upon the, spplieitioft of logle to
o tat etranb .
e Lflte111rils w31 be t+ 3.a-msi it Dal'y
our Occideuta3 ap rrOe1 to logic
to that of the Orient, Russian *ied."
Is, the USSR . s STAB. that a
to s sorted by CIA, ,rill tW- the
.Uty of Stalin.. Adds that If Stab's eon-
Approved For Release 2000/05/04: CIA-RDP67-00059AO00200120026-8